Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My boyfriend expects me to pay for everything

391 replies

Fanofbeasmith · 29/08/2023 23:50

My boyfriend gave up his job and now expects me to pay for everything.

He has this idea that if he wasn't with me he wouldn't be eating in this place or that, he wouldn't be visiting this place or that, so he just let's me pay. He's right, yesterday we did a day out with my children, brunch out, tea out, all in all it cost me over £300 for the day plus the takeaway the night before. If he wasn't with me he'd make food at home. But he didn't, he joined in.

I hate that attitude, it's really giving me the ick.

Last week we ate in a nice restaurant, i paid. Later I asked for the money, he said he thought I was treating him because he's not working. But why should I?

He's a nice guy other than this. He's kind, he's funny, I love being with him. But I can't help feeling used. He chooses not to work, I work hard and obvs have a lot more disposable money than him. But really although I earn a good salary, he is much better off, he's a home owner, no mortgage, I rent and have children. I'm using credit cards to live, he's increasing his savings even while not working.

I can't bear to speak to him ATM so just wondered if I'm being ridiculous?

OP posts:
Dweetfidilove · 31/08/2023 22:41

@Fanofbeasmith I voted YABU, because I want to hug you, shake you or just kmt and walk away all at the same time.

I don't even blame him either, because this is so bleeding obvious.

He doesn't live with you, so you can quite easily go out without him. You can spend time together at the park (free), library etc. Save the expensive meals and trips for you and your children, because he won't help you repay credit card debts he considers unnecessary.

I can also guarantee this relationship won't progress further, because he'll not want to move you into his house when you've ruined your finances treating him. And in the unlikely event it does, it will only be because he knows you'll work and fund the lifestyle to which you've gotten him accustomed.

You really need to catch a grip!

MissBiljanaElectronika · 31/08/2023 22:33

He’s not kind and nice

also maybe stop going for takeaways and meals out and £300 days out if you live off credit cards 🫣🤯

3luckystars · 31/08/2023 22:31

He is stealing joy from you and money from your children.

LaDamaDeElche · 31/08/2023 22:27

Thank you everyone for the messages. I don't think it's possible to summarise someone's entire personality from a couple of posts but I appreciate the opinions nonetheless I don’t think it’s necessary to summarise any other part of his personality apart from the tightness. If you eventually live together he’s not going to magically change. What is giving you the ick now will be the cause of major resentment and arguments, which will affect the environment your children grow up in. Why prolong something that has no future, especially when there are kids and their emotions involved? Everyone is a mix of good/bad (or maybe annoying as opposed to bad exaxtly) qualities. A negative quality like being messy or late or something like that can be overlooked if someone is kind, supportive and generous. Some negative points are just too big to be balanced by positives. I think for most people, this is one.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 31/08/2023 22:20

I can see both points of view but I think you have to take the kids out for a meal alone a few times. If you’re out for the day tell him you’ll be eating out so not to forget his sandwiches. Just don’t pay for him, stop for tea or ice cream and don’t buy him one.
and for the love of god please stop saying ‘ick’ - we’re all adults.

SpiralHecate · 31/08/2023 22:09

It sounds like he's changed in those 3 years, I expect things were different before he quit his job and decided to live like a miser?

You don't have to say 'you can't come', you can tactfully explain that you can't afford to pay for him as well as yourself and the children on a day out or at a restaurant. If he wants to live on a shoestring that's his choice, he can't expect you to give up doing anything fun or face paying his way the whole time.

It sounds like you're growing apart.

PyongyangKipperbang · 31/08/2023 22:07

The thing is, if he really isnt bothered about doing anything that doesnt involve sitting at home not spending money, then that isnt going to change.

Take the money out of the equation for a second. Lets assume you both pay your way but he only goes along with these things because you want to and lets you know that thats the only reason he is there. "I am doing this FOR YOU". So that means that you always wondering if he is having a good time or counting the minutes, therefore maybe you will stop suggesting doing things so often and eventually you end up living his way anyway. OR you keep doing things but it builds up the resentment that whatever you do and wherever you go, its always you doing the organising and transporting. He will never ever take the initiative to organise something simply for the joy of surprising you with something that he knows would make you happy.

So you are basically incompatible.

Adding in that if you want to do anything then you have to pay for him aswell, thats just plain insulting and almost like a punishment for you daring to want to do anything that he wouldnt choose to do for himself.

Does he holiday? If you wanted to I take it he would happily go but expect you to pay for him?

Bin him.

booksandbeans · 31/08/2023 22:05

I took my children on holiday last month and his attitude is that if I can waste £ thousands on a holiday I can pay a few quid for a meal.

But this is all your kids childhood. Did he never go on holiday as a child? he has chosen not to work, you can chose not to fund his chosen lifestyle.

Maybe ease up on the meals out but otherwise he needs to start paying his way if he wants to join you on days out.

GUARDIAN1 · 31/08/2023 22:00

The only thing that is ridiculous is putting up with him for a moment longer. He's taking away money that should be used for you and your children. Get rid of him.

Radiohat · 31/08/2023 21:57

Zone2NorthLondon · 31/08/2023 21:47

More nonsense and some inappropriate emoji too. You erroneously linked his stingy behaviour to mental illness and I disputed it.That isn’t so nasty it’s simply challenging stigma that labels any unsavoury behaviour as indicative of mental illness.

My mind is open to the possibility that such behaviour may have a link to MH . I am not saying it is the only answer but something that could be possible.

You are obviously not an emogi person 🙄 - & we all express ourselves in different ways. 😉

RadishAndTwiglet · 31/08/2023 21:52

he would rather we ate cheaply at his every single meal. By cheaply I mean toast or porridge or soup. That's what he'd eat. When I don't want to, he has the idea I should pay. I think he should pay for himself but I do really see his side, he would be happy to eat toast or whatever, why should he pay for wagamama etc. But I still think he should pay his own way

So you need to stop inviting him to eat out with you. Accept that you want different things and have different priorities. Do your own thing with your kids and spend your money how you like, just don't include him in these trips out. As unattractive as I find all this, he has a point. If he's only eating out with you at your insistence then why should he pay? Of course it's ridiculous and unsustainable to carry on like this, so just stop going out to eat when he is there.

Or better still, just dump him. You've got the ick now anyway. You are just not compatible.

retirementrocks · 31/08/2023 21:48

I think you already know the answer to this. If you don't then it's all a bit sad.

Riverlee · 31/08/2023 21:48

It gives me the ick and I don’t even know him.

Zone2NorthLondon · 31/08/2023 21:47

Radiohat · 31/08/2023 21:33

Lol so nasty - I just thought it would be nice and simple to show possible links. I did not say it was a diagnostic tool.

It is not in my nature to be unnecessarily rude. I find people that are "silly" 🤔😂

More nonsense and some inappropriate emoji too. You erroneously linked his stingy behaviour to mental illness and I disputed it.That isn’t so nasty it’s simply challenging stigma that labels any unsavoury behaviour as indicative of mental illness.

Batalax · 31/08/2023 21:44

“If you are going to come, you’ll need to pay for yourself and it’s your turn to drive.”

Fanofbeasmith · 31/08/2023 21:40

Thank you everyone for the messages. I don't think it's possible to summarise someone's entire personality from a couple of posts but I appreciate the opinions nonetheless.

We have actually been together for 3 years now. There are a few issues, but this is the biggest and yes, I agree it makes us quite incompatible, and I think it's a very unattractive trait of his.

I don't want to be saying "I'm going out, you can't come". I know it might seem like I can't afford to be generous but I just wouldn't want to live like that.

It's not that he wants to be treated. It's just that he wants to spend time with me and if I want to do anything that costs money, or, you know, go anywhere, he doesn't expect to pay. But life isn't free. If I was happy to spend time at his he would provide meals (that he would make for himself anyway) for me too. If I was happy to go where he wants to go he would drive us in his car.

I don't really know why he gave up his job. He hated working but he was reasonably content in his previous role. It's bizarre to me, his attitude towards many things is quite bizarre to me!

Whatever it is though, it's giving me the ick and sucking the joy out of everything, so perhaps it is time to let go.

