Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go to dinner with another man?

641 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 29/08/2023 19:42

DH is being a bit funny and thinks it's inappropriate so just want to get some other opinions.

A good friend of mine was married recently, unfortunately he is now serperated through no choice of his own. He has some wedding gifts in the form of vouchers, this specific one to a super nice restaurant that I couldn't usually afford. DH also wouldn't go because he doesn't like a set menu.

He asked me today if I would go with him. We have been good friends from before his last relationship, throughout the marriage etc and are quite close.. Entirely mutually platonic. We meet up for walks, the occasional drink etc sometimes alone sometimes with friends. DH knows him and knows when we meet up, never been an issue. Recently we've probably been meeting a bit more because he's been having a hard time and could do with the company.

DH thinks it's inappropriate because its a fancy meal, I'm married, he's not anymore and seems like a date.

I appreciate that if he had out of the blue asked to take me for an overpriced dinner and wine I would feel uncomfortable and it would be inappropriate but that's not the case, it's exceptional in that it's a crappy situation and he has this voucher to use and rather than it go to waste we enjoy each others company and have nice food and that DH wouldn't even have with me anyway.

I think DH will get over it, he trusts me and I think its more that if someone else saw us together it could look sus.. But surely that shouldn't really matter?

Or am I just thinking with my belly and it's an entirely inappropriate situation...

OP posts:
GCSister · 02/09/2023 14:47

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:41

@GCSister I'm not saying it will always result in an affair, I'm saying that is how it starts. You only have to look on the boards on here to know that's true.

Of course you can't hide away from life but I've got through life perfectly fine without getting into situations which could cause issues. I still have a social life, it's just within certain boundaries.

It only works if both are on the same page though.

I'm sorry but that's such a sad way to live. Do you really not trust yourself not to be unfaithful?
What situations should you avoid because I've known people start affairs on the school run and with their next door neighbour! How do you avoid those situations?

Affairs happens because people choose to be unfaithful, they don't happen by accident. There is always a choice.

I have complete faith in my ability to not cheat on my husband so it's not a problem if I make friends or form bonds with other people.... male or female as I'm bisexual.

TheAOEAztec · 02/09/2023 14:47

ErosandAgape · 02/09/2023 14:42

It must be absolutely exhausting to think you can only stay faithful to your spouse by keeping yourself strictly away, physically and psychologically, from anyone you could potentially have sex with.

I just can’t imagine trusting myself so little.

Thsre are countries which are aet uo like that.... I always said that some mumsnetters would be very happy in these contrary to mkaning about exactly that separation of sexes....

I am still giggling at "intimate dinner" and wondering if you can do that in Nandos

talkito · 02/09/2023 14:46

You're willing to sacrifice your relationship with your husband for the sake of a fancy dinner you can't afford otherwise.

I'm on your husband's side.

If he's uncomfortable with it, which is perfectly reasonable, it should have been the end of it. No need to come to the internet for that.

He's separated.
He confides in you in this hard time.
Offers to take you out on a fancy dinner, which yes, does sound like a date.

You might have innocent intents but the set up is really not good.

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:44

@ErosandAgape Clearly everything I am saying is being either misinterpreted at best or deliberately twisted at worst.

I said that is how affairs usually start and how cracks enter into a relationship. Not all the time but that is how it happens.

You didn't answer my question. Would you be ok with your husband sharing a bed with another woman? Showering with another woman? Providing nothing happened and they didn't do anything sexual, you should trust him right?

ErosandAgape · 02/09/2023 14:42

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:34

@Frabbits In your opinion it's not healthy but in my opinion it's not healthy to develop close friendships with other men who aren't your partner. That's how affairs start and it's naive to think otherwise. The closer you become to someone and form a bond, the further away you can drift from your partner and then the doors are opened for an affair.

So if it's to do with trust (according to your perception) would you be ok with your partner doing anything with a woman? Showering? Sleeping in bed together?

It must be absolutely exhausting to think you can only stay faithful to your spouse by keeping yourself strictly away, physically and psychologically, from anyone you could potentially have sex with.

I just can’t imagine trusting myself so little.

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:41

@GCSister I'm not saying it will always result in an affair, I'm saying that is how it starts. You only have to look on the boards on here to know that's true.

Of course you can't hide away from life but I've got through life perfectly fine without getting into situations which could cause issues. I still have a social life, it's just within certain boundaries.

It only works if both are on the same page though.

GCSister · 02/09/2023 14:39

your opinion it's not healthy but in my opinion it's not healthy to develop close friendships with other men who aren't your partner. That's how affairs start and it's naive to think otherwise. The closer you become to someone and form a bond, the further away you can drift from your partner and then the doors are opened for an affair.

Are you really that one dimensional? Men and women can't have close friendships with each other because it's inevitable that they'll end up having an affair?
I'm afraid it's you who are naive, most adults don't behave that way. Im perfectly capable of forming a bond with someone without having an affair as are most people I know.

Of course affairs happen, but locking yourself away from the world won't stop them 🙄

GCSister · 02/09/2023 14:34

I understand people can't help feeling a particular way but that doesn't mean you have act upon feelings that might be unreasonable. Otherwise where would that leave us? What if the OPs husband decided he didn't want her to be friends with the person in question because it made him uncomfortable? What if he decided she couldn't work with men because that made him uncomfortable? Would you be saying 'but those are his feelings'??

You can apply logic and address feelings in a sensible way. Like reasonable adults.

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:34

@Frabbits In your opinion it's not healthy but in my opinion it's not healthy to develop close friendships with other men who aren't your partner. That's how affairs start and it's naive to think otherwise. The closer you become to someone and form a bond, the further away you can drift from your partner and then the doors are opened for an affair.

So if it's to do with trust (according to your perception) would you be ok with your partner doing anything with a woman? Showering? Sleeping in bed together?

JaneIntheBox · 02/09/2023 14:18

Boogiewoogieanddance · 02/09/2023 09:40

In hindsight.. I think if in had explained how the arrangement came about better to DH he wouldn't have had an issue. But I didn't because I didn't think anything of it. I know I've said he asked me.. he did. I just interuppted and finished his sentence (correctly.. who knows?).. so spme may say we might aswell be married already.

Look OP I know this is AIBU but really. In this situation I don't think other people's opinions are much relevant. This isn't a clear cut situation unlike, say, your husband preventing you from seeing male friends at all (bad).
The only person whose opinion matters (other than you) is your DH. He has already said he's uncomfortable with it. Personally I agree with him, logically yes there should be no reason, it's 'just a gift' etc etc but it wouldn't sit right with me. I can't logic away the feeling. My wedding is special to me, so is everything I got from it and if God forbid something happened to DH I could never coldly see it as 'just' a gift. Unlike a birthday or Christmas present.

There's another thread on here with a woman feeling a bit apprehensive about attending a wedding 'with' a male friend, all above board but she still had quite a bit of emotion as it was the first wedding she attended without her (recently passed away) DH! Feelings are feelings.

Usually if it's a woman posting on here, especially with the context that her H had been spending more time than usual with a newly divorced woman MN would be up in arms, but that's by the by.

Anyway, if you want to go badly enough to 'talk him around', that's your prerogative but I wonder why you're so insistent on going. As much as I like food I wouldn't put a free meal over my husband's feelings. And I highly doubt that whatever arguments people have put forth on MN are going to convince him, like I said this isn't something that can be 'logic-ed' away. But it's your marriage, you know your husband best. Neither of you are wrong I'd say you both have your feelings. Whether you want to go despite failing to talk him around, or whether he will come around once he's talked to .. that's up to you.

Both the people calling your husband rude names ('controlling ') and the people saying your marriage would be over are being utterly dramatic. I wouldn't pay any attention to them!

