Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go to dinner with another man?

641 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 29/08/2023 19:42

DH is being a bit funny and thinks it's inappropriate so just want to get some other opinions.

A good friend of mine was married recently, unfortunately he is now serperated through no choice of his own. He has some wedding gifts in the form of vouchers, this specific one to a super nice restaurant that I couldn't usually afford. DH also wouldn't go because he doesn't like a set menu.

He asked me today if I would go with him. We have been good friends from before his last relationship, throughout the marriage etc and are quite close.. Entirely mutually platonic. We meet up for walks, the occasional drink etc sometimes alone sometimes with friends. DH knows him and knows when we meet up, never been an issue. Recently we've probably been meeting a bit more because he's been having a hard time and could do with the company.

DH thinks it's inappropriate because its a fancy meal, I'm married, he's not anymore and seems like a date.

I appreciate that if he had out of the blue asked to take me for an overpriced dinner and wine I would feel uncomfortable and it would be inappropriate but that's not the case, it's exceptional in that it's a crappy situation and he has this voucher to use and rather than it go to waste we enjoy each others company and have nice food and that DH wouldn't even have with me anyway.

I think DH will get over it, he trusts me and I think its more that if someone else saw us together it could look sus.. But surely that shouldn't really matter?

Or am I just thinking with my belly and it's an entirely inappropriate situation...

OP posts:
spookehtooth · 03/09/2023 22:42

I'm beginning to feel like I've been excluded from the brotherhood of man 🤷‍♀️ I hope I've not missed out on anything exciting

Livelifelaughter · 03/09/2023 21:52

MichaelAndersen · 02/09/2023 15:20

So your husband hates a set menu more than he hates the idea of you going to a fancy dinner with a man alone? He is acting like he’s so concerned about this friend date but the set menu is like a river of crocodiles he just can’t cross in order to join you. What a weirdo. Go to the dinner. Bring home delicious leftovers and eat them right in front of him. Your husband is weird.

I didn't really understand this point..I thought OP said the voucher would cover a set meal for two with wine but they could have a normal menu but the voucher wouldn't cover the drinks ? So set menu is better value. Then in another post I think OP said her friend preferred go with another person...dinner a deux

MasterBeth · 03/09/2023 21:50

What topics can’t be spoken about in front of women? Do your husband and his brother live in the 19th century?

sezzer87 · 03/09/2023 21:05

MasterBeth · 03/09/2023 18:05

Why do men have to drink beer and talk about manly topics? My partner has always preferred the company of women, which is one of the reasons I liked him!

Mine enjoys the company of women too, but he loves his Friday nights with his brother where he can chat about certain topics that can't be spoken about in front of women.
I'm sure there are topics you'd only talk about with women too.

spookehtooth · 03/09/2023 20:39

I'm getting worried here too now, I don't talk about many so-called manly things and most of the people I get on with well tend to be women 🤷‍♀️ I wouldn't call it a choice or a preference, its just how life's gone since I was small, I'll try and get on with anyone and sometimes I have wondered why that's how it is.

MarkWithaC · 03/09/2023 18:43

I'm here to find out what 'manly topics' are too Grin

Hey, maybe the OP talks about 'manly topics' to her friend and that's why they like each other?

ErosandAgape · 03/09/2023 18:08

sezzer87 · 03/09/2023 17:14

The question is why he feels the need to go for walks and meals with a married women? Why not go with a mate and go for beers and talk about manly topics. Seems strange that he'd choose a female who's married with kids.
My husband goes for drinks with a mixed group from work. That's different but if he had the opportunity to go for a walk or a meal out he wouldn't pick another women over me and definitely not a married women.
Seems like this man is filling a void in your own marriage. Perhaps your husband is now cottoning on to that, and worried that this big posh meal will make the two of you even closer and highlight what's missing in your marriage.

Does he have some kind of disability that only enables him to talk about ‘manly topics’ to men? What exactly are ‘manly topics’? The Arsenal defence? Prostate checks? Peeing standing up?

MasterBeth · 03/09/2023 18:05

Why do men have to drink beer and talk about manly topics? My partner has always preferred the company of women, which is one of the reasons I liked him!

sezzer87 · 03/09/2023 17:14

The question is why he feels the need to go for walks and meals with a married women? Why not go with a mate and go for beers and talk about manly topics. Seems strange that he'd choose a female who's married with kids.
My husband goes for drinks with a mixed group from work. That's different but if he had the opportunity to go for a walk or a meal out he wouldn't pick another women over me and definitely not a married women.
Seems like this man is filling a void in your own marriage. Perhaps your husband is now cottoning on to that, and worried that this big posh meal will make the two of you even closer and highlight what's missing in your marriage.

