Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it is odd that DH has started dog walking with a 23 year old?

538 replies

themadcarter · 29/08/2023 23:10

I'm honestly hoping for people to tell me I am being absolutely delusional and insecure, I can assure you I am actively not wanting to make a big deal out of nothing and hence I have come here for a reality check on how others would actually see it, as it's very easy to think all kinds of things in your head.

DH is 35 and I admit, usually quite an isolated man. He works from home and does have very few friends and hobbies. He has wanted a dog his whole life and I admit that I am not a huge animal person, I do love our dog but DH does do almost it all, especially as he is the one at home (I work full time out the house). He had to go for an in person workshop a few months ago and there was an icebreaker challenge (I'm honestly shocked they still do this!) and this 23 year old mentioned her new puppy (hers was only about 13 weeks and ours 8 months at this time) and apparently they clicked over the dogs?? Not trying to be a downer here, but surely owning a dog isn't that rare, I am friends with about 8 people that have dogs. I instantly found it rather childish when he was telling me but this woman ended up giving her number to him at the end of the day. DH tells me how he told her how much me and her would get along and tried to say as much as he could to me to make it sound so obviously nothing more than friends but I just got the impression he had a bit of chemistry there.

Anyway, don't want to go on for pages and pages with every little detail. Basically he did text her and they arranged a play date for the dogs, the messages to seem very innocent and he would always tell me and it didn't seem like he was telling me for any weird motive and was just out of excitement (don't want to shit on his cereal, but I'm really not getting it and never have). She then got him a birthday present only a week later and now they meet up twice a week every week to walk the dogs... he's very open about it with me and is never trying to act secretive but it really rubs me up the wrong way, I think I must have issues because seriously, him even saying her name makes me cringe. Am I just massively insecure?? I simply don't like it, she sounds a bit obsessive with him and DH has said how he does purposely leave a minimum 12 hour delay before responding to her because she replies almost instantly and constantly sends him pictures of her dog, I said to him just tell her to stop and he really just says "no I don't mind her doing it if she wants to" so then I ask why he delays replying and he says because he just doesn't want the expectation of him just being there to respond all day.

Seriously I hate the whole thing. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nowhyshouldi · 19/10/2023 12:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/09/2023 16:57

Sally2791 · 11/09/2023 06:47

Hmm. I’d go along and suss her out. She sounds infatuated and he’s loving it. Plenty of fat old men to dog walk with. And birthday present?? Not ok.

She did.

Needanewnamebeingwatched · 11/09/2023 10:33

Any update @themadcarter

Sally2791 · 11/09/2023 06:47

Hmm. I’d go along and suss her out. She sounds infatuated and he’s loving it. Plenty of fat old men to dog walk with. And birthday present?? Not ok.

Hollywolly1 · 06/09/2023 18:38

Maybe op ask a couple of your friends that also have dogs to join you so to make it seem like you are setting up a doggie walking group,the 23yr old may not be to happy with that,either way you will know soon enough

Raggy81 · 06/09/2023 06:58

I'd definitely join them for a walk, you'll know then how they are, you may hate walking but I'd do it to see for myself what the 'friendship' looks like

ForestFrank · 03/09/2023 16:19

Ah yes, highly suspicious.
I'll bet he enjoys dogging dog walking with a 23yr old.
Out twice a week with a 23yr old, playing with their 'puppies'.
Just as well she's not a cat person with a really cute pu moggy he wants to play with too!
(Insert face palm here!)

ForestFrank · 03/09/2023 16:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 03/09/2023 10:43

It isn't unusual or controlling to ask your DH not to go out regularly with someone of the opposite sex, and it may well be inviting an emotional affair, but I do loathe that phase "I wouldn't let ". It's not your choice . You can ask, and you can respond or take your own action if you don't like the answer.

Riverlee · 03/09/2023 10:17

I’m glad you’re reassured by the meet-up, but I would still randomly go on walks unannounced, or take the dog out alone, or monitor the connect. As Others have said, I meet people of all ages on my dog walksand haven’t a clue when their birthday are.

Caiti19 · 03/09/2023 10:01

I'd make a point of joining for the next 5 walks to suss out the whole vibe.

Atsocta · 03/09/2023 09:56

I’ve met people while dog walking, some for years but have never bought or received birthday gifts 🤷🏻‍♀️or exchanged mobile numbers come to think of it! To me this isn’t right.

Atsocta · 02/09/2023 23:00

It still is a red flag to me sorry but it is 🤷🏻‍♀️

itsmyp4rty · 02/09/2023 13:15

First I thought aye, aye, what he's bonding over here is all the attention she's paying him and this is an affair in the making. But then your update completely changed my mind.
You say your DH is generally awkward and antisocial and that she's odd, annoying and went on and on asking loads of questions. I'm wondering if there's a possibility that they're both ND. IME people who are ND sometimes bond like this when they normally really struggle socially as they feel the other person gets them. I'd also say it's probably innocent and it's good that your DH has put in the 12 hour boundary.

HateLongCovid · 02/09/2023 12:49

Chersfrozenface · 29/08/2023 23:32

She's pursuing him.

Who the hell buys a birthday gift for someone they meet to walk their dogs?

Actually my dad is in his eighties and other dog walkers buy him birthday gifts. However it does sound in this case that she's a bit infatuated. She's behaving like a puppy dog! Definitely go walking with them!

TedMullins · 02/09/2023 08:49

LemonyTicket · 02/09/2023 00:58

Some people here don't know an awful lot about infidelity.

It isn't controlling to ask your spouse not to form close bonds with members of the opposite sex. It really isn't. There are circumstances where this can be "safe" but it would be dependent on there being no attraction on either part.

Intimacy is formed through propinquity. A man and a woman doing an activity alone together every week can form an emotional bond. If they talk about their lives and begin to share intimacy of their inner worlds.

Once that happens, attraction and feelings can build. No married person should be spending a couple of hours a week on walks with a member of the opposite sex who may or may not have a crush on them.

That isn't to say men and women can't have friends of the opposite sex - I have lots of great male friends and we meet in a group or send some texts or catch up on a call now and then. We DON'T meet up twice a week alone.

OP I suggest you buy "Just Good Friends" by Shirley Glass and read the first couple of chapters with your husband. It describes how people of the opposite sex can begin "hanging out" like this and explains the theory of walls and windows.

With your spouse, there are meant to be windows - they can see into your inner world and have intimacy and closeness with you, but with other potential mates, there should be walls. Limits on that intimacy, and if you spend a great deal of time alone together those boundaries can become blurred incredibly easily.

I would buy the book, read the first couple of chapters with your husband, and put protecting the marriage before developing new intimate relationships with young girls who fancy you.

I think this is a good insight into the differences between those of us who think this is fine and that meeting one on one with friends of the opposite sex is fine, and the people who insist it’s not okay. I don’t agree with what you said about intimacy. I think it’s a positive and healthy thing to have closeness and emotional intimacy with people who aren’t your partner. I don’t believe one person can meet all your emotional needs or that they should always be the no1 priority. My friends and the closeness I have with them are equally as important as my romantic relationship. I really fundamentally disagree with the concept of closing yourself off emotionally to anyone who isn’t your partner.

ellie09 · 02/09/2023 08:47

Some men don't necessarily go for looks. My partners ex was a gorgeous girl, great body, but she was a horrible person who cheated and abused him.

Unlike the OP on here, he has a lot of friends and most of his real life ones are girls. He has autism and bonded more with females during his time at school and uni etc. I was a bit threatened by this, but I've met a few of them and realized they are all lovely girls and if nothing has happened now, it probably won't.

He also became very friendly with a girl from his work. So I met her. She is also lovely and chatty. She's also gorgeous 😂 but it was nice to meet her, I could also gauge how they interacted with each other.

LaDamaDeElche · 02/09/2023 08:27

EinyLinky · 02/09/2023 08:07

@LaDamaDeElche I think it's odd to comment on the fact she thought the woman would be attractive but isn't and that puts her mind at rest, like only attractive people can possibly be wanted by married men

I saw it as more relieved as she’d obviously built an image in her head. I think that’s pretty normal.

ButterCrackers · 02/09/2023 08:25

EinyLinky · 02/09/2023 08:07

@LaDamaDeElche I think it's odd to comment on the fact she thought the woman would be attractive but isn't and that puts her mind at rest, like only attractive people can possibly be wanted by married men

Not at all an odd comment to feel relieved that this women isn’t what the op thinks is attractive. She feels ok about herself physically compared to this other woman. Everyone would gauge another person they thought a potential affair partner for their dh/dp in terms of how this person compares to them. It’s human nature.
edited to add that physical attraction is generally part of what gets partners together. It doesn’t have to be supermodel quality for a man or a woman but some physical quality the other finds attractive. Obviously other aspects too such as personality, interests, life stages, wanting kids or not wanting kids or past the kids stage etc

EinyLinky · 02/09/2023 08:07

@LaDamaDeElche I think it's odd to comment on the fact she thought the woman would be attractive but isn't and that puts her mind at rest, like only attractive people can possibly be wanted by married men

LaDamaDeElche · 02/09/2023 07:31

EinyLinky · 01/09/2023 12:03

I'm assuming, OP, that you think you're this extremely attractive 30 something year old woman, who has a socially awkward, isolated DH that should absolutely feel he has won the lottery by marrying you and only had this woman been very attractive would she have been a threat to you (as age is then on her side more)

What an odd comment. I haven’t gauged that at all from OP’s posts.