JudgeRudy · 02/09/2023 14:14

Boogiewoogieanddance · 29/08/2023 19:42

DH is being a bit funny and thinks it's inappropriate so just want to get some other opinions.

A good friend of mine was married recently, unfortunately he is now serperated through no choice of his own. He has some wedding gifts in the form of vouchers, this specific one to a super nice restaurant that I couldn't usually afford. DH also wouldn't go because he doesn't like a set menu.

He asked me today if I would go with him. We have been good friends from before his last relationship, throughout the marriage etc and are quite close.. Entirely mutually platonic. We meet up for walks, the occasional drink etc sometimes alone sometimes with friends. DH knows him and knows when we meet up, never been an issue. Recently we've probably been meeting a bit more because he's been having a hard time and could do with the company.

DH thinks it's inappropriate because its a fancy meal, I'm married, he's not anymore and seems like a date.

I appreciate that if he had out of the blue asked to take me for an overpriced dinner and wine I would feel uncomfortable and it would be inappropriate but that's not the case, it's exceptional in that it's a crappy situation and he has this voucher to use and rather than it go to waste we enjoy each others company and have nice food and that DH wouldn't even have with me anyway.

I think DH will get over it, he trusts me and I think its more that if someone else saw us together it could look sus.. But surely that shouldn't really matter?

Or am I just thinking with my belly and it's an entirely inappropriate situation...

I get that it's the sort of eatery you'd go to for a special date or celebration rather than with your friend however I think as you've explained about the vouchers it makes sense.
You're OH may be a bit jealous. That doesn't mean he doesn't trust you. It doesn't even mean he's wrong to feel a small pang. What's wrong is to say he doesn't want you to go.
Don't keep telling him he has nothing to be jealous of, that's disregarding his feelings. Acknowledge his feelings and maybe tell him it's good to know he can still feel so territorial.

Frabbits · 02/09/2023 14:08

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:05

@Frabbits It's nothing to do with trust. It's what each person finds acceptable in a marriage and OPs DH clearly feels uncomfortable about it. Disregarding his feelings in this manner is not going to be a positive thing for any marriage.

It's totally about trust. Marriage isn't about indulging every little paranoid thought someone has.

Partners don't get to be controlling fuckwits and veto their OH's seeing other people. That's not healthy.

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:05

@Frabbits It's nothing to do with trust. It's what each person finds acceptable in a marriage and OPs DH clearly feels uncomfortable about it. Disregarding his feelings in this manner is not going to be a positive thing for any marriage.

Frabbits · 02/09/2023 14:01

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 13:33

I agree. This has the potential to cause marriage problems.

Yes, a complete lack of trust in your partner not to be able to have dinner with a friend without shagging them is an issue.

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 13:33

Sanitas · 02/09/2023 12:05

Do what you want, OP, but I think you're making a big mistake.
Why have you not got more respect for your dh? Why are you not giving credence to his ability to sense a situation?
His intuition senses something is off, why aren't you listening?
He's hardly a controlling guy., is he? So for him to be wary does indeed suggest something is off.
I'm not suggesting he doesn't trust YOU, but he clearly doesn't trust HIM.
No man wants to imagine another guy hitting on his wife, even if she rebuffs the advance-which I think you will, fair play to you, it has the potential for anger and bad feeling. Wanting to protect your spouse is not controlling, it's normal.
Yet you're still going.
You disregard your husband's entirely reasonable concerns for a nice meal. Ffs.
Best of luck, I think you're gonna need it.
Yes, if I were your dh I'd be considering divorce, no exaggeration, I've been in a marriage where my feelings have been disregarded and it's not good.
It's soul destroying.

I agree. This has the potential to cause marriage problems.

Womencanlift · 02/09/2023 13:18

ErosandAgape · 02/09/2023 13:01

@Sanitas projects so much you could use him/her to show PowerPoints.

😂😂😂😂

Sad that there are people in the world living such limited lives because they can’t accept that men can just be friends with women and vice versa

And I am not naive @Sanitas In fact I think you are

GCSister · 02/09/2023 13:02

Sanitas projects so much you could use him/her to show PowerPoints.

Ha! 🙊

ErosandAgape · 02/09/2023 13:01

GCSister · 02/09/2023 12:48

There's a heck of a lot of projection and assumptions going on here!!

@Sanitas projects so much you could use him/her to show PowerPoints.

Frabbits · 02/09/2023 13:00

Sanitas · 02/09/2023 12:05

Do what you want, OP, but I think you're making a big mistake.
Why have you not got more respect for your dh? Why are you not giving credence to his ability to sense a situation?
His intuition senses something is off, why aren't you listening?
He's hardly a controlling guy., is he? So for him to be wary does indeed suggest something is off.
I'm not suggesting he doesn't trust YOU, but he clearly doesn't trust HIM.
No man wants to imagine another guy hitting on his wife, even if she rebuffs the advance-which I think you will, fair play to you, it has the potential for anger and bad feeling. Wanting to protect your spouse is not controlling, it's normal.
Yet you're still going.
You disregard your husband's entirely reasonable concerns for a nice meal. Ffs.
Best of luck, I think you're gonna need it.
Yes, if I were your dh I'd be considering divorce, no exaggeration, I've been in a marriage where my feelings have been disregarded and it's not good.
It's soul destroying.

Mate, you think When Sally Meets Harry is non-fiction.

I think OP can safely ignore your views.

Stompythedinosaur · 02/09/2023 12:53

Sanitas · 02/09/2023 12:05

Do what you want, OP, but I think you're making a big mistake.
Why have you not got more respect for your dh? Why are you not giving credence to his ability to sense a situation?
His intuition senses something is off, why aren't you listening?
He's hardly a controlling guy., is he? So for him to be wary does indeed suggest something is off.
I'm not suggesting he doesn't trust YOU, but he clearly doesn't trust HIM.
No man wants to imagine another guy hitting on his wife, even if she rebuffs the advance-which I think you will, fair play to you, it has the potential for anger and bad feeling. Wanting to protect your spouse is not controlling, it's normal.
Yet you're still going.
You disregard your husband's entirely reasonable concerns for a nice meal. Ffs.
Best of luck, I think you're gonna need it.
Yes, if I were your dh I'd be considering divorce, no exaggeration, I've been in a marriage where my feelings have been disregarded and it's not good.
It's soul destroying.

Er, yeah, dictating what social activities your wife can or can't do is definitely controlling, and framing it as "for her protection" is insulting and infantilising.

GCSister · 02/09/2023 12:48

Sanitas · 02/09/2023 12:05

Do what you want, OP, but I think you're making a big mistake.
Why have you not got more respect for your dh? Why are you not giving credence to his ability to sense a situation?
His intuition senses something is off, why aren't you listening?
He's hardly a controlling guy., is he? So for him to be wary does indeed suggest something is off.
I'm not suggesting he doesn't trust YOU, but he clearly doesn't trust HIM.
No man wants to imagine another guy hitting on his wife, even if she rebuffs the advance-which I think you will, fair play to you, it has the potential for anger and bad feeling. Wanting to protect your spouse is not controlling, it's normal.
Yet you're still going.
You disregard your husband's entirely reasonable concerns for a nice meal. Ffs.
Best of luck, I think you're gonna need it.
Yes, if I were your dh I'd be considering divorce, no exaggeration, I've been in a marriage where my feelings have been disregarded and it's not good.
It's soul destroying.

There's a heck of a lot of projection and assumptions going on here!!

