Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is teaching children to use cutlery no longer a thing?

307 replies

Pixieb34 · 31/08/2023 11:05

Genuine question…
Do parents of younger children teach them to use a knife and fork nowadays?
I’m a parent of older teens and I did, along with general table manners like eating with your mouth closed and waiting for others to start/finish.
Am I being old fashioned to think being able to eat food with a knife and fork is a basic skill, or is eating with fingers or just a fork or spoon what’s done nowadays?

OP posts:
Crowfinch · 31/08/2023 13:07

But my kids aren't left handed. Cack handed, maybe, but not left handed. It's painful to watch then try and cut things with the knife in the wrong hand. Although dc 2 will, if ignored, eschew any attempts at cutting and just stab a lump of cauliflower or broccoli like the giant in jack and the fucking beanstalk eating a tree.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 31/08/2023 13:07

JenniferBarkley · 31/08/2023 12:57

I know it's not a popular view on MN but mine are 5 and 3 and this just isn't a priority. Mealtimes can be such battles anyway especially during the week when they're wrecked from a long day at school and childcare.

If they come to the table, actually eat some vegetables and have some nice chat I'm not going to cause a row over using a knife and fork properly. They are given them and gently encouraged but unless they're being truly disgusting I'm happy to let them be.

I wonder if this is why there has been a decrease in table manners.

My Gran was taught to put her cutlery a certain way after she was finished, to not put her elbows on the table, eat at the same pace as everyone else, set the table correctly by putting a place mat over a doily and putting the cutlery in specific places etc and most of it is just stupid and so pointless.

It’s a bit like when rich people have loads of different forks for different dishes, it’s just pointless and I do think certain things don’t need to continue being taught.

I think no child should be rude or misbehave whilst eating and that means sitting down until they’ve finished (mainly so they don’t choke) and not being silly with their food.
But most things that were taught 50 years ago I think is irrelevant now.

Mariposista · 31/08/2023 13:07

I am very strict with mine. My gran was with me, and I now have excellent manners and I want them to be the same, unlike my cousins who eat as though they were born in a barn.

RampantIvy · 31/08/2023 13:02

of course eldest insists on using his knife and fork in the wrong hands

Comments like this make me angry.

There is no such thing as the "wrong hands". People hold a knife in their dominant hand, so if you are left handed you hold your knife in your left hand.

Unless you are eating at a trestle table it isn't going to affect any other diners.

Castigating people for being left handed is so Victorian and should have been left behind in the 19th century.

Canisaysomething · 31/08/2023 13:01

They teach laying place settings with cutlery and using them from pre school where I live. Feeling pretty thankful of that reading these posts.

drearydear · 31/08/2023 12:59

In my experience a lot start primary only used to using a fork.

JenniferBarkley · 31/08/2023 12:57

I know it's not a popular view on MN but mine are 5 and 3 and this just isn't a priority. Mealtimes can be such battles anyway especially during the week when they're wrecked from a long day at school and childcare.

If they come to the table, actually eat some vegetables and have some nice chat I'm not going to cause a row over using a knife and fork properly. They are given them and gently encouraged but unless they're being truly disgusting I'm happy to let them be.

Qilin · 31/08/2023 12:57

Katiesaidthat · 31/08/2023 11:38

Oops, made me think. My daughter is 5 and no, she does not get a knife at table. If we are at a restaurant we remove the knife, or the waiters themselves remove the knife when my daughter sits at her alloted place. It is the done thing, basic safety. But then I am Spanish and it may be a cultural thing. Was trying to think back as to when my English mother gave us a knife, I would have been at least 6, minimum. Had to smile at pp saying they gave their 1 year old toddler a knife!!!!! No way would that happen in my house.

In an English school children are given metal cutlery at school from day 1, so from age 4y. We would expect most to be able to use it to some extent.

To be fair most table knives aren't very sharp anyway.

Phos · 31/08/2023 12:57

My kid can sort of use them, at the age of 6 but she's still ever so clumsy with cutting. I think it's a coordination thing with her, she writes with her right hand but everything else she does lefty! So she gets lazy and tries to get away without doing it. She's getting better, she can cut stuff like fish fingers or sausage ok but then we have to remind her when she's trying to shovel a whole Yorkshire pudding into her mouth.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 31/08/2023 12:52

Metatarse · 31/08/2023 12:44

I still have to remind mine which hand the cutlery goes in. They're teen and tween. We have eaten by the table since they were tiny, so no idea why they still can't get it right. I have to remind one of them to eat with mouth closed too. Even when they're in the back of the car eating sweets, I can tell if mouth is open.

Modelling good behaviour and reminders don't appear to work.

I’m an adult and couldn’t tell you which hand the knife and fork go in.

I tend to put my fork in my left hand and use my right hand for the knife, as I’m right handed.
If I’m eating soup or stir fry and don’t need a knife I would use my right hand only as that’s my dominant hand.

But I would assume that left handed people would be the opposite.

I didn’t know there was a correct hand.

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 31/08/2023 12:51

I've taught mine - of course eldest insists on using his knife and fork in the wrong hands (and he's not a lefty), but at least they know how in theory, and I don't feel embarrassed if we're out for dinner.

They even eat cake with a fork - but that's more because they don't like getting dirty hands than out of training.