ButterCrackers · 02/09/2023 07:18

ellie09 · 01/09/2023 11:30

Just giving my opinion.

I think its odd, but you can also be doing more.

Would the friendship have started if you had joined your partner from the start on these walks? You missed an opportunity to be his walking dog buddy.

Does he hide any messages from her or are all messages related to the dogs? My mind would rest easier if all texts etc were just around arranging the "doggy play dates" etc rather than casual chats thrown in or flirty behaviour also.

I would approach the fact he's asked you to join with a bit of caution. You'd be surprised how many cheaters actually introduce their partners to their bit on the side "as a friend" so they have the excuse to talk about them a lot more.

Nonetheless, you're invited. I would go. But try not to pre warn. I would wait a couple of minutes before leaving, then tell him you're coming. Watch his reaction. Does he text her to let her know immediately that you are coming or take off to the toilet all of a sudden as a chance to communicate this?

I would then go and just act like a loving couple. Hold his hand, hold the dogs lead, be polite, be talkative. Even if you didn't enjoy it, tell him that you did afterwards, let him know that you're keen to start going for regular walks with him.and the dog.

Show enthusiasm for the walks. Initiate them yourself. I walk my dog with my child and occasionally my partner, and it is a great bonding experience and an excuse to get out in the air.

You'll find that once you start actively participating, either the new found friendship will fizzle out or you will also gain a new friend.

Good advice.
Go on every dog walk. Say to your dh let’s go on a dog walk and then after awhile your dh will know that the dog has been walked and there’s no reason to go out so early any more or at all with this woman.
Get added to their WhatsApp chat. See if it moves to any other platform.

MsDogLady · 02/09/2023 05:37

Your impression was of a friendly, odd, somewhat annoying, plain looking young woman who made the effort to talk to you, but didn’t catch on that you weren’t really interested in her topics of conversation, which you describe as mostly ‘a load of nothing.’ She eventually refocused on your H, who happily engaged with her. She may be odd and quirky, but he obviously appreciates that.

They’ve clearly struck a chord in each other, and have developed a closeness and reliance via this fun new adventure. They share a valued interest, a warmth and fondness for each other, and lively conversation as they walk 1:1 in nature twice a week. They ‘get’ each other. This can be a heady combination. He’s on a perilous, slippery slope.

@themadcarter, I wouldn’t downplay the threat of their close friendship evolving into a deeper intimacy that damages your marriage. This is just the type of situation that Shirley Glass researched and wrote about, when fidelity is not protected, boundaries blur, and more and more emotional energy is invested in the new relationship and drained from the primary one, fraying that connection.

In your shoes, I’d be having a serious conversation with your H.

LemonyTicket · 02/09/2023 03:41

@GrannyGoggins

Additionally, no matter how strong a person thinks they are and how much they think they wouldn't cheat etc, they are still human and when certain hormones and chemicals flood the body, all logic and reason goes out the window. It's putting yourself in a position that could be quite dangerous and lead to emotional affairs or even worse, perhaps unintentionally. I know you will probably say that's a load of rubbish but humans have been doing this and falling prey to it since the beginning of time. It's just not worth opening the marriage up to that possibility

Very well said.

Its wonderful to trust your husband and for him to trust you. It's wonderful to have a deep, caring bond formed of intimacy and mutual support. Those things didn't appear by magic though. You spent time together, invested, shared your thoughts and grew at attraction.

Any spouse, no matter how much they love you, is at risk of infidelity if they grow those things with someone else.

When my husband had an affair many years ago, it was with someone he didn't fancy. She, very similarly, invited him on walks regularly, and over time when I was away for an extended period, an affair began.

Because they spent time together, talking, bonding and he developed intimacy with her and from there it's a slippery slope. He had one really bad day and who did he call? His new chum, and 8 drinks later...

He saw no harm in the walks because he didn't fancy her. Next thing he knew, the wife he loved was gone. He was utterly devastated and if you asked him now what his biggest regret on life is; it was saying yes to those walks.

People, I think, have beliefs about love and loyalty being magic and impenetrable. They're not really. They're things you work at and maintain and grow. If you start working at intimacy elsewhere you run a risk of crossing boundaries.

If the OPS husband loves her, it's not about "allowing" him or not. It's about an adult discussion over boundaries, and choosing as a team to keep their marriage safe.

catrescuelady · 02/09/2023 03:13

🚩

Swipe left for the next trending thread