Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why so many children are feral these days?

306 replies

ChocBanana · 30/08/2023 19:07

I have two DC, one (13) with ASD and hypersensitivity, so she wears ear defenders and ear plugs in noisy environments.
However, today, we have had to leave a museum because of the behaviour of other kids.
I know it’s the last week of the holidays but we tend to prefer quieter places, or quieter times of day. We tend to go to museums and parks, woodlands or if we are going somewhere busier generally we go in the afternoon.

We went to a museum today near us, not a particularly big one. After about ten minutes, a mum came in with three kids and basically said “Off you go” and let them run riot. They were climbing on the exhibits, trying to pull things off the wall, picking up the listening device things and swinging them against the wall and one of them scribbled all over an information panel.
A member of staff asked them to be careful. The mum titled and says “Come on kids, we’re obviously not welcome.” Then on the way out one of them kicked a wall, leaving a scuff mark. As they left, another family came in, the was a display thing where you can pretend to dig for fossils, the two kids were throwing the sand at each other, then a third family came in, one of them, a teenager sat next to where my teenager was trying to regulate herself. She stood up and he instantly out his feet up on her bag then kicked it to the floor and put his feet up on the sofa.
The mum was chatting away to her partner, the youngest child was hiding under a shelf, then started pulling out all the display drawers at once and slamming them shut.

We had to leave at this point, my daughter was in tears.

Now, I said, I get that it’s the last week of the summer holidays. I get that many people are desperate for free things to do, and I know many children have various reasons for acting in various ways. I’m not asking for special treatment or being naive, but SERIOUSLY, AIBU to expect a certain level of behaviour in a museum?
If I am BU, any suggestions on where the hell I am supposed to take a 13 year old who struggles with people at the best of times?

OP posts:
horseyhorsey17 · 31/08/2023 11:36

Too many parents who think 'parenting' means giving kids an iPad or phone to shut them up and don't bother disciplining or instilling manners. Was at a family festival recently and really noticed this - entitled lazy parents who don't give a sh*t how much their feral children are annoying everyone else.

DoraSpenlow · 31/08/2023 11:32

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 31/08/2023 10:14

The thing is obviously the kids you mentioned were behaving terribly but what you probably didn't notice was the 50 or so other families who were behaving themselves. People just don't notice good behaviour, then they see a couple of kids who are being awful and then you get all the "kids today are terrible" chat.

My DH volunteers at a museum and actually had the opposite of this. He said that the school holidays have been a nightmare this year with kids running and screaming and climbing on exhibits with seemingly little in the way of control by parents.

He came home last week and told me about a lovely family they had had in. He said it was mum, dad and three children he thought would be under 10. He noticed that the parents talked to their children about different exhibits and when they got to where he was on duty the children asked sensible questions prefixed by, excuse me, but why/what, or sorry I don't quite understand could you please tell me again? He said it was quite refreshing after having to ask parents to remove their offspring from exhibits and being talked over by kids. The favourite was, well they want to look inside. There were plenty of things to look inside of but you would have thought that they would realise that the exhibits that were roped off were not for climbing on.

Anyway, when he later went for his break several of the volunteers mentioned this lovely little family and what a joy it was to see. So people do notice.

StTropezTan · 31/08/2023 11:26

Ponoka7 · 31/08/2023 10:48

@Viralsunflower it might actually be the professionals around the child who are fobbing the mother off with that. Continence services are very poor and little is done before the age of seven. Again speech services in this country are a disgrace. My youngest GC has suffered irreversible hearing loss because of lock down. Other children won't get their speech back. The back logs are still being cleared, children who are borderline and not in school are bottom of the list.

This is also a very valid point.
Working as a TA I spent a lot of time in meetings in schools with Behaviour Support. Even they were at a loss to recommend coping strategies for many children and often the only advice they could suggest was to say to the child, “I see you’re struggling. What would you like to do about it?”