Boogiewoogieanddance · 03/09/2023 12:46

@Aprilrosesews

He has in a round about way said all the things, he jealous a bit because it should be me and him in a nice restaurant.. although still wouldn't go to a set menu place lol and i think it is do to with the jump from coffee - dinner in the circumstances with him seperating. And I think in usual circumstances I would completely agree and see that's its inappropriate, but in this situation with the conversation leading to it & voucher it isn't a pass by him.

DH has made it clear he thinks it's weird, isn't like rushing me off to it but he trusts me and doesn't think its an affair at all. I've told him if I ever thought friend was getting too close I would step back and let him know.

I'll take the dinner because I know I'm a good wife and friend and I deserve a treat. So over all, I think we both see it from eachothers view point and will take it on board. But I don't think in an equal relationship either of us has to completely succumb to eachothers idealisation.

And whoever asked, I don't have plans to see my friend before the dinner. He's fine with the friendship though, I do think he aware friend is vulnerable right now and doesnt want him to lean on me too much. Friend checks in with DH with me aswell because he wouldn't want me to send time with him over my family.. I say this like we are together always. We really aren't, like maybe 1/2 times a month at the mo, and a majority of the time some kids are with me

OP posts:
spookehtooth · 03/09/2023 11:58

Whilst I agree with the responses above, I do accept the unplanned things happen and that sometimes circumstances can play a bigger role than intent. However I still maintain trust matters, it's not something to do in expectation of a desired outcome. If both people want to behave the way that's been described, then I guess that's okay, but one person setting rules and controlling what someone else can do isn't on. Even at my most insecure, when younger, I couldn't help showing it but I made it clear that she should go and do what she wanted anyways because the idea of being a dickhead was an even worse fear 🤣🤣

GCSister · 03/09/2023 10:36

@gannett absolutely spot on!
If I lived my life thinking about the situations that could lead to an affair then I wouldn't be where I am in my career.
I have to travel regularly with my male boss. We get on extremely well, in fact I often comment about how he's practically a clone of my husband. I value him as a colleague and a friend.
We often find ourselves half way across the world missing our partners and families. Yet we've never had an affair or even a hint of something inappropriate.

MasterBeth · 03/09/2023 09:49

So yeah he may well make a pass which OP may refuse but embarrassment all around and the friendship won't recover.
And all for fancy meal
.

So actually, you admit there won't be an affair, because the OP won't be a partner in one.

And your concern is the potential for the OP's heartbroken friend to make a pass.

So the OP has to police his possible bad behaviour by missing out on what is likely to be a perfectly platonic evening out for both parties.

Sorry, but any responsibility there for the friendship's survival is not the OP's. She shouldn't be living her life on the basis of "what if my good friend is so disrespectful to me, my husband and my marriage that he makes a pass at me?"

I trust my friends until they do something that suggests I shouldn't. It seems the OP is doing the same.

gannett · 03/09/2023 09:32

Sanitas · 03/09/2023 08:41

I'll also add that few people set out to have affairs. They can happen organically over time.

I think a lot of us think affairs are deeply immoral therefore we are immoral if we have them and as few people want to be immoral as a rule, it's like they emphasise that they'd never do it.

Now there are some things that we'd never do but I'm afraid all that is required for an affair are conditions to be right.

OP's friend is really, really vulnerable to an affair, OP may just may be feeling a bit 'mumsy' at the moment if on maternity leave.

We can never ever be fully trusted not have an affair because life happens. None of us.

This is why it is, correctly, a social norm for men and women not to get too close, it's not old-fashioned it's common sense.

(For me, I've got male acquaintances I'm fond of, care about even: I once cleaned the house of an acquaintance that I knew was sick. That's fine, to care about other men. That's OK. But one on one time? No way.)

An affair isn't a heinous crime. So it's best to be real and say that we are all capable of one and be aware enough to realise that sometimes conditions are right and it seems to me they are just right for OP's friend, not her but him.

So yeah he may well make a pass which OP may refuse but embarrassment all around and the friendship won't recover.
And all for fancy meal.

