Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled at how this woman is treated

134 replies

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:09

My best friend and I were chatting today. His partners mum has broken her leg after a nasty trip over her dog.
She was in hospital for a couple of days following a bone reset and cast and the staff rang to collect her to bring her home.
Her adult children refused point blank.

His partners attitude was that the government could pay for her care and rehabilitation and meals as that is what they paid taxes for.
Her mum is 65, fit and generally healthy and lives alone.
Her mum is devastated as she has now been moved to a care home miles away from anyone of her family . They visit her once a week and refuse discharge until she is 'perfect' again.
Their mum was a SAHM all her life and devoted her life to her kids. Their Dad is dead. She needs minimal care but physio three times per week. She is mobile on crutches and
Can self care.

They are all shift workers, one with no kids, the others with teens so I'm pretty sure they could have supported her in her own home and offered her lifts or organised taxis between them.

Now my best friend and I go back thirty years and know each other inside out and each others families and hell would freeze over before he would allow that for his own mum and mine for the matter !
He was embarrassed telling me , probably not helped by my face showing absolute disbelief.
It has made me think about my own children and what they would do.
His partner is ok, a bit of a cold fish but he loves her so that's what matters .
AIBU to be appalled or is this becoming the norm now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
saltinesandcoffeecups · 30/08/2023 17:04

I’m with the others that there is much more going on in this situation. Hell, 65 is still working age where I live. Unless it’s a significant injury requiring significant rehab you’re being discharged home (and back to work!) at that age.

Now sure they’re going to ask about the home situation, but as a 65 yo with sound mind if I say I can manage my tri-level house with spiral staircases and floors carpeted in marbles and banana peels, they may offer me services but at the end of the day they can’t stop me from discharging home.

tattygrl · 30/08/2023 11:47

"The government are paying of course"

I wonder if this isn't really the crux of your chagrin at this situation. It is of course only right that the government of a civilised country should step in and provide care to frail/vulnerable/unwell people when there are no alternatives. As has been highlighted by PPs, it's exceptionally unlikely that a care home stay was arranged for this lady without very definite need.

My gut feeling is that you're miffed at the concept of "the government paying" for something you personally deem unnecessary, while not being abreast of all the facts.

I'd stop worrying about this if I were you; you're definitely not seeing the full picture.

DameCurlyBassey · 30/08/2023 11:18

Perisoire · 29/08/2023 20:32

No, we’re all in full time jobs Confused

Mum is still mobile, so the care we’re providing is taking her to doctors appointments shopping, bringing medication, taking meals over, rubbing ointment, etc.

All of which can be managed in evenings and weekends and the odd day off.

With due respect I have a feeling that this woman needs much more than that so there is probably no real comparison. But it is very good that you have all done that. It will be very useful when the care needs increase and entail more than evening and weekend commitment.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/08/2023 09:40

I think the SAHM point is a total red herring. That was her choice/ hers and her late husbands. Not that of their children.

It does sound odd that she would be put in a care home when so little is needed, almost as though it can’t be right.

Generally speaking, you’d expect adults to be able to arrange a visiting shift between them but maybe they can’t make it work with the shift work.

Goldbar · 30/08/2023 09:35

DameCurlyBassey · 30/08/2023 08:38

@Goldbar so sorry. I quoted you by mistake.

No probs - I agree 😊. Nowadays with the pressures of life, very few family members are geared up to take on substantial caring responsibilities, even if they wanted to. Most people would do what they could but are often struggling themselves.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 30/08/2023 08:40

I wouldn't be surprised to find out that the DM has wider health problems that the family have been trying to get sorted for years and are now taking the opportunity to push for better support. I've had this situation with a friend where a group of us were supporting someone who was unwell who kept getting discharged then having a health crisis shortly after which we would have to drop everything to deal with and they would end up being readmitted. The friend was part of the problem and would tell the hospital they could stay with friends. At the last crisis I pretty much dumped them at A&E and we all told the friend we weren't going to help - they ended up in hospital for 6 weeks which got their health stabilised. It can be easier to set up formal ongoing post-discharge support services if you are in a healthcare setting.

It could be something as straightforward as the DM having osteoporosis (hence the break) and they are concerned that another fall in the home environment whilst unsteady could cause life changing harm.

DameCurlyBassey · 30/08/2023 08:38

@Goldbar so sorry. I quoted you by mistake.

DameCurlyBassey · 30/08/2023 08:28

Goldbar · 29/08/2023 18:34

Indeed. If it's such a straightforward case and she doesn't need care from her children, why can't she discharge herself?

You haven’t got the whole story and neither has your friend (after all it isn’t his mother) so I would reserve judgement. Are you sure that you aren’t jumping on this because you don’t really like his partner and are looking for yet another thing (I’m sure there are others) that proves that she’s a bit of a cold fish?

ExtraOnions · 30/08/2023 08:18

We are just going through the discharge process with mum, she’s 88 and has had a severe stroke.

There is no way a fit, 65 year old woman, who can self-mobilise has been sent, against her will, too a care home, for the duration it will take for her bone to heal.

Heronwatcher · 30/08/2023 08:14

Yes I agree also a backstory here which you probably don’t know about. Also I do think that hospital/ care services are terrible for seizing on any living relative for the elderly or ill and trying to make them take responsibility for serious amounts of care when actually this is not possible. Sometimes they just seem to want to tick a box to get the relative out of hospital without putting proper support in place. Not letting them discharge her into their care could be to stop this happening.

Flakey99 · 30/08/2023 08:03

YANBU

They sound like selfish pricks and I’m guessing that because the mum didn’t go back to work, they got used to her putting their needs above their own. Sadly, I’ve already seen this happen with a few of my friends adult children. I’m in my late 50’s.

When I was a young teen, my mum had to leave her job in order to care for her mum at our home. Granddad had died and Grandma had dementia and needed full time care. Sadly, both my parents died quite young, so I’ve never been in that position but I know I’d have done anything for my lovely mum.

I’m currently supporting a friend who has moved back home to look after his elderly (80’s) mum who has dementia. He’s had to change his job and go p/t 15hrs a week and work from home in order to care for her. His older brother doesn’t want anything to do with caring for her and has left it to Bob to sort out everything. Bob isn’t married but used to have a very full social life with many friends which has slowly diminished because he can’t leave her alone for very long. We’re currently exploring any respite options he can access as he’s getting very run down mentally and I worry about him.

ohotoframe · 30/08/2023 06:30

This also happened recently to someone I know. Adult children refused discharge for them to cate for their elderly father, but for different reasons - work commitments and travel distance to his home and they wouldn't take him into their home.
So in the end the hospital moved him to a care home.
Again, from what I know he didn't really have high level care needs but couldn't go back to his empty home.

Lonicerax · 30/08/2023 06:16

I suppose if she had an upstairs loo, steps to the front door , that hosp regs might say another person must be available.
And cos family busy she has to go to a care home.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 30/08/2023 01:27

VanGoghsDog · 30/08/2023 00:58

I don't have medical POA for my mum and she's been in and out of hospital since April (in currently) and they consulted me all along about her various discharges and moves. Both social services and the hospital occupational therapists called me several times.

She does have capacity , so I can't overrule her preferences of course. But they absolutely did ensure I knew what was going on and that I agreed it made sense.

There's no way I can look after her so she knew full well to tell them that.

Yes, exactly as I was saying. The hospital consults the family but, without a health and welfare POA, this family cannot make this sort of decision for their mother and cannot instruct the hospital about what has to be done. If their mother was genuinely distraught, she could have handled the situation and facilitated going home herself. It all smacks of conversations that have become distorted by several retellings, misunderstood snippets of "information" and a bit of "Well they said so and so I said so and so. I wasn't having any of it" also. I was full time carer for my mother for 10 years. The hospitals I dealt with have been unfailingly sympathetic and helpful but at the same time, they won't be bullied or manipulated or told what to do by family members. They don't have the time or the resources.

VanGoghsDog · 30/08/2023 00:58

Floatlikeafeather2 · 29/08/2023 21:01

Unless they have Power of Attorney for her (Health and Welfare), there is no way the hospital would have consulted the children, except perhaps as a courtesy or in the hope that they might step up. If the mother is in a care home (and I think it's more likely to be a rehabilitation ward rather than a care home, per se), it's because she has agreed to it. It doesn't make her family's behaviour any better but I really think you have only got half the story here. Do you think this is a tentative attempt by your friend to get your approval and support to begin the process of leaving his partner?

I don't have medical POA for my mum and she's been in and out of hospital since April (in currently) and they consulted me all along about her various discharges and moves. Both social services and the hospital occupational therapists called me several times.

She does have capacity , so I can't overrule her preferences of course. But they absolutely did ensure I knew what was going on and that I agreed it made sense.

