Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my solicitor has screwed me over!

192 replies

Lakes11 · 30/08/2023 17:58

Its 4 days before I attend the first hearing for a child contact court order that my ex as raised. My solicitor (she's actually a paralegal) has been away for a week and previous to that I had not heard much and thought she had everything in hand.
She had months ago told me she could attend court with me if I wished her too. She's put in a legal aid application for me too which I thought was in hand. Today after emailing her asking about court and what the process is and what's happening and can she attend and my legal aid, it is only now she's telling me she can't attend court with me as she has no advocacy rights and I'll have to pay for a barrister privately as my legal aid decision will not come though until next Wednesday at the earliest.

So she's said I may have to self represent. I've paid her so much money previously whilst waiting to apply for legal aid which I can't really afford but what has she actually done other then send some emails. She hasn't advised me even when I've asked questions.
On top of this we are still awaiting a court bundle from my ex which I knew nothing about until now and she's only just chasing up for. So I don't have that. Reading up on a court bundle.it states about having personal statements in there? I asked her months ago about me having my say as I haven't had any chance to respond she said that I wouldn't need to do that until the fact finding hearing.

I feel like she's absolutely screwed me over and is completely useless. I don't have the money to go to anyone else and there is only one other firm in my region who does legal aid but they are no use either and did not get back to me.

I am so stressed, I don't know what I'm going to do and I don't know anything about court!

OP posts:
Pilateshappy · 30/08/2023 19:40

I'm a Solicitor and the firm I used to work in had paralegals who would carry out a lot of work themselves and in some instances were more knowledgeable that the solicitors / trainees.

I would contact the Partner in charge of the family department first thing tomorrow and try and clarify the situation.

Are you in England or Wales?

RoyKentFanclub · 30/08/2023 19:36

wejammin · 30/08/2023 19:30

If it's a first hearing in child arrangements (FHDRA) it would be very unusual to have written a full witness statement.
You can prepare a position statement which just sets out an overview of what you would like the court to order, and your solicitor's office should help you to do that.
I would definitely push for the solicitors office to make someone available to represent you on Monday. Just be mindful that if they charge by hourly rates, and they are senior, they may end up costing more for a morning at court than a junior barrister on a fixed fee.

It will definitely be more expensive to have a solicitor there than a barrister (although I’ve not done legal aid work for decades (literally) so have no knowledge of how that works)

I agree with a Pp that she’s probably lost control and is trying to keep it secret from her supervisor. It’s far easier for that to happen now that there is so much remote working

Canonlythinkofthisone · 30/08/2023 19:36

https://www.facebook.com/groups/fathersjustice/?ref=share

Please join this group. They'll help you. You do not need a solicitor. Waste of money.

Facebook

https://www.facebook.com/groups/fathersjustice?ref=share

LondonLass91 · 30/08/2023 19:36

Kezabella84 · 30/08/2023 19:09

Hi,

I’ve just joined specifically to reply to this post.

Firstly, I’m so sorry you’re going through this . Im going through similar with my ex and it’s all consuming.

I just wanted to try and appease your stress a little. I can’t help in regards to making a complaint against the paralegal but just wanted to tell you that similar happened to me before my first court hearing in that I wasn’t represented that first time. I’d had a solicitor lined up who had applied for legal aid but a few days before the hearing she contacted to let me know that her or her firm couldn’t represent me due to conflict of interests (I think my ex had used them before).

My would-be solicitor was really helpful though explaining that she’d try and find me another solicitor (which she did but he wasn't available to represent me at that first hearing).

She said I could try for a postponement but honestly that it would be better just to go ahead with it and that the judge was used to people self representing and that I should explain to the judge that the circumstances were that I’d tried for representation and was going to get some for next time.

On the day it was absolutely fine. The judge heard from my ex’s Barrister and then asked me a few questions (about what I intended the outcome to be - ex has gone for the children living with him full time) and then instructed what he wanted me (and the other side) to do before a certain date (think it was a month). All he asked of me was that I prepare and file a statement (in response to my ex’s statement which had been in the court bundle and which I’d seen before the court date).

After that court hearing I had a few meetings with the new solicitor who helped me with my statement and whilst things are still ongoing with my case things are (touch wood) sorted new legal representation wise.

Good luck try not to worry.

Fantastic advice here.

wejammin · 30/08/2023 19:30

If it's a first hearing in child arrangements (FHDRA) it would be very unusual to have written a full witness statement.
You can prepare a position statement which just sets out an overview of what you would like the court to order, and your solicitor's office should help you to do that.
I would definitely push for the solicitors office to make someone available to represent you on Monday. Just be mindful that if they charge by hourly rates, and they are senior, they may end up costing more for a morning at court than a junior barrister on a fixed fee.

Oysterbabe · 30/08/2023 19:25

It wouldn't surprise me if she has lost control of her caseload and she didn't give you details of someone else to deal because she doesn't want to bring it to the attention of her supervisor.
You need to speak to a manager.

RoyKentFanclub · 30/08/2023 19:21

Who has signed the client engagement letter OP. It will most likely be in a partners name. Call that partner tomorrow.

Haretest · 30/08/2023 19:19

Op post this again under legal so you get people answering who actually know if a paralegal can reprint you in court or not!

feellikeanalien · 30/08/2023 19:13

OP I would try to speak to the solicitor named in the retainer letter as a matter of urgency or failing that to the managing partner. It's a long time since I've been involved in this field but the firm are not going to want any complaints which may put their legal aid contract in jeopardy.

The most important thing is to make sure either that you are represented at the hearing or can apply for an adjournment or, in the worst case scenario, that you are prepared to represent yourself.

Any complaint to the SRA can be made later.

Kezabella84 · 30/08/2023 19:09

Hi,

I’ve just joined specifically to reply to this post.

Firstly, I’m so sorry you’re going through this . Im going through similar with my ex and it’s all consuming.

I just wanted to try and appease your stress a little. I can’t help in regards to making a complaint against the paralegal but just wanted to tell you that similar happened to me before my first court hearing in that I wasn’t represented that first time. I’d had a solicitor lined up who had applied for legal aid but a few days before the hearing she contacted to let me know that her or her firm couldn’t represent me due to conflict of interests (I think my ex had used them before).

My would-be solicitor was really helpful though explaining that she’d try and find me another solicitor (which she did but he wasn't available to represent me at that first hearing).

She said I could try for a postponement but honestly that it would be better just to go ahead with it and that the judge was used to people self representing and that I should explain to the judge that the circumstances were that I’d tried for representation and was going to get some for next time.

On the day it was absolutely fine. The judge heard from my ex’s Barrister and then asked me a few questions (about what I intended the outcome to be - ex has gone for the children living with him full time) and then instructed what he wanted me (and the other side) to do before a certain date (think it was a month). All he asked of me was that I prepare and file a statement (in response to my ex’s statement which had been in the court bundle and which I’d seen before the court date).

After that court hearing I had a few meetings with the new solicitor who helped me with my statement and whilst things are still ongoing with my case things are (touch wood) sorted new legal representation wise.

Good luck try not to worry.

WhatapityWapiti · 30/08/2023 19:07

DelurkingLawyer · 30/08/2023 18:51

Ok so she has not held herself out as a solicitor (I am not surprised by this). Forget that.

Can I say again please focus on getting this fixed and put the complaint to one side for the moment. I understand why you are angry but:

  1. Can someone from the firm with rights of audience attend? How much would that cost? Do they consider it necessary?

  2. If not can the hearing be adjourned? Is there time? How much would such an application cost? Would this carry any risk that the other side could get their costs off you?

  3. If not, where’s the bundle - you need it urgently and they need to crack on so you can read it and ask them any questions about it. What is this reference to statements? Why have they not asked you to do one?

  4. Other questions about the purpose of the hearing and arguments you should make, obtain book as per my comment above.

If you can’t get anything sensible from her then ask to speak to the supervisor to get answers to these questions.

I agree with what you say but this IS the complaint, and should be addressed to the partner named in the retainer letter.

I agree that going straight to the SRA is not the answer here.

Ap42 · 30/08/2023 18:56

I had a similar situation when my ex took me to court for a child arrangements order. I used a paralegal, they are generally great at wording legal stuff and cheaper than a solicitor. They can come to court with you, in a mackenzie friend capacity but they cannot speak on your behalf, so you would be sef representing anyway. I was advised to use a barrister, often they work out cheaper if you only need them to represent you in court. I had some issues with my paralegal too, she was very difficult to get hold of, was also on annual leave a lot etc... found it very frustrating!

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 30/08/2023 18:56

🌺

Diorama1 · 30/08/2023 18:56

OP what work did you pay her to do, who did she send emails to?

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/08/2023 18:54

Paralegals can be highly experienced, often more than trainee solicitors. They work under the supervision of a solicitor but carry their own caseload.

It's commonplace to appoint a barrister to represent you in court. Solicitors can but barristers are typically more experienced in this area. Think of solicitors as GPs and barristers as hospital consultants if you like.

Having said that it's absolutely perfectly possible to self represent in family court. In my experience judges allow more flexibility/more guidance is given if this is the case.

You need to raise this with the partner as a complaint.

bluebellthecat · 30/08/2023 18:54

Don't panic. You can represent yourself.
Write the statement and send it to the court on Friday - they read it a few days beforehand. If you look at the court documents, there should be a deadline for submitting it. If there's no email there, just find it from their website.

You can find a statement template online or just write one in a logical, easy to understand way.

In the email to court, apologise for the misunderstanding and briefly explain change in representation.

Family court is different to regular court - it's like a formal work meeting. You can have your day just don't slate him off in the statement or in court - make it revolve around the child.

My representation also fell through prior to my fact-finding hearing. There was someone in the court on the day who was on duty to represent parents. I did use him and he was okay, but I felt that I would have done a better job and got a better negotiation. For the second, and last hearing I represented myself.

If you are reasonably intelligent, and can present yourself in a decent and articulate way, you can represent yourself.

Doveyouknow · 30/08/2023 18:53

The whole thing sounds extremely odd. She should've been aware she couldn't represent you in court as she doesn't have rights of audience. At best a judge might let her advise you / speak for you as a Mackenzie friend but that's at the discretion of the judge. As others advise you need to contact the managing partner or complaints handling partner and see if they can help sort this out.

Chasetherainblownfearsaway · 30/08/2023 18:52

You have had very poor service. I would suggest sending a succinct email to the partner responsible for complaints tonight, summarising the problem. You should explain that you have been left in the lurch due to the failure to tell you promptly that the paralegal could not represent you, and the apparent failure to prepare the case properly for the hearing. You should say that you need them to draft an email you can send to the court explaining the situation and that it is not your fault but theirs, and that you should not be penalised as a result, but that an adjournment will be necessary to enable you to prepare adequately.

GrannyGoggins · 30/08/2023 18:52

anywherehollie · 30/08/2023 18:46

Paralegals absolutely can represent you in court. I'm a paralegal and I just ask the Judge for rights of audience. I literally have a trial next month. I'm not in family law but all our paralegals do hearings.

She sounds really awful though from what you are saying, this would never fly in my firm!

Is this a fairly new thing because it never used to be the case?

TheAOEAztec · 30/08/2023 18:51

Well this one is studying toward her law degree and based on her conduct is not an experienced paralegal who should be handling own cases

DelurkingLawyer · 30/08/2023 18:51

Ok so she has not held herself out as a solicitor (I am not surprised by this). Forget that.

Can I say again please focus on getting this fixed and put the complaint to one side for the moment. I understand why you are angry but:

  1. Can someone from the firm with rights of audience attend? How much would that cost? Do they consider it necessary?

  2. If not can the hearing be adjourned? Is there time? How much would such an application cost? Would this carry any risk that the other side could get their costs off you?

  3. If not, where’s the bundle - you need it urgently and they need to crack on so you can read it and ask them any questions about it. What is this reference to statements? Why have they not asked you to do one?

  4. Other questions about the purpose of the hearing and arguments you should make, obtain book as per my comment above.

If you can’t get anything sensible from her then ask to speak to the supervisor to get answers to these questions.

Offyoupoplove · 30/08/2023 18:50

Parentingmishaps · 30/08/2023 18:21

She's overstepped hugely. Contact the practice tomorrow and ask to speak to one of the partners and make a complaint with the question "and how do you plan on fixing this" as the primary agenda.

This!

Soontobe60 · 30/08/2023 18:48

Katrinawaves · 30/08/2023 18:04

A paralegal usually has no legal qualifications whatsoever. How did you find this woman and is she attached to a reputable legal firm, which would mean that she should in theory be being supervised by someone legally qualified?

If this is a bona fide law firm with a legal aid contract, then you need to contact the managing partner ASAP and ask what they plan to do to put all this right. From what you have said in your OP there has been clear negligence and your interests have been prejudiced. The SRA would definitely be interested in all this in due course but your immediate priority needs to be to protect your interests at the hearing next week.

Not strictly true. paralegals can have plenty of qualifications!

anywherehollie · 30/08/2023 18:46

Paralegals absolutely can represent you in court. I'm a paralegal and I just ask the Judge for rights of audience. I literally have a trial next month. I'm not in family law but all our paralegals do hearings.

She sounds really awful though from what you are saying, this would never fly in my firm!

Justneedagirlname · 30/08/2023 18:46

Lakes11 · 30/08/2023 18:23

Because I'm currently awaiting legal aid I just feel like they won't care as I won't be bringing in that much money for them

They will care about potential complaint to SRA though, it is Solicitors Regulation Authority!

Swipe left for the next trending thread