Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you prefer private school?

396 replies

Dontbeamenace · 31/08/2023 00:52

I'm sure I would prefer private school for my children. Would it matter to you if money was no cost?

OP posts:
G5000 · 04/09/2023 08:18

Yes, as a teacher. It's hard going with 8

Yes, fair enough, I was indeed thinking from my DC's perspective and not so much concerned with what's easier for teacher. I guess in some circumstances 1-1 might be more challening for the teacher indeed than just telling kids to discuss in groups.

Charlotteowensdodgydad · 04/09/2023 08:16

All academic isn’t it. Vast majority couldn’t afford private education even if they wanted to send DC there. For most folk there’s no alternative to a poorly performing state school because of the cost, even if you drive a knackered old car, never go on holiday or have takeaways. For most it’s just out of the question.

SlippySarah · 04/09/2023 07:56

There was a girl who joined my state 6th form college from private boarding school. She stood out like a sore thumb and it was painful to watch her having to assimilate to "real life" after years of privilege. She ended up dropping out of two different good universities because she knew her parents would pick up the pieces financially and nothing ever met her high expectations. I don't think private school did her any favours.

Fizbosshoes · 04/09/2023 07:43

My DD is at state school and due to the subjects she chose there's only about 8 of them in all her A level classes. In the creative subject it means there's lots of interaction and discussion of ideas and sketchbooks with the teacher.

jeaux90 · 04/09/2023 07:26

Boomboom22 · 03/09/2023 22:27

As a teacher 12 is too small a class size, even at a level. 18 to 24 is perfect up to gcse, 14 to 18 for a level, to facilitate group discussions etc.

Um small classes is the reason I pay for private school and DD14 is flourishing in class of 12. She has ADHD and ASD so large classes and schools are overwhelming for her.

PostMasting · 04/09/2023 00:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

surreygirl1987 · 04/09/2023 00:53

As a teacher 12 is too small a class size, even at a level. 18 to 24 is perfect up to gcse, 14 to 18 for a level, to facilitate group discussions etc

You can't be serious? I teach a class of 9 and it's brilliant.. including wonderful, lively discussion and debate. My class of 10 last year saw more than half of them get full marks in one of the two essay tasks!!

Boomboom22 · 03/09/2023 22:38

Yes, as a teacher. It's hard going with 8 or less and lots of 1-1 in place of other methods. I'm sure the students don't know 🤣

babbscrabbs · 03/09/2023 22:31

Boomboom22 · 03/09/2023 22:27

As a teacher 12 is too small a class size, even at a level. 18 to 24 is perfect up to gcse, 14 to 18 for a level, to facilitate group discussions etc.

I disagree. In my school I did two A Levels with class sizes smaller than 8 and we all got top marks with distinction in one area. We could all have easygoing, grown up conversations collectively (sometimes with two teachers at a time!) on our topics and could focus on any weak points needing improvement virtually 1-1.

Boomboom22 · 03/09/2023 22:27

As a teacher 12 is too small a class size, even at a level. 18 to 24 is perfect up to gcse, 14 to 18 for a level, to facilitate group discussions etc.

prescribingmum · 03/09/2023 22:03

TheEverdelightfulsamantha · 03/09/2023 07:54

No - I could afford it but wouldn’t. I don’t want to live in a world where you can buy something as fundamental to the structure of society as education - ‘better’ education for the rich and worse for the poor?! That just makes inequality in society worse. Also, the worse thing is the sense of entitlement and lack of self awareness that comes from private education - I work at a university and whilst I meet a wide variety of wonderful young people - a small proportion of privately education students genuinely do not understand the privilege that they have, make choices without any understanding of the limitations that others face, and seem to live as if the world will just give them what they need as it has for the first 20 years of their lives. They often really struggle with failure, like poor grades, because they haven’t been allowed to fail at anything for their whole childhood so haven’t developed resilience, only to be picked up by a safety net that just pays for the next degree, or a year of travelling or whatever. And - I genuinely think that exams grades from public schools are worth less - and university admissions boards are starting to see that too - look at the number of contextual offers - entry to law at Edinburgh for example. top grades at GSCE when there were ten people in your class, compared to 33 as a starter, and the assumption that you had an easy and privileged life (when, as we all know, many parent scrape to send kids to private school, and kids at private school may also have experienced trauma etc) - means people which judge you more harshly, so private school is longer a sure thing for better outcomes

Another person who ironically is unable to identify their own privilege in having access to decent state schools whilst condemning others for the same thing.

Entitlement and lack of self-awareness comes from indulgence and poor parenting. It is not restricted to those who have been privately educated. There is a small proportion of ALL students who don't understand how fortunate they are or how the other half live. They all have mum and dad bankrolling them for as long as they desire. It is just as likely a bright student from state sector has not experienced failure in their lives (in my experience, private schools mark more harshly for internal exams)

Either you don't really work in a university or you are pretty poor at your job to make such sweeping generalisations about those who have been privately educated. The fact that you use the term public school and state school interchangeably make me think the former is the case.

I don't disagree that the same exam grade from a private school can be worth less than from a state school. Students in some state schools need to overcome far more to achieve the same grade and it is a good thing for this to be recognised by universities and employers. The places should go to the best person for it regardless of where they have been educated. As a parent who has chosen private education, I have not done it for the grades. I have done it for the overall education experience and have no problem with contextual offers for state educated students.

Barbadossunset · 03/09/2023 21:14

TheEverdelightfulsamantha · Today 07:54

Also, the worse thing is the sense of entitlement and lack of self awareness that comes from private education.

Im sure you get great pleasure from putting these ghastly poshos in their place and telling them what’s what, eh?

JMSA · 03/09/2023 20:38

My 3 daughters have been through the private system. I work in the state.
My conclusion is that NO school is perfect, whether you pay for it or not.

MariaVT65 · 03/09/2023 20:09

jeaux90 · 03/09/2023 20:05

@Regholdsworthswaterbed I'm not scaremongering. The stats speak for themselves as do the statistics on girls achieving better results in single sex environments.

This was my personal experience.

I went to a state mixed junior school where a boy liked to expose his genitals to me, and a group of boys tried to beat me up with a scooter.

I then went to a private girls school. There was obv a slight bit of bitchiness but I didn’t endure any bullying and certainly no physical bullying.

My local state all-girls school where I live now also far outperforms the boys school

jeaux90 · 03/09/2023 20:05

@Regholdsworthswaterbed I'm not scaremongering. The stats speak for themselves as do the statistics on girls achieving better results in single sex environments.

TheaBrandt · 03/09/2023 20:03

Mine go to a girls state school. I am happy with single sex overall but get pangs when I see my friends (in the mixed sex schools) kids in jolly mixed groups. Dd says the boys at all boys state are the worst boys the boys from the mixed schools (state and private) are much nicer. . So i do question it sometimes.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 03/09/2023 19:53

jeaux90 · 03/09/2023 19:39

Sending my DD14 to private all girls school was the best decision.

No way would I send a girl to mixed secondary school given the current sexual assault statistics.

Yes because girls are known for being so lovely to each other aren't they. Stop treating all boys like they are predators, it's scaremongering and it'll do your daughter no favours.

SlippySarah · 03/09/2023 19:49

My DC go to an excellent state school, have lots of friends and are happy there and predicted to do well. However DD would benefit a lot from a calmer environment without so many disruptions so if a private school could guarantee that I would consider it but they can't.

G5000 · 03/09/2023 19:45

you are deeply naive if you think there aren’t kids in private school who are entirely unengaged and determined to make things difficult for all those around them

In our school, those kids are asked to find alternative options.

Baconisdelicious · 03/09/2023 19:40

And even a mediocre teacher, but with a class of 12 engaged students will in my opinion, achieve better results and happier environment

you are deeply naive if you think there aren’t kids in private school who are entirely unengaged and determined to make things difficult for all those around them .

jeaux90 · 03/09/2023 19:39

Sending my DD14 to private all girls school was the best decision.

No way would I send a girl to mixed secondary school given the current sexual assault statistics.

G5000 · 03/09/2023 19:29

As a state school teacher, it’s hard not to feel a bit disappointed that so many people feel we’re not fit to teach their children. There are so many great teachers out there!

Of course there are. But the local school my DC went to had 35 kids in class, several of them disruptive and not interested in learning one bit. Even the best teacher can only do so much. And even a mediocre teacher, but with a class of 12 engaged students will in my opinion, achieve better results and happier environment.

G5000 · 03/09/2023 19:22

a small proportion of privately education students genuinely do not understand the privilege that they have - but are you sure it's because they went to private school, or because they come from a wealthy family with indulging parents? I grew up in a country where private education didn't exist, but spoiled kids still did.

HelpaFriend85 · 03/09/2023 15:25

Society has become more meritocratic BUT there are still huge gaps. I genuinely believe if you are of colour and a female you are still held back, I work in an arena where I see many equal CVs from ethnic minorities where they have not quite achieved what their white counter parts have, where this changes but only slightly is via education. I have increasingly noticed children from Private schools of Asian origin are not so behind their white counterparts even ahead, Im
not talking Rishi Sunak level but I doubt if he’d gone to his local comp he’d be PM today.

However 10 years ago he wouldn’t have been PM even with the same path he’s taken. Therefore I genuinely believe if you are off colour and want ‘access’ to a part of society you just can’t access then pay for the education.

Mercibuckets · 03/09/2023 13:24

Depends on the school and depends on the fit. I went to a genuinely mixed comprehensive in the local town from a rural primary. Nothing special at all but I had a great state education. Me and my brothers were the first generation of our family to go to university and have gone on to become a doctor, QC and university lecturer. More generally - despite normal ups and downs - we’re all quite close and have had good lives. I even have a few friends in adulthood who stayed in the village I grew up in. I would love a similar option for DC but it doesn’t exist where I am now:

Local academy gets top grades but is exceptionally strict and hard driving. OFSTED seem to love it. We were just outside the small catchment which is a mix of v expensive housing and social housing. To be honest I thought it would be a bad fit for DC. I don’t like the hot housing vibe and competition - good grades aren’t everything.

Academically selective options are single sex. DC probably could have attempted entrance exams but people tutor heavily for these here. I suppose we could do the same but not what I want for my children eg. Lots tutor from age 7. 1 tutor gave me a flyer for one of his tutees getting an A* in maths at age 9 and banged on about the importance of us + DC being committed to the process and hours of homework 😬. I’ve been told the boys school in particular has good pastoral care (much more relaxed and progressive than the academy) once you’re in so might have been good if DC had gone and the pace suited them.

The most local local has a GCSE pass rate of less than 40% and there was a knife problem a few years ago (not heard anything recently to be fair).

We have gone private. DC are thriving, happy, bright and doing well academically. Most private schools don’t aspire to turn out the Burlington Club types that have messed up our country, but they do offer families choices in a way the current state system doesn’t.

Think that’s why I’m posting and it’s so long sorry. In my 20s and childless I’d have been ideologically opposed to private school, truly believed you couldn’t get better than state education and assumed those who went were snobs buying privilege so they didn’t have to mix with poorer people. A bit older and with my actual children in the mix the decision is more pragmatic based on the actual schools available. Although I know it’s not a choice open to everyone.