Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go to dinner with another man?

641 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 29/08/2023 19:42

DH is being a bit funny and thinks it's inappropriate so just want to get some other opinions.

A good friend of mine was married recently, unfortunately he is now serperated through no choice of his own. He has some wedding gifts in the form of vouchers, this specific one to a super nice restaurant that I couldn't usually afford. DH also wouldn't go because he doesn't like a set menu.

He asked me today if I would go with him. We have been good friends from before his last relationship, throughout the marriage etc and are quite close.. Entirely mutually platonic. We meet up for walks, the occasional drink etc sometimes alone sometimes with friends. DH knows him and knows when we meet up, never been an issue. Recently we've probably been meeting a bit more because he's been having a hard time and could do with the company.

DH thinks it's inappropriate because its a fancy meal, I'm married, he's not anymore and seems like a date.

I appreciate that if he had out of the blue asked to take me for an overpriced dinner and wine I would feel uncomfortable and it would be inappropriate but that's not the case, it's exceptional in that it's a crappy situation and he has this voucher to use and rather than it go to waste we enjoy each others company and have nice food and that DH wouldn't even have with me anyway.

I think DH will get over it, he trusts me and I think its more that if someone else saw us together it could look sus.. But surely that shouldn't really matter?

Or am I just thinking with my belly and it's an entirely inappropriate situation...

OP posts:
GCSister · 04/09/2023 11:46

Who's says your not sharing a bed... How do you know you won't click that night... Drink does all sorts between people

If drink makes you have sex with people you aren't in a relationship with then you need to stop drinking.

Livelifelaughter · 04/09/2023 11:30

TedMullins · 04/09/2023 10:51

Isn’t him asking her not to go a lack of respect though? He doesn’t respect her autonomy, choice of friends, or trust her. Why do his wishes automatically trump hers?

I don't think it is a lack of respect because it's not completely unreasonable for H to feel uncomfortable in this situation.

Livelifelaughter · 04/09/2023 11:28

JillinSwindon · 04/09/2023 06:56

Am I right in thinking DH has been offered the choice of going but has turned it down simply because it's a set menu? So he has effectively agreed to the arrangement and consequently hasn't got a leg to stand on IMHO.

I think the voucher covers the cost of two tasting menus with wine but it can be used at the same value for the normal menu, but OP said then there would be the cost of the drinks as the voucher isn't enough...

TedMullins · 04/09/2023 10:51

randomusernam · 04/09/2023 10:46

For me it would be the lack of respect. I've told you it makes me uncomfortable and you have chosen to go anyway and tell him to get over it.

I would be telling the friend to ask someone else. You can't be his only friend.... or take his mum

Isn’t him asking her not to go a lack of respect though? He doesn’t respect her autonomy, choice of friends, or trust her. Why do his wishes automatically trump hers?

TedMullins · 04/09/2023 10:49

TheAOEAztec · 04/09/2023 09:59

Black and Decker
Squish them down with distractions, preferably with beer and pizza
Thor 100%. I mean it's electricity vs fish innit

Oh no! Will I grow penis now😔

I was pissing myself at ‘manly topics’. Here’s a few more suggestions:

Prostates, just, generally having them
Best time to go to the tip
Longest poo they’ve ever done (in time, not length of turd)
How many letters they have that need shredding
Ranking every Fast and Furious or Transporter movie from worst to best
How many pubes on average are left in the shower basin after they wash
How likely on a 1-10 scale they are to be moaned at about said pubes

randomusernam · 04/09/2023 10:46

For me it would be the lack of respect. I've told you it makes me uncomfortable and you have chosen to go anyway and tell him to get over it.

I would be telling the friend to ask someone else. You can't be his only friend.... or take his mum

ErosandAgape · 04/09/2023 10:37

Father1 · 04/09/2023 10:21

Who's says your not sharing a bed... How do you know you won't click that night... Drink does all sorts between people

Does your husband know this bloke? Does he know how you both get on with each other? If the answer to both is no then as a husband I wouldn't be happy.

If you regularly drink until you lose control to the point where you have sex with people other than your spouse, I think you might want to consider whether you have an alcohol problem.

Father1 · 04/09/2023 10:21

Boogiewoogieanddance · 29/08/2023 20:07

@OnlyFoolsnMothers we arent sharing a bed.. We are sitting across a table from each other on an evening surrounded by the public

Who's says your not sharing a bed... How do you know you won't click that night... Drink does all sorts between people

Does your husband know this bloke? Does he know how you both get on with each other? If the answer to both is no then as a husband I wouldn't be happy.

TheAOEAztec · 04/09/2023 09:59

SleepingStandingUp · 04/09/2023 09:55

Manly topics?? What are these topics op can't discuss on account of her lack of penis? The best screwdriver on the market? How to bury your feelings and not discuss them? Who'd win between Thor and Aquaman? 🤣

Black and Decker
Squish them down with distractions, preferably with beer and pizza
Thor 100%. I mean it's electricity vs fish innit

Oh no! Will I grow penis now😔

GCSister · 04/09/2023 09:59

DJhowzy · 04/09/2023 09:42

(Disclaimer for other mumsnetters - this is a response to the OP's question and not an invite for the masses to respond to me, twist my words and put me down. I have answered the OP's question from my own personal opinion. Please only do the same if you feel the need to respond, lol). For what it's worth...

Well well well, OP,

I'm wondering if you regret posting your question on here not, lol? Did you get the response your were hoping for? After all, people mostly post on here seeking validation of their own viewpoint, as opposed to putting in their subsequent lost time working on the issue with the relevant person. How much time exactly has been spent reading all of the responses and formulating further responses yourself? Who knows...

I love reading MN posts as it is a fascinating insight into human behaviour, values and principles. As usual, the OP receives several hundred perspectives based on the life experiences and values of other people, none of whom are living the OP's life, therefore throwing the actual dynamics and true context out of the window.

OP, there are many, many valid points posted on here in response to your question, some with extremely adept articulation, and others with the comprehension of a monkey holding an iPad and being asked to back it up to a PC. I enjoyed wasting 30-45 minutes reading some selected answers and typing up my response, which I do agree is far too long, lol. Apologies.

Your husband sounds like a great partner and your relationship has been presented as robust, but, we are all emotional beings at the end of the day and we simply cannot help the way we feel in any given situation.

In my humble opinion, you should simply respect your husbands feelings and decline the invitation. You have asked him and he has given you his answer. It seems you posted on here to attain validation for going out with another man as you would like to enjoy this nice meal and you have come up with every reason imaginable to justify why you should attend the experience. HOWEVER... you are repeatedly dismissing your husbands feelings and are trying to overcome his objection from every perceivable angle. He sounds a reasonable man who simply is not comfortable with his wife having a posh meal in a romantic setting with another man who may possibly be on the rebound.

Rather then post on here and spending eternity reading hundreds of posts and posting reply after reply, your time would have been better spent discussing your husbands feelings with him and ultimately respecting his viewpoint.

If your DH was comfortable with the scenario, then fine, but the reality is, he is not. If you eventually do manage to twist his arm into agreeing you should go for the meal (perhaps you would show him that 68% of musnetters agree with you, not sure?), there will still be a part of him that is resentful and your relationship may have been negatively affected, even if only ever so slightly. As husband and wife in a stable and balanced relationship, you both should absolutely respect one anothers feelings, no matter what the scenario is that arises.

Obviously, this is purely my own humble opinion as an outsider looking in, like all the other responses, and I am sorry I do not agree with your viewpoint, but please do also consider my response when choosing how you will proceed. In answer to your question, I think YABU in this situation, as your husband has given you his answer and he simply is not comfortable with the situation. He is an emotional being, bless him, as we all are.

Wow, this has to be up there as one of the most patronising things I've ever read.
There's certainly nothing 'humble' about it.

SleepingStandingUp · 04/09/2023 09:58

sezzer87 · 03/09/2023 21:05

Mine enjoys the company of women too, but he loves his Friday nights with his brother where he can chat about certain topics that can't be spoken about in front of women.
I'm sure there are topics you'd only talk about with women too.

Like what?? Their sex lives and who they want to shag? Surely anything else is fine on mixed company

SleepingStandingUp · 04/09/2023 09:55

sezzer87 · 03/09/2023 17:14

The question is why he feels the need to go for walks and meals with a married women? Why not go with a mate and go for beers and talk about manly topics. Seems strange that he'd choose a female who's married with kids.
My husband goes for drinks with a mixed group from work. That's different but if he had the opportunity to go for a walk or a meal out he wouldn't pick another women over me and definitely not a married women.
Seems like this man is filling a void in your own marriage. Perhaps your husband is now cottoning on to that, and worried that this big posh meal will make the two of you even closer and highlight what's missing in your marriage.

Manly topics?? What are these topics op can't discuss on account of her lack of penis? The best screwdriver on the market? How to bury your feelings and not discuss them? Who'd win between Thor and Aquaman? 🤣

ErosandAgape · 04/09/2023 09:51

DJhowzy · 04/09/2023 09:42

(Disclaimer for other mumsnetters - this is a response to the OP's question and not an invite for the masses to respond to me, twist my words and put me down. I have answered the OP's question from my own personal opinion. Please only do the same if you feel the need to respond, lol). For what it's worth...

Well well well, OP,

I'm wondering if you regret posting your question on here not, lol? Did you get the response your were hoping for? After all, people mostly post on here seeking validation of their own viewpoint, as opposed to putting in their subsequent lost time working on the issue with the relevant person. How much time exactly has been spent reading all of the responses and formulating further responses yourself? Who knows...

I love reading MN posts as it is a fascinating insight into human behaviour, values and principles. As usual, the OP receives several hundred perspectives based on the life experiences and values of other people, none of whom are living the OP's life, therefore throwing the actual dynamics and true context out of the window.

OP, there are many, many valid points posted on here in response to your question, some with extremely adept articulation, and others with the comprehension of a monkey holding an iPad and being asked to back it up to a PC. I enjoyed wasting 30-45 minutes reading some selected answers and typing up my response, which I do agree is far too long, lol. Apologies.

Your husband sounds like a great partner and your relationship has been presented as robust, but, we are all emotional beings at the end of the day and we simply cannot help the way we feel in any given situation.

In my humble opinion, you should simply respect your husbands feelings and decline the invitation. You have asked him and he has given you his answer. It seems you posted on here to attain validation for going out with another man as you would like to enjoy this nice meal and you have come up with every reason imaginable to justify why you should attend the experience. HOWEVER... you are repeatedly dismissing your husbands feelings and are trying to overcome his objection from every perceivable angle. He sounds a reasonable man who simply is not comfortable with his wife having a posh meal in a romantic setting with another man who may possibly be on the rebound.

Rather then post on here and spending eternity reading hundreds of posts and posting reply after reply, your time would have been better spent discussing your husbands feelings with him and ultimately respecting his viewpoint.

If your DH was comfortable with the scenario, then fine, but the reality is, he is not. If you eventually do manage to twist his arm into agreeing you should go for the meal (perhaps you would show him that 68% of musnetters agree with you, not sure?), there will still be a part of him that is resentful and your relationship may have been negatively affected, even if only ever so slightly. As husband and wife in a stable and balanced relationship, you both should absolutely respect one anothers feelings, no matter what the scenario is that arises.

Obviously, this is purely my own humble opinion as an outsider looking in, like all the other responses, and I am sorry I do not agree with your viewpoint, but please do also consider my response when choosing how you will proceed. In answer to your question, I think YABU in this situation, as your husband has given you his answer and he simply is not comfortable with the situation. He is an emotional being, bless him, as we all are.

People who genuinely think their own opinion is ‘humble’ don’t tend to post it at such performative length.

SleepingStandingUp · 04/09/2023 09:43

Sanitas · 03/09/2023 09:06

Well unless all your female friends are also bisexual then of course there'll be no affair.
If you have straight female friends there'll never be an affair.

Ok so bisexual people in relationships are now only allowed straight friends?

DJhowzy · 04/09/2023 09:42

(Disclaimer for other mumsnetters - this is a response to the OP's question and not an invite for the masses to respond to me, twist my words and put me down. I have answered the OP's question from my own personal opinion. Please only do the same if you feel the need to respond, lol). For what it's worth...

Well well well, OP,

I'm wondering if you regret posting your question on here not, lol? Did you get the response your were hoping for? After all, people mostly post on here seeking validation of their own viewpoint, as opposed to putting in their subsequent lost time working on the issue with the relevant person. How much time exactly has been spent reading all of the responses and formulating further responses yourself? Who knows...

I love reading MN posts as it is a fascinating insight into human behaviour, values and principles. As usual, the OP receives several hundred perspectives based on the life experiences and values of other people, none of whom are living the OP's life, therefore throwing the actual dynamics and true context out of the window.

OP, there are many, many valid points posted on here in response to your question, some with extremely adept articulation, and others with the comprehension of a monkey holding an iPad and being asked to back it up to a PC. I enjoyed wasting 30-45 minutes reading some selected answers and typing up my response, which I do agree is far too long, lol. Apologies.

Your husband sounds like a great partner and your relationship has been presented as robust, but, we are all emotional beings at the end of the day and we simply cannot help the way we feel in any given situation.

In my humble opinion, you should simply respect your husbands feelings and decline the invitation. You have asked him and he has given you his answer. It seems you posted on here to attain validation for going out with another man as you would like to enjoy this nice meal and you have come up with every reason imaginable to justify why you should attend the experience. HOWEVER... you are repeatedly dismissing your husbands feelings and are trying to overcome his objection from every perceivable angle. He sounds a reasonable man who simply is not comfortable with his wife having a posh meal in a romantic setting with another man who may possibly be on the rebound.

Rather then post on here and spending eternity reading hundreds of posts and posting reply after reply, your time would have been better spent discussing your husbands feelings with him and ultimately respecting his viewpoint.

If your DH was comfortable with the scenario, then fine, but the reality is, he is not. If you eventually do manage to twist his arm into agreeing you should go for the meal (perhaps you would show him that 68% of musnetters agree with you, not sure?), there will still be a part of him that is resentful and your relationship may have been negatively affected, even if only ever so slightly. As husband and wife in a stable and balanced relationship, you both should absolutely respect one anothers feelings, no matter what the scenario is that arises.

Obviously, this is purely my own humble opinion as an outsider looking in, like all the other responses, and I am sorry I do not agree with your viewpoint, but please do also consider my response when choosing how you will proceed. In answer to your question, I think YABU in this situation, as your husband has given you his answer and he simply is not comfortable with the situation. He is an emotional being, bless him, as we all are.

northlife34 · 04/09/2023 08:59

One of my best friends is male we regularly go out together, none of our spouses have a problem with it. I say go for it and enjoy yourselves!

If your husband has an issue he needs to grow up, you're not exactly being dishonest about it and you've been friends a long time.

GCSister · 04/09/2023 08:55

If he needs support and uplifting I think the correct thing to do it find it with a male friend or unmarried female one if she so wished.

I'm sorry, have we forgotten it's 2023 and married women are now allowed to participate fully in society??

GCSister · 04/09/2023 08:54

The question is why he feels the need to go for walks and meals with a married women? Why not go with a mate and go for beers and talk about manly topics.

Hilarious. What are manly topics?!

dibley27 · 04/09/2023 08:40

Totally depends on your relationship dynamics I guess. People are different. Personally, if something bothers either DH or myself - reasonable or not, because feelings are not always reasonable - then we don't do it. It's just how we both are. We have always been about putting each other above anybody else and that's just our vibe, it works for us. We do obviously have serious chats if there is something we don't agree on - try to come to an arrangement that we are both happy with. But if one of us still isn't happy with it after that, then we just wouldn't do it.
Your relationship sounds different, so just follow your instincts and if it feels OK, go and enjoy yourself! 😁

Ohhbaby · 04/09/2023 08:02

Yeah, sorry I think it is inappropriate. I do not think a man going through a hard time (granted) should choose a married woman's proverbial shoulder to cry on. If he needs support and uplifting I think the correct thing to do it find it with a male friend or unmarried female one if she so wished.
I think in a society where marriage is made quite cheap, I would be protective of my marriage, meaning I am not going to make sure my emotional energy, compassion and time is not wasted on someone other than my dh. Obviously you want to be there for a friend but one on one time at a restaurant would be a no go for me and dh. I know other posters that have used the term respect have been shut down pretty fast, but i feel the same way. It's not respecting the current marriage.

Scaraben · 04/09/2023 07:29

I think this is totally fine. One of my closest friends is a man, we go out together to do all sorts of things and his wife/my DH have never attempted to curtail us spending time together. Our friendship predates either of them! I'm surprised by the responses here.

My DH recently got given a voucher for a fancy steak restaurant and he took a female friend of ours. I can't stand steak so was pleased he got to use it and that I didn't have to go along and eat a bunch of side dishes!

If people are going to have affairs they'll have affairs, they don't need a tasting menu to facilitate it...

Birch101 · 04/09/2023 06:58

Your friend is going through a hard time and personally I would go and enjoy the meal with a friend.

The only thing is to make your.pattner know that on your side it is entirely platonic and if you ever start to feel that your friend is using you more like a crutch and not getting out there in the future to meet new people as he is getting some emotional needs met from you that you would reassess the situation

JillinSwindon · 04/09/2023 06:56

Am I right in thinking DH has been offered the choice of going but has turned it down simply because it's a set menu? So he has effectively agreed to the arrangement and consequently hasn't got a leg to stand on IMHO.

Martin123456 · 04/09/2023 06:48

Your old man isn't comfortable with it, and has said so, I wouldn't be either, if you're still considering going, then I'm not sure you really respect your old man's decision on not to go. I can appreciate that (on your part) it is purely platonic. But can you guarantee that the other two guys feel the same way. Certainly doesn't sound like your old man does.
Maybe you'll go against your old man's wishes. Maybe you won't go, against your friends wishes, which one do you feel you owe the honour of being respectful to the most?

theGooHasGone · 03/09/2023 22:56

You've already made up your mind; why are you asking for input?