Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go to dinner with another man?

641 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 29/08/2023 19:42

DH is being a bit funny and thinks it's inappropriate so just want to get some other opinions.

A good friend of mine was married recently, unfortunately he is now serperated through no choice of his own. He has some wedding gifts in the form of vouchers, this specific one to a super nice restaurant that I couldn't usually afford. DH also wouldn't go because he doesn't like a set menu.

He asked me today if I would go with him. We have been good friends from before his last relationship, throughout the marriage etc and are quite close.. Entirely mutually platonic. We meet up for walks, the occasional drink etc sometimes alone sometimes with friends. DH knows him and knows when we meet up, never been an issue. Recently we've probably been meeting a bit more because he's been having a hard time and could do with the company.

DH thinks it's inappropriate because its a fancy meal, I'm married, he's not anymore and seems like a date.

I appreciate that if he had out of the blue asked to take me for an overpriced dinner and wine I would feel uncomfortable and it would be inappropriate but that's not the case, it's exceptional in that it's a crappy situation and he has this voucher to use and rather than it go to waste we enjoy each others company and have nice food and that DH wouldn't even have with me anyway.

I think DH will get over it, he trusts me and I think its more that if someone else saw us together it could look sus.. But surely that shouldn't really matter?

Or am I just thinking with my belly and it's an entirely inappropriate situation...

OP posts:
MichaelAndersen · 02/09/2023 15:20

So your husband hates a set menu more than he hates the idea of you going to a fancy dinner with a man alone? He is acting like he’s so concerned about this friend date but the set menu is like a river of crocodiles he just can’t cross in order to join you. What a weirdo. Go to the dinner. Bring home delicious leftovers and eat them right in front of him. Your husband is weird.

Stompythedinosaur · 02/09/2023 15:17

There's something so fragile about the idea that you should not do totally normal social activities with friends outside your relationship.

It would be a deal breaker to me (as would telling me what to do tbh). I don't think that's normal in a healthy relationship.

GCSister · 02/09/2023 15:14

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 15:13

@Womencanlift I beg to differ. Questioning is one thing, but the things said on this thread towards those with my views are awful. People can't open their minds to understand another way of life - there's is the right way and that's final.

Anyway, as I said, I'm out.

What has been says that is awful?
I would say you are unable of seeing another way of living though......

GCSister · 02/09/2023 15:13

as I said on the dog walker thread, I don’t think limiting your close emotional relationships to only your partner is good or healthy. I think it’s a positive and necessary to be emotionally close to other people, friends of both sexes. I don’t think one’s partner can be expected to cater to all your emotional needs.

Totally agree!!

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 15:13

@Womencanlift I beg to differ. Questioning is one thing, but the things said on this thread towards those with my views are awful. People can't open their minds to understand another way of life - there's is the right way and that's final.

Anyway, as I said, I'm out.

GCSister · 02/09/2023 15:12

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 15:08

Again, my points are being twisted and having meaning applied where it was not intended by me.

I think you sharing a bed with another man and thinking it's ok says more about you than you realise. That is in no way a normal thing to do when in a relationship.

On that note, considering the manipulation evident on this thread, I'm out.

Challenging your views is not manipulation!!

TedMullins · 02/09/2023 15:12

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 15:06

@GCSister That can also apply to the scenario being discussed. As you can see on this thread, having close relationships with another man outside the marriage is not the social norm for some.

as I said on the dog walker thread, I don’t think limiting your close emotional relationships to only your partner is good or healthy. I think it’s a positive and necessary to be emotionally close to other people, friends of both sexes. I don’t think one’s partner can be expected to cater to all your emotional needs.

Womencanlift · 02/09/2023 15:11

On that note, considering the manipulation evident on this thread, I'm out.

Challenging your point and having an opposite view is not manipulation, it’s a discussion and since your views are very different than the majority of course people are going to question it

I for you genuinely think you believe in what you are posting, unlike some others who I think are just being controversial for the sake of an argument

GCSister · 02/09/2023 15:11

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 15:06

@GCSister That can also apply to the scenario being discussed. As you can see on this thread, having close relationships with another man outside the marriage is not the social norm for some.

They key phrase is 'for some'.
In fact, I would say it's a social norm that has evolved and that society as a whole is more accepting of male/female friendships and socialising.... thankfully!
The old fashioned idea that men and women can't have platonic relationships just holds women back, particularly professionally.

Frabbits · 02/09/2023 15:09

talkito · 02/09/2023 14:46

You're willing to sacrifice your relationship with your husband for the sake of a fancy dinner you can't afford otherwise.

I'm on your husband's side.

If he's uncomfortable with it, which is perfectly reasonable, it should have been the end of it. No need to come to the internet for that.

He's separated.
He confides in you in this hard time.
Offers to take you out on a fancy dinner, which yes, does sound like a date.

You might have innocent intents but the set up is really not good.

Ah, so if our men are uncomfortable with something, not matter how irrational it may be, we just roll over and accept it?

No, fuck that. That's not an equal relationship.

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 15:08

Again, my points are being twisted and having meaning applied where it was not intended by me.

I think you sharing a bed with another man and thinking it's ok says more about you than you realise. That is in no way a normal thing to do when in a relationship.

On that note, considering the manipulation evident on this thread, I'm out.

ErosandAgape · 02/09/2023 15:08

SayingwhatIreallythink · 02/09/2023 15:00

This! If he has no one to go to the restaurant with, shouldn’t he give it back ?

The OP addressed this earlier. I think she said he raised it with the giver, who told him to use it.

It’s not as if it’s a pair of pillow cases with the initials of the (formerly) married couple monogrammed on them.

Frabbits · 02/09/2023 15:07

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:34

@Frabbits In your opinion it's not healthy but in my opinion it's not healthy to develop close friendships with other men who aren't your partner. That's how affairs start and it's naive to think otherwise. The closer you become to someone and form a bond, the further away you can drift from your partner and then the doors are opened for an affair.

So if it's to do with trust (according to your perception) would you be ok with your partner doing anything with a woman? Showering? Sleeping in bed together?

Total, total strawman.

Obviously there are limits, but to set that limit at a partner having dinner with someone else is absurd.

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 15:06

@GCSister That can also apply to the scenario being discussed. As you can see on this thread, having close relationships with another man outside the marriage is not the social norm for some.

ErosandAgape · 02/09/2023 15:06

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:44

@ErosandAgape Clearly everything I am saying is being either misinterpreted at best or deliberately twisted at worst.

I said that is how affairs usually start and how cracks enter into a relationship. Not all the time but that is how it happens.

You didn't answer my question. Would you be ok with your husband sharing a bed with another woman? Showering with another woman? Providing nothing happened and they didn't do anything sexual, you should trust him right?

It’s hilarious that you are equating having dinner together with showering together. That says way more about you than I think you realise.

re. Bed sharing. I spoke up the thread about sharing a bed with a male friend when stranded. I’ve definitely shared a tent with a male friend. DH has, I’m sure, shared beds with female friends on occasion in the 30 years we’ve been together in similar circumstances.

But as he’s actually in Barcelona visiting a longterm female friend this weekend, while I stay at home with DS and finish a work project, I’d be surprised if you find any of the norms of our relationship acceptable to you!

All I can say is that we haven’t needed to hide ourselves away from opposite-sex friends to have a happy, 30-year committed relationship. It’s sad you can only see men in sexual terms.

GCSister · 02/09/2023 15:04

My point was based upon the notion of trust as someone raised that was the reason why i have my views. I was demonstrating why not do these other things if you trust your partner.

Social norms.....I don't shower with my friends for the same reason I wouldn't shower with colleagues. That's nothing to do with trust, it's to do with social rules and norms.

SayingwhatIreallythink · 02/09/2023 15:02

Sorry , missed last comment re the gift.

SayingwhatIreallythink · 02/09/2023 15:00

Allywill · 29/08/2023 20:20

How long ago were they married? If I’d bought a voucher for the bride and groom to go out for a fancy meal as a wedding present I’d be a bit pissed off if he took someone else to be honest (if I ever found out)

This! If he has no one to go to the restaurant with, shouldn’t he give it back ?

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 15:00

GCSister · 02/09/2023 14:54

Your made up examples are irrelevant.

As are everyone else's 🤷🏼‍♀️
It doesn't stop people using them to support their argument. There are people comparing a dinner in a public restaurant to showering!!!

Ridiculous

My point was based upon the notion of trust as someone raised that was the reason why i have my views. I was demonstrating why not do these other things if you trust your partner.

JaneIntheBox · 02/09/2023 15:00

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:53

@JaneIntheBox I completely agree. What is reasonable within a relationship is subjective which is why all feelings and motivations for those feelings need to be considered.

Exactly.
If I thought my husband's feelings were generally unreasonable I wouldn't have married him in the first place. If he was abusive, controlling etc etc then this would manifest in a lot of other things.
It amazes me how much people leap to conclusions, and project the state of things from one small occurrence.
The OP's husband being a reasonable man in general is different from him being controlling. We don't know him. The OP does.
If he's the former and she still puts a free meal over his opinion that's on her. Voucher being 'wasted' is not even her problem anyway.
If he's the latter certainly she shouldn't be caring about anything he says, but also that's a bad marriage.
We don't know which it is.

FWIW my husband has a boring palate, so I'm often out with male friends, or just one of them, eating in nice places! Doesn't bother him at all. If he expressed concerns about a particular outing though I'd pay close attention, because there'd be something different about it. I know him, and I value his opinion. If i married a man constantly trying to tell me what to do.. I'd roundly tell him to piss off and call a divorce solicitor.

GCSister · 02/09/2023 14:59

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:52

@GCSister People who you never thought in a million years could cheat in the right circumstances, no one is immune.

I love my husband so I wouldn't put myself in a position where bonds could form with another man, making my husband feel concerned and that he is not as important. So it's more about how my DH feels, not about not trusting myself.

But cheating is always a choice. You don't start an affair by accident.
And given affairs can start in all kinds of circumstances which situations do you avoid?

I'm so pleased my husband's ego isn't so fragile that a friendship would leave him feeling threatened.

GCSister · 02/09/2023 14:54

Your made up examples are irrelevant.

As are everyone else's 🤷🏼‍♀️
It doesn't stop people using them to support their argument. There are people comparing a dinner in a public restaurant to showering!!!

Ridiculous

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:53

@JaneIntheBox I completely agree. What is reasonable within a relationship is subjective which is why all feelings and motivations for those feelings need to be considered.

GrannyGoggins · 02/09/2023 14:52

@GCSister People who you never thought in a million years could cheat in the right circumstances, no one is immune.

I love my husband so I wouldn't put myself in a position where bonds could form with another man, making my husband feel concerned and that he is not as important. So it's more about how my DH feels, not about not trusting myself.

JaneIntheBox · 02/09/2023 14:47

GCSister · 02/09/2023 14:34

I understand people can't help feeling a particular way but that doesn't mean you have act upon feelings that might be unreasonable. Otherwise where would that leave us? What if the OPs husband decided he didn't want her to be friends with the person in question because it made him uncomfortable? What if he decided she couldn't work with men because that made him uncomfortable? Would you be saying 'but those are his feelings'??

You can apply logic and address feelings in a sensible way. Like reasonable adults.

The big flaw in your argument is the definition of 'reasonable'. Logic is something cast in stone. Questions of feelings, and by implication morality are not. It's a spectrum. There is no such thing as logic and a 'sensible way' to apply feelings in all situations because what is sensible for you is not sensible for someone else.

Situation A:
You have made up examples, such as 'drop friend because husband uncomfortable'. Which the 'vast majority' (picking words here carefully) would find an 'unreasonable' complaint from the husband, in the absence of further evidence.
Situation B:
I can also make up examples, such as 'my wife spending more time with another man compared to me and prioritising him', that the vast majority of people would find a 'reasonable' complaint.
Situation C:
Of course, some things are most definitely clear cut. Someone banning their spouse from going out at all -unanimous! Banning all interaction with opposite sex - unanimous!

You think this a situation C, he is clearly being unreasonable and should deal with his feelings sensibly. I think not. If he is otherwise fine with whatever the OP does and just objects to this his feelings are valid, not 'insensible' or 'illogical' as you seem to imply. Your made up examples are irrelevant. They are logical fallacies of a slippery slope, or false equivalences.

As a PP said there's a lot of black and white thinking on this thread, and inability to accept nuance.