Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled at how this woman is treated

134 replies

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:09

My best friend and I were chatting today. His partners mum has broken her leg after a nasty trip over her dog.
She was in hospital for a couple of days following a bone reset and cast and the staff rang to collect her to bring her home.
Her adult children refused point blank.

His partners attitude was that the government could pay for her care and rehabilitation and meals as that is what they paid taxes for.
Her mum is 65, fit and generally healthy and lives alone.
Her mum is devastated as she has now been moved to a care home miles away from anyone of her family . They visit her once a week and refuse discharge until she is 'perfect' again.
Their mum was a SAHM all her life and devoted her life to her kids. Their Dad is dead. She needs minimal care but physio three times per week. She is mobile on crutches and
Can self care.

They are all shift workers, one with no kids, the others with teens so I'm pretty sure they could have supported her in her own home and offered her lifts or organised taxis between them.

Now my best friend and I go back thirty years and know each other inside out and each others families and hell would freeze over before he would allow that for his own mum and mine for the matter !
He was embarrassed telling me , probably not helped by my face showing absolute disbelief.
It has made me think about my own children and what they would do.
His partner is ok, a bit of a cold fish but he loves her so that's what matters .
AIBU to be appalled or is this becoming the norm now.

OP posts:
Perisoire · 29/08/2023 20:37

Dymaxion · 29/08/2023 20:35

All of which can be managed in evenings and weekends and the odd day off.

So how come you need to plan who is moving in with your Mum ?

Because she will need a lot more help immediately after the knee op, as I understand it. Hopefully she’ll be reasonably independent again after recovery.

Alwaysdecorating · 29/08/2023 20:37

justtrees · 29/08/2023 19:29

All I know is what he told me and I took him at face value. He has no reason to lie but may not know the whole story. Regardless of why she is there , it was his partners attitude that astounded me.

But did you not question why he was telling you something he was clearly embarrassed about telling you?

He didn’t need to tell you this half story that makes his partner out to be awful. But he did and was embarrassed by it.

The point about having half story is just that. You have half a story. So you can’t say their behaviour is awful.

If she had to go in a home the situation is far worse than he is sharing or knows. Which is why they can’t care for her.

Theres absolutely no way, a woman with full capacity with no care needs was forced to go into a home because her adult children couldn’t care for her or arrange a taxi to appointments. She could arrange it herself.

I would be questioning why he is giving you this half tale about how awful his partner is.

Dymaxion · 29/08/2023 20:35

All of which can be managed in evenings and weekends and the odd day off.

So how come you need to plan who is moving in with your Mum ?

Perisoire · 29/08/2023 20:32

Winter2020 · 29/08/2023 20:27

It is great that you are able to do that but does suggest your family are not all working full time jobs outside the home in order to make ends meet - which is the situation for a lot of people.

No, we’re all in full time jobs Confused

Mum is still mobile, so the care we’re providing is taking her to doctors appointments shopping, bringing medication, taking meals over, rubbing ointment, etc.

All of which can be managed in evenings and weekends and the odd day off.

Dymaxion · 29/08/2023 20:27

She needs minimal care but physio three times per week. She is mobile on crutches and
Can self care.

Self care as an inpatient and self care at home are completely different, in one situation you are at one level and have people around 24/7, have meals brought to you etc in the other you are completely on your own.

If she lives in a house with stairs, how will she manage those stairs on crutches if she doesn't have a downstairs toilet ? Is there somewhere to put a bed ? a commode ? ( and you wouldn't believe the number of people who refuse a commode ) and where would the contents of the commode go if the toilet is upstairs and she is on crutches, so how can she carry the contents upstairs to dispose of them ? TMI but the bowls on commodes don't hold that much , so do need emptying at regular intervals !
How will she have a wash , will she manage at the kitchen sink whilst on crutches ? She probably won't manage if she has a bath with over head shower as won't be able to climb in and out safely.
Relatives can organise shopping to be delivered but how will she manage to put it away whilst on crutches, how easy is it to make a meal and carry that meal or even a cup of tea whilst on those crutches ?

Do you see where I am going with this ?

Winter2020 · 29/08/2023 20:27

Perisoire · 29/08/2023 20:14

Without knowing their particular challenges, that does seem harsh.

We are Asian and us siblings have settled within one mile radius of mum, so we can always be available for care.

Mum may need a knee op soon and we have started planning who will move in with her whilst she recovers.

Edited

It is great that you are able to do that but does suggest your family are not all working full time jobs outside the home in order to make ends meet - which is the situation for a lot of people.

Perisoire · 29/08/2023 20:14

Without knowing their particular challenges, that does seem harsh.

We are Asian and us siblings have settled within one mile radius of mum, so we can always be available for care.

Mum may need a knee op soon and we have started planning who will move in with her whilst she recovers.

Ghastisflabbered · 29/08/2023 19:59

moomoosaka · 29/08/2023 18:22

It's not always as simple as it sounds to an outsider

This.

My 86 year old gran was recently discharged into home care (4 visits a day) following a double hip break 3 weeks ago.

At no point was residential care even offered so for her to be in residential for what sounds like a simple break in a 65 years old means there’s way more to this story than you know.

Willmafrockfit · 29/08/2023 19:58

so she has gone for rehabilitation?

Willmafrockfit · 29/08/2023 19:56

perhaps she couldnt get community carers
perhaps her home wasnt suitable

Toddlerteaplease · 29/08/2023 19:47

That's shit. My dad hurt his knee and was in hospital for a week. I dropped everything to help my mum, as she doesn't drive. It was covid and she wasn't allowed to visit and was really lonely without him.

Dymaxion · 29/08/2023 19:46

I lost count of the number of patients who assured me their family would be able to do X,Y and Z for them once discharged home, but when you spoke to family members this wasn't something they would be able to manage due to work/family/distance. You had a patient telling you one thing, relatives being told something completely different by the patient and the relative stuck in the middle trying to figure out the truth.

mrsm43s · 29/08/2023 19:41

justtrees · 29/08/2023 19:29

All I know is what he told me and I took him at face value. He has no reason to lie but may not know the whole story. Regardless of why she is there , it was his partners attitude that astounded me.

His partner's attitude of not wanting to give up her job (and therefore likely endangering her finances and the roof over her head), her family life, her time with her children, her social life, her other commitments etc to become a full time unpaid carer? I think that's quite reasonable tbh.

If you are so very worried, perhaps you like to volunteer to be an unpaid carer for this person?

Do you have any idea whatsoever how utterly exhausting, difficult , life altering and soul destroying being a full time carer to an elderly parent is?

Iateallthechocolate · 29/08/2023 19:32

A lot of patients are entitled to 6 weeks rehab in a care home as a step down from hospital. My local hospital has bought a former care home for this purpose.
It frees up an acute bed on a ward and gives a bit more time to recover.

MargaretThursday · 29/08/2023 19:29

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 29/08/2023 18:21

If it required a care home stay rather than arranging carers to help at home then the care requirements would be to much for full time working adults. They may have been very aware of their own limitations. Besides the physio is probably a lot better than she would have got if discharged home.

Edited

This.

We've been through a situation where an elderly relative did exactly this. Was discharged home with broken leg, because all she needed was "a little bit of help", she also said her children would do it.
Became very quickly evident that her children popping in a couple of times a day (they lived 40 minutes away so an hour's visit took them over 2 hours) was draining them, plus they couldn't be there due to shift work at the times she really wanted them.
Ultimately she decided that she needed something and couldn't wait for the next time they were in, which was an hour or so later, and fell down the stairs and had to have a double hip replacement.
Not something you'd wish on anyone.

If she really was okay at home with the odd popping in and out, then the NHS would have provided a carer to come in for that rather than a home. If she's in a care home then she needs far more care than her children can reasonably provide.

justtrees · 29/08/2023 19:29

All I know is what he told me and I took him at face value. He has no reason to lie but may not know the whole story. Regardless of why she is there , it was his partners attitude that astounded me.

OP posts:
LadyMary50 · 29/08/2023 19:24

This doesn’t sound right at all.When my DM was 72(same age I am now).she was visiting my sister in Sheffield when she tripped on the pavement and fractured her hip.She was admitted to the General Hospital and had an operation to pin her hip.After spending a week in hospital she was ready for discharge but she decided she would rather be in her own home than stay longer with my sister so the hospital arranged a taxi to take her back home to Bedford.Age Uk delivered a walker with a tray so she could get around her flat.We did her food shopping but she refused all other help as she was very independent.She actually managed to do all her cooking and personal care.

C152 · 29/08/2023 19:24

I'm sorry, OP, but it really does sound like the mum's needs must be greater than you say. If she's an otherwise healthy 65 year old, lives alone, can manage on crutches and doesn't need help to care for herself, why can't she discharge herself and get a taxi home? (Obviously it would be nicer if family came to collect her and settle her back into her own home.)

And if she does need more help than you've suggested, as terrible as it is, I can understand her family's point of view. Perhaps they don't live near their mum? Drs and physio appointments aren't always close by or at convenient times. If they're all in full time employment, how do you expect them to drop everything each time she needs medicines collected or to be taken to the GP for a blood test or a check up or driven to wherever the physio is, wait for the session to finish and be driven home (and that's assuming it starts on time). It really isn't that simple being even an occasional carer. I'd reserve your judgement on this one.

Andthereyougo · 29/08/2023 19:21

OP is correct, if you can’t be discharged home then it’s small local hospital or care home. The level of care can be very low, my friend was told she could have a shower once a week as that was the only time they’d have a staff member to wheel her to the shower which was in another building. This was in England about 9 years ago, not a developing country !
I always invent a relative at home to care for me.
OP this lady can discharge herself, but depends on her house layout how she’ll toilet, wash , sleep etc…

Winter2020 · 29/08/2023 19:19

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:40

They admitted her and the hospital wouldn't discharge her without care in place. The family refused to care for her , leaving the hospital with no other option than sorting out a care home as there are no immediate carers available.
Am I being unclear. Genuine question?

Yes very unclear/contradictory

At the same time you are saying that this lady is independent on crutches and needs no help with personal care. You have inferred she has capacity - lives alone usually for example. You say she only needed a lift home from hospital and the odd lift to an appointment.

In the next breath you say the hospital won't discharge her without a care package. Suggesting she needs care unless your third hand information assessment of her health is better than the judgement of the hospital. And you also say that a competent, independent adult with capacity went to a care home where they are really upset because of no lift home - rather than ring a taxi. Unlikely.

It sounds infinitely more likely that this lady requires care and her children do not feel in a position to give it. They may work, have small children, have health issues themselves, live far away or for whatever reason not feel able to. And yes they feel that the NHS should care for their mum in this circumstance as our society isn't geared up to adults taking unknown amount of time off work and child raising for caring responsibilities.

My MIL broke her hip and went into catastrophic decline of health. It is ongoing 6 months later. My husband , myself and his siblings are in no position to offer full time care with jobs, children and for one sibling distance. Her husband is a carer 24/7 except the odd hour an adult child can give him respite. If the lady in your story were fine she would be home - she has been given a care home place because she requires care at the moment.

Washyourfaceinmysink · 29/08/2023 19:16

This doesn’t make sense to me. I think she must need more care than you’ve been led to believe. If someone doesn’t need full time care, I think they are usually sent home with a care package.
My aunt (89) has just had a knee operation - normally very mobile but not at the moment. She’s been discharged home and carers are visiting 4x daily to help make meals/personal care.

Stomacharmeleon · 29/08/2023 19:16

A piece of the jigsaw is missing...

AcclimDD · 29/08/2023 19:15

I think you've been given a version of events here OP that are about 50% true.

Clefable · 29/08/2023 19:14

Who is looking after the dog?!

Lonicerax · 29/08/2023 19:12

She could discharge herself, get a taxi home, eat something from the freezer until Tesco delivered.