Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You're so lucky if you don't have a mortgage"

284 replies

NoTheyAreNotLucky · 30/08/2023 21:03

This is nothing to do with mortgage rates or cost of living, it's about people who are so caught up in their own little bubble of self pity and victimhood, and who expect the whole world to feel sorry for them.

I've heard this so many times lately - "you're so lucky you don't have a mortgage to pay" but it's just such a stupid thing to say. At best it's thoughtless, at worst it's heartless and cruel.

  • My next door neighbour - she was brought up in the 1950's in a very deprived inner city area with an abusive father and an alcoholic mother, she married a good man who gave her safety and security, but who died in his forties. She was married and widowed a second time. Home is her haven, her security, but she owns it and is mortgage-free. Is she "lucky"?
  • My old school friend - she paid off her mortgage at the age of 24. Both her parents died within 6 months of each other and the inheritance paid off her mortgage. Is she "lucky"
  • A lady i used to work for threw herself into work as a way to cope with the death of her child and the breakdown of her marriage. She worked hard and her mortgage is paid off. Is she "lucky"?
  • And i've left this one until last because i'll be dripping tears on the keyboard before i've finished. I have a friend who's been told a couple of times how lucky she is to own her house mortgage free. She just nods and smiles and makes an excuse to walk away and goes home and shuts herself in her house and sobs her fucking heart out. She's so lucky that she and her kids have a nice house, she's so lucky she has no mortgage to pay, she's so lucky she doesn't have to worry about paying the bills, she's so lucky that her husbands life insurance paid it off after he was killed by a speeding driver while he was out with the dog. . Yeah, tell her again how fucking lucky she is.

I didn't intend this post to turn into a rant, and it's not directed at people who talk about their problems and worries. It's not directed at posters on here. People are struggling financially, I know, I get it. And it's good to talk, and it's good to ask for support when you need it. But to tell someone face to face that they should feel lucky? To whinge and whine and play the victim because one aspect of your life is hard when you know so little about their history or their family circumstances?

Rant over. I wish i could say i felt better for it but I don't. It just makes me so angry.

OP posts:
RobertaFirmino · 30/08/2023 21:51

DeNeushoornHeeftEenHoorn · 30/08/2023 21:10

You do get that there are people with terrible lives of deprivation or experiences of early bereavement who don’t get free houses out of it?

What a cunty thing to say. Free houses? I'll tell you now, I would rather live in a cardboard box if it meant I could have my Dad back.

Seashellies · 30/08/2023 21:51

user76541055773 · 30/08/2023 21:35

How is it coming up so often? I can’t imagine the conversation that leads to this.

I don’t think any of my friends or colleagues know whether I have a mortgage or not.

Yeah exactly, I know if close friends have a mortgage or not but not through talking about it at length, just with it coming up in conversation as we know eachother so well once or twice, but no idea and genuinely don't care if other people do or not! I agree with a PP though that plenty of people suffer horrific loss and don't recieve an inheritance/insurance or whatever else- if someone is dead they are dead, not having as many financial worries is better than the alternative of them being gone and having nothing. So I suppose it is still fortunate even though the circumstances are not.

Naominumbers · 30/08/2023 21:51

As pp have said, plenty of people have shit luck and still don't get a chunk of money at the end of it. Loads who have sad lives and still have to pay to live somewhere. Stop whining. You sound incredibly ungrateful.

R4ID · 30/08/2023 21:50

thdskdrggs · 30/08/2023 21:44

@R4ID to answer your question aimed at someone else, you are not lucky to be in poor health (and I am genuinely sorry about that) but you are lucky you have a DH who financially supports you, there are disabled people living in poverty no doubt making their lives even harder than they would be if they didn't have to worry about money. No one is saying you're lucky overall, but I suspect, when people are saying things like that, they're trying to highlight positives to you from a place of good intention, not necessarily trying to diminish your experience.

And some people just say daft things without really thinking about what they're saying. It's really not worth overthinking.

I don’t overthink it. When someone says it to me I just think it’s unbelievably rude to comment on someone’s else situation without knowing all of the facts. Using an excuse of ‘not thinking about what they’re saying’ is not acceptable imo. They don’t need to give an opinion if it’s not asked for.

thdskdrggs · 30/08/2023 21:49

Asked why I was lucky when borrowed money and paid it back over 21 years

Because some people aren't able to to pass credit checks, perhaps they don't earn enough, perhaps they had a difficult upbringing and never had good financial planning modelled to them, perhaps they are disabled and struggle to maintain a job that earns enough for a mortgage, perhaps they never had a partner they could share a mortgage with, perhaps they suffered trauma that made committing to a job and mortgage difficult.

It is always important to remain humble, no matter how hard you worked for something, you've always had a bit of luck one way or another too.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 30/08/2023 21:49

Depends how you look at it.....I mean I know of someone who lost her entire world to a drink driver, her husband and dc were wiped out in an instant. She now struggles to pay the rent on the only home they ever had, to lose that would be to lose them too......would she be lucky if she owned it outright ? No, probably not. But her life would be a damn sight easier, it would take away a huge chunk of worry.

ActDottie · 30/08/2023 21:49

In those cases they aren’t lucky.

There are some cases though where people are lucky, someone I know for example was given £750k by her parents to buy a house… she’s mortgage free and I’d say very lucky!

Winnipeggy · 30/08/2023 21:48

It's a tough one. I was nearly killed in a car accident 10 years ago and it has changed my life significantly. I got enough compensation to buy a house mortgage free and although I had to go through horrendous circumstances I do feel grateful day to day that I don't have to worry about the stress of paying a mortgage. I understand where you're coming from though, I hated people telling me at the time I was 'lucky to survive' because I felt like the unluckiest person in the world at that time (was hit by driver who over spun a corner onto my side of the road and hit me head on). In my experience it's not said with malice though, and if anyone said I was lucky not to pay a mortgage I don't think I'd get upset, maybe just gently remind them that I didn't exactly win the lottery.

Katmai · 30/08/2023 21:48

DeNeushoornHeeftEenHoorn · 30/08/2023 21:10

You do get that there are people with terrible lives of deprivation or experiences of early bereavement who don’t get free houses out of it?

Yes, but this thread is about only one aspect of that.

SignsOfWeakness · 30/08/2023 21:47

I don't have mortgage due to an inheritance from parents' estate. But I am lucky in this current climate not to have one.

Yes, I'd rather have my parents but having a secure housing situation is a great privilege.

CherryCokeFanatic · 30/08/2023 21:46

Yeah but presumably the people they are saying it to are just older people who have paid it off or are rich or have family money that paid it off or inheritance from relatives who lived to a grand old age. So yes they are lucky.

TheSkull · 30/08/2023 21:45

A shocking indictment of society to consider someone “lucky” because they don’t have a mortgage. What about all the other shit there is to worry about. Money and houses have become the be all and end all. People are more important than money

lemonyaid · 30/08/2023 21:44

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 30/08/2023 21:34

I think lucky is just a word used without much thought, when people mean fortunate

Good point. Like "at least"

thdskdrggs · 30/08/2023 21:44

@R4ID to answer your question aimed at someone else, you are not lucky to be in poor health (and I am genuinely sorry about that) but you are lucky you have a DH who financially supports you, there are disabled people living in poverty no doubt making their lives even harder than they would be if they didn't have to worry about money. No one is saying you're lucky overall, but I suspect, when people are saying things like that, they're trying to highlight positives to you from a place of good intention, not necessarily trying to diminish your experience.

And some people just say daft things without really thinking about what they're saying. It's really not worth overthinking.

Saschka · 30/08/2023 21:44

My dad died when I was 12. Obviously it wasn’t lucky he died, but it absolutely was lucky he’d made good financial provision for us, because there’s no way DM could have managed the mortgage herself, and we’d have lost our home on top of everything else.

Towdalinenow · 30/08/2023 21:42

Everyone’s circumstances are different, you don’t know the full story.

A friend inherited a lot of money from a relative and paid off mortgage. I’d say that’s lucky.

I stand to inherit several hundred thousands of pounds. But my parents slogged their guts out working on their own business throughout my childhood, I missed out on play dates, I was lonely, I had to go to work with them every weekend. Whereas my children have had a great childhood in comparison, are much happier and healthier than I was. I’m not sure the inheritance is worth it.

sheworemellowyellow · 30/08/2023 21:41

What a weird position to take.

Nobody is saying “oh you’re so lucky your husband died and left you with enough money to pay off your mortgage”.

People are saying “of all the stressors in life, you’re fortunate/lucky you don’t have paying the mortgage as one”.

It takes a particular mindset to warp the latter into the former. One of victimhood, one might say. You’ve lost perspective. Not everything is about you/your friends’ misfortunes. Everyone has stuff they’re dealing with.

TwoRoadsDiverged · 30/08/2023 21:41

I think it’s just a Figure of speech.

Of course the situations and anecdotes you outline are sad and people feel compassion - but as others have said these same stories happen (and worse) all the time - except these folk don’t get inheritance and life insurance to allow the families to not have to worry about money/pay off the mortgage. So it can be argued that, yes, they are ‘lucky’. It doesn’t mean their pain and suffering is not valid and they don’t deserve support and compassion.

The situations are sad and in life few of us manage to avoid heartache and sadness - but having money to pay off the mortgage would help.

Wizadora25 · 30/08/2023 21:40

Thanks for the post OP. I've been stressing today about our mortgage and i needed to hear this. It puts it into perspective. I still have my child, a husband, parents etc. It could be a lot worse.

LemonSqueezy0 · 30/08/2023 21:39

I feel that you are hugely missing the point, and I'm not sure if it's on purpose or not....

I'd much rather have financial security, and more security in my accommodation while dealing with any of those awful situations. It's something I would want to gift to my loved ones, or would appreciate if I were gifted that during any similar situation.... Worrying about clumsy or inarticulate comments /assumptions would be so far down my list of things I'd be worried about, I don't know if it would register.

Who are these people that somehow know the intimate Detail of mortgages and financials but not of death and heartache that has befallen these same people?

echt · 30/08/2023 21:39

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 30/08/2023 21:34

I think lucky is just a word used without much thought, when people mean fortunate

But those two words are synonyms.

At the literal level people who are in the position the OP describes are lucky as it's chance that gave them their house. However the overlay of its being good is what makes it bloody rude to say.

Full disclosure. My mortgage is paid off due to the sudden and unexpected death of my DH. No-one's pointed out my good luck though. Must be my death-ray stare.

AnneValentine · 30/08/2023 21:39

thdskdrggs · 30/08/2023 21:10

Well imagine being in all those situations AND having a mortgage, it is a privilege to be mortgage free, that's not to say you would choose it to be that way, I'm sure many would pay to have loved ones back, but the happiest people are the ones who recognise what they have, as well as what they don't.

Stop over analysing things, it's just something people say, they're not thinking about it in that level of detail.

This. Exactly this.

SnowWhiteAndTheTwoKids · 30/08/2023 21:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

rwalker · 30/08/2023 21:38

I was told I was lucky because we have no mortgage
Asked why I was lucky when borrowed money and paid it back over 21 years

thdskdrggs · 30/08/2023 21:37

think lucky is just a word used without much thought, when people mean fortunate

Agree, it must be exhausting to be so offended all the time. It's pretty self involved to think people are evaluating your life to the nth degree to ensure they precision their words so perfectly, news flash, people just aren't thinking that much, they're just saying things in what is probably a difficult conversation.