I haven't taught them about weirder cutlery or odd rules like piling peas on the back of the fork or the 'correct' way to eat soup, because that's a step to far in my opinion :)

Personally, I think it's such an easy basic, something that will get noticed when they're adults (a bit like how they hold a pencil) that I feel sorry for kids who haven't been taught it.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 31/08/2023 12:49

My DD does know how to use cutlery but I don’t think I’ve ever taught her to wait until everyone’s finished before getting up (she’s always the last one) or any other table manners, as she has never really needed it.

But we’ve never had a dining table as we’ve never lived in a home big enough, so sitting at the table has always been very rare.

I think this is a big issue with most children these days, is that many people don’t have the room for a dining table and so table manners aren’t necessarily taught as strictly as they once were.

There has also been an increase in bringing in crap for packed lunches eg a packet of biscuits and an energy drink or a happy meal that was bought 2 days ago or a just share bag of Doritos (all real examples).
I don’t know where this has stemmed from though and why making a sandwich is so difficult.

DragonflyLady · 31/08/2023 12:49

I work in a primary lunch hall. All the children with school dinners are capable of using their cutlery to varying levels. We help the Reception children with cutting up mostly. But sometimes some of the older ones need a hand if there’s something a bit tough. Jacket potatoes are tricky for some. There is one little lad who sometimes wants to eat using finger, but he’s just reminded about his cutlery. My own daughter is at secondary and struggles with cutlery in the conventional sense, but still uses it. But this is due to a mobility issue with her fingers and wrists. She had a very bad experience with a welfare assistant at primary who yanked the cutlery out of her hands and forced them back into her hands in the way the welfare assistant wanted them to be - she still talks about that. I think the best way to teach children to use cutlery is to model how they’re used, with a guiding hand if they’re struggling.

Fiddlesticks24 · 31/08/2023 12:48

Do you mean being able to cut food with a knife and pick it up with a fork? Or which implement goes in which hand/stabbing meat with the prongs rather than shovelling/scooping soup up backwards etc?

Wisteria29 · 31/08/2023 12:48

Teaching “proper” cutlery use isn’t something that’s important to me. If they can cut with a knife and eat with a fork I don’t care which hand it’s in. I find formality over cutlery use annoying.

Metatarse · 31/08/2023 12:44

I still have to remind mine which hand the cutlery goes in. They're teen and tween. We have eaten by the table since they were tiny, so no idea why they still can't get it right. I have to remind one of them to eat with mouth closed too. Even when they're in the back of the car eating sweets, I can tell if mouth is open.

Modelling good behaviour and reminders don't appear to work.

Myfavouritepenguin · 31/08/2023 12:42

I appreciate that food culture has changed, as some pp have mentioned, and that cutlery use is less formal now- but I also feel there’s an undertone of things “going to the dogs” and things being “better in my day” going on in this thread. I’m in my 40s, so no spring chicken, but I loathe that generational one-up-manship that I see on social media.

guiltyfeethavegotnorythym · 31/08/2023 12:41

All children will fork food and try to eat it like it's a lollipop , they need to be told no that is not how we eat. It is trying but you do have to keep telling them .Put your fork down and cut it a piece at a time .

Gertrudetheadelie · 31/08/2023 12:41

@deveronvalley yes! I'm so glad someone else has noticed this! I think they shovel it down to play and they definitely don't wait for everyone to be seated like we do at home. It's really grating to hear complaints about lazy parenting when I know I worked bloody hard at home to get him to have good manners and he's lost it at school!

deveronvalley · 31/08/2023 12:37

My son went to school knowing how to use cutlery and had wonderful table manners e.g “please may I get down?” … like a well-to-do Victorian child. A few weeks of school dinners soon knocked that out of him! At school they grab food off each others plates, do “trades”, eat everything with a spoon or fingers, dip potatoes into the custard (it’s all served up on 1 plastic tray). He’s told me this himself! So what you see in school may be very far from what is expected of them at home, at least some of them anyway!

RampantIvy · 31/08/2023 12:37

Katiesaidthat · 31/08/2023 11:38

Oops, made me think. My daughter is 5 and no, she does not get a knife at table. If we are at a restaurant we remove the knife, or the waiters themselves remove the knife when my daughter sits at her alloted place. It is the done thing, basic safety. But then I am Spanish and it may be a cultural thing. Was trying to think back as to when my English mother gave us a knife, I would have been at least 6, minimum. Had to smile at pp saying they gave their 1 year old toddler a knife!!!!! No way would that happen in my house.

But table knives aren't sharp enough to accidentally cut yourself on.

I'm surprised at how many posters have voted YABU, given that the posters who work in schools have noticed that there is an increase in children who can't use cutlery.

DD had a couple of friends from school who used a fork in their fist to stab their food to be able to cut it.

jannier · 31/08/2023 12:36

Xrays · 31/08/2023 11:48

I laughed at this. My family is American too. Everyone just eats with a fork. They use the fork to cut everything like a knife by holding the fork sideways. 😆

How do you cut steak with a fork?

jannier · 31/08/2023 12:35

SleepingStandingUp · 31/08/2023 11:26

My kids can use cutlery, but yes clearly I'm just a shit lazy parent with my nappy clad preschooler twins.

Are your pre school twins going into full time reception class and nearing 5?

jannier · 31/08/2023 12:34

No there not by and large it seems to be a case of throw them a spoon and a screen and go do something else. I've had a parent say no they can't use a fork they might stab someone

KnittedCardi · 31/08/2023 12:34

I have infinite respect for teachers who have to teach young children to eat properly, go to the toilet unaided, wash their hands, dress and undress for PE. No wonder they've got no extra time for academics. This is basic stuff, and ND aside, every child should be school ready by four.