MarkWithaC · 02/09/2023 12:26

Sanitas · 02/09/2023 12:05

Do what you want, OP, but I think you're making a big mistake.
Why have you not got more respect for your dh? Why are you not giving credence to his ability to sense a situation?
His intuition senses something is off, why aren't you listening?
He's hardly a controlling guy., is he? So for him to be wary does indeed suggest something is off.
I'm not suggesting he doesn't trust YOU, but he clearly doesn't trust HIM.
No man wants to imagine another guy hitting on his wife, even if she rebuffs the advance-which I think you will, fair play to you, it has the potential for anger and bad feeling. Wanting to protect your spouse is not controlling, it's normal.
Yet you're still going.
You disregard your husband's entirely reasonable concerns for a nice meal. Ffs.
Best of luck, I think you're gonna need it.
Yes, if I were your dh I'd be considering divorce, no exaggeration, I've been in a marriage where my feelings have been disregarded and it's not good.
It's soul destroying.

Yes, if I were your dh I'd be considering divorce, no exaggeration

Fuck's sake.

I think your own experiences might be colouring your responses just a tad.

Sanitas · 02/09/2023 12:05

Do what you want, OP, but I think you're making a big mistake.
Why have you not got more respect for your dh? Why are you not giving credence to his ability to sense a situation?
His intuition senses something is off, why aren't you listening?
He's hardly a controlling guy., is he? So for him to be wary does indeed suggest something is off.
I'm not suggesting he doesn't trust YOU, but he clearly doesn't trust HIM.
No man wants to imagine another guy hitting on his wife, even if she rebuffs the advance-which I think you will, fair play to you, it has the potential for anger and bad feeling. Wanting to protect your spouse is not controlling, it's normal.
Yet you're still going.
You disregard your husband's entirely reasonable concerns for a nice meal. Ffs.
Best of luck, I think you're gonna need it.
Yes, if I were your dh I'd be considering divorce, no exaggeration, I've been in a marriage where my feelings have been disregarded and it's not good.
It's soul destroying.

Boogiewoogieanddance · 02/09/2023 09:40

In hindsight.. I think if in had explained how the arrangement came about better to DH he wouldn't have had an issue. But I didn't because I didn't think anything of it. I know I've said he asked me.. he did. I just interuppted and finished his sentence (correctly.. who knows?).. so spme may say we might aswell be married already.

OP posts:
Boogiewoogieanddance · 02/09/2023 09:36

Posters concerned about the gift aspect - this has been covered. It's a gift from friends side and they would rather he enjoyed it than return it. Also shocked that some people would expect a gift back from a friend/family member that are going through a rubbish time, could imagine saying to someone "sorry you're wife walked out on you massively unexpectedly but can i please have my wedding gift back now your marriage as failed?" I'd also feel absolutely grim eating that meal knowing the other person is miserable at home.

@Livelifelaughter he could have asked someone else, although we all have busy jobs, weird hours, families to work around and the restaurant has limited availability so it's not as easy to fit it in. If I wasn't off work ATM I don't even know if I would have got.

I think regardless of if I go or not (99% going) my marriage will survive.. I dont know why he's funny about it. Yes he thinks it's weird or off for some reason, but has also said he 100% trusts me so I don't know why.. maybe he's a bit jealous it's not me and him because we haven't been out alot recently together with the young kids so the two of us are missing that time, which I do get. I'll take him somewhere nice, varied menu, keep the candle lit and who know where the night will go.. except @Sanitas She deffinatley knows. Divorce I imagine.

As to how the invite came about... it was very casual which I think impacts. We where in my car and just having general chat about nice places we had been to for food (with or respective partners.. so for recommendations rather then reminiscing for those that's are going to jump to the conclusion we are regluar fine diners) and then he said "I have this voucher as a wedding gift for this really nice place... " and I said excitedly "will we go to dinner??".. he laughed and said I was very presumptuous but yes he was getting to that. And then said he had been trying to figure out how to use it with family/a group but that defeats the purpose because everyone would still spend a fotune and to get the value without spending more it for two.

Also I would never have presumed an invite like that without the previous offer of the hotel voucher, and it was just a very naturally flowing conversation lol

But here, maybe he was never going to invite me and I've ruined his chance of bringing a real date out because of him being polite, my marriage will end in divorce, I'll loose a friend and had friend brought someone single it could have ended in a happy ever after. Time will tell.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread