Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children touching things in charity shops

108 replies

Nih · 30/08/2023 19:10

I took my children charity shopping today, we went to a different area, it's an "affluent" area according to google. Dulwich.

The DC like to pick up and have a proper look at the toys they're interested in buying which I don't think is unreasonable. How else would you know whether something works?

DD (4) liked the look of a spinning top and wanted to see what it did. Before she even had chance to push the lever down she was told off by the woman behind the till because "those toys are to be sold, not played with"

We put it back and left the shop so they lost that sale.

5 minutes down the road we had another frosty reception at another charity shop.

AIBU to think the children did nothing wrong and it's perfectly acceptable to handle and even try out toys in charity shops? Obviously not opening packaging etc but loose things on shelves.

It all felt very snob-like.

OP posts:
towriteyoumustlive · 30/08/2023 21:49

My local charity shop literally encourages the kids to go and play with the toys so I can then look at the grown up stuff!

Then pester power usually results in me buying lots of stuff 🤣🤣

Lavender14 · 30/08/2023 21:45

Charity shops are often staffed by volunteers, many of which are in some way vulnerable or a bit lonely and its a way to get out and meet people. So sometimes you can come across people who don't have the social skills you'd expect in a retail setting. You're not being unreasonable and you shouldn't have been spoken to that way but I think it's part of the challenge of the voluntary sector.

WillowCraft · 30/08/2023 21:45

If kids toys are broken that easily they aren't fit for purpose. Toys should withstand many hours of play, not break after 5 minutes!

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 30/08/2023 21:43

We live opposite a lovely charity shop, a few meters from a primary school. They are very child friendly and encourage the children to try the toys or look at the books. I think it’s a good sales approach as it’s very popular! My kids often want to visit and we always find something we love.

AcclimDD · 30/08/2023 21:40

Manners matter OP, you and your children sound rude. Be a role model and teach your children to look, not touch going forward.

ThelmaBorden · 30/08/2023 21:36

East Dulwich not Dulwich - Mind manager is kind hearted, teflon,
been there for years and we all love him

Leah5678 · 30/08/2023 21:22

QueenCamilla · 30/08/2023 20:52

if everyone let their kids touch things they'd all be broken/trashed/covered in snot and dribble.

I think you'd find that most children's toys in charity shops have been through that many times already and by multiple generations sometimes 😁
Do you even shop in charity shops if any sort of washable snot bothers you?!
I mean multiple human (and probably animal) arses have sat on my second-hand Duresta sofa... 🤔

A friendly tip: avoid M&S (new) underwear if dribble is bothersome. There's some weird stuff that goes on in their unisex changing rooms.

Tbh ancient dirt and snot doesn't bother me. It's the live kind I don't want sorry but kids carry a ton of germs and if 20 kids have sneezed or blown their nose on the item in question within the 24 hours before I pick it up that's when there's a problem. I know I know I know it's the same for bus stops Door handles and pretty much everywhere but my dad would of lost his shit if I ever touched anything in a shop. I appreciate the tip although there's no m and s within about thirty miles radius from me I'll remember it if I'm ever in another town and need new knickers though

oakleaffy · 30/08/2023 21:22

KnobbingtonKnobberson · 30/08/2023 19:45

some charity shop staff have a tendency to treat the shop like their own personal fiefdom. they can be a bit much.

😆 So true!

ShanghaiDiva · 30/08/2023 20:58

I volunteer in a charity shop and we don’t have a problem with children touching the toys. Ime most parents are very good at keeping their children away from anything breakable in the bric section. If a child did break something I would be more concerned about child cutting themselves than the broken item.

QueenCamilla · 30/08/2023 20:52

if everyone let their kids touch things they'd all be broken/trashed/covered in snot and dribble.

I think you'd find that most children's toys in charity shops have been through that many times already and by multiple generations sometimes 😁
Do you even shop in charity shops if any sort of washable snot bothers you?!
I mean multiple human (and probably animal) arses have sat on my second-hand Duresta sofa... 🤔

A friendly tip: avoid M&S (new) underwear if dribble is bothersome. There's some weird stuff that goes on in their unisex changing rooms.

Nih · 30/08/2023 20:44

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 30/08/2023 20:34

I think OP is completely showing themselves up and they definitely are ‘that’ parent with their darling children. It didn’t take long for the ‘the charity shop workers are snobs’ to come out which I was just waiting for.

I’d also question if the person you’re trying to get sacked was an employee, most are volunteers apart for the manager themselves.

I live locally and I know what shop you’re talking about, it’s easing funds for a local hospice. They regularly get people in who let their children run riot, ‘try’ the toys, leave them all over the floors, break them, whilst the parent leaves them too it and looks around.

If you haven’t guessed I don’t think the shop / person did anything wrong and I’m sure they’ll be glad you’re not visiting again.

Give it a rest will you. I have sang the praises of the majority of charity shops I've been in, did you miss those posts or just choose not to take any notice of them because they contradict your point?

Yes, I was left wondering whether our experiences today were linked to snobbery as like I continue to say.. we've never had this problem anywhere else.

I decided to venture into an "affluent area" with a view to get some higher end items and this is the reception we get.

Also, I don't think you do know the shop I'm talking about as if you did you'd know there's nowhere near enough of the shop dedicated to toys and children's things to make what you're describing possible.

It's not St Christopher's which is clearly what you think, it's mind down at the end opposite the pub on the corner.

They had one short shelf with 4 or 5 lonely children's toys on it. No children's clothes.

OP posts:
Leah5678 · 30/08/2023 20:41

Why does it matter that it's a charity shop? I was raised never to touch anything in a shop as a kid "you can look but you can't touch". Y'all are calling the people in the shop "snobs" but it's kinda "snobby" of you to think you can let Ur kids touch things in shops were poor people buy things but not expensive shops. I'm sure it's easy to feel like your kids should be the exception but if everyone let their kids touch things they'd all be broken/trashed/covered in snot and dribble.

QueenCamilla · 30/08/2023 20:40

YANBU.

What sense does it even make that I can try on a dress or ten but my DS can't open a children's book or "run" a plastic horse on the shelf. It does suck to be a child. 🤷

aspirationalflamingo · 30/08/2023 20:38

Nih · 30/08/2023 20:16

Those of us who are unhappy about an employees attitude.

If enough people complain they might do something about their staff.

Employee?

Or volunteer giving up their time in the hope of helping an organisation close to their heart, but instead getting grief from members of the public who think the charity exists for their personal benefit?

So can you tell me, if you will, why shops selling brand new merchandise don't mind small children taking a closer look at the toys but these charity shops do?

For Sainsbury's, writing off damaged stock will barely have a perceptible impact on their profitability.

For a charity, it could have a significant impact on their ability to break even, let alone raise money for the cause.

For Sainsbury's, you were dealing with an employee with no emotional investment in the organisation.

For a charity, you are dealing with people who have probably chosen a charity that has an emotional connection to them - often due to bereavements. It's therefore much more personal if a succession of "customers" trash the stock and prevent the charity raising money for that cause.

Charity shop volunteers will often be aware of how well their individual shop is doing (or not). They will know how much stock gets written off after customers damage it or steal it.

Slating them on the internet is completely unnecessary and disproportionate.

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 30/08/2023 20:34

I think OP is completely showing themselves up and they definitely are ‘that’ parent with their darling children. It didn’t take long for the ‘the charity shop workers are snobs’ to come out which I was just waiting for.

I’d also question if the person you’re trying to get sacked was an employee, most are volunteers apart for the manager themselves.

I live locally and I know what shop you’re talking about, it’s easing funds for a local hospice. They regularly get people in who let their children run riot, ‘try’ the toys, leave them all over the floors, break them, whilst the parent leaves them too it and looks around.

If you haven’t guessed I don’t think the shop / person did anything wrong and I’m sure they’ll be glad you’re not visiting again.

aspirationalflamingo · 30/08/2023 20:27

Nih · 30/08/2023 19:48

Of course, wouldn't the vast majority of people?

Well, no. Which is probably why they are cautious.

People try it on with charity shops.

missymousey · 30/08/2023 20:25

My kids prefer charity shops to new toy shops because they can try before we buy. It's a great way to encourage a habit of reuse and the value of buying pre-loved. The shops round me are fortunately really welcoming.

gogomoto · 30/08/2023 20:24

I work in one, whilst we do let kids touch things, unfortunately parents use us like a stay and play and tong clear up after their kids, it's a nightmare. We've taken to sealing things with cling film if they have multiple parts. Then there's the removing from sets and hiding the toy elsewhere in the store. If parents actually intervened and stopped their children making a mess then volunteers may be kinder

LondonLovie · 30/08/2023 20:24

I am guessing this could be a charity shop that's connected to a hospice..?

anunlikelyseahorse · 30/08/2023 20:18

Who the hell goes on Google to review a charity shop??
Nih does.

I'm on the fence with this OP, I've seen children break things in charity shops, and then parents complain about broken items....yes really! And that's the issue, some people are piss takers and ruin it for other parents who are vigilant with their kids and if anything did get damaged, they'd pay for the object. And whilst it's not great being rude to the customer some people struggle with interpersonal skills, and don't deliberately mean to be rude.

Nih · 30/08/2023 20:16

HarrietJet · 30/08/2023 20:06

Who the hell goes on Google to review a charity shop??

Those of us who are unhappy about an employees attitude.

If enough people complain they might do something about their staff.

OP posts:
Nih · 30/08/2023 20:14

RedHelenB · 30/08/2023 19:59

No. You should have explained or shown how it works. Children should look and not touch just like any other shop. Yabu.

Like any other shop?

I have been into hundreds of shops over the years and not one, other than these two charity shops today, have had a problem with children handling toys.

We bought a soft toy from Sainsburys last week, found for us by an employee who showed us where it was, and he didn't give a toss that DS took it off the shelf.

Insert the dozens of other charity shops we've gone into over the past year. Nope, they didn't care about the toys being handled either.

So can you tell me, if you will, why shops selling brand new merchandise don't mind small children taking a closer look at the toys but these charity shops do?

OP posts:
eatdrinkandbemerry · 30/08/2023 20:09

My daughter absolutely loves charity shops 😂
She's learnt she can get much more with her pocket money if it's been previously loved .
She always looks makes sure it's all there and works but gosh some kids trash the shelves and leave toys all over the floor (while the parents browse oblivious to the mess).
So yes try things and the volunteers should know who's being parented and who's not!

Abfab63 · 30/08/2023 20:06

Our local charity shop is adjoined to a cafe. They let the children play with the toys in a part of the cafe whilst you have a coffee. Obviously we always buy one or two of them to take home as well. So, not all charity shops mind you playing with the toys and I really can't see a problem with it as long as you take care of them.

At the end of the day these aren't new toys and I personally give to charity for our things to get some more use / love rather than ending up in the tip. So that's exactly what's happening!

HarrietJet · 30/08/2023 20:06

Nih · 30/08/2023 20:02

Unfortunately if google reviews are to be believed then the male manager is even worse than the lady we encountered today. The poor reviews stem back years too.

Who the hell goes on Google to review a charity shop??