Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is teaching children to use cutlery no longer a thing?

307 replies

Pixieb34 · 31/08/2023 11:05

Genuine question…
Do parents of younger children teach them to use a knife and fork nowadays?
I’m a parent of older teens and I did, along with general table manners like eating with your mouth closed and waiting for others to start/finish.
Am I being old fashioned to think being able to eat food with a knife and fork is a basic skill, or is eating with fingers or just a fork or spoon what’s done nowadays?

OP posts:
UnctuousUnicorns · 31/08/2023 14:05

Xrays · 31/08/2023 11:48

I laughed at this. My family is American too. Everyone just eats with a fork. They use the fork to cut everything like a knife by holding the fork sideways. 😆

My DH does this, and he's as British as me. I swear he's allergic to knives.

Pebblesontheside · 31/08/2023 14:04

Geniune question, can PP’s explain exactly how they ‘taught’ their little ones to use the knife and fork? We have always provided DS with a knife and fork for meals since he was 2, and we model using ours every mealtime - he uses his fork but rarely chooses to use his knife, even when directed - and I don’t really want to spend mealtimes constantly badgering him to use it. So I just assumed his current skill level is normal, but sounds like lots of people have their LOs using their knife and fork perfectly from toddlerhood!
He goes to nursery full time, so they obviously don’t have any rigorous knife-training programme either.
He starts reception on Tuesday and after reading this I am panicking a bit that he is behind where he should be with this set of skills.
Hopefully they won’t be served great slabs of tough meat etc in reception, and he should get by! But any tips are welcome.

CaptainMyCaptain · 31/08/2023 14:03

That's fine @JenniferBarkley but, by the time your children go to school, I would hope they would be able to use the utensils provided to feed themselves. There should be an adult on hand to cut meat up for them if required but nobody will have the time to sit down with them and cajole them into eating. I suppose they could always take a packed lunch and continue to eat with their fingers.

user123212 · 31/08/2023 14:01

I think part of it could be less time eating with family. Both parents are forced to work more hours these days, so less time for family meal times. I've only started getting more strict about it recently, now DC is old enough, and has gotten better motor skills. It's only a matter of time.

I never knew there was a stigma against using the "wrong" hand for the fork/knife... I thought it was just traditional vs not. I usually lay the table with fork on the right 😆

JenniferBarkley · 31/08/2023 13:56

ismu · 31/08/2023 13:49

@JenniferBarkley if children have no developmental issues then they should absolutely be able to use a knife and fork by the time they start school as well as sitting at table, enjoying food etc.
If children couldn't write their name by the time they were 8 would we all just say oh no worries, it's old fashioned and shaming anyway

Should be able to. Sure.

Not every kid can do everything they should be able to do, and not every kid does everything they can do every single time.

Every child is different and like I said I have firmly put this in the battles-not-worth-fighting column. There are enough battles that are worth fighting. Other people will feel differently and that's fine - unless they have the most compliant children on the planet there's probably stuff that they don't prioritise but I do.

My friend's DCs have beautiful table manners. But, they LOVE their food and are (she'd say it herself), slightly obsessed. Great, well behaved kids with a fantastic diet and healthy weights, who utterly love food. There is no issue with getting them to the table and they pretty much always scrape their plates, so she has had plenty of time and scope to encourage table manners. Mine is a decent eater but can need to be cajoled to the table - especially, frustratingly, when tired and hungry. When she finally makes it there and starts eating the food she needs to feel less grumpy (the hanger is strong in that one), I'm not about to make a battle over the use of a knife that will just have her refuse to eat in a strop. She can finesse the table manners when she's a bit bigger.

Decent parents respond to the needs of their individual children and prioritise accordingly.

MariaVT65 · 31/08/2023 13:55

DragonflyLady · 31/08/2023 13:40

Absolutely right. But even if you’re not left handed and you prefer to use your knife in your left hand - it’s still not the wrong hand!

THANK YOU. I eat ‘left handed’ and my mum’s partner constantly tells me off for ‘not eating properly’. Load of bollocks.

WeWereInParis · 31/08/2023 13:52

It's lazy parenting

@HappiDaze sorry, did you mean to reply to my comment where I said we were teaching her use a knife but she just hadn't quite got the hang of it depending on what she's trying to cut? That's not lazy parenting. That's a child who hasn't quite grasped a skill yet.

Whataretheodds · 31/08/2023 13:51

Adults use knife and fork much less often than they used to, and less likely to sit at a table to eat, I suspect.

OP might also be observing baby-led weaning?

StephanieSuperpowers · 31/08/2023 13:50

was told at school I don't eat properly and I needed to have my cutlery the other way around...why?

