Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you prefer private school?

396 replies

Dontbeamenace · 31/08/2023 00:52

I'm sure I would prefer private school for my children. Would it matter to you if money was no cost?

OP posts:
JustKen · 02/09/2023 14:20

I live in an area with both state and private schools in plentiful supply.

I can't afford private school so my DD went to a good state school. In spite of it's good-not-excellence, she did well at GCSEs and that's down to all the effort she put into it.

I admire the private sector's facilities and class sizes, alongside their promotion of extracurricular activities. My daughter never wants to join anything. I also note that PS is much more culturally diverse these days, if not economically so.

Maybe if I did have the cash, I'd send her. But the "normal" thing for me is state school. I don't know anyone who went private.

Approaching · 02/09/2023 14:09

paddyclampofthethirdkind · 02/09/2023 13:59

Why do people assume that the behaviour in a state secondary is so appalling? The behaviour in the inner city deprived area that I teach in is excellent and more schools round here are going down the route of zero tolerance.

30 pages here of posts, many from your teacher colleagues, despairing of appalling behaviour in schools. https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4836123-is-behaviour-out-of-control-in-a-lot-of-schools?page=1

Is behaviour out of control in a lot of schools? | Mumsnet

Not sure whether to move DD (10) to another school. Everyday she's coming home saying she can't learn as there are a group of boys who throw stuff abo...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4836123-is-behaviour-out-of-control-in-a-lot-of-schools?page=1

paddyclampofthethirdkind · 02/09/2023 13:59

Why do people assume that the behaviour in a state secondary is so appalling? The behaviour in the inner city deprived area that I teach in is excellent and more schools round here are going down the route of zero tolerance.

LolaSmiles · 02/09/2023 13:44

Totally agree with this, the whole being smug about your left wing politics whilst owning a £2million house in the catchment of the best state school in the country is exceptionally irritating.
I agree. It comes up on most private education threads though.

There's also a (misplaced and naïve) belief that as long as a school isn't in special measures then it's a decent school with few issues, so you'll also get people saying things like "people with funds to go private are unlikely to have poor state schools". Anyone who has spent any time in the state sector would be able to give dozens of examples that show this isn't the case.

Most parents want to do what's best for their children in their circumstances with the education that's on offer. The tiny minority who will deliberately give their kids a poor deal so they can get on their political soapbox and maintain their place in the purity spiral need to get a grip in my opinion.

WeAreBorg · 02/09/2023 11:39

dcbc1234 · 31/08/2023 23:50

Quote 'We decided our money would be better spent buying a house in the catchment of excellent state schools, funding extra curricular activities and, if needed, tutoring'
The ultimate left-wing hypocrisy right there, using money in a different way to advantage their kids whilst attempting to retain the moral high ground. My DC were state educated but I wouldn't have put them in just any failing state school.
All posters in this thread stop virtue-signalling and should instead simply admit that most parents will do what they believe is best for each child to the best of their (financial) ability and there is nothing wrong with that. You should not sacrifice your child to your political principles in either direction.

Totally agree with this, the whole being smug about your left wing politics whilst owning a £2million house in the catchment of the best state school in the country is exceptionally irritating.
Equally annoying is “bright children do well anywhere”. Well maybe my kid is thick as a plank mate, piss off

MrsAvocet · 02/09/2023 10:23

RockaLock · 01/09/2023 14:51

Yes, I understand all that, and I did say I could see an effect for the class as a whole if the proportion of ex-private pupils in a class was high enough.

But realistically, you are likely to only have a few ex-private pupils per class turning up in each state school. At least, that's what posters on this type of thread seem to always say: local schools wouldn't be overwhelmed, it would only be a handful of extra children per school etc etc.

So I'm still not convinced that forcing lots of private schools to close would result in a noticeable improvement to any individual state school.

No, it probably wouldn't make a massive difference as the type of state schools that ex private school pupils are likely to go to are probably fairly high performing anyway.
In fact this scenario occurred in our area a few years ago when an independent school closed at short notice. Some children went to other private schools, but of those who transferred to the state sector they pretty much all ended up in one of the two sought after schools in the area. I know some took places in less good schools initially because they were the only schools with space but they all went on waiting lists for the popular schools and by virtue of where they live all got in eventually. People who educate privately tend to live in more expensive areas of course and the state schools in their areas tend to be the more sought after ones, for all the reasons LolaSmiles describes.
Having a more affluent parent body does help schools directly too. The demographics of my DCs school are quite mixed, but on average we're a fairly well heeled bunch of parents and you see that reflected in how much is made at fundraisers and donations made by local businesses that are often run by families with a link to the school. And it's not just money, parental involvement makes a difference too - plenty of solicitors to advise the Mock Bar team, engineers who help with the robotics team, doctors and scientists who come in to give talks to the STEM club and so on at our school. It is so much easier for schools to run those kind of activities if they have supportive parents with appropriate skills. In an area where lots of parents are struggling to put food on the table then no matter how much they might want to help the local school they just can't.
But I agree that closing private schools wouldn't have many positive effects for the state sector. It wouldn't benefit struggling schools because those children would not end up going to those schools, by virtue of where they live. And the schools where they do live are likely to be good and relatively well resourced anyway. All that is likely to happen is that competition for places in the good schools would go up even more, potentially leading to at least some less well off children who currently do benefit from a good state education being pushed out.

Ringdoodledumpling · 01/09/2023 19:32

DC at private school. Wouldn’t change it.

TheaBrandt · 01/09/2023 19:24

I don’t see how a level playing field can ever be achieved. Private / state is a red herring. The real advantage is having engaged and
intelligent parents. We were having this conversation today as discussing results. Mix of state and private parents but that wasn’t the point. The state schools are good here. We all university educated. Friend who’s a pharmacist guiding her Dd to be a doctor as she knows all about that career path and most of her friends are doctors.

Dd wants to be a solicitor - we both are so can offer real guidance there and contacts. Not to mention the “soft” social
skills of being middle class having high expectations for yourself. How much harder if you have a single parent mother who is a cleaner and left school at 16? You’re on your own then in accessing a professional career even if your school is quite good. That was Dh - he did it all himself his parents left school at 16 and were blue collar workers - it’s possible but it’s much much harder.

LolaSmiles · 01/09/2023 15:55

But realistically, you are likely to only have a few ex-private pupils per class turning up in each state school. At least, that's what posters on this type of thread seem to always say: local schools wouldn't be overwhelmed, it would only be a handful of extra children per school etc etc.
But it isn't likely to be a couple of pupils shared across schools.

What's likely to happen is that the ex-private school families will flock to the best state schools, and the knock on will happen on average families, and not much will change for those at the bottom.

RamblingRosieLee
I totally agree with you. I don't think private schools is the big issue here. The state sector isn't going to improve for the majority until SEN services, SALT, EdPsch, social care, OT, physio, the services that many parents/families need to break their own cycles etc are all properly funded.

Until every family can access the support they need, schools are always going to be papering over the cracks with limited resources. The families with money will flock to the top schools that are least affected by these issues or they'll opt out and home educate with private tutors. Ultimately the more a school has to paper over cracks in wider services, the less time and fewer resources are available for educating.

RamblingRosieLee · 01/09/2023 15:32

@LolaSmiles
The main chance of breaking those cycles you see in b is by education in sen across the board and proper Senco.

Proper diagnose and support from as early as possible and getting children reading by using flexible reading scheme.

This needs to happen from primary

RamblingRosieLee · 01/09/2023 15:29

@RockaLock

No parent has a chance to try and change an entire school. I. Know one school that is known for its bloody mindedness and yes actually it's a reasonably good school.
However their sen provision was atrocious.
Parents lobbied, tried to educate, wrote everywhere got on governor board... Zilch.

Parents of sen children know the harsh reality of trying to get knowledge into school.
There is absolutely no hope for any other issues.

RockaLock · 01/09/2023 14:51

Yes, I understand all that, and I did say I could see an effect for the class as a whole if the proportion of ex-private pupils in a class was high enough.

But realistically, you are likely to only have a few ex-private pupils per class turning up in each state school. At least, that's what posters on this type of thread seem to always say: local schools wouldn't be overwhelmed, it would only be a handful of extra children per school etc etc.

So I'm still not convinced that forcing lots of private schools to close would result in a noticeable improvement to any individual state school.

LolaSmiles · 01/09/2023 14:23

RockaLock
Because it much easier to educate to a higher level if your intake becomes higher prior attaining, has a higher literacy level, with low to non-existent social issues caused by poor public services, able to work at a curriculum at a higher rate, and there's less time spent on a huge range of pastoral issues.

If a private school closes and those families flock to School A, the families who'd otherwise get School A won't get in and School A will become a private school cohort in all but name.

I'm not a better professional working at School A and School B, but I'm certainly able to offer a better quality education in School A.

Which of my GCSE groups gets a stronger education:

  • The group where I can spend 55 minutes out of 60 teaching, I can circulate well, speak to every child every lesson, the children are regularly attending, there's huge support for homework and revision from home, parents value education and there's a positive culture of home and school working together
  • The group where I regularly have 5 or more students missing from school, others regularly excluded/in isolation, pastoral staff in and out dealing with issues, other interruptions due to non-teaching issues, huge range of literacy levels, inconsistent homework completion, a substantial number of parents who are ambivalent about GCSEs, and a handful of students who will disrupt the learning knowing their parents will argue with me and pick fights

For the children in the second class who want to learn, it doesn't matter how great I am as a teacher, they get a worse deal than the first group.

RockaLock · 01/09/2023 13:14

But, I still don't see how school A has been made intrinsically better.

They are getting better results, sure, but this is due to the parents of that cohort spending money on their children. Is it actually due to anything that the school are doing?

I can see that if you have a class full of highly motivated children who are keen to learn, then this will make the teacher's job easier, so I suppose it might have an effect on overall results if the proportion of such children in a class was high enough.

But even if school A benefits, then as you say, there will be children that would have otherwise gone to school A who will lose out - thus continuing the inequality, only this time it's because of house prices and not the ability to pay school fees.

SurprisedWithAH0RSE · 01/09/2023 12:53

Popsicle42 · 31/08/2023 08:06

I never thought I’d send my children to private school, but after 2 years of horrendous disruption and bullying at her state school with countless meetings with staff and nothing changing, we took the plunge. It has been transformative for her. She is thriving, happy and confident. She can be herself - put herself forward for things, without fear of abuse and repercussions. Maybe she could have got that at another state school, but from my limited experience, I doubt it. State schools seem pretty brutal for a lot of geeky, academic, non-sporty kids.

Although we will give our younger child some say in where he wants to go for secondary school, our preference for him will be to join his sister.

I’m glad that you’ve found somewhere that your daughter is thriving.

And yes, there are lots of academic, geeky, non sporty kids at state schools as well as at private ones. I have two who were very happy at their state secondary,

Same as they are lots of non academic, cool and sporty kids at private schools.

They all just need to find their tribe.

LolaSmiles · 01/09/2023 12:50

RockaLock
It boosts the school because it means the overall attainment of their cohort increases, and it also means that the 'better' state schools will have an increasing number of families who value education highly and have the money to pay inflated house prices.

If I think about two different Year 7 classes I have had in different schools.

School A: Students come from high prior attaining primary schools. Tutors for SATS is quite normal. The feeder primaries have much fewer social issues to contend with that others in the same local authority. Students who join from prep school are often higher prior attaining too. This Year 7 class was almost entirely expected standard with a large proportion of greater depth. Some children are working towards, but they generally have SEN needs and because they're such a small number it's very easy as a classroom teacher to meet their needs. In a mixed ability class I am able to meet the needs to all students well in my subject. The children in this class have good oracy, arrive in Year 7 with strong reading skills, they're good at working with other children, they've got a range of soft skills that means they handle challenges well, and generally can resolve disputes well. The curriculum is challenging, moves quickly and in turn these children are likely to cover a lot between Year 7-11.

School B: Year 7 students come in with highly varied attainment levels. Most are below average, with many leaving primary school with a reading age of upper KS1/LKS2. These children have to access a secondary curriculum from this point. There's a high level of diagnosed and undiagnosed SEN, as well as a high prevalence of poor SEMH behaviours. The school employs parent and family workers as well as a huge pastoral team to pick up the never ending series of issues from outside of school (many of these issues are caused by problems accessing other services). In a class of 30 Year 7 students, only a tiny number come from households where reading is valued. Attendance in this school has been low for decades, just like previous schools in the catchment. Lots of time at the start of the year has to be spent teaching 11/12 year olds how to disagree without being rude, threatening, and verbally abusive. Many of the parents have a low view of schooling and a sizable minority are highly confrontational. On the whole the school is not only having to try to catch up children who are behind educationally, but they're having to try to break complex intergenerational cycles.

School B has a mixed history with it's standards, but locally it's accepted it's doing the best it can with the cohort and they're making some progress. Outcomes are low though.

In the event private schools close, those parents are going to move into School A's catchment. They're simply not going to send their children to School B. Why would they because the overall level of education is lower?

School A will be even more oversubscribed, School A families who lose out due to School A catchment prices astronomically rising will find their children sent elsewhere, (School C, D etc as parents select the next best schools). Nobody concerned about outcomes will choose School B. Some children whose parents haven't the means will be forced into School B, and they'll get a substandard education. Those with the means to home educate and pay for tutors will do that rather than send their child to School B.

Closing private schools isn't going to suddenly make School B better.

RockaLock · 01/09/2023 12:34

Lola, I'm not sure how ex-private school parents tutoring their individual child and paying for enrichment activities for them "boosts the school".

It boosts those children, certainly, and raises the average grades for the school so that on paper it looks better, but for the other children surely nothing has changed. The quality of the teaching or the extra curricular opportunities provided by the school haven't suddenly taken a turn for the better?

Barbadossunset · 01/09/2023 12:07

I mean, how exactly are they meant to do that? I've never seen any actual examples given, other than maybe they might raise some extra funds for the PTA to fund some equipment.

I agree and it’s so patronising to the other parents who are apparently incapable of making improvements without the help of new ex private school parents.

thirdistheonewiththehairychest · 01/09/2023 11:48

RockaLock · 01/09/2023 10:40

I am always a bit puzzled by the view that if private school parents suddenly had to send their child to the local state school, they would get super involved and magically transform the state school into the best school ever.

I mean, how exactly are they meant to do that? I've never seen any actual examples given, other than maybe they might raise some extra funds for the PTA to fund some equipment.

It is surely far more likely that they will simply pay for private tutoring for their child, which will do nothing to address the privilege issues that are so often raised.

A private primary school in my city recently closed as it went bankrupt. A lot of parents chose to homeschool instead of sending them to the state school.

fireplavefish · 01/09/2023 11:16

This reply has been deleted

Sorry all, but the OP is a previously banned troll with a new tale each namechange. We've deleted their threads and posts.

Cyclebabble · 01/09/2023 11:03

This reply has been deleted

Sorry all, but the OP is a previously banned troll with a new tale each namechange. We've deleted their threads and posts.

Actually most of the data shows that there is a correlation between migrant communities and high performing schools. Statistically you would do better and be pushed harder in a class with a good proportion of migrant children.

LolaSmiles · 01/09/2023 10:53

RockaLock
It wouldn't magically improve the struggling schools, but having worked in an area with great state schools and great private ones, my observation is that the parents who value education (and have the financial means to buy in an expensive catchment) will want their children in the great state school. Those parents will also fund a lot of enrichment opportunities and fund a range of private tutors to plug the gaps in the state system. Because the pupils are higher attaining on the whole, the school gets a boost through the school.

If the private schools closed in that area, the parents with money will want to go to the great state schools. The catchment will probably shrink down further and become even more elite.

It might improve the school because you're getting a higher amount of families who value education and have the means to top up, but it definitely won't help other state schools.

JonSnowedUnder · 01/09/2023 10:47

The thing is, this is so area specific. In our area, for my academic, quiet asd boy there are no grammars, one shit state school and one okish massive state school. That's it state wise. We've chosen to go down the private secondary route based on what we felt was best for him. I went to private secondary but wouldn't necessarily recommend it to everyone.

We had about 5 excellent primary schools in our area so didn't consider private. If we'd had a good state school to chose for high school we probably wouldn't have looked at the private options.

So many people on this thread have such a stereotypical view of private schools though. Some schools are very elite and full of extremely wealthy people (some who are nice, some will be twats) but there are lots of private schools which are full of children with parents who have worked hard and made sacrifices because they feel its best for their family.

RockaLock · 01/09/2023 10:40

I am always a bit puzzled by the view that if private school parents suddenly had to send their child to the local state school, they would get super involved and magically transform the state school into the best school ever.

I mean, how exactly are they meant to do that? I've never seen any actual examples given, other than maybe they might raise some extra funds for the PTA to fund some equipment.

It is surely far more likely that they will simply pay for private tutoring for their child, which will do nothing to address the privilege issues that are so often raised.

Positive41 · 01/09/2023 10:38

DryHair · 31/08/2023 09:08

Mine have just left. It was a huge financial struggle as we were both public sector workers. Our local London secondary did not feel safe so our principles went out of the window. My kids seemed to be the only ones who had never flown long-haul or gone skiing, though were never bullied for it. I am still aware it was a privilege to pay the fees.

It has been worth every penny. They have made friends for life and it has been lovely. My kids are not cool but said that even the cool, wealthy and sporty kids were nice. They left school with full sets of 9s and A stars and have all gone to RG universities and Oxbridge. They are inquiring and love to learn.

And because of us, they are grounded.
They are mixed race kids with public sector parents. Maybe this has ‘saved’ them from the posh/elitist mindset. Who knows. But they are kind and decent young adults with no airs or graces.

People who say all private school people are awful are prejudiced. There is a big range. And of course many people you meet, you have no idea where they went to school. Even the nice ones may have been to private school!

My lot recognise their privilege. They had online schooling throughout the pandemic. Even the last couple of years, they have been unaffected by strikes and teacher shortages. It’s a huge ‘top’ London school so they may have been luckier then smaller private schools with recruitment and retention issues.

I have no regrets but wish the local state offering had been better. It’s been an expensive time and I wish we hadn’t ‘needed’ it.

You sound like an amazing parent that did your children well.

Good luck to you all.