Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car Insurance

34 replies

jellytable · 30/08/2023 17:26

AIBU to think car insurance is not making sense. It seems fraudulent that a small ding (my fault) has resulted in a claim for £3700 (more than the cost of the other car) and my insurance going up by £1000 even with 20 years no claims protection. The cost of the claim was mainly the hire car. I kind of wish I hadn't been honest and left a note saying I'd done it, it has certainly made think I might not if it ever happened again.

Are the insurance comparison sites the best places to try to get a better deal going forward and is it worth considering a monitoring box/app or is that an excuse to rip you off too? What is the point in the no claims protection thing if it doesn't stop your insurance going up?

OP posts:
Fightyouforthatpie · 30/08/2023 17:58

Loving all the PR from Insurers. Mysterious statistics that "prove" if someone runs into you, it was your fault 😂
What a laugh.

They are all robbing bastards end of.

FFSWhatToDoNow · 30/08/2023 17:56

Hence being called Protected NCB.

Barleysugar86 · 30/08/2023 17:55

SmileyClare · 30/08/2023 17:37

I use GoCompare every time my car insurance is due for renewal. It’s a faff to change but always saves money.

All insurance companies are robbing bastards though. My policy went up after a claim where I was declared not at fault. Seems unfair, but apparently I deemed “higher risk” if someone drives into me?!

I think it’s common place with minor prangs to ask the other driver if they’d like to settle it without involving insurance.

My neighbour scraped my car and offered me cash which I gladly accepted. I won’t go through the insurance unless I have to.

The thing with no fault claims is statistically having one you are more likely to have others, fault or non fault. The data isn't personal, there are huge databases of information that says this is the case.

It makes more sense if you think of it as some non faults would be caused by less than ideal driving, but fault went to the other car because they had hit you from behind when you did something they weren't expecting. Or it might suggest your eyesight or reaction times might not be as sharp as other drivers who may have reacted in time to avoid a collision, even though the other car caused it.

I appreciate how annoying it is though. Ours went up following a very obvious cash for crash set up. The system isn't perfect but its reliant on a rather cold calculation of risk by a computer for the most part.

FFSWhatToDoNow · 30/08/2023 17:55

What is the point in the no claims protection thing if it doesn't stop your insurance going up?

it protects the discount.

example:

5 years NCB = 70%. 3 years NCB = 50%

base premium £1000
price paid with 5 years NCB £300

after accident:

base premium £1500
price with protected no claims £450
price without protected no claims £750

Cyclistmumgrandma · 30/08/2023 17:51

SmileyClare · 30/08/2023 17:37

I use GoCompare every time my car insurance is due for renewal. It’s a faff to change but always saves money.

All insurance companies are robbing bastards though. My policy went up after a claim where I was declared not at fault. Seems unfair, but apparently I deemed “higher risk” if someone drives into me?!

I think it’s common place with minor prangs to ask the other driver if they’d like to settle it without involving insurance.

My neighbour scraped my car and offered me cash which I gladly accepted. I won’t go through the insurance unless I have to.

Unfortunately you are required to declare any prior accidents, even if you didn't claim....

Barleysugar86 · 30/08/2023 17:49

As much as everyone likes to pile on car insurance companies they aren't a rip off really. They run at a loss (pay out more in claims per year than they get in in premiums) and any profit they make is dependent on investing your premium between the time they are received and claims paid. In a way they could be seen as quite a nifty money saving service as the profit isn't at anyone's expense.

Premiums are calculated as a percentage of risk you represent to the overall pot. Clearly after a £3700 claim (not insignificant at all) you are going to be a worse risk, statistically once you've had a claim you are more likely to have another one unfortunately. As far as your insurer knows maybe there were hidden health/ eyesight problems at play. This will come down over the next five years if there are no futher claims but is a bit of a waiting game I'm afraid.

The worst case for an insurer is an accident where someone causes lifelong injuries to a person, these costs far exceed anything the insurer is paying out on the value of cars and will be what the increased premium is representing. There is also a sizeable increase generally for all policies this year due to inflation, same as everything we buy, so some of your increase will be this. Car insurers ran a huge loss last year (109% loss ratio- 100% is where they break even on claims paid out and premiums in) so all premiums have had to go up.

Comparison sites and brokers and shopping around is your best bet. The most favourable premiums will come for you from insurers targeting those with claims history who can see the nuances that make you less of a risk for them. It's always a good idea to use at least three sources as some are affiliated with certain insurers and may have deals with them. Also try and search around two weeks or more ahead of your renewal date.

I'd be open to a telematics box if it works out cheaper for you, although these are usually more beneficial for new drivers.

jellytable · 30/08/2023 17:37

What would it have gone up by if I didn't have an immaculate history and no claims protection? My insurance was £250 not to many years ago. Now it's probably going to be £1500+ just like when I was a teen in a sports car!

OP posts:
SmileyClare · 30/08/2023 17:37

I use GoCompare every time my car insurance is due for renewal. It’s a faff to change but always saves money.

All insurance companies are robbing bastards though. My policy went up after a claim where I was declared not at fault. Seems unfair, but apparently I deemed “higher risk” if someone drives into me?!

I think it’s common place with minor prangs to ask the other driver if they’d like to settle it without involving insurance.

My neighbour scraped my car and offered me cash which I gladly accepted. I won’t go through the insurance unless I have to.

Rosesarere · 30/08/2023 17:31

The protected no claims bonus aspect of your insurance is to stop them being stepped back in the event of a fault claim. You will still have a load on your premium with a fault claim unfortunately

Swipe left for the next trending thread