I wanted to scream myself and say that these children didn’t want ‘choices’ they wanted structure and consistency. They wanted to know where they were on the ladder and to know that the adults around them could be relied upon to be firm but fair. Choices are only appropriate if the alternatives are made very clear, otherwise they’re too nebulous.

I felt that a lot of these strategies were fads and that the children were just part of some kind of social experiment which was a huge disservice and ultimately, quite destructive to them. Too many middle class parents have got suckered into this experiment by believing their child is a special case and deserves exceptional treatment rather than recognising much of the challenging behaviour is a result of their policies rather than an inherent fault in their child or the school.

TripleDaisySummer · 31/08/2023 11:17

Totally agree. I think that's partly why it's harder to keep kids focussed and engaged at school too. They expect everything to be entertaining, almost gamified, and to get extrinsic rewards all the time. It's not their fault. It's partly due to spoiling and over-scheduling by parents and partly due to being used to constant little dopamine hits from devices, especially social media and gaming.

Part of the reason I had to step in with maths was because their primary school tried constantly to do fun games to teach maths.

So idea then mess around setting up group fun bit - and by then my kids had forgotten the maths idea and struggled with the group social bit.

As I was dealing with reading and spelling with multiple kids I had to turn to on-line maths help which is often gamified so they the do the practise - one we found massively helped them but it was video 20 questions then game formats - they probably were getting dopamine hits but they also got the practise in.

It often felt like I was doing the basics and ensuring practise and the school was focused on making it all fun.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 31/08/2023 11:07

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 31/08/2023 10:50

No, it's not a good thing. Children need to be able to learn to amuse themselves, and to be able to find something to do during the times they are bored, they can't expect to be constantly entertained.

Totally agree. I think that's partly why it's harder to keep kids focussed and engaged at school too. They expect everything to be entertaining, almost gamified, and to get extrinsic rewards all the time. It's not their fault. It's partly due to spoiling and over-scheduling by parents and partly due to being used to constant little dopamine hits from devices, especially social media and gaming.

Yes. I struggle with this and I'm an adult!

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 31/08/2023 10:50

No, it's not a good thing. Children need to be able to learn to amuse themselves, and to be able to find something to do during the times they are bored, they can't expect to be constantly entertained.

Totally agree. I think that's partly why it's harder to keep kids focussed and engaged at school too. They expect everything to be entertaining, almost gamified, and to get extrinsic rewards all the time. It's not their fault. It's partly due to spoiling and over-scheduling by parents and partly due to being used to constant little dopamine hits from devices, especially social media and gaming.

Ponoka7 · 31/08/2023 10:48

@Viralsunflower it might actually be the professionals around the child who are fobbing the mother off with that. Continence services are very poor and little is done before the age of seven. Again speech services in this country are a disgrace. My youngest GC has suffered irreversible hearing loss because of lock down. Other children won't get their speech back. The back logs are still being cleared, children who are borderline and not in school are bottom of the list.

TripleDaisySummer · 31/08/2023 10:43

Highly visible subset of permissive/gentle parenting - usually very middle class.

Exhausted parents both working long commutes money worries little energy or time to parent well - and often trips out huge expectations to avoid arguments and enjoy/make memories.

Covid - it's not just kids who seem unable to behave in public places.

Undermining parents - worst kids I knew parents were constantly undermining each other also a trend that seems to go along with DGP demand to have very young babies alone - DGP undermining parents.

My kids DGP would try and undermine kids being corrected as I wasn't depending on them for childcare I could stop that - it was much harder for DSis dependent on family for childcare - it can - not always - I think blur who in charge and how indulgent extended family can be. IL family friend are an extreme example basically with the daughter husbands help basically pushing her out entirely IL used to think it great now think it's a car crash.

Less outside time/exercising - my kids had to walk we stop of in parks get buses and trains - so they had less energy than kids pick up from in front of screen put in car and then expected to behave or be quiet.

Ponoka7 · 31/08/2023 10:41

My GC were appalling on Tuesday. They were great all day in soft play, then we went into the shops and the bickering was off the scale. It sounds even worse because the eldest has verbal ticks (ADHD diagnosed) and the youngest has had grommets and can't wear her hearing aids, so has to be spoken to, loudly in certain buildings. They are sick of each other and could have done with going back this week. They are perfect in school. The eldest did say to my sister "it's great in school we aren't even in the same play yard" 😆

TiredButDancing · 31/08/2023 10:32

i think what is missing out in a lot of families is consistency. There’s constantly a mixed message about expectations. So many parents blow hot and cold. They threaten all sorts of sanctions but don’t follow through and give in because they don’t want to be seen as the mean one. Children learn very quickly what an adult’s tolerance, boundaries and limits are. If there appear to be none, it becomes open season.

Yes. Also, if the messages are mixed, I think when the children are younger, they genuinely don't know what's okay and what's not okay. Because one day they'll get to do something and the next they get shouted at. So they just figure they'll give it a go.

Plutonium7000 · 31/08/2023 10:30

StTropezTan · 31/08/2023 10:28

I think people do notice the well behaved ones.

My children certainly weren’t saints and I had on more than one occasion remove them from situations because their behaviour wasn’t acceptable to and potentially about to impact others - consequently, they quickly learnt that they would be the ones missing out if they misbehaved.

But I also had many compliments from people about their manners and their ability to fit in well with others. This did come with a lot of hard work and emotional pain. I can clearly recall sitting in my car or at home sobbing to myself because I felt I didn’t have a grip and wasn’t handling them well but I made sure they never saw that.

i think what is missing out in a lot of families is consistency. There’s constantly a mixed message about expectations. So many parents blow hot and cold. They threaten all sorts of sanctions but don’t follow through and give in because they don’t want to be seen as the mean one. Children learn very quickly what an adult’s tolerance, boundaries and limits are. If there appear to be none, it becomes open season.

I agree with this entirely.

Plutonium7000 · 31/08/2023 10:28

I do think there need to be more free/low cost indoor places for kids to let off steam.

However, that behaviour was unacceptable and there is no excuse really. I have had the times when my kids have behaved badly in museums/cafes/libraries (one is ADHD/ASD and can be very hyperactive and silly). I have never allowed it and when it was clear they couldn't behave in the right way I marched them straight out.

I have learnt not to take them to places where they can't behave appropriately either due to age/personality/SEN. There was a (long!) time when I only ever took them to parks/fields/soft play areas - they enjoy those places more anyway!

StTropezTan · 31/08/2023 10:28

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 31/08/2023 10:14

The thing is obviously the kids you mentioned were behaving terribly but what you probably didn't notice was the 50 or so other families who were behaving themselves. People just don't notice good behaviour, then they see a couple of kids who are being awful and then you get all the "kids today are terrible" chat.

I think people do notice the well behaved ones.

My children certainly weren’t saints and I had on more than one occasion remove them from situations because their behaviour wasn’t acceptable to and potentially about to impact others - consequently, they quickly learnt that they would be the ones missing out if they misbehaved.

But I also had many compliments from people about their manners and their ability to fit in well with others. This did come with a lot of hard work and emotional pain. I can clearly recall sitting in my car or at home sobbing to myself because I felt I didn’t have a grip and wasn’t handling them well but I made sure they never saw that.

i think what is missing out in a lot of families is consistency. There’s constantly a mixed message about expectations. So many parents blow hot and cold. They threaten all sorts of sanctions but don’t follow through and give in because they don’t want to be seen as the mean one. Children learn very quickly what an adult’s tolerance, boundaries and limits are. If there appear to be none, it becomes open season.

WinterGold · 31/08/2023 10:16

givemeasunnyday · 31/08/2023 09:55

No, it's not a good thing. Children need to be able to learn to amuse themselves, and to be able to find something to do during the times they are bored, they can't expect to be constantly entertained. It's also not good for the parents to be rushing around from activity to activity, along with working - when do they get any down time?

Totally right.

All this ‘structured’ entertainment has its place and its benefits. However, children also have to learn to play and use their imaginations without being directed constantly by an adult. It’s part of learning to operate within a social group and about give, take and awareness of others. And that through that play, they learn about how their behaviour impacts others from their peers. A lot of this ‘rampaging’ is almost insular. I’ve noticed that even if it sometimes appears to be a group thing, it’s actually quite an egocentric thing - which children naturally are, until they learn about the needs of others.

mydogisthebest · 31/08/2023 10:16

Sigmama · 30/08/2023 20:59

I've not noticed children being more feral, more annoying gadgets maybe, but not more screaming

You are lucky then.

My next door neighbour thankfully moved earlier this year. Her daughter is 10 and we had had 5 years of screeching, screaming and shrieking. In the summer holidays she would be in the garden from quite early morning till about 8pm and the noise drove me mad. She would often have friends there and, they too, would screech and scream.

Next door but one have their grandchildren regularly. The girl, aged 8, also screams and screeches so much of the time.

Two boys opposite scream a lot. One day I honestly thought something terrible had happened and started to go across to see but then the boy stopped and started laughing.

Almost every time we go to a supermarket or cafe there seems to be a child screaming for no reason.

Me and my siblings would not have been allowed to scream and screech and neither would my siblings' children.

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 31/08/2023 10:14

The thing is obviously the kids you mentioned were behaving terribly but what you probably didn't notice was the 50 or so other families who were behaving themselves. People just don't notice good behaviour, then they see a couple of kids who are being awful and then you get all the "kids today are terrible" chat.

Viralsunflower · 31/08/2023 10:07

Dont have time to read through the whole thread but I've seen very few acknowledgements of how shit lockdowns were on children, their behaviour, the resilience of their parents etc.

I do agree with this but I also hear people using lockdown as an excuse not to support their children with their development or behaviour, several years on. I met a 4 year old the other day who is still in nappies through the day and can't speak, and was told it is because she was a lockdown baby (she was born in 2019 I think, from our conversation), so they didn't go in to public toilets when she was a baby and everyone was wearing masks so she didn't see people's mouths moving.

Pretty sure you went to the toilet during 2020, and that nobody wore masks at home? The child clearly needs assessing and help with their development, but it's easier to blame lockdown.

Viralsunflower · 31/08/2023 10:04

There are a lot of people on this thread who don't understand what gentle parenting is. You absolutely have boundaries, consequences, tell your child no, and teach them right from wrong. You just do it in a way you'd like to be spoken to yourself, and take time to explain things to kids rather than just going "well life isn't fair!!", "TOUGH!!", or "because I said so!!", and acknowledge your child's feelings whilst holding your own boundaries. I gentle parent and we absolutely have boundaries and consequences. We often get stopped on days out and told how refreshing it is to see a well behaved child and also a mum who doesn't shout at them every five seconds. This isn't a brag, it's just the truth. Meanwhile, I have friends who think that they gentle parent, and I can't stand spending time around their children because they completely lack boundaries, social skills, and act like brats. They are parented in a permissive way and it is misunderstood for gentle parenting.

Chavs raise chavs

It isn't always chavs, either. I have 3 nephews on DB side, and we avoid going to places like cafes for lunch with them because they'll be crawling under tables, banging the salt pots on the table, shouting. Sometimes the parents end up shouting at them, kids have a shouting match with them, it's downright embarrassing. If the parents don't say anything, it's because "boys will be boys" aka "I'm going to use my child having a penis as an excuse for shit behaviour that I'd never tolerate from a girl".

ValancyRedfern · 31/08/2023 09:59

I feel like I'm by far the strictest parent of all of my friends. It does seem like the fashionable middle class parenting style is to let the kids get away with murder.

givemeasunnyday · 31/08/2023 09:55

Hawkins0090 · 31/08/2023 00:35

Surely that's a good thing with all the activities and extracurriculars ?

Edited

No, it's not a good thing. Children need to be able to learn to amuse themselves, and to be able to find something to do during the times they are bored, they can't expect to be constantly entertained. It's also not good for the parents to be rushing around from activity to activity, along with working - when do they get any down time?

MotherEarthisaTerf · 31/08/2023 09:40

Dont have time to read through the whole thread but I've seen very few acknowledgements of how shit lockdowns were on children, their behaviour, the resilience of their parents etc.

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 09:37

Oh, and the other thing I've noticed is that I think too often parents are doing things that aren't age appropriate. the PP who mentioned that her child is very energetic and struggles in museums but she still wants him to go to them is a good example - at 6, if your child isn't ready for museums, it's okay because there are plenty of years left for them to engage with them.

It's like people who say, "well, when I was younger, I used to sit at the table in a restaurant with my colouring in pencils" forgetting that if you remember it you were probably at least 6 and probably older. It's almost like the accessibility of all these things has made people forget that they aren't necessarily FOR everyone.

I remember how excited my brother and I were when we were about 11 or 12 and we started being allowed to go to restaurants with my parents that were not specifically for children. Before that, if they went out, they went without us and we were at home with a babysitter. Similarly, I lived in a small city so we didn't have a lot of museums etc, and it was definitely a thing to go with school in primary at some point but then with parents or even by ourselves in high school. Not when I was 6.

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 09:33

It's definitely parenting. I know two children from different families with very "energetic" children whose behaviour can be less than stellar. One has been diagnosed with ADHD and ASD. But the difference is the parents. One set of parents are on top of it all the time - keep an eye on their child, constantly remind them of appropriate behaviour, set boundaries etc. The other set appear to be completely oblivious and veer between indulgent, "oh look, it's so cute when he goes up to random people in pubs and wants to sit with them and chat" and screaming at him. The poor kid has zero idea of appropriate behaviour because it's never been taught to him.

I also agree that parents are too quick to defend their children. My children are not always perfectly behaved but I don't think I've ever had random people come up to complain to me about DS' behaviour. The child above's parents have got into altercations with other parents on a regular basis but they don't seem to realise this is unusual.

DelurkingLawyer · 31/08/2023 09:17

Is it the after effect of the pandemic?

We’ve rented a cottage in a sleepy and remote coastal village for years over August BH. One attraction was that second home owners who owned adjacent properties stayed in their own properties over that weekend. So you knew what you were going to get - the same people every year, and they respected the fact that the village was very quiet after about 10pm.

Since the pandemic both the adults and children of the second homers have behaved noticeably worse. This year was the worst of all - teenagers playing music on iPhones on the street at 1.30am, drunken shouting from both parents and children, singing happy birthday in the garden (also both well after midnight). I am amazed because they had previously seemed to respect that this wasn’t Magaluf and that the permanent residents weren’t on holiday and had to get up for work the next day. They always had friends staying, BBQs etc, but they’d invariably managed to do so without disturbing anyone else - they went inside at 10.30 and carried on or ended the party or whatever.

It’s like somebody flicked a switch. Is it the survival instinct of the pandemic when you looked after your own and forget the rest? Lack of socialisation over several years? I don’t know.

StTropezTan · 31/08/2023 09:09

Plus children expect and demand instant gratification. Many parents aren’t teaching patience or about taking turns. It’s all about getting to the front first and my child’s needs are paramount.

My daughter, who is a teacher, believes that children actually need to be taught by adults that it’s ok to be bored and to learn how to entertain themselves rather than demanding and being supplied with constant adult validation. I think there is something in this; not so long ago you used to see children in restaurants or public places happily colouring in or drawing calmly. Whenever mine were little, I always had some crayons and paper in my bag for occasions like this, plus colouring is surprisingly calming and focusing.

Currently, everything seems to competitive. Gaming, attention and entitlement.

Swipe left for the next trending thread