Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled at how this woman is treated

134 replies

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:09

My best friend and I were chatting today. His partners mum has broken her leg after a nasty trip over her dog.
She was in hospital for a couple of days following a bone reset and cast and the staff rang to collect her to bring her home.
Her adult children refused point blank.

His partners attitude was that the government could pay for her care and rehabilitation and meals as that is what they paid taxes for.
Her mum is 65, fit and generally healthy and lives alone.
Her mum is devastated as she has now been moved to a care home miles away from anyone of her family . They visit her once a week and refuse discharge until she is 'perfect' again.
Their mum was a SAHM all her life and devoted her life to her kids. Their Dad is dead. She needs minimal care but physio three times per week. She is mobile on crutches and
Can self care.

They are all shift workers, one with no kids, the others with teens so I'm pretty sure they could have supported her in her own home and offered her lifts or organised taxis between them.

Now my best friend and I go back thirty years and know each other inside out and each others families and hell would freeze over before he would allow that for his own mum and mine for the matter !
He was embarrassed telling me , probably not helped by my face showing absolute disbelief.
It has made me think about my own children and what they would do.
His partner is ok, a bit of a cold fish but he loves her so that's what matters .
AIBU to be appalled or is this becoming the norm now.

OP posts:
applesandmares · 29/08/2023 19:12

You've been clear OP. From what you know, her kids sound awful.

mrsm43s · 29/08/2023 19:10

Riapia · 29/08/2023 19:06

MN verdict.
It must be all her own fault that her children don’t give a fuck about her.
No other explanation possible.

No.

The overwhelming Mumsnet verdict is that facts, as the OP is presenting them, are simply not true and would not happen, so she is either talking nonsense or has been fed misinformation/an incomplete story.

truthhurts23 · 29/08/2023 19:09

if all her kids treat her like that there must be a reason

VanGoghsDog · 29/08/2023 19:07

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:29

There really is no more to this .
NOK refused discharge. Hospital needed bed. Care home was only option. That's it .
No one would mind her.

That's not a thing, they cannot "refuse discharge". She's an adult woman, she makes her own life choices not them. Unless you are suggesting she does not have mental capacity.

Noone goes into a care home for a broken leg. She would just have been asked if she could manage and if not then might have arranged a carer.

There's other stuff going on here, there has to be.

None of this makes any sense.

heatherheathe · 29/08/2023 19:06

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:40

They admitted her and the hospital wouldn't discharge her without care in place. The family refused to care for her , leaving the hospital with no other option than sorting out a care home as there are no immediate carers available.
Am I being unclear. Genuine question?

not unclear but it doesn't tie in with what I (background in hospital discharges) and others on this thread have commented which suggests you don't know the whole story (given you are hearing it third or fourth hand).

If someone is well enough to manage at home with minimal care they can't be forced into a care home. The mum could organise her own care to come in as needed and pay privately, if her needs are that minimal, including paying for taxis to her physio. Or if she couldn't afford to do so it would be much cheaper for the hospital to organise care visitors for her once a day or whatever she needs than for her to go into a care home.

Even if both she and the hospital refused to organise any at-home care, as long as she has mental capacity the hospital can't force her to go into a care home. As long as you're mentally capable you can discharge yourself against medical advice. Therefore the mother must agree she needs a lot of help and wouldn't be able to manage at home, even with carers, which suggests she needs more care than her children could easily provide.

Does that make it 'right' that the children won't put themselves out for a few weeks if they otherwise have a good relationship with her? Maybe not, but it's not as clear cut as 'she only needs someone to take her some shopping and give her a lift once a week and all her kids are refusing to even do that.'

Riapia · 29/08/2023 19:06

MN verdict.
It must be all her own fault that her children don’t give a fuck about her.
No other explanation possible.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 29/08/2023 19:06

Unless she’s mentally incompetent, she doesn’t need a NOK to discharge her, no one has ever needed someone to discharge them unless they’re physically or mentally incapable of leaving the hospital under their own steam.

Whippetlovely · 29/08/2023 19:05

Hobbesmanc · 29/08/2023 18:34

If she's 65. Otherwise fit with mental capacity then she doesn't require next of kin to discharge. There's no way they'd put someone in a nursing home. Too expensive. They'd arrange patient transfer home with a reablement care package. Unless where she lives has no homecare available. I think there's only half a story here.

Exactly this, she would be sent home and carers organised if it was minor. I bet the hospital have asked the kids to have her they have said no because they don’t have the capacity to look after her needs with working and children and that’s why they can’t take her not that they don’t care. They probably want her getting the full care she needs to recover.

Dpace · 29/08/2023 19:04

OP it doesn't make sense because we simply don't live in a world where adults with full mental capacity need the permission of NOK in various medical situations. What you're describing is some kind of George Orwell fantasy.

Adults are allowed to discharge themselves and arrange their own care, unless they're in a situation where they aren't actually capable. If this is the case this lady must need so much more care than that your friend has described.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 29/08/2023 19:04

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:28

She doesn't require that level of care but they refused her discharge home as her next of kin so the hospital had no choice but to find her a care home.

This is nonsense. As a competent adult she was entirely capable of discharging herself and booking a taxi home. Not a cat in hell's chance she's gone into a care home because her next of kin refused her discharge.

SueVineer · 29/08/2023 19:04

I wouldn’t be so quick to judge- you don’t know their side. My mother is a fairly awful individual and a terrible mother who would never go out her way to help anyone.

Oldermum84 · 29/08/2023 19:02

I'm another one who agrees this doesn't make sense. To add to PPs, if she has a cast on her leg then she won't be receiving physio! She won't have gone to a rehab bed as won't be fit for rehab. She won't have gone to a care home funded by the government if she has no care needs.

The only thing I can think of is that she may have gone to a "non-weightbearing bed" which is actually funded by the NHS.

I think it sounds like you don't have all the facts but no, I don't think it's overly shitty for adult children to have to give up their own lives for weeks to look after their mum if they're not in a position to do so.

Willmafrockfit · 29/08/2023 19:01

i also wouldnt be so quick to judge
perhaps they need to work to keep a roof over their head and cant get time off
perhaps there is a break down in the relationship

DistantSkye · 29/08/2023 19:01

Something doesn't add up here tbh. It seems really really unlikely that the authority would fund a care home place rather than a care package at home for a straightforward broken leg with no other issues.
Patient transport is available to take patients home, and to appointments and I the maximum care package on offer is 4 visits a day - including washing, dressing and getting ready for bed.

The stuff about "the hospital needing to find her a bed" and "not getting her home until she's perfect" sound like Daily Mail headline fodder 🙄

Iwasafool · 29/08/2023 18:59

LondonLass91 · 29/08/2023 18:56

The only thing I would say is that when you get discharged from hospital into either someone's care or in your own home with social services help, then the physio is non existent. You'll get a sheet of exercises and forgotten. So while she is in a care home (it would actually be a rehabilitation care home, not an older person's care home), then she would get better and more targeted physio and after care. I speak from experience. So perhaps refusing to take her was more about understanding that once she was discharged then she would not be taken care of by clinicians.

Edited

I got fantastic physio support when I was discharged with a broken ankle, elderly relative discharged to her care home got no physio at all. The hospital said it was up to the care home, they did what they could but they weren't physios.

purplecorkheart · 29/08/2023 18:59

I do wonder if there is more to the story than your friend has been told. Maybe their partner is trying to shield them from the truth.

Or else your friends partner and his family are selfish/unable to cope or manage etc. If it is purely put of selfish view maybe your friend should consider their relationship and what would happen if they were in this ladies position.

FictionalCharacter · 29/08/2023 18:58

MermaidEyes · 29/08/2023 18:55

Also if she has full mental capacity then no next of kin has any right to decide anything for her.

This is one of the things I don’t get.
There are without doubt details of this story that the OP’s friend has misunderstood or misinterpreted. Or he’s holding something back.

LondonLass91 · 29/08/2023 18:56

The only thing I would say is that when you get discharged from hospital into either someone's care or in your own home with social services help, then the physio is non existent. You'll get a sheet of exercises and forgotten. So while she is in a care home (it would actually be a rehabilitation care home, not an older person's care home), then she would get better and more targeted physio and after care. I speak from experience. So perhaps refusing to take her was more about understanding that once she was discharged then she would not be taken care of by clinicians.

LakeTiticaca · 29/08/2023 18:56

What significance to this is that she was a SAHM?
I broke my ankle a few years back (age mid 50s) my DH took a couple of days off work while I acclimatised and then I was on my own all day. I was on crutches and a neighbour lent me a wheelchair. I coped perfectly well. I worked out how to shuffle up and down the stairs on my bum and I was able to wash myself leaning against the sink. I could wash my hair with no problem. Everything just took a little while to work out.
This is a strange post and there must be more to it, although it's a bit shitty to expect the government to pay fees to look after those who are capable of looking after themselves. Surely the kids don't work 24/7 and could call in once or twice a day between them.
That's what people did back in the days when folk looked out for their own.
Many don't seem.to give a shit now.

MermaidEyes · 29/08/2023 18:55

Also if she has full mental capacity then no next of kin has any right to decide anything for her.

BiscuitsandPuffin · 29/08/2023 18:55

They do a frailty score on people and assess their care needs before deciding they need the expensive round the clock care given by a care home. They don't just put any random sick person in a care home just because they live alone.

MrsElsa · 29/08/2023 18:53

Where does she normally reside? In her own home? As pp have said this makes no sense, you have got 3rd hand information and clearly it's not accurate.

BiscuitsandPuffin · 29/08/2023 18:53

Something doesn't add up here because MIL broke her leg at 68 and they sent her home no questions asked. Does your friend sometimes lie/exaggerate?

anunlikelyseahorse · 29/08/2023 18:52

Have you changed details so this isn't outing? Because a dislocated hip, may necessitate a short term stay in a care home, a broken bone and the patient on crutches, well that would be extremely unusual, especially in England where you have to have very high level needs to get any type of funding.
So either, you're not being told the full story, or you've changed some of the details.

MermaidEyes · 29/08/2023 18:52

You've obviously never had to deal with an elderly parent in hospital and all the complications that go with it regarding aftercare, patient transport, physio, carers etc. It's really not a case of children refused to let her home and now she's stuck in a residential home. There'll be a lot more that you're not aware of.

Swipe left for the next trending thread