There's no way I can look after her so she knew full well to tell them that.

minou123 · 29/08/2023 22:38

Longagonow96 · 29/08/2023 22:15

Yes, bound to be her fault.🙄MN misogyny and ageism strikes again.

My post is neither misogynistic nor ageist.

You only need apply a tiny bit of critical thinking to realise there could be a myriad of reasons why the adult children cant/won't care for thier mum.

The point is the Op doesn't know the full story, but has rushed to judgement.
Same as you.

Longagonow96 · 29/08/2023 22:15

minou123 · 29/08/2023 18:16

I wouldn't be so quick to judge.

It could be all the adult children are terrible, awful people, who won't look after their mum.

Or, it could be she was a awful mum. Maybe she treated her children terribly and this is the consequence.

You are appalled?- I think its likely you don't know the full story.

Yes, bound to be her fault.🙄MN misogyny and ageism strikes again.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 29/08/2023 21:01

Unless they have Power of Attorney for her (Health and Welfare), there is no way the hospital would have consulted the children, except perhaps as a courtesy or in the hope that they might step up. If the mother is in a care home (and I think it's more likely to be a rehabilitation ward rather than a care home, per se), it's because she has agreed to it. It doesn't make her family's behaviour any better but I really think you have only got half the story here. Do you think this is a tentative attempt by your friend to get your approval and support to begin the process of leaving his partner?

FictionalCharacter · 29/08/2023 20:54

Rachie1973 · 29/08/2023 20:44

She can discharge herself. She doesn’t have to be allowed out like a child.

The OP isn’t explaining why the hospital asked the adult children’s permission to discharge a competent 65 year old, but just keeps saying “well that’s what my friend said”. The story doesn’t add up. The friend has misunderstood or is leaving out a lot of detail. It’s possible the mother agreed to the rehab/care home, someone made a comment about the cost and the friend’s partner said “well I can’t go there to look after her, and besides our taxes are paying for this” or something similar.

Perisoire · 29/08/2023 20:53

Dymaxion · 29/08/2023 20:42

@Perisoire so you and your siblings who all work fulltime jobs are going to share moving in with your Mum to enable her to come home and you hope that her surgery goes well and she recovers quickly, and if it doesn't ? how long can you maintain that situation for ? Thats an honest question by the way, because when it comes to these sort of situations I always look at the worse case scenario as opposed to the best, because the reality is often somewhere inbetween.

We’ll have to see how things go. We work locally so it’s easy enough going to work from mum’s.

Mum loves her house, and would hate a care home, so the plan is to keep her home as much as possible, or she move in with one sibling if really needed. Who knows what the future holds, I hope she doesn’t develop an illness that requires her to move into a care home but anything’s possible.

As I said, the situation described by OP seems harsh because we don’t know the adult children’s challenges. But within our current set up, the care that is needed, as described by OP, would not be a problem.

Rachie1973 · 29/08/2023 20:49

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:40

They admitted her and the hospital wouldn't discharge her without care in place. The family refused to care for her , leaving the hospital with no other option than sorting out a care home as there are no immediate carers available.
Am I being unclear. Genuine question?

No. You’re completely clear, however you’re also completely wrong.

unless she lacks capacity she doesn’t need ‘permission’ to be discharged.

They can want care in place but cannot demand it.

Rachie1973 · 29/08/2023 20:47

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:36

She can't discharged herself because she doesn't have anyone to help her .. at all.. with anything. She needs physio, appointments presumably, a little help here and there by the sounds of it but they're not in any way involved in her care. His partner thinks the government should provide all of this because she knows they won't throw her out onto the street with no care package available or support system.

Of course she can! She gets up and leaves. No one can stop her.

Rachie1973 · 29/08/2023 20:46

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:34

I expect she needs transport to physio and appointments but has these raised these children so will not be able to go.
The government are paying of course.

Still wouldn’t stop her discharging herself with some leaflets about community transport options etc

Rachie1973 · 29/08/2023 20:44

justtrees · 29/08/2023 18:29

There really is no more to this .
NOK refused discharge. Hospital needed bed. Care home was only option. That's it .
No one would mind her.

She can discharge herself. She doesn’t have to be allowed out like a child.

Dymaxion · 29/08/2023 20:42

@Perisoire so you and your siblings who all work fulltime jobs are going to share moving in with your Mum to enable her to come home and you hope that her surgery goes well and she recovers quickly, and if it doesn't ? how long can you maintain that situation for ? Thats an honest question by the way, because when it comes to these sort of situations I always look at the worse case scenario as opposed to the best, because the reality is often somewhere inbetween.