Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reborn dolls in the pram bay

680 replies

gezelligheid · 31/08/2023 07:34

A couple of times now I've been unable to get on the bus with my baby in a pram because there are two local women who take their reborn dolls out in prams and take up the pram bays. I know they are reborn dolls as I've seen the dolls in their pram.

I understand people have reborn dolls for many different reasons but to take up a space meaning a real baby can't get on the bus surely isn't fair?

I've complained to the bus service and they've said they cannot monitor whether babies are real or not so if they get on the bus first I should ask them to put their pram down upon boarding.

I'm worried this will cause an altercation on the bus so I'm wondering AIBU to say something on the bus even though it may be embarrassing for the women?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
orangeyeahthatsright · 31/08/2023 12:19

Namechangey23 · 31/08/2023 12:12

Sorry but that's really weird and creepy and I don't get it. I would say loudly please can you move your pretend baby and make space for my real life baby? I'd probably get stabbed though. Surely they are too old for dollies? Why on earth?! I get it if they had special needs and needed a cuddly toy. But it just sounds like grownups playing mummies and daddies..maybe get a dog!? At least it's real and will love you back.

There are other, often quite sensitive, reasons besides SEN that someone might have a reborn. Bereavement, inability to conceive... and no, I don't have one myself, but I wouldn't judge someone for owning them. Reborn therapy is a thing.

I do, however, think they shouldn't be allowed to take up pram spaces real babies need.

Myalternate · 31/08/2023 12:18

I’m so grateful that I drive because with 3 under 20 months old it would have been impossible to use public transport.

gezelligheid · 31/08/2023 12:18

sunglassesonthetable · 31/08/2023 12:06

Only a very small proportion said anything about them being a substitute for a lost baby. So I would hesitate to assume that just because a woman is doing something unusual, that she is necessarily either bereaved or mentally ill.

Exactly, you don't know.

But on a busy bus, baby under one arm, pram and shopping, in public, is not the ideal place to discover which way the wind blows.

I feel for you OP because it would be the last straw realising they were dolls.

The first time there was another bus due that was going "kind of" near where I needed to be, so just had to get off and take a 10 minute walk so it wasn't a big deal and I felt awkward as I saw they were dolls and didn't want to say anything. This was when they pushed in front of me at the bus station (rude but as I say, another bus was coming and I didn't want confrontation as I felt awkward)

The second time I was actually at a bus stop close to my house and I had to wait 30 minutes for the next bus because they were already on the bus.

The third time is when I decided to inform the bus company and put a complaint in as its becoming a regular thing and I'm dreading getting the bus anywhere just in case now.

It wouldn't bother me so much if it was just one woman with a doll in a pram, but because there are two of them and they are always together it's just frustrating. If I were to say something I'd be going 2v1 and worry about an altercation as I just want to get home safely with my baby. Pretty disappointed with Arriva's response basically telling me to sort it myself tbh but I do get they can't check babies are real or fake, but still 😅 annoying

OP posts:
Someoneonlyyouknow · 31/08/2023 12:15

I think the point for the bus driver will be that they simply don't know which prams/buggies contain 'real' babies and which don't. And once I am on a bus I'm not really looking to see who else is trying to get on at the next stop. So driver or OP could ask "Is anyone able to fold your pram/buggy so another one can get on board?" but prams are often not foldable and buggies usually well-laden.

The doll-owners may not be being deliberately difficult. I have just realised, reading this thread, that I was probably on a bus with one recently. Several people admired the pram occupant and I thought maybe it was a dog. I think that lady would have liked the validation and been accommodating to another buggy (though don't think her pram would have folded up could have taken carrycot off wheels perhaps)

Superfood · 31/08/2023 12:14

HairsprayBabe · 31/08/2023 11:42

@Superfood McLaren don't make buggies any more I think this is one of the reasons there are less public transport friendly buggies around is because there is no go to name for them.
I used to have a Cosatto umbrella but it was SO heavy it was rubbish to collapse one handed. I have a Hauck travelncare now and that is great for public transport. Small light and you can put it up and down with one hand.

Also a lot of busses have designated pram spaces not just wheelchair spots now so people don't have to always collapse - these spots are for babies not dolls.

Wow, I had no idea maclaren had stopped making buggies. What a shame. It was indispensable for me as a mum of small children in London without a car.

I also had a similar lightweight mothercare one which I used for travelling abroad.

Those tank-like prams stuffed full of shopping bags with everything hanging off them are completely unsuited to public transport.

HarpieDuJour · 31/08/2023 12:12

Jamtartforme · 31/08/2023 11:57

Well what happened last time we agreed to make allowances for a supposedly very small number of people, who wanted to identify as something they weren’t, because it was ‘kind’ to do so and they likely had some kind of severe mental health issue which needed our accommodation more than we needed to stick by the facts of reality?

We’ve learned that is is never in anybody’s interests to pretend something is real when it isn’t, in order to accommodate somebody else’s fantasy.

I’m truly empathetic towards any person struggling for any reason, but (and I’ll be flamed) I don’t think MH issues entitle somebody to whatever they wish.

This is a good point, I hadn't made the connection. I don't think anyone needs to be spelling out to these women that their dolls are not real babies (if only because they already know that!), but neither is it a good idea to pretend that they are.

Namechangey23 · 31/08/2023 12:12

LakeTiticaca · 31/08/2023 08:17

I had no idea people actually did this!!

Sorry but that's really weird and creepy and I don't get it. I would say loudly please can you move your pretend baby and make space for my real life baby? I'd probably get stabbed though. Surely they are too old for dollies? Why on earth?! I get it if they had special needs and needed a cuddly toy. But it just sounds like grownups playing mummies and daddies..maybe get a dog!? At least it's real and will love you back.

sunglassesonthetable · 31/08/2023 12:09

There should be fines for people who obstruct the pram bay with luggage/shopping/ weird creepy dolls and refuse to move them when asked. Not pandering because of "mental health".

Agree about the luggage and shopping.

And also that you are clearly compassion personified.

readbooksdrinktea · 31/08/2023 12:08

Waffle78 · 31/08/2023 11:37

Yes but if you're in the wheelchair bay and a wheelchair user need's to get on. The wheelchair user takes priority anyway. I've had 8 weeks of this with DS in wheelchair who has severe learning LD and can't use crutches. Only option was a wheelchair. Honestly don't know how people do it all the time. I've had more FFS we can't get the pram on cos there's a wheelchair than I can count.

Welcome to my life. Sympathy to you and your son. It doesn't make you feel great, that's for sure.

sunglassesonthetable · 31/08/2023 12:06

Only a very small proportion said anything about them being a substitute for a lost baby. So I would hesitate to assume that just because a woman is doing something unusual, that she is necessarily either bereaved or mentally ill.

Exactly, you don't know.

But on a busy bus, baby under one arm, pram and shopping, in public, is not the ideal place to discover which way the wind blows.

I feel for you OP because it would be the last straw realising they were dolls.

Brexile · 31/08/2023 12:04

There should be fines for people who obstruct the pram bay with luggage/shopping/ weird creepy dolls and refuse to move them when asked. Not pandering because of "mental health".

sunglassesonthetable · 31/08/2023 12:02

@doroda

sunglassesonthetable · 31/08/2023 12:01

Tbh I reckon most people got the gist about " mother of a doll " when referring to PRAMS.

Well not you. Thank you for being so punctilious. In case no one realised.

HarpieDuJour · 31/08/2023 11:59

Insommmmnia · 31/08/2023 09:15

What they actually need more than compassion is professional help

My baby was still born so I absolutely have sympathy. But what I needed was therapy to help me manage my grief not to carry my grief around for years in the physical form of a baby

What's actually needed is better professional intervention at the point you lose the baby. The support I got medically was pitiful and underfunded

My experiences were very similar. I got some leaflets and some sleeping tablets, that's all. One of the leaflets actually suggested using a doll for comfort. I was suicidal at this point, so I thought that even the slightest improvement would be worth it. So, I tried it. It didn't help at all, it just provided a focus and I became fixated on this doll very quickly. I had it for less than 48 hours, but it was very clear to me, even in the state I was in, that this was not a good or healthy thing for me.

Fortunately, I saw what was happening and sought help elsewhere. My priest was a huge help to me and I believe saved my life.

I certainly wouldn't be rude or nasty to anyone with a doll on a bus (although the buses where I live have no wheelchair spaces and most are more like builders' crew buses than anything else) but I would ask them to fold their pram if I was in this situation elsewhere.

I've only ever come across Reborn doll enthusiasts online, I've never seen one in the wild, but a large proportion of those claimed to just enjoy the dolls, or take pride in having made them. Only a very small proportion said anything about them being a substitute for a lost baby. So I would hesitate to assume that just because a woman is doing something unusual, that she is necessarily either bereaved or mentally ill.

Jamtartforme · 31/08/2023 11:57

Ap24 · 31/08/2023 11:38

Is there any benefit in getting the general public to play along with these people's fantasies? Its all a bit shutter Island, is it not?

Well what happened last time we agreed to make allowances for a supposedly very small number of people, who wanted to identify as something they weren’t, because it was ‘kind’ to do so and they likely had some kind of severe mental health issue which needed our accommodation more than we needed to stick by the facts of reality?

We’ve learned that is is never in anybody’s interests to pretend something is real when it isn’t, in order to accommodate somebody else’s fantasy.

I’m truly empathetic towards any person struggling for any reason, but (and I’ll be flamed) I don’t think MH issues entitle somebody to whatever they wish.

doroda · 31/08/2023 11:56

sunglassesonthetable · 31/08/2023 11:45

A person with a doll isn't a mother, and a doll isn't a baby. HTH.

Who exactly thinks the above???
Err No one.

And it's definitely not about putting a human child at risk in favour of a doll. Dear God.

It's how to actually deal with this situation in a decent and civil and yes , shoot me, kind way. And an effective way.

OP needs to get home with her baby.

Thank god I don't have to wrestle babies and prams and slings anymore. It's a bitch.

Who thinks it - literally the poster I was quoting

sunglassesonthetable · 31/08/2023 11:53

Surely people should be being helped to come to terms with the real world rather than everyone else walking on eggshells to participate in the fantasy?

Of course they should.

But as a previous poster who sadly has been through baby loss pointed out, there is no help.

marblesthecat · 31/08/2023 11:50

Carouselfish · 31/08/2023 11:47

Of course there are people with mental health issues that do this. But the real world takes precedence. And how much good does it do someone being encouraged to live in a fantasy world that is inevitably going to collide with the real one? Surely people should be being helped to come to terms with the real world rather than everyone else walking on eggshells to participate in the fantasy?

Agree. When I had a miscarriage a few years back I joined a miscarriage support FB group and people were sharing pictures of these life-like plastic foetuses that you could buy at various stages to keep in your pocket and pretend you were still pregnant and the baby was still growing. I thought it was very unhealthy even then.

Carouselfish · 31/08/2023 11:47

Of course there are people with mental health issues that do this. But the real world takes precedence. And how much good does it do someone being encouraged to live in a fantasy world that is inevitably going to collide with the real one? Surely people should be being helped to come to terms with the real world rather than everyone else walking on eggshells to participate in the fantasy?

munchmagic · 31/08/2023 11:45

gezelligheid · 31/08/2023 10:58

Also the way I knew they were reborn dolls: I've seen their dolls and they are very obviously fake. I've seen them on multiple occasions, waiting for buses and pottering about town, their babies are always the same and have never aged nor changed because they are dolls.

Completely fair enough, and I apologise for questioning the legitimacy of your post.
I hope everything went ok for you at the dentist.
I think you're reasonable in wanting the ladies to move/give you space. You have a baby, and while the sling suggestion is helpful it's not really the point. You shouldn't need to be making accommodations for reborn doll mums.
And I say that as an autistic adult myself. I can totally see the reasons for having a reborn and why people do, but none of that negates your need with a very much alive and real baby.
Sorry you're having to deal with this when you're just trying to get on a bus.

sunglassesonthetable · 31/08/2023 11:45

A person with a doll isn't a mother, and a doll isn't a baby. HTH.

Who exactly thinks the above???
Err No one.

And it's definitely not about putting a human child at risk in favour of a doll. Dear God.

It's how to actually deal with this situation in a decent and civil and yes , shoot me, kind way. And an effective way.

OP needs to get home with her baby.

Thank god I don't have to wrestle babies and prams and slings anymore. It's a bitch.

HairsprayBabe · 31/08/2023 11:42

@Superfood McLaren don't make buggies any more I think this is one of the reasons there are less public transport friendly buggies around is because there is no go to name for them.
I used to have a Cosatto umbrella but it was SO heavy it was rubbish to collapse one handed. I have a Hauck travelncare now and that is great for public transport. Small light and you can put it up and down with one hand.

Also a lot of busses have designated pram spaces not just wheelchair spots now so people don't have to always collapse - these spots are for babies not dolls.

Ap24 · 31/08/2023 11:38

Is there any benefit in getting the general public to play along with these people's fantasies? Its all a bit shutter Island, is it not?

Waffle78 · 31/08/2023 11:37

Yes but if you're in the wheelchair bay and a wheelchair user need's to get on. The wheelchair user takes priority anyway. I've had 8 weeks of this with DS in wheelchair who has severe learning LD and can't use crutches. Only option was a wheelchair. Honestly don't know how people do it all the time. I've had more FFS we can't get the pram on cos there's a wheelchair than I can count.

rileynexttime · 31/08/2023 11:36

Many thanks @FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper , I'll have a read.

Swipe left for the next trending thread