Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL babywearing

211 replies

Carrotcake93 · 29/08/2023 16:28

MIL is coming tomorrow to pick up my DD (11 weeks) to her home to spend the day with her. It's the first time I will leave her with someone other than DP.

From the beginning I made it clear to MIL that as long as DD was a baby she wouldn't stay with anyone else, and she respected that. A few days ago she offered to take care of DD and hinted that my DP and I need a little rest and quality time for ourselves. She was right tbf, and precisely because she has kept her distance is what convinced me. I told her that she could have DD all day at her house but no sleeping there for now. Well, on the same day she decided to buy a crib, which I can understand, since it's better for DD to nap there than in a bed. But today she has also texted me saying that she has bought a baby carrier, without asking me if I agree to her using it. All this after telling me today to don't worry about express milk, that she has a bottle of formula at home when she knows that I exclusively BF. I have spoken to DP who agrees with me and will speak to her first. But I need you to tell me if AIBU, since my FTM brain won't let me think straight.

OP posts:
Romiley · 29/08/2023 22:14

It takes a village to raise a child. Would you react this way if it was your mum? Assuming you have/had a loving mother.

Obviously, with the BF, one can be put right. Your MIL might have assumed.ed that you bottle feed when the child is not with mum. In which case, just clarify. There is no need to turn a small thing into WW 3. She is your partner's mother and deserves the same respect you would give your own mum.

pictoosh · 29/08/2023 22:14

I am left wondering if I'm some sort of sociopath because I didn't worry about any of this stuff when mine were wee babies. I didn't think a whole day was far too long or worry about grandparents not being able to fall safely while wearing a carrier...ha ha. I was glad of a few hours of peace granted by people who were willing and more than capable of looking after a baby. I must be weird.

Eta: I will take the ensuing 'good for you' posts in good humour. It was good for me. Lovely as it goes.

Crossstich · 29/08/2023 22:12

The sling makes perfect sense they are wonderful things. That is if she has a good one and she uses it properly.
But not the formula.
To be honest I think a full day is much too long for a breast fed baby to be away from its mother. And it will be uncomfortable for you. A couple of hours at most.
Can you suggest just a morning or afternoon and send expressed milk telling her not to feed her formula.

supersonicginandtonic · 29/08/2023 22:10

11 weeks is not far too young for you to leave your baby, if you are ready. My mum had my children over night by that age. It was a welcome break and gave me time to recharge. If you aren't ready then just be honest with her.

Oioicaptain · 29/08/2023 22:05

I can understand your reservations, Inc with the baby carrier. It somehow seems somewhat intimate for another woman to be holding your baby for prolonged periods next to her chest. It would bother me less if it was for the occasional walk outside, but more if it was for a sling inside/attachment style parenting. If the latter, I can understand how that could feel too much for you. She also seems rather full on, which can make it hard for you to feel in control of your own baby when someone comes on a bit too strong/overly enthusiastic. My mil was like this with my baby. She would hold him all the time, turn her back to me and walk out of the room with him, change his nappy and bath him/pick him up when he was sleeping. This was when he was around 2 weeks old and she was visiting. She bought herself baby items (a new pram, cot, etc). It just felt as though she was muscling in and taking over my baby. It's a very hard situation when they are so young and when in laws can get a bit excited/enthusiastic or pushy. Unlike your own parents though, you can't tell them to readily to back off. It is tough though, but she sounds very excited. A whole day is a lot though, so perhaps a couple of half days would work better at the start?

Peanutbutter11 · 29/08/2023 22:05

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns, so we've agreed to take this down now.

EandKDJ · 29/08/2023 22:02

Some of the comments on here are ridiculous. The baby is literally going to spend a day with a loving grandparent who has bought things.. crib/carrier to make the experience easier for her and make the baby more comfortable. The OP could simply ask the MIL to give the expressed milk. I doubt very much that the MIL has a secret Vendetta to sabotage her breast feeding journey with formula, it was probably just an oversight of the MIL.

I am also a FTM to an 11 week old baby girl, and would trust my parents 100% to care for my daughter. My daughter is now formula fed but was fed expressed milk until she was 8 weeks old, I supplied my parents with the milk and they gave it.. no problem.

The carrier situation is absurd. I have a carrier for my daughter, my parents have used it to carry her as does my DP. I have also carried my niece and nephews in a sling. Never once has it occurred to me to be afraid of something as innocuous as a baby sling and the poster who suggested that using a sling to carry another person's child is too "intimate" is frankly bonkers.

To sum up, OP you're either ready to let another person care for your child or you're not. But I think it's inappropriate to suggest your MIL is doing something wrong here. She sounds like a nice lady who wants to spend time caring for her grandchild not a villain set to sabotage you.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/08/2023 21:59

Carrotcake93 · 29/08/2023 21:52

I love how easy it is on Mumsnet to twist a comment. If DP would like to use the baby carrier I would never object, but he prefers the stroller since adjusting it to size can be very annoying for both of us. And my fear for someone else using the carrier isn't just based on falling, I'm also worried about poor posture or suffocation. In any case, I will not oppose if the situation arises that DP wants to carry DD😂

Now you're worried about the size of your MIL's breasts?

Come on now.

Hufflepods · 29/08/2023 21:56

And my fear for someone else using the carrier isn't just based on falling, I'm also worried about poor posture or suffocation.

That isn’t making you sound any more rational.

Hibiscrubbed · 29/08/2023 21:52

Sorry, why is she going there at 11 weeks old? So this woman can play mummies again? I’d cancel. She’s going to do her own thing and you’ll probably find that immensely stressful.

Carrotcake93 · 29/08/2023 21:52

I love how easy it is on Mumsnet to twist a comment. If DP would like to use the baby carrier I would never object, but he prefers the stroller since adjusting it to size can be very annoying for both of us. And my fear for someone else using the carrier isn't just based on falling, I'm also worried about poor posture or suffocation. In any case, I will not oppose if the situation arises that DP wants to carry DD😂

OP posts:
Mamai90 · 29/08/2023 21:50

Toddlerteaplease · 29/08/2023 20:43

@TheBarbieEffect since her mum is not a Mumsnetter and therefore a fairly chilled out parent I don't think she cared two hoots. She was a very difficult baby and mum is a single mum. She was glad of the break!

Some people get absolutely batshit over their babies!

Waffle19 · 29/08/2023 21:41

Mamai90 · 29/08/2023 21:28

Who doesn't put their arms out when they fall?

Anyone over the age of 48 according to the OP

Waffle19 · 29/08/2023 21:40

Completely get the formula thing but she was probably just trying to help, just explain to her about breastfeeding.

The crib sounds sensible to me, I’ve always found it helpful that my in laws have their own Moses basket, travel cot, pushchair etc.

I think YABU over the baby wearing though. I think it’s absolutely lovely your MIL wants to do this. By all means check the fit, brand and positioning and explain to her about TICKS, but don’t take that opportunity away from her. I think you’re absolutely bonkers to not let your DH have the baby in the carrier, that’s unfair to both him and baby.

FoodFann · 29/08/2023 21:37

My 8 month old isn’t leaving my sight. Let alone an 11 week old! Bloody crib and formula, she needs to get a grip, it’s not her baby!

Mamai90 · 29/08/2023 21:36

Dropthedonkey · 29/08/2023 18:03

At 48 I had a 6 year old. I hope I wasn't in imminent danger of falling over.

I laughed at that too, I'm 41 and pregnant, I best not stumble incase my ancient arms aren't quick enough to break my fall! 😂

AxolotlEars · 29/08/2023 21:35

The formula thing is weird. If you don't want a day off from your baby then don't take her. I couldn't get my knickers in a knot about a carrier maybe because I have carried other people's babies and children in my slings. Even if it wasn't one you thought was the absolute best, realistically your baby wouldn't be in it that long.

Bellyblueboy · 29/08/2023 21:29

Too much too soon.

cut it down to a few hours and be clear no formula.

Mamai90 · 29/08/2023 21:28

WongWifi · 29/08/2023 16:55

I know modern mums are enthusiastic baby wearers. However, I come from another time where a pram or stroller is more than adequate as I see the potential dangers in baby carriers. The number one problem is falls. I’m assuming your MIL is over 50? Your sense of balance changes as you are and I wouldn’t trust anyone to carry my baby like that. Think if the weight of an adult female falling on top of your baby. Just no way I’d allow it.

Who doesn't put their arms out when they fall?

Trenchfootinthescottishhighlandstoday · 29/08/2023 21:24

You don't trust mil to hold or feed your dc appropriately so dc stays with you. Not trusting your dh to use a carrier is quite worrying...

Icantthinkofausername123 · 29/08/2023 21:22

I haven't read all the messages so there might be further info but I actually think this is really sweet and a grandmother trying to show she's trying to make your baby and you as comfortable as possible. She has somewhere for the baby to sleep properly and has the carrier as a resource to try and comfort them so I couldn't get worked up over them. I wouldn't have been comfortable with the formula for my babies but it might just be misguided as a way to help. She has been respectful up to now so it might just be a calm and kind conversation with her to explain your thoughts on it?

Ýsette · 29/08/2023 21:18

Carrotcake93 · 29/08/2023 19:06

Why are you angry? I never discriminated based on age.

What worries me is someone else using a baby carrier with my baby there.
As my Dd's mum, I'm more adapted to my baby and I feel that if one day I fall to the ground my mommy reflexes will know how to make me fall in a safe way for the baby. I don't even want DP to wear baby carriers ffs

To be fair, I once fell over with a bottle of wine. Needless to say, the bottle didn't touch the pavement 😂

Absolutelynotfor2019 · 29/08/2023 21:10

My three full functioning adults were left overnight with their grandparents at 7,6,9 weeks. They survived,we had enjoyable nights out and weirdly they are absolutely fine ! I would suggest that the baby has normal milk from Mum . Hopefully you