I think it has to do with space at a table. So you get everyone to hold their fork in one hand and their knife in the other. You do a bit more manouvering with your knife so you need more room. You keep your fork hand completely tucked at all times.

Monkeybutt1 · 31/08/2023 13:50

TheBirdintheCave · 31/08/2023 13:47

There was a HUGE thread on this exact topic a while back and certain MumsNetters get incredibly angry about people like us. We were called all sorts (including lazy, stupid and uncouth) and it was quite shocking to read.

Wow that's shocking, for me its just what is comfortable.

ismu · 31/08/2023 13:49

@JenniferBarkley if children have no developmental issues then they should absolutely be able to use a knife and fork by the time they start school as well as sitting at table, enjoying food etc.
If children couldn't write their name by the time they were 8 would we all just say oh no worries, it's old fashioned and shaming anyway

Cheesenpickleontoast · 31/08/2023 13:48

StephanieSuperpowers · 31/08/2023 13:09

I just don't want my children to do it wrongly without knowing. I think there's power in knowing and making a conscious decision that you aren't bothered about that kind of thing, but genuinely not knowing leaves you exposed. I want my children to be confident to go where life takes them, knowing that they can fit in if they want to. I would hate if they went to a new partner's house and felt like they'd been raised by wolves.

I agree with this. I don't care too much about them using the correct knife and fork but I do care about them being judged for not knowing when they are older. If they have the knowledge and some degree of practise they can make a conscious decision on how they eat and are perceived. I'd like them to feel as comfortable at a diplomatic dinner engagement (I aim high!) as eating fish and chips with their fingers at the seaside.

Treasureboxkey · 31/08/2023 13:48

LunaNorth · 31/08/2023 11:09

I’ve heard that primary school teachers are increasingly having to teach kids how to use cutlery.

I have been teaching for 15 years and have taught every year 1 class that I have had how to use cutlery. We start with playdough in sausage shapes to practice stabbing and slicing, then play dough made to look like peas to practice scooping and pushing.

They graduate to Jaffa cakes to give them the incentive.

TheBirdintheCave · 31/08/2023 13:47

Monkeybutt1 · 31/08/2023 13:46

I agree that table manners and being able to eat with cutlery is very important but why are people so hung up on which is the correct way round to hold your knife and fork. I am right handed but eat with my knife in my left hand, I spent years growing up being embarrassed when eating out as waiters would swap my cutlery back, I was told at school I don't eat properly and I needed to have my cutlery the other way around...why? My DS is the same as me and so is my cousin. All 3 of us use the cutlery properly, we cut our food up and don't talk with food in our mouths so why are some people so bothered which hand the knife is in and which hand the fork is in. The big issue here is children who don't know how to use a knife and fork at all.

There was a HUGE thread on this exact topic a while back and certain MumsNetters get incredibly angry about people like us. We were called all sorts (including lazy, stupid and uncouth) and it was quite shocking to read.

Natsku · 31/08/2023 13:47

I teach my children to use cutlery but my 12 year old outright refuses to use anything but a fork by itself at home (and only one particular fork) with a grumbly exception for soup. But at school they have to use knives and forks and every so often they have 'good manners week' when the teachers are extra hot on proper cutlery use (the teacher eats lunch with them) so I trust that she can use them properly when needed so not going to make a big deal out of it at home.

TheBirdintheCave · 31/08/2023 13:46

@DragonflyLady Thank you!

Flying the flag for ambidextrous people here. I eat with my knife in my left hand as that's what's most comfortable and was once described by a teacher as the neatest eater he'd ever seen. It's not bad or wrong, just different. I still have excellent table manners.

Do people really force their children to eat in a way contrary to what feels comfortable to them? 🤔

Flaskfan · 31/08/2023 13:46

hby9628 · 31/08/2023 13:43

Eating with their mouth open drives me mad more than anything else. Currently sat listening to 2 children doing exactly that.

My most mc friend did this all through school. She mixes with a much posher crowd now and I often wonder if she still does it.

Monkeybutt1 · 31/08/2023 13:46

I agree that table manners and being able to eat with cutlery is very important but why are people so hung up on which is the correct way round to hold your knife and fork. I am right handed but eat with my knife in my left hand, I spent years growing up being embarrassed when eating out as waiters would swap my cutlery back, I was told at school I don't eat properly and I needed to have my cutlery the other way around...why? My DS is the same as me and so is my cousin. All 3 of us use the cutlery properly, we cut our food up and don't talk with food in our mouths so why are some people so bothered which hand the knife is in and which hand the fork is in. The big issue here is children who don't know how to use a knife and fork at all.

chickensaresafehere · 31/08/2023 13:44

My dd (16) has a severe learning disability (eating has alwaysbeen a struggle for her)& I just noticed the other day how beautifully she navigated her plate,cut up her food & ate it with no fuss. I was so proud. Must have done something right!!!

hby9628 · 31/08/2023 13:43

Eating with their mouth open drives me mad more than anything else. Currently sat listening to 2 children doing exactly that.

