Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to manage adult DSD reclaiming her childhood room when she no longer lives at home?

133 replies

zazas · 30/08/2023 20:34

My DSD who is 23 next month is currently moving out of staff accommodation where she has been living as part of her job since she finished university in May 2022. She asked if we could store some of her things as she is going traveling for a month or so before she moves to another country for further training. Not a problem as we have a large storage space and her siblings already store their things there - we are talking kitchen stuff / small furniture / books etc.

However while we have been away on a holiday she has moved her things back into her old room that had been converted into a guest room and completely reconfigured it and decorated it with her things - including furniture (the existing furniture in there has been squeezed up against the walls). In fairness some of her small things have remained in the room since she left for university and it is always the room she stays in when she returns. She hasn't mentioned that she is wanting to move back home for a period (although she is welcomed) as she is 100% leaving in October after her travels - as far as we know.

My DH (her DF) and I are a little confused to how to deal with it. We are keen to keep this room as the guest room and continue with doing up the house (in our style) now that the older children who are in their twenties are living independently (we have one 16 years old DD still at home) but we also sensitive to the emotional connection young adults have to their home. It is worth mentioning that we live relatively rurally and not close to employment or educational opportunities, so we aren't offering a home in an area that young people would struggle to find accommodation.

Do we just accept that this is what she needs right now and accommodate or do we mention that while she is always welcome to come back to stay and obviously store things with us, that it is also the time that we need to reclaim the house and start to change it into one that is suitable for our needs now? If not now - then when?

Parenting 20 year olds is tricky at times!

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 31/08/2023 17:00

NotQuiteHere · 31/08/2023 16:48

If you are planning to use it as a guest room anyway, does it matter that it is decorated to her taste?

Have you actually read what the OP wrote though?

The DD has
rearranged the room with her furniture to the point where it isn’t usable as a guest room and she is about go away for a long time. All the existing furniture in the room has been pushed up against a wall and we can't access it - which we need to.

StinkyWizzleteets · 31/08/2023 16:58

Mumof4plusbonus · 31/08/2023 16:56

She’s not coming back from uni, she had moved out and was working and living alone. How else would she have all this excess furniture?

Point still stands. Do parents no longer have any stake in their offspring’s well-being once they’re 18? Is the fact she wants to stay at home temporarily negated by the fact she moved away to uni and didn’t move back the day after her final exam?

Your pendantry doesn’t change the point of my post.

Soontobe60 · 31/08/2023 16:58

AnneLovesGilbert · 30/08/2023 20:47

She should have asked. She hasn’t lived there for years, it’s bizarre and very rude to redecorate and fill up a room in your home without even asking first.

I have no sympathy for the idea that rooms belong to adults who no longer live in them. The day I left for uni one of my brothers took over mine at mum’s, I completely understood! We didn’t have bedrooms each at my dad’s, no one came to any short term or long lasting harm…

‘Since 2022’ isnt years!

TenderDandelions · 31/08/2023 16:56

"We were wondering, DSD, whether you are still planning on going travelling?"

If she answered yes, you can just say "we'll help you move all your stuff in to the garage/storage before you go then, so we can use the room as a spare room while you're away."

That way you're not saying she can't return at the end of her travels, but you get the room back. Chances are the life experiences she gets while travelling will mean that she either never comes back, or only stays for a short while, as she decides on her next step.

I don't think the "will you be staying here when you get back" conversation needs to happen just now.

Mumof4plusbonus · 31/08/2023 16:56

StinkyWizzleteets · 31/08/2023 16:52

I’ll never understand how parents just open the door kick their kids out for uni then get surprised when they want their rooms back at the end, if even temporarily.

i think you’re being really unreasonable. To her it will feel like the second she’s gone all traces removed (why keep a few of her things in there if it is no longer her room to use?) and where’s she meant to sleep? The sofa?

Theres this weird juxtaposition on MN where kids hit 16 and they’re independent whether they like it or not and expected to be 100% adult in all they say and do, leave home and instantly know how to conduct themselves as an adult. Then there are the ones who treat their adult kids like they’re still incapable children Who need everything done for them, don’t ever have to pay rent or do their washing etc.

Where is everyone from real life who lives in the middle where life is shades of grey.

Edited

She’s not coming back from uni, she had moved out and was working and living alone. How else would she have all this excess furniture?

Mumof4plusbonus · 31/08/2023 16:54

It’s probably to protect her things, she maybe thinks they won’t be as protected in the storage unit. Either way it’s very cheeky and entitled. She’s moved out it’s not her room anymore. Yes you would allow her to move back on if she needed, but at the moment she does not live there. Move the stuff to the unit. She should have packed them appropriately

StinkyWizzleteets · 31/08/2023 16:52

I’ll never understand how parents just open the door kick their kids out for uni then get surprised when they want their rooms back at the end, if even temporarily.

i think you’re being really unreasonable. To her it will feel like the second she’s gone all traces removed (why keep a few of her things in there if it is no longer her room to use?) and where’s she meant to sleep? The sofa?

Theres this weird juxtaposition on MN where kids hit 16 and they’re independent whether they like it or not and expected to be 100% adult in all they say and do, leave home and instantly know how to conduct themselves as an adult. Then there are the ones who treat their adult kids like they’re still incapable children Who need everything done for them, don’t ever have to pay rent or do their washing etc.

Where is everyone from real life who lives in the middle where life is shades of grey.

NotQuiteHere · 31/08/2023 16:48

If you are planning to use it as a guest room anyway, does it matter that it is decorated to her taste?

MzHz · 31/08/2023 16:44

@zazas The hanging new curtains is odd! Your DH needs to speak to her and say that the deal was the stuff gets stored out in the storage area, not in the room, so he'll be moving the stuff back out there and putting the room as it was before.

If your H is diplomatic enough to speak to her without offending her, then he should do so.

HamBone · 31/08/2023 16:43

@zazas My Mum always welcomed me home, but I think she wanted to make it clear that I was an adult now. She also said that I’d need to pay rent if I returned home after uni.

Like you, I was only gone for a short time before moving away for work so that never happened…and she was actually a real softie and did a lot for me!

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 16:41

haha, I love th posters who seem to think you're tossing her out. My parents made it clear we were welcome to stay or visit or use them as backstop but we had to move out after uni. When I returned to visit I always slept in "my" room - and there were still a few bits and pieces from my life with them in the room but it was redecorated in the meantime with different furniture and bedding etc. My furniture was stored or sent to me or got rid of, as required.

If it wasn't for the lamps and curtains I'd say she just dumped it for convenience. But it is definitely a bit odd.

Tinkerbyebye · 31/08/2023 16:41

i would text that you dont understand why she has done this, you agreed storage but that will be where the others are so you will move the stuff thre and the room will be put back to how it was

end of discussion

zazas · 31/08/2023 16:37

Shinyandnew1 · 31/08/2023 16:26

It sounds like she has rearranged the room with her furniture to the point where it isn’t usable as a guest room. I think that’s pretty rude! Bringing your own curtains round and hanging them up is odd as well-what did she do with the existing ones?!

They are still there she has hung extra ones on the bar to add more layers and I think swapped the lamp shades and lamps over - maybe other things - have not looked too closely!

OP posts:
Maddy70 · 31/08/2023 16:35

Skybluecoat · 30/08/2023 20:49

I would just move her stuff into the storage area with everyone else’s.

This is what I would do

zazas · 31/08/2023 16:35

HamBone · 31/08/2023 16:31

I agree with PP’s that your DH should explain to her that as the wardrobe, etc. isn’t currently accessible, you’ll be moving some of her stuff to the storage area so that guests can use the room in her absence. It’s simply about accessibility, not permanently taking away her room.

My parents turned my room into an office during my first term at university. I could still sleep in there, but it was weird coming home to find a new desk, filing cabinet and their paperwork in there. 🤣

Yep - will make sure all emotion is taken out of the conversation! Good point. That must have been strange, my friend at 45 was upset when her parents re wallpapered her old room! I couldn't believe how often they came home from university that first year - not that we touched their rooms!

OP posts:
zazas · 31/08/2023 16:33

Shinyandnew1 · 31/08/2023 16:28

It’ll be best if he has the conversation with her directly.

Is this your only spare room and who else stays in it? Does she know people stay in it-does that bother her?

Yes it probably is. Yes apart from my office but I work from home a lot in it at the moment. I don't think so as she is not really aware who is staying.

OP posts:
zazas · 31/08/2023 16:31

Specialtoes · 31/08/2023 16:25

Can you honestly imagine not letting your own child use their old room between jobs/homes?

No it is not that at all - it is as mentioned below it is what she has done - rearranged the room with her furniture to the point where it isn’t usable as a guest room and she is about go away for a long time. All the existing furniture in the room has been pushed up against a wall and we can't access it - which we need to. Just trying to get thoughts on it as I don't want to be insensitive to her but also a bit bemused about why she has done it?

OP posts:
HamBone · 31/08/2023 16:31

I agree with PP’s that your DH should explain to her that as the wardrobe, etc. isn’t currently accessible, you’ll be moving some of her stuff to the storage area so that guests can use the room in her absence. It’s simply about accessibility, not permanently taking away her room.

My parents turned my room into an office during my first term at university. I could still sleep in there, but it was weird coming home to find a new desk, filing cabinet and their paperwork in there. 🤣

Shinyandnew1 · 31/08/2023 16:28

It’ll be best if he has the conversation with her directly.

Is this your only spare room and who else stays in it? Does she know people stay in it-does that bother her?

zazas · 31/08/2023 16:27

Shinyandnew1 · 31/08/2023 16:24

I’d tell your husband to have this conversation with her-he can explain where the stuff can go. If she complains, he can complain back!

We are I complete agreement here - so yes he can definitely have the conversation!

OP posts:
zazas · 31/08/2023 16:27

Shinyandnew1 · 31/08/2023 16:20

If she’s gone for a year, that’s not fair to leave it unusable as a guest room. Tell her you’re going to box it up and put it with other stuff in storage so you can decorate and use it as a spare room. Do you think she will react badly?

She might as she is quite emotional. Both my DH and I had very different childhood experiences so don't have the experience of the leaving / returning home so want do what is right for her but also establish some sort of boundary I guess.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 31/08/2023 16:26

Specialtoes · 31/08/2023 16:25

Can you honestly imagine not letting your own child use their old room between jobs/homes?

It sounds like she has rearranged the room with her furniture to the point where it isn’t usable as a guest room. I think that’s pretty rude! Bringing your own curtains round and hanging them up is odd as well-what did she do with the existing ones?!

zazas · 31/08/2023 16:25

Hopingforagreatescape · 31/08/2023 16:18

Tricky, because as you say, that room still had some of her stuff in it already. So she probably hasn't realised that it's not 'her room' anymore.

To avoid upset, I would leave it as it is for the month that she's travelling, and then tackle it when she goes abroad for her further study after that. How long is the studying overseas? Will she move back your way after that?

It is probably worth mentioning that she also has a room at her mother's not far away (we all get on great - so there is nothing of concern between all the different relationships but we do have the storage unit) and while she has always had a room with us - she has always treated her room at her mother's as her main one - as in keeping most of her things there etc. I think we will leave it for a month, it was on my list to move some more of the books (that are in boxes!) into a new bookcase that we have ordered for that room but I think maybe leave things for the next month. She will be away for at least a year from October.

OP posts:
Specialtoes · 31/08/2023 16:25

Can you honestly imagine not letting your own child use their old room between jobs/homes?

Shinyandnew1 · 31/08/2023 16:24

zazas · 31/08/2023 16:21

I think we will need to say something, it is a bit strange. Especially as my DH replied when she messaged us while we were away, asking if she could access the house to drop some things off, "to put them in plastic boxes for storage and we would help move them into the unit when we returned." She then replied, "I don't have time to do that now - I will drop it off and do it when I can." However she did seem to have time to move the furniture around and hang new curtains and move the beds!

I’d tell your husband to have this conversation with her-he can explain where the stuff can go. If she complains, he can complain back!