Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think I’m doing anything wrong here?

113 replies

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 13:57

Work in an office role for a busy company. Lots of phone calls and emails between departments. Apparently I have a reputation for being short on the phone i.e. straight to the point, no ‘how are you’, and that I don’t say goodbye. This wasn’t brought up in a formal way, more as a laugh actually.

Truth is, I hate chit chat, with the amount of phone calls I do I can’t bear chit chatting every single time. I’d get nothing done! I tend to just say ‘Hi, (hi) please can you send that me that document when you get chance? (Yeah sure) Great thanks.’ Conversation done.

I am often stressed as role is demanding. I can’t help but think that people don’t like it especially when it comes from a woman because we’re supposed to be nice and kind and polite all the time. Don’t know if it makes a difference that I’m younger (should I be sweetness and all things nice?).

TBH I think that some of my colleagues could really do with being a bit more efficient and less chit chatty!

I’m also in a management role so don’t know if that makes a difference.

I have plenty of friends at work and always get invited to events etc.

Just wondered what others thought/their experiences?

OP posts:
andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 30/08/2023 16:31

I don’t have time on the phone. If people want to come to my desk and chat once things have quietened down then please do!

Nobody's so busy that they can't stay on the phone for an extra two seconds to say goodbye Hmm

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 16:30

@Strictlyfanoftenyears I always say hello. Not always goodbye though.

OP posts:
Strictlyfanoftenyears · 30/08/2023 16:28

I would be offended if someone didnt say hello and goodbye. That is rude and unprofessional.

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 16:26

@Spectre8 I do care in terms of interested to hear people’s thoughts yes! That’s what I said way back at the start.

@andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow I don’t have time on the phone. If people want to come to my desk and chat once things have quietened down then please do! We have great chats in my office team. Also can’t be arsed too!

@Doormatnomore Enjoyed that story!

OP posts:
Spectre8 · 30/08/2023 16:22

You're like my manager, zero emotional intelligence. You just treat people like robots thats how its come across. In fact it is quite dehumanising in a way.

Noone comes to work for the fun of it, we only work to earn money cos most of us wouldn't do it otemherwise. So these small little pleasantries make going to work that little bit nicer. It doesn't cost you anything it really doesn't (a mere few seconds) if you framed it right.

You say u don't care then why start a thread about feedback you got, it is obviously bothering you but you don't seem like you're willing to change. How much time have you wasted on this thread about something you say you dont care about...bit odd isn't it.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 30/08/2023 16:21

I don’t want to upset people and it isn’t my intention. I just genuinely don’t have time for it. I find it tedious and boring

You do have time for it, you just can't be arsed with it because you don't think it's important.

Doormatnomore · 30/08/2023 16:16

My favourite manager in the whole world feels the same about gibber jabber. We would have god awful team catch up meetings which would go on until the janitor came to lock up given half a chance. When it was just the 2 of us (about every 6 weeks) we’d crash through the bullet points and sit and work in silence for the rest of the hour.
it was noted in his CPD that he needed to develop more personal relationships with his underlings which meant he asked opened ended questions and they they told him what he wanted to hear. Rather came to a head when 2 team members were having an affair and were outed by a third and I somehow missed it cause I was working rather than making small talk. Was given serious stink eye by HR when I said honestly I had no idea they’d been to the same places every weekend and ate together every lunchtime cause that was part of my job.

sheworemellowyellow · 30/08/2023 16:07

The world needs more people like you OP!

Hi and bye are fine, the rest is just aaaaarrrrgggghhhhhh!

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 16:04

@BatildaB I don’t particularly mind either way whether people like or dislike me, in all areas of life not just work. I’ve never much been bothered about that, even from young. I definitely don’t launch straight into requests. If they avoid my
calls then that’s life I suppose. The task will still need to get done eventually by them.

@caringcarer I have wondered this! I do think I’m more task focused than people focused like you say.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 30/08/2023 15:57

Sounds like you're a task orientated person working in a people orientated environment. I'm similar and would get irritated by colleagues wasting so much time.

BatildaB · 30/08/2023 15:53

Not saying ‘hi, how are you?’ Or ‘hello, it’s crawdad from bla’ and waiting a second for a response, and not saying ‘thanks, bye’ is clearly not more efficient - I’m sure if you launch straight into a request people must often have to ask you to repeat yourself, the fact people have told you it is rude means they’ll be less likely to want to do whatever you’re requesting soon and well, and I wouldn’t be surprised if some people avoid answering calls from you. It’s obvious that following a short expected conversation format is more efficient, both for that conversation and for general workflow. So this isn’t about efficiency, it’s about identity or power. Do you want people to think you’re a very driven but eccentric maverick, or do you want them to think you consider yourself too important to treat them with courtesy while making requests? I think you are being disingenuous about your motivations for this behaviour.

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 15:40

Thanks all it’s been a really helpful thread and good to hear different sides of it!

OP posts:
LonginesPrime · 30/08/2023 15:18

Topping and tailing a request with a bit of small talk should be enough to negate the negative feedback.

This.

I just have the same brief "script" I use with everyone and then I might change it for people I know better depending on the situation. But the basics stay the same and it's just as much a habit as, say, knowing to dial 9 for an outside line or anything else involved in making a phone call.

I just see it as part of the process of calling someone and part of what I'm being paid to do (via the fact that most employment contracts are contingent on satisfactory appraisals and this kind of thing is often raised in appraisals as an area for improvement when people are considered abrupt). Yes, it may seem mad that they would pay me to be nice to people at the expense of efficiency, but if that's how they want to spend their money, then that's up to them. I can play along for the pay check.

CharlotteBog · 30/08/2023 15:16

There must be a middle ground between chatting about your personal life and just hanging up w/o saying good bye.

Colleague: great, I'll send the documents over later.
OP: thanks [hangs up]

OP: crawdag here, I'm confirming the meeting is at 2pm tomorrow.
Colleague: great, thank you
OP [hangs up]

Is that how the conversations go? They seem a bit awkward and blunt.

I mean, "bye" at the end of a call signifies the conversation is over.

ManateeFair · 30/08/2023 15:14

From what you've said here, my guess is that when your colleagues say you are 'a bit short' on the phone, what they actually mean is that you come across as brusque and rude. They would not have mentioned it otherwise.

For example, not saying goodbye at the end of a call is definitely rude. And rudeness is unprofessional.

I don't have really long phone chats with people at work, but I would say that a bare minimum of something like 'Hi, how are you?' and a thanks and goodbye is required for a professional telephone manner. Basic people skills and a degree of self-awareness about how you come across to others are all facets of professional behaviour, and even more so when you're in a managerial role.

You don't need to have a chat about people's personal lives, but simple good manners and a friendly tone are required. It doesn't matter how stressed or busy you are. Other people manage to be polite and personable when they're stressed and busy, and you should be able to manage it too.

Nothing to do with being female, either.

WeWereInParis · 30/08/2023 15:10

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 14:37

@FartSock5000 thank you. I think this is it. I don’t want to upset people and it isn’t my intention. I just genuinely don’t have time for it. I find it tedious and boring. But it sounds like your approach is best and I have to fake it. It’s just very frustrating when I have so many calls a day. And often multiple with the same people!

You can't possibly find it tedious and boring to say "bye". Who could be bored by saying something that takes less than a second.

Small talk more generally I find differs person to person. Some people I work with will drone on about their cats for the first 10 mins of every conversation, some get straight to the work related point of the call. EVERYONE says bye at the end.

PuppyMonkey · 30/08/2023 15:04

I don’t agree with inane small talk but saying “thanks bye” before you hang up hardly takes half an hour of precious time.

i worked with a bloke once who not only didn’t say goodbye, he didn’t say hello or anything else either. Phoning him was excruciatingly awkward.

so it would go:

Me (ringing from other office): Hi Graham, it’s Puppy here.
Him: tumbleweed.
Me: You asked me to call about that report.
Him: tumbleweed.
Me: I’ve done it all, should I send it off or do you need to look at it first?
Him: continued tumbleweed
Me: waits.
Me: waits.
Me: waits.
Me: Hello?
Him: Yep, send it. (Hangs up)
Me: Confused

BellaJuno · 30/08/2023 15:04

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 14:37

@FartSock5000 thank you. I think this is it. I don’t want to upset people and it isn’t my intention. I just genuinely don’t have time for it. I find it tedious and boring. But it sounds like your approach is best and I have to fake it. It’s just very frustrating when I have so many calls a day. And often multiple with the same people!

You can still keep it brief “Hi sorry me again, feel like I talk to you more than my partner some days! Anyway, can you tell me…..”

Topping and tailing a request with a bit of small talk should be enough to negate the negative feedback.

SummerDayz47 · 30/08/2023 15:02

Surely this is not a one size fits all model and it should be based on who you talk to.

I have some colleagues who want a direct and quick conversation. I have some who don’t want to talk about anything from their personal life, I have others that love it when you ask how their weekend / child / dog is. It takes 2 minutes to make the latter feel good…

Uterusbegone · 30/08/2023 15:02

The thing is people who describe themselves as 'efficient' are often perceived by others as abrupt and a bit rude, and therefore less approachable. That is not a positive thing when you rely on collaboration to get things done

If it is being said in a jokey way, it has been noticed and you should pay attention because people will often try to address issues like this first before raising it as 'an issue' with your manager

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 30/08/2023 15:01

I'm with you. As lovely as it is to start every slack conversation with enquiries about the weather and my health, I'd prefer to just get to the point.

TBH, I suck it up and I'm polite when other people start it, but when I start a conversation it's short and to the point (polite, but not chatty). I've had feedback that it's appreciated (especially by other techs)

LonginesPrime · 30/08/2023 14:58

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 14:37

@FartSock5000 thank you. I think this is it. I don’t want to upset people and it isn’t my intention. I just genuinely don’t have time for it. I find it tedious and boring. But it sounds like your approach is best and I have to fake it. It’s just very frustrating when I have so many calls a day. And often multiple with the same people!

I've been recently diagnosed as autistic and I don't see the point of the social chitchat stuff either and find it super tedious, but have always done it because that's what people expect and it's how the reciprocal social stuff works.

No-one is going to know if you're only pretending to care about someone's holiday or kids or if you actually do - they never know the difference (and other people might not genuinely care either - who knows?), and I've found I often get further in work if I just pretend to care and do what everyone else is doing.

I learnt how to behave by reading about it, observing others and then experimenting to see what worked and what didn't.

I suggest experimenting with doing things slightly differently in a low-stakes situation, and seeing if it helps make things feel a bit smoother with your colleagues. If it's too exhausting and unbearable, then you don't have to do it, but you might find that it sometimes makes your job a bit easier, so it's definitely worth experimenting with different communication styles to see the effect it has on your interactions.

I find that even though I'm not always inclined to be sociable at work, I'm glad I developed those skills to use when I need to, as they have definitely come in handy over the years!

MrsColinRobinson · 30/08/2023 14:58

Wherethecrawdadssingg · 30/08/2023 14:26

@MrsColinRobinson If I I struggled I wouldn’t ask for opinions on mumsnet 🙄

Except you only respond positively to those who tell you you're fine and defensively to those who say you need to modify your behaviour.

As is demonstrated in your snippy reply to me.

Bye op (took a second to say)

aWorkOne · 30/08/2023 14:57

I would be offended if anyone - male or female - hung up the phone on me. Not saying 'thanks, bye' is rude. If my manager did it I would be even more offended! I also don't want chit chat on the phone, but hanging up without saying good-bye is really rude

willWillSmithsmith · 30/08/2023 14:52

I think as long as you say please and thank you no further chatter is necessary. Manners are important but chatter isn’t.