By this logic, women can never have business meetings or take business trips with male colleagues, one-on-one. Because those are also conditions for an affair. How very... regressive. You seem to be arguing for near-total gender segregation when it comes to socialising. And as ever, no thought given to situations where one or both parties are bisexual, gay, lesbian etc.

In any case the obvious counterargument is the massive number of times all your conditions are met, but no affair has resulted.

This year alone I have been to Michelin-starred restaurants with male friends, I have travelled abroad with male colleagues and hung out in hotel bars overseas with them, I have been out clubbing and danced til 6am with a male friend, I have had extremely jolly big nights out on the town and gone back to male friends' houses for drinks. All one-on-one! (I have also done the same with female friends, and in groups, and with DP.) Not a single affair resulted. Not even so much as a pass.

Every one of your silly "conditions" can be countered easily by having awareness of morals and boundaries, and having male friends who are the same.

GCSister · 03/09/2023 09:22

Well unless all your female friends are also bisexual then of course there'll be no affair.
If you have straight female friends there'll never be an affair.

I do have a number of bisexual friends who I socialise with so.....🤷🏼‍♀️ am I not allowed to be friends with them?

Let's say I do find my friend attractive and wanted an affair, it doesn't matter if she's bisexual or not if she's not interested or as equally up for it. People have agency and can make decisions.

Sanitas · 03/09/2023 09:06

GCSister · 03/09/2023 08:56

@Sanitas having an affair is still a choice. They don't happen by accident.
Human beings have agency, even if the conditions are perfect for an affair it still requires individuals to make decisions and act upon particular feelings.

As for your suggestion that men and women shouldn't get too close or form bonds due to the risk of an affair...... I'm bisexual, should I not be forming close bonds with anyone? I've asked this question a couple of times but it's still not been answered.

I'm going out for a boozy brunch with a female friend today. According to your logic my husband should be telling me not to go as there is a risk it will turn into an affair.

Well unless all your female friends are also bisexual then of course there'll be no affair.
If you have straight female friends there'll never be an affair.

GCSister · 03/09/2023 08:56

@Sanitas having an affair is still a choice. They don't happen by accident.
Human beings have agency, even if the conditions are perfect for an affair it still requires individuals to make decisions and act upon particular feelings.

As for your suggestion that men and women shouldn't get too close or form bonds due to the risk of an affair...... I'm bisexual, should I not be forming close bonds with anyone? I've asked this question a couple of times but it's still not been answered.

I'm going out for a boozy brunch with a female friend today. According to your logic my husband should be telling me not to go as there is a risk it will turn into an affair.

Sanitas · 03/09/2023 08:41

I'll also add that few people set out to have affairs. They can happen organically over time.

I think a lot of us think affairs are deeply immoral therefore we are immoral if we have them and as few people want to be immoral as a rule, it's like they emphasise that they'd never do it.

Now there are some things that we'd never do but I'm afraid all that is required for an affair are conditions to be right.

OP's friend is really, really vulnerable to an affair, OP may just may be feeling a bit 'mumsy' at the moment if on maternity leave.

We can never ever be fully trusted not have an affair because life happens. None of us.

This is why it is, correctly, a social norm for men and women not to get too close, it's not old-fashioned it's common sense.

(For me, I've got male acquaintances I'm fond of, care about even: I once cleaned the house of an acquaintance that I knew was sick. That's fine, to care about other men. That's OK. But one on one time? No way.)

An affair isn't a heinous crime. So it's best to be real and say that we are all capable of one and be aware enough to realise that sometimes conditions are right and it seems to me they are just right for OP's friend, not her but him.

So yeah he may well make a pass which OP may refuse but embarrassment all around and the friendship won't recover.
And all for fancy meal.

Sanitas · 03/09/2023 08:13

Aprilrosesews has made best comment, you should listen.

Aprilrosesews · 03/09/2023 00:08

The issue I have with his issue is I don't really know what it is, he's never voiced and won't voice that he has concerns about my friend (we socialise as a couple with him too and they get on) so i don't understand why coffee/breakfast/walk is fine but a dinner isn't.

if you look at it objectively as if you were dating, a coffee/breakfast/walk is a relationship builder/getting to know someone and a very nice dinner is when you’re turning the heat up a bit and trying to get into their pants 😂 that’s objectively speaking of course as I would happily go for drinks/dinners with my male friends

maybe the dinner is the thing that’s solidified that niggle he had in his head and that’s why he’s voiced this opinion now? Will you be seeing friend before this dinner? Maybe see how he reacts to those plans so you know if it’s dinner or your friendship?

If it was me I would really need to push him for an answer and wouldn’t relent till I got it but that’s my personality 😂

if he’s worried he will offend or be embarrassed that he’s jealous its a lot easier for him to agree to what you’ve said ‘I know you trust me fully but do you think friend is starting to like me/think this dinner is to intimate etc’ that him have to say ‘I think our friend is going to try it on with you’

spookehtooth · 02/09/2023 20:07

I used to be uneasy about various things when I was younger, I always knew it was unreasonable but shrug if only emotions were logical, I did my best to be reasonable. Now I'm a lot more relaxed, and realistic about this. Every time you're not together, its an opportunity one of you to cheat, and most often its not going to be done openly. I feel expressing a lack of trust is damaging to a relationship, and its important to let a person be themselves. If they trust someone they shouldn't, and the relationship is healthy, I'd trust them to decline. I'd like to think they'd be comfortable with talking about it too. Concern might be a sign there's already a problem of some sort.

Boogiewoogieanddance · 02/09/2023 19:49

@Aprilrosesews yes!! How you've worded it all so well is an achievement. B,1 is a great way to word it and a completely fair agreement.

The issue I have with his issue is I don't really know what it is, he's never voiced and won't voice that he has concerns about my friend (we socialise as a couple with him too and they get on) so i don't understand why coffee/breakfast/walk is fine but a dinner isn't.

I do have respect for my husband and his opinions, when I say talk him round/he'll get over it I mean to have a conversation and I believe he will see why its completely fine and that his issues with it being weird cause it's in the evening is a bit crap. If something more comes from his side I'll take it on board and reevaluate.

OP posts:
JaneIntheBox · 02/09/2023 18:33

Aprilrosesews · 02/09/2023 15:42

from the sounds of it your husband isnt usually the ‘I don’t want you to do this’ type and is reasonable. If that’s correct then I think you need to trust him and get a clear answer why he doesn’t want you to go.

a) is he feeling a bit jealous - then he’s BU. You should go and he needs to work on why he feels like that

b) is his intuition telling him somethings off - you have 2 options here.

  1. you ask you husband to trust you and in return you will make sure you are going to dinner and watching for any signs his intuition is right and get rid off ‘we’re platonic friends’ mindset because that can make you naive and see your friends flirting as just being friendly
  2. you respect your husbands intuition and decline the meal

i say this as someone who has had a similar scenario and that my husband would joke that my friend is in love with me. A few years in my marriage was were going through a rough patch which my friend thought would be the perfect opportunity to tell me he was in love with me and had been for years.

Your friend is in an emotionally vulnerable state and you are, from the sounds of it, a good friend and wife. It would be very easy for your friend to project his feelings onto you when you are what he wishes his wife had been.

i believe you can have truly platonic opposite sex friendships but don’t be naive enough to miss warning signs

Edited

You put across exactly what I was trying to say. much more succinctly!

Aprilrosesews · 02/09/2023 15:42

from the sounds of it your husband isnt usually the ‘I don’t want you to do this’ type and is reasonable. If that’s correct then I think you need to trust him and get a clear answer why he doesn’t want you to go.

a) is he feeling a bit jealous - then he’s BU. You should go and he needs to work on why he feels like that

b) is his intuition telling him somethings off - you have 2 options here.

  1. you ask you husband to trust you and in return you will make sure you are going to dinner and watching for any signs his intuition is right and get rid off ‘we’re platonic friends’ mindset because that can make you naive and see your friends flirting as just being friendly
  2. you respect your husbands intuition and decline the meal

i say this as someone who has had a similar scenario and that my husband would joke that my friend is in love with me. A few years in my marriage was were going through a rough patch which my friend thought would be the perfect opportunity to tell me he was in love with me and had been for years.

Your friend is in an emotionally vulnerable state and you are, from the sounds of it, a good friend and wife. It would be very easy for your friend to project his feelings onto you when you are what he wishes his wife had been.

i believe you can have truly platonic opposite sex friendships but don’t be naive enough to miss warning signs

Womencanlift · 02/09/2023 15:24

GCSister · 02/09/2023 15:14

What has been says that is awful?
I would say you are unable of seeing another way of living though......

Exactly. Nothing has been said that’s awful, just challenging opinions that are very much not the norm in the UK from my experience

But since she has told us twice now she is out of here I guess we will never know 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread