Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You're so lucky if you don't have a mortgage"

284 replies

NoTheyAreNotLucky · 30/08/2023 21:03

This is nothing to do with mortgage rates or cost of living, it's about people who are so caught up in their own little bubble of self pity and victimhood, and who expect the whole world to feel sorry for them.

I've heard this so many times lately - "you're so lucky you don't have a mortgage to pay" but it's just such a stupid thing to say. At best it's thoughtless, at worst it's heartless and cruel.

  • My next door neighbour - she was brought up in the 1950's in a very deprived inner city area with an abusive father and an alcoholic mother, she married a good man who gave her safety and security, but who died in his forties. She was married and widowed a second time. Home is her haven, her security, but she owns it and is mortgage-free. Is she "lucky"?
  • My old school friend - she paid off her mortgage at the age of 24. Both her parents died within 6 months of each other and the inheritance paid off her mortgage. Is she "lucky"
  • A lady i used to work for threw herself into work as a way to cope with the death of her child and the breakdown of her marriage. She worked hard and her mortgage is paid off. Is she "lucky"?
  • And i've left this one until last because i'll be dripping tears on the keyboard before i've finished. I have a friend who's been told a couple of times how lucky she is to own her house mortgage free. She just nods and smiles and makes an excuse to walk away and goes home and shuts herself in her house and sobs her fucking heart out. She's so lucky that she and her kids have a nice house, she's so lucky she has no mortgage to pay, she's so lucky she doesn't have to worry about paying the bills, she's so lucky that her husbands life insurance paid it off after he was killed by a speeding driver while he was out with the dog. . Yeah, tell her again how fucking lucky she is.

I didn't intend this post to turn into a rant, and it's not directed at people who talk about their problems and worries. It's not directed at posters on here. People are struggling financially, I know, I get it. And it's good to talk, and it's good to ask for support when you need it. But to tell someone face to face that they should feel lucky? To whinge and whine and play the victim because one aspect of your life is hard when you know so little about their history or their family circumstances?

Rant over. I wish i could say i felt better for it but I don't. It just makes me so angry.

OP posts:
harriethoyle · 30/08/2023 21:36

HeadNorth · 30/08/2023 21:29

My child died suddenly and tragically. We still have to work to pay our mortgage. We wouldn’t have our child back, but we would still be luckier than we currently are if we didn’t have a mortgage. People can experience terrible tragedy and have to cope with financial pressures on top.
I think your rant is shallow and ill thought through, to the point of offensiveness.

I'm so sorry @HeadNorth 🌻🌻

user76541055773 · 30/08/2023 21:35

How is it coming up so often? I can’t imagine the conversation that leads to this.

I don’t think any of my friends or colleagues know whether I have a mortgage or not.

thaegumathteth · 30/08/2023 21:35

How do you even know whether so many people have mortgages or not and how do other people know??

Also you just sound a bit like you want to be outraged and melodramatic on their behalf tbh.

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 30/08/2023 21:34

I think lucky is just a word used without much thought, when people mean fortunate

lemonyaid · 30/08/2023 21:33

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 30/08/2023 21:27

@lemonyaid

Not lucky, fortunate. Better word.

Yes

R4ID · 30/08/2023 21:31

readbooksdrinktea · 30/08/2023 21:30

Quite.

But why should that mean that people who do get free houses are called lucky? Luck has nothing to do with either set of circumstances.

Solitaryasanoyster · 30/08/2023 21:30

continentallentil · 30/08/2023 21:16

Oh give over.

Awful things happen, and the people you refer to have had some shit luck, but then the people who still have mortgages probably have too.

Life is easier if you have a home that can’t be taken from you. When someone says that they are just stating a fact, not playing the victim (which is meaningless in this context).

Don’t create drama where there is none. There are enough real problems in the world.

This.

readbooksdrinktea · 30/08/2023 21:30

DeNeushoornHeeftEenHoorn · 30/08/2023 21:10

You do get that there are people with terrible lives of deprivation or experiences of early bereavement who don’t get free houses out of it?

Quite.

SabbatWheel · 30/08/2023 21:29

What a pile of mawkish crap.
MIL died at 63 leaving a very small legacy that enabled us to escape our negative equity burdened previous house. Nobody would describe any similar situation as lucky, it was just a fact of our lives.

SophieIsHereToday · 30/08/2023 21:29

NorwayLass · 30/08/2023 21:27

All these situations are better mortgage free than enduring with a mortgage or while renting. Losing parents, husband, child is bad enough but to face this loss without financial security creates added anxieties

That's super concise and well put

HeadNorth · 30/08/2023 21:29

My child died suddenly and tragically. We still have to work to pay our mortgage. We wouldn’t have our child back, but we would still be luckier than we currently are if we didn’t have a mortgage. People can experience terrible tragedy and have to cope with financial pressures on top.
I think your rant is shallow and ill thought through, to the point of offensiveness.

violetcuriosity · 30/08/2023 21:29

Well, yes in those situations it would be incredibly unkind to say that to the person. However, I have been in some horrific situations (partner in a coma in ICU for months, house nearly repossessed because I didn't know his banking details and mortgage coming out of my account and too traumatised to try and deal with the bank) and I would have seen me having no mortgage as one positive in my life. People are so quick to criticise and see the worst in others, maybe the people saying they're lucky are in horrific situations themselves.

Clefable · 30/08/2023 21:28

@lemonyaid But it's often someone else's sound financial planning. That's where the luck happens. I didn't do anything to earn my inheritance or do any financial planning. It was luck of birth. Not to say I am not very grateful for it and glad for it, of course. But it was my mum's hard work, not mine.

Here is the previous thread I mentioned: Inheritance treated as a 'hand out' http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4868118-inheritance-treated-as-a-hand-out

Dotcheck · 30/08/2023 21:27

OP why is it that those people are sharing such personal financial information? I would be far more likely to tell someone both my parents had died than to say I’m mortgage free. << disclaimer: I’m not mortgage free>>

I guess I’m saying that if the people saying ‘you’re lucky’ know the circumstances behind being mortgage free, and they still say it, then of course they are dicks.

NorwayLass · 30/08/2023 21:27

All these situations are better mortgage free than enduring with a mortgage or while renting. Losing parents, husband, child is bad enough but to face this loss without financial security creates added anxieties

SophieIsHereToday · 30/08/2023 21:27

NoTheyAreNotLucky · 30/08/2023 21:03

This is nothing to do with mortgage rates or cost of living, it's about people who are so caught up in their own little bubble of self pity and victimhood, and who expect the whole world to feel sorry for them.

I've heard this so many times lately - "you're so lucky you don't have a mortgage to pay" but it's just such a stupid thing to say. At best it's thoughtless, at worst it's heartless and cruel.

  • My next door neighbour - she was brought up in the 1950's in a very deprived inner city area with an abusive father and an alcoholic mother, she married a good man who gave her safety and security, but who died in his forties. She was married and widowed a second time. Home is her haven, her security, but she owns it and is mortgage-free. Is she "lucky"?
  • My old school friend - she paid off her mortgage at the age of 24. Both her parents died within 6 months of each other and the inheritance paid off her mortgage. Is she "lucky"
  • A lady i used to work for threw herself into work as a way to cope with the death of her child and the breakdown of her marriage. She worked hard and her mortgage is paid off. Is she "lucky"?
  • And i've left this one until last because i'll be dripping tears on the keyboard before i've finished. I have a friend who's been told a couple of times how lucky she is to own her house mortgage free. She just nods and smiles and makes an excuse to walk away and goes home and shuts herself in her house and sobs her fucking heart out. She's so lucky that she and her kids have a nice house, she's so lucky she has no mortgage to pay, she's so lucky she doesn't have to worry about paying the bills, she's so lucky that her husbands life insurance paid it off after he was killed by a speeding driver while he was out with the dog. . Yeah, tell her again how fucking lucky she is.

I didn't intend this post to turn into a rant, and it's not directed at people who talk about their problems and worries. It's not directed at posters on here. People are struggling financially, I know, I get it. And it's good to talk, and it's good to ask for support when you need it. But to tell someone face to face that they should feel lucky? To whinge and whine and play the victim because one aspect of your life is hard when you know so little about their history or their family circumstances?

Rant over. I wish i could say i felt better for it but I don't. It just makes me so angry.

Well yes, they are lucky that house prices were much cheaper then the house was bought, so the the mortgage could be paid off. They were unlucky for their other circumstances

If the same people were 20 years younger in the same circumstances. They would still be unlucky for their circumstances. And they might not own a house, which would make them less lucky for but having a stable home

Whataretheodds · 30/08/2023 21:27

It is possible to be lucky to be mortgage free and for that to be for a totally unenviable reason.

Who are these people declaring other people's luck, how do they know so much about your friends' finances?

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 30/08/2023 21:27

@lemonyaid

Not lucky, fortunate. Better word.

lemonyaid · 30/08/2023 21:26

Towdalinenow · 30/08/2023 21:25

You should retaliate with “well you’re lucky to actually have a mortgage, a lot of the younger generation will be trapped in a cycle of high rent for life!”

Personal tragedy can bring financial benefits and I guess for that, the berveaived is lucky that they don’t have to cope with financial problems on top of the trauma and grief. So in this way, they are lucky… not that their relatives died, but that they were shielded from financial hardship. A lot of people are t.

It's not luck though. It's sound financial planning.

Flopsythebunny · 30/08/2023 21:26

I agree with you op.
I paid my mortgage off with my life insurance that paid out when I was diagnosed with incurable cancer.
I've got 8 years to go to get my state pension so I'll never be able to enjoy the fruits of 40 years of working either

R4ID · 30/08/2023 21:25

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 30/08/2023 21:20

Of course people who don't have a mortgage are lucky!

Doesn't mean that the circumstances that got them there are.

You do know that bad things happen to people who do have mortgages too right?

Lots of people have the awful circumstances you've described, and have the weight of a mortgage or massive rent to pay also.

There's so much wrong with your post I don't know where to start.

What do you mean by ‘they are lucky’? If someone said I was lucky I would take it that they meant it was down to luck that I was in that position otherwise how else can it be lucky?

Lucky - having, bringing, or resulting from good luck.

lemonyaid · 30/08/2023 21:25

Gosh that's hit me hard OP.

I'll be mindful in future - I don't think I've ever told someone they are lucky they don't have a mortgage bit I'll be sure not to.

Clefable · 30/08/2023 21:25

There was a long discussion a week or two ago where someone took issue with the idea of an inheritance being 'lucky'. I imagine this will rehash all the same ideas.

Personally, I just split the things. I'm not lucky my mum is dead at 69 and won't get to see her grandchildren grow up. I am lucky to be in line for enough money to pay off our mortgage and then some. The two things aren't linked other than one had to happen to allow the second. Lots of people lose loved ones and are left with nothing.

So I am both lucky and unlucky in different ways.

Towdalinenow · 30/08/2023 21:25

You should retaliate with “well you’re lucky to actually have a mortgage, a lot of the younger generation will be trapped in a cycle of high rent for life!”

Personal tragedy can bring financial benefits and I guess for that, the berveaived is lucky that they don’t have to cope with financial problems on top of the trauma and grief. So in this way, they are lucky… not that their relatives died, but that they were shielded from financial hardship. A lot of people are t.

lljkk · 30/08/2023 21:25

yabu, what Starlight said is perfect.