Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why so many children are feral these days?

306 replies

ChocBanana · 30/08/2023 19:07

I have two DC, one (13) with ASD and hypersensitivity, so she wears ear defenders and ear plugs in noisy environments.
However, today, we have had to leave a museum because of the behaviour of other kids.
I know it’s the last week of the holidays but we tend to prefer quieter places, or quieter times of day. We tend to go to museums and parks, woodlands or if we are going somewhere busier generally we go in the afternoon.

We went to a museum today near us, not a particularly big one. After about ten minutes, a mum came in with three kids and basically said “Off you go” and let them run riot. They were climbing on the exhibits, trying to pull things off the wall, picking up the listening device things and swinging them against the wall and one of them scribbled all over an information panel.
A member of staff asked them to be careful. The mum titled and says “Come on kids, we’re obviously not welcome.” Then on the way out one of them kicked a wall, leaving a scuff mark. As they left, another family came in, the was a display thing where you can pretend to dig for fossils, the two kids were throwing the sand at each other, then a third family came in, one of them, a teenager sat next to where my teenager was trying to regulate herself. She stood up and he instantly out his feet up on her bag then kicked it to the floor and put his feet up on the sofa.
The mum was chatting away to her partner, the youngest child was hiding under a shelf, then started pulling out all the display drawers at once and slamming them shut.

We had to leave at this point, my daughter was in tears.

Now, I said, I get that it’s the last week of the summer holidays. I get that many people are desperate for free things to do, and I know many children have various reasons for acting in various ways. I’m not asking for special treatment or being naive, but SERIOUSLY, AIBU to expect a certain level of behaviour in a museum?
If I am BU, any suggestions on where the hell I am supposed to take a 13 year old who struggles with people at the best of times?

OP posts:
beeswaxinc · 31/08/2023 13:20

JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 31/08/2023 13:11

And that to me is great parenting. It’s recognising when enough is enough and when behaviour is impacting other people. It’s also sending a message to the child that there are consequences of certain actions and that if, after a warning it continues, we will be leaving.

My two were chalk and cheese. My DD was very biddable and happy to play calmly, either on her own or with others. My DS was the very opposite. He hit 2 and the switch flicked. He would throw himself on the floor and roar and scream if he wanted something. He didn’t care where or with whom. DH and myself regularly scooped him up and left shops or restaurants with him screaming and kicking and drove home with our heads ringing with the noise and people tutting as we walked by.

I remember throwing him on his bed one day, slamming the door and sitting alone in the living room crying because I feared if I went upstairs again, I would seriously hurt him, such was my frustration. It would have been so much easier to short term appease him and it was without doubt a battle of nerves. But slowly he got the message that we weren’t having it. That the fact we left enjoyable places because he had kicked off made him connect cause and effect and eventually, whenever he teetered on the edge, a gentle reminder of what would happen was usually sufficient.

He has grown up into the loveliest temperament now - who knows whether that would have happened anyway - and is patient, calm and works in a profession where having a rational and unflappable personality is vital, so there is always light at the end of the tunnel!

This is so lovely to hear and gives me some hope! I think the fact that we are so stressed and put so much effort into dealing with the fallout shows that perhaps we are not the type of parents OP was talking about.

12345change · 31/08/2023 13:14

Don't think it is any worse now than it was 40 plus years ago.. as other posters have said we tend to focus on the apparently badly behaved children forgetting how many well behaved children there are out and about.

I also find these kind of posts so judgmental - people have no idea of what is going with families with children who misbehave in public.

JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 31/08/2023 13:11

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 12:38

I do wonder though, how we expect children to build up this tolerance of being in quiet communal places and not just child centric places if as a society we are so hostile to kids acting up. I would leave a place if my kids were being disruptive but obviously it would need to have got to that point first, which people would then witness!

In my experience, a child who starts to get disruptive is not, as a rule, blamed. it's when that child's behaviour is ignored by the parents that people get upset. We've all see that screaming toddler being carried out of a restaurant and usually people are sympathetic to both the child and the parents. I was having lunch with a friend a few weeks ago and a woman with a baby, a toddler and an older child came in. The older child started behaving badly - but she was clearly doing her best and then when he wouldn't calm down she packed up and left. The child was extremely annoying but I didn't blame her or him - they were all just trying their best.

And that to me is great parenting. It’s recognising when enough is enough and when behaviour is impacting other people. It’s also sending a message to the child that there are consequences of certain actions and that if, after a warning it continues, we will be leaving.

My two were chalk and cheese. My DD was very biddable and happy to play calmly, either on her own or with others. My DS was the very opposite. He hit 2 and the switch flicked. He would throw himself on the floor and roar and scream if he wanted something. He didn’t care where or with whom. DH and myself regularly scooped him up and left shops or restaurants with him screaming and kicking and drove home with our heads ringing with the noise and people tutting as we walked by.

I remember throwing him on his bed one day, slamming the door and sitting alone in the living room crying because I feared if I went upstairs again, I would seriously hurt him, such was my frustration. It would have been so much easier to short term appease him and it was without doubt a battle of nerves. But slowly he got the message that we weren’t having it. That the fact we left enjoyable places because he had kicked off made him connect cause and effect and eventually, whenever he teetered on the edge, a gentle reminder of what would happen was usually sufficient.

He has grown up into the loveliest temperament now - who knows whether that would have happened anyway - and is patient, calm and works in a profession where having a rational and unflappable personality is vital, so there is always light at the end of the tunnel!

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 31/08/2023 13:09

But actually, your example is flawed. Because we have to assume that the prevalence of ND is the same in the adult population as it is in the children's population. But the vast bulk of ND adults at some point still were able to learn how to modify their behaviour etc

WTH does this mean? I'm not talking about ND kids or adults. Just that kids have not got the same level of cognitive development as an average adult. You can't possibly expect the same response to a situation from a 4 year old and a 40 year old??

TripleDaisySummer · 31/08/2023 13:09

We arehostile to kids

My parents said it was much worse when we were kids - so 70s early 80s.

I've been in locations were people have seen our then young kids and based on other's parenting assumed they were going to be noisy and disruptive and they were well behaved - I know as people do tell you - it's not welcoming to be prejudged like that.

So I think poor parenting and noisy kids actually erodes wider societies patience's so there's less around for those who need more tolerance and those off moments they all have.

MsMarch · 31/08/2023 13:06

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 31/08/2023 12:59

as a society we are so hostile to kids acting up.

I think this is a key phrase actually.

We are hostile to kids. I mean how many people would start a thread about feral adults with special needs? Or elderly people with dementia if they were shouting and touching things they shouldn't? But we expect more from little kids who also don't have the cognitive abilities of able bodied adults. Why?
And no my kids arent badly behaved and they're older anyway but I really hate all the snide remarks made about young kids and their parents. Kids are mostly pretty well behaved in my experience and some kids have always played up, whether that's now or 20 or 30 years ago.

But actually, your example is flawed. Because we have to assume that the prevalence of ND is the same in the adult population as it is in the children's population. But the vast bulk of ND adults at some point still were able to learn how to modify their behaviour etc.

And as others have pointed out, while the OP asked about "feral kids" the vast bulk of the responses have highlighted that the issue is the parents, not the children. My nephew is, frankly, appallingly badly behaved and it is unbearable. BUT, his parents, unfortunately, are also appallingly bad parents and have never taught him any better. I don't blame him, I blame them.

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 31/08/2023 13:02

Before anyone lays into I'm not calling adults with special needs "feral" just using the same terminology as the OP used about children.

SusiePevensie · 31/08/2023 13:02

What splishsplash said.

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 31/08/2023 12:59

as a society we are so hostile to kids acting up.

I think this is a key phrase actually.

We are hostile to kids. I mean how many people would start a thread about feral adults with special needs? Or elderly people with dementia if they were shouting and touching things they shouldn't? But we expect more from little kids who also don't have the cognitive abilities of able bodied adults. Why?
And no my kids arent badly behaved and they're older anyway but I really hate all the snide remarks made about young kids and their parents. Kids are mostly pretty well behaved in my experience and some kids have always played up, whether that's now or 20 or 30 years ago.

Alondra · 31/08/2023 12:51

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 12:38

I do wonder though, how we expect children to build up this tolerance of being in quiet communal places and not just child centric places if as a society we are so hostile to kids acting up. I would leave a place if my kids were being disruptive but obviously it would need to have got to that point first, which people would then witness!

In my experience, a child who starts to get disruptive is not, as a rule, blamed. it's when that child's behaviour is ignored by the parents that people get upset. We've all see that screaming toddler being carried out of a restaurant and usually people are sympathetic to both the child and the parents. I was having lunch with a friend a few weeks ago and a woman with a baby, a toddler and an older child came in. The older child started behaving badly - but she was clearly doing her best and then when he wouldn't calm down she packed up and left. The child was extremely annoying but I didn't blame her or him - they were all just trying their best.

I've done the same, and not only with toddlers. I can't tell you the amount of times I left a supermarket because one of my kids wanted a sweet I refused to take, and were becoming disruptive.

No one in a supermarket needs to be on the screaming end from kids wanting to impose their own will on their parents. It's up their parents to make clear boundaries from the get go, "you are not getting what you want by screaming and we are leaving right now". That was my policy anyway.

It only takes a few times for children to understand they can't get what they want by misbehaving. They are sponges and learn fast.

SusiePevensie · 31/08/2023 12:42

Kids used to be able to play in the street - we took those away and gave them to cars. They used to have school playing fields - we sold those off. They used to have freedom to roam their neighbourhoods on bikes - again, we gave them to cars and paranoia about stranger danger.

And we're surprised they act up?

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 12:38

I do wonder though, how we expect children to build up this tolerance of being in quiet communal places and not just child centric places if as a society we are so hostile to kids acting up. I would leave a place if my kids were being disruptive but obviously it would need to have got to that point first, which people would then witness!

In my experience, a child who starts to get disruptive is not, as a rule, blamed. it's when that child's behaviour is ignored by the parents that people get upset. We've all see that screaming toddler being carried out of a restaurant and usually people are sympathetic to both the child and the parents. I was having lunch with a friend a few weeks ago and a woman with a baby, a toddler and an older child came in. The older child started behaving badly - but she was clearly doing her best and then when he wouldn't calm down she packed up and left. The child was extremely annoying but I didn't blame her or him - they were all just trying their best.

beeswaxinc · 31/08/2023 12:35

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 12:18

And he is still not a “bad” child he just has different needs, and some needs are harder to figure out than others. Triggers need to be identified and young children cannot yet adequately communicate even to themselves what their issues are. Anxiety in children often presents as anger or naughtiness. Labelling every negative behaviour a child presents as needing chastisement or punishment as a solution does not help them develop the coping skills needed to learn to self regulate and feel better. Yet in the UK there is a pressure to treat children with an overly firm hand especially in public, or else be labelled as a pathetic parent with a nightmare child, as evidenced on this thread!

I do sympathise but I think the point is that if your child cannot cope in certain environments, it's actually on you as the parent to keep them out of those environments. It's better for you, better for the child and better for the people around you. DS could not cope in restaurants or coffee shops for more than a short period. We accepted that and didn't go to those places or only went in situations where we could take him out quickly as needed. Slowly, he built up his tolerance and ability to manage. Even now, as a pre-teen, given the choice, he'll choose places that are less busy, less manic and less overwhelming for him.

Very true and to be fair this is what I do and actually DS on his own is a wonderful travel companion, but other people have different situations where they may not be able to avoid built up places. I’m just relating my experience to the OP and all the opinions flying in.

I do wonder though, how we expect children to build up this tolerance of being in quiet communal places and not just child centric places if as a society we are so hostile to kids acting up. I would leave a place if my kids were being disruptive but obviously it would need to have got to that point first, which people would then witness!

Alondra · 31/08/2023 12:31

beeswaxinc · 31/08/2023 12:11

I would have thought this too if I had only had my first and third child. I would be very smug and assume it was all down to parenting but the truth is a lot of this comes down to the child’s nature as well.

I am not saying it’s an excuse for poor behaviour but it is important to acknowledge that some children for many reasons are much more resistant than you have painted here. Good behaviour is not a problem at all for 2 of my 3 children but my middle son is wired in a completely different way; it was noticeable literally from the day he was born.

And he is still not a “bad” child he just has different needs, and some needs are harder to figure out than others. Triggers need to be identified and young children cannot yet adequately communicate even to themselves what their issues are. Anxiety in children often presents as anger or naughtiness. Labelling every negative behaviour a child presents as needing chastisement or punishment as a solution does not help them develop the coping skills needed to learn to self regulate and feel better. Yet in the UK there is a pressure to treat children with an overly firm hand especially in public, or else be labelled as a pathetic parent with a nightmare child, as evidenced on this thread!

Some kids are special with different needs, I agree completely with you. But this is not the majority of kids screening and yelling. My nephew in Spain is severely disabled with extreme behaviours. His parents have exposed him to social life since he was a baby and he's doing great at 26. The exposure was in degrees - when he triggered, his parents left bit by bit at a time. He also had essential feedback like "we love you but you can't do that" from his trusted barman at the local bar or bakery. He still can have a meltdown but it rarely happens now and he's travelled all over the world.

These are exceptional kids, but the majority are not exceptional. Something is not right when neurotypical kids keep yelling and screaming in public when they shouldn't.

TripleDaisySummer · 31/08/2023 12:24

Yes, I found this very difficult as well as a parent of a child with SEN. I wanted the school to offer suggestions and solutions and ideas that I could then reinforce at home. But they kept putting it back to me, "what do you think he needs?". I don't know. If I knew, I wouldn't be tearing my hair out because he's behind in everything. And he doesn't know either because he's only 8.

Quite often I knew what he didn't need - but I'm not a professional and I needed them to tell me what was possible.

I found this as well - we'd often be told they weren't behind and then suddenly be told they were - ie what we'd been saying - and then we'd ask how do we help with this and get blank looks.

I can only think of one teacher who offered a suggestion over three kids and other times the school would put them in some additional support which often wasn't appropriate because it was what they had. The primary boards here were much more helpful.

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 12:18

And he is still not a “bad” child he just has different needs, and some needs are harder to figure out than others. Triggers need to be identified and young children cannot yet adequately communicate even to themselves what their issues are. Anxiety in children often presents as anger or naughtiness. Labelling every negative behaviour a child presents as needing chastisement or punishment as a solution does not help them develop the coping skills needed to learn to self regulate and feel better. Yet in the UK there is a pressure to treat children with an overly firm hand especially in public, or else be labelled as a pathetic parent with a nightmare child, as evidenced on this thread!

I do sympathise but I think the point is that if your child cannot cope in certain environments, it's actually on you as the parent to keep them out of those environments. It's better for you, better for the child and better for the people around you. DS could not cope in restaurants or coffee shops for more than a short period. We accepted that and didn't go to those places or only went in situations where we could take him out quickly as needed. Slowly, he built up his tolerance and ability to manage. Even now, as a pre-teen, given the choice, he'll choose places that are less busy, less manic and less overwhelming for him.

tootyflooty · 31/08/2023 12:17

I know, right, "gentle parenting", that means not parenting, and is an excuse for inept parenting, never heard so much bulls**t, society has gone mad, as can be seen by behaviour in schools and in public.

2weekstowait · 31/08/2023 12:13

Sorry to hear of your experience. We like museums and have honestly never experienced anything like you describe. Perhaps we’re just lucky we haven’t been there at the ‘wrong’ time. For the most part, we’ve only seen well behaved kids just enjoying themselves.

Nannydoodles · 31/08/2023 12:12

I volunteer in a charity shop twice a week and children get bought in here and told to play with the toys whilst Mum looks around.
Mostly fine but some children think they can open boxes, pull out the contents and shoot cars etc all over the floor. We had one lady step on a car and fall into a stand, hurting her arm. When you try and stop them and explain it’s a shop not a playground the responses are unbelievable, often SEN issues are mentioned, but all children need to be taught to respect others or supervised closely if they can’t.
Everyone is part of society and nowadays few are taught to consider others unfortunately.

Alondra · 31/08/2023 12:11

I've been in Australia 10 years now, and I still can't get used to kids screaming and yelling in a grocery shop. I'm pretty laid back and try to understand it, but I really don't. Last year I went back to Spain, Madrid, and it was so incredibly obvious the difference. No yelling, no screaming kids, no matter how young they were in the shops.

Maybe it's parenting, maybe it's culture. In Spain, kids from very young age are exposed to socialise with the community with their parents, and they get told off by a barman, shopkeeper, teller, friends or family, if they are misbehaving in public.

Probably the adage of "raising a kid by a village" or country norms, have a lot to do with it.

beeswaxinc · 31/08/2023 12:11

Alondra · 31/08/2023 11:54

Children are sponges. Give them time, attention, clear boundaries and expose them to social settings from a very young age, and they'll behave beautifully with few exceptions when they are toddlers. Even they are toddlers, leaving a shop when they are in full meltdown mode screaming blue murder, gives them a clear boundary - they can't get what they want by behaving badly..\

Children are not feral, there is bad parenting.

I would have thought this too if I had only had my first and third child. I would be very smug and assume it was all down to parenting but the truth is a lot of this comes down to the child’s nature as well.

I am not saying it’s an excuse for poor behaviour but it is important to acknowledge that some children for many reasons are much more resistant than you have painted here. Good behaviour is not a problem at all for 2 of my 3 children but my middle son is wired in a completely different way; it was noticeable literally from the day he was born.

And he is still not a “bad” child he just has different needs, and some needs are harder to figure out than others. Triggers need to be identified and young children cannot yet adequately communicate even to themselves what their issues are. Anxiety in children often presents as anger or naughtiness. Labelling every negative behaviour a child presents as needing chastisement or punishment as a solution does not help them develop the coping skills needed to learn to self regulate and feel better. Yet in the UK there is a pressure to treat children with an overly firm hand especially in public, or else be labelled as a pathetic parent with a nightmare child, as evidenced on this thread!

GingerIsBest · 31/08/2023 12:08

StTropezTan · 31/08/2023 11:26

This is also a very valid point.
Working as a TA I spent a lot of time in meetings in schools with Behaviour Support. Even they were at a loss to recommend coping strategies for many children and often the only advice they could suggest was to say to the child, “I see you’re struggling. What would you like to do about it?”

I wanted to scream myself and say that these children didn’t want ‘choices’ they wanted structure and consistency. They wanted to know where they were on the ladder and to know that the adults around them could be relied upon to be firm but fair. Choices are only appropriate if the alternatives are made very clear, otherwise they’re too nebulous.

I felt that a lot of these strategies were fads and that the children were just part of some kind of social experiment which was a huge disservice and ultimately, quite destructive to them. Too many middle class parents have got suckered into this experiment by believing their child is a special case and deserves exceptional treatment rather than recognising much of the challenging behaviour is a result of their policies rather than an inherent fault in their child or the school.

Yes, I found this very difficult as well as a parent of a child with SEN. I wanted the school to offer suggestions and solutions and ideas that I could then reinforce at home. But they kept putting it back to me, "what do you think he needs?". I don't know. If I knew, I wouldn't be tearing my hair out because he's behind in everything. And he doesn't know either because he's only 8.

Quite often I knew what he didn't need - but I'm not a professional and I needed them to tell me what was possible.

With SIL - I think they're also so busy pussy footing around that I'm not sure she's getting the message about how difficult her DC is. So she tells us about x or y issue at school and sanctions or things put in place but seems to gloss over it as she hasn't clocked it's an issue - says things like, "it's to help him make better choices" or whatever. There's never anything about what she should be doing or DC should be doing to support these "better choices". Drives me mad.

Alondra · 31/08/2023 11:54

Children are sponges. Give them time, attention, clear boundaries and expose them to social settings from a very young age, and they'll behave beautifully with few exceptions when they are toddlers. Even they are toddlers, leaving a shop when they are in full meltdown mode screaming blue murder, gives them a clear boundary - they can't get what they want by behaving badly..\

Children are not feral, there is bad parenting.

MissingMoominMamma · 31/08/2023 11:47

Screamingabdabz · 30/08/2023 19:58

You’re clearly not ‘firm’ enough if you have to ‘try to get them under control’ 🙄 Try to get yourself under control if you think weak parenting is going to win you their affection when they are teenagers who have zero respect for you.

Wow.

CatPancake · 31/08/2023 11:43

notanaturalmum · 30/08/2023 20:33

I find this hard to read.
I'm sure I'm a good mum, people always tell me my kids are well behaved eg babysitters.
But my 6 year old DS cannot sit still. He's always fidgeting, running about, singing. If we go to museums, he tries to touch stuff etc. I spend my days going "don't touch that, play quietly, keep your voice down, sit still, look at me when I'm talking, wait, stop.
I feel like I'm constantly giving him orders the poor child doesn't know if he's coming or going.
But if I don't do this, then he acts "feral" and then I get looks like I'm a bad parent. But I'm not. He's just a kid who is wired. I don't think he's ADHD or rather I'm open to believing he's just an energetic little boy. But I want him to go to museums and art galleries. Why should be consigned to only going to parks because he's a bit noisy.

Aren't children with ADHD also just energetic hyperactive little boys (or girls) too?

6 is too young to diagnose ADHD so I'm not suggesting your son has it - but I have ADHD and so does my daughter, and my 2 nephews.

I just want to challenge what I pick up from your post as possibly being a little bit ableist? My DNs are like little puppies - need to be active and kept engaged - constant vigilance to remind them of appropriate behaviour.

They're not bad kids. It makes them more energetic than most, more impulsive than most, have selective hearing Grin and benefit from consistency. I dont know what you think ADHD is?

(My DD and I both have inattentive type of ADHD)