Endofsummerisinsight · 31/08/2023 13:43

Katiesaidthat · 31/08/2023 11:38

Oops, made me think. My daughter is 5 and no, she does not get a knife at table. If we are at a restaurant we remove the knife, or the waiters themselves remove the knife when my daughter sits at her alloted place. It is the done thing, basic safety. But then I am Spanish and it may be a cultural thing. Was trying to think back as to when my English mother gave us a knife, I would have been at least 6, minimum. Had to smile at pp saying they gave their 1 year old toddler a knife!!!!! No way would that happen in my house.

This is a huge difference in the UK. Children will be given a metal knife and fork at school when they are 4 and will be using them at home by the age of 2 at the latest.

By 5/6 I would expect a child to use a sharp cooking knife under close supervision.

JenniferBarkley · 31/08/2023 13:41

HappiDaze · 31/08/2023 13:26

It's lazy parenting

It isn't though. Actively choosing to prioritise enjoyment of healthy food, conversation, sitting nicely etc at the table over use of cutlery isn't lazy parenting, it's just different parenting to yours. That's fine. Every child and every family are different and no one can do everything perfectly, we all have to choose little things to let slip in order to focus on things that are more important to us.

rainbowstardrops · 31/08/2023 13:41

I'll hazard a guess that many posters on here haven't actually witnessed lunch times in an infant school!!! It's CARNAGE!
A lot of the children clearly don't even know what a knife/fork or spoon is actually for and will happily dive into a roast dinner/spaghetti bolognaise or whatever with their hands. Awful, lazy parenting. Children should at least be able to eat with a fork or spoon when they start school!
Honestly, at my school, the children who do eat with a knife and fork are in the minority. Oh and we happily cut their food up for them, so no excuse not to even use a spoon.
To the people who say teachers don't have time, you're right. It's the TAs in my school that have to cover lunchtimes before or after their 30 minute break.
My children had toddler cutlery sets, so I don't understand people saying they wouldn't give a young child a knife. It's not a bloody machete!
Don't even get me started on the children that have no idea how to use the toilet properly and wash their hands when they start school.

DragonflyLady · 31/08/2023 13:40

RampantIvy · 31/08/2023 13:02

of course eldest insists on using his knife and fork in the wrong hands

Comments like this make me angry.

There is no such thing as the "wrong hands". People hold a knife in their dominant hand, so if you are left handed you hold your knife in your left hand.

Unless you are eating at a trestle table it isn't going to affect any other diners.

Castigating people for being left handed is so Victorian and should have been left behind in the 19th century.

Absolutely right. But even if you’re not left handed and you prefer to use your knife in your left hand - it’s still not the wrong hand!

PinkTonic · 31/08/2023 13:38

HoppingPavlova · 31/08/2023 12:24

I’ll admit mine, as adults, really struggle to the point it’s a bit embarrassing. It all stems from the fact they never really ate meals requiring knives as kids and still don’t as adults. For instance, they would never have had a piece of meat to cut up. They have lived on stir-fries and curries which have bite size pieces of meat and or-cut veg, soups and home-made burgers, with some spag bol thrown in. I think the hardest they have to contend with is lasagne. Even sausages at a bbq don’t present a problem for them as they all tend to put it on a roll with salad and it eat it that way, and just eat the sides such as potato salad or coleslaw with a fork. Other bbq meats these days tend to be skewers or wings or similar, not slabs of meat. I would think that due to what they have grown up on, a full piece of meat is an odd thing to them, and none will willingly eat it.

So, if they go out to a restaurant that only/mainly has dishes with full pieces of meat it’s the only time they eat it and use a knife - and it shows. Not a day to day problem with restaurants though as they tend to go to Thai or Indian restaurants, or pub meals where you order a burger. So they may face a knife once or twice a year. I on the other hand take any opportunity to have a decent steak if out as it’s a nice change, and i can use a knife😊.

Didn’t you ever roast a chicken? What about chips, roast potatoes? I saw my 8 year old great niece stab a roast potato with a fork last week and bite it, burning her lip in the process. Even though my children had their fair share of curries with rice, pasta dishes, tacos and burgers etc. they’d have been sent from the table for stabbing a roaster or a large chip or a piece of broccoli with a fork and biting it. It’s not just about style of food, it’s basic table manners.