OP posts:
Oli83 · 31/08/2023 21:35

Sounds like you need to look at your finances and not be spending money you don't have on expensive holidays away and meals out irrespective of whether this man is on the scene or not. If you like him then let him show you he cares by cooking for you and arranging thoughtful but cheap dates he can afford.

How can he afford to pay utiliy bills on his house with no income? There is info we're not getting here

Radiohat · 31/08/2023 21:33

Zone2NorthLondon · 31/08/2023 21:14

A perfunctory google is not a diagnostic tool. You’re making yourself look silly
Try harder see what other random things you can find, make more spurious claims

Lol so nasty - I just thought it would be nice and simple to show possible links. I did not say it was a diagnostic tool.

It is not in my nature to be unnecessarily rude. I find people that are "silly" 🤔😂

babbscrabbs · 31/08/2023 21:32

Ew no wonder you have the ick, he sounds mean, selfish and unhealthy.

Blueink · 31/08/2023 21:26

Spend your money on yourself and your kids but cut the dead weight OP, no wonder you have the ick!

He’s taking the piss with possible hints of gaslighting to boot.

ElizaAgainn · 31/08/2023 21:25

Fanofbeasmith · 30/08/2023 00:19

Yeah he's not totally honest with his energy company either 😔

Yep....another one thinking "He cannot possibly be paying that little for his fuel - no matter how careful he is". So I do wonder whether its his energy company (ie the rest of us) covering that. Is his house detached? The reason I ask is because I did voluntary work years back now for an organisation that shall be nameless and used part of a large house for their office/etc. The other part of that large house was a flat rented to a private household by them. I saw the organisations (large!!!!!) fuel bill one day and queried as to how on earth their bill could be so huge for what I estimated they were using. I got pooh-poohed by the person concerned (who was probably used to huge fuel bills - given how large their house was). Years later - they found out I was correct and it was suspicious - as the tenant in that flat had found a way to tap through their meter into the organisations meter and had connected them up somehow. Net result being the organisation was paying his fuel bill as well as their own. They shoulda believed me that there was summat wrong in the first place - but, because they didnt, they'd had thousands of £s stolen off them. So - I ask again - is his house detached or does he have an attached neighbour he could be stealing fuel from? You may be dating a thief!

Mirabai · 31/08/2023 21:21

Fanofbeasmith · 30/08/2023 00:32

I'm not desperate for a man tho. I was just wondering if this guy is right, he would rather we ate cheaply at his every single meal. By cheaply I mean toast or porridge or soup. That's what he'd eat. When I don't want to, he has the idea I should pay. I think he should pay for himself but I do really see his side, he would be happy to eat toast or whatever, why should he pay for wagamama etc. But I still think he should pay his own way

If he stayed home and ate toast every time you went out - ok. But he comes with you doesn’t he - he expects to eat and you to pay for it.

DeeCeeCherry · 31/08/2023 21:16

I'm not desperate for a man tho

You are, or you'd never have such a freeloading scrounger in your life. You are paying to have a man. & considering that you and your children eat cheap rubbish, at his behest. Desperate. You're being a complete mug and I feel sorry for your children who will be impacted by your poor choices.

Andthereyougo · 31/08/2023 21:15

He hates me spending money generally. I took my children on holiday last month and his attitude is that if I can waste £ thousands on a holiday I can pay a few quid for a meal.

I do see his point that he wouldn't ordinarily pay money to eat in these places, but I just don't see why I should pay for his meals 😔

This seems very controlling. He wants to decide how you spend YOUR money. The money you earn. While he does what all day? He may well bankrupt you.
Get rid now.

Zone2NorthLondon · 31/08/2023 21:14

Radiohat · 31/08/2023 20:39

https://www.treatmyocd.com/what-is-ocd/common-fears/fear-of-spending-money-ocd

I don't doubt he is stingy but there are conditions that are considered a MH issue.

Chrometophobia is an illness & those suffering are very stingy.

A perfunctory google is not a diagnostic tool. You’re making yourself look silly
Try harder see what other random things you can find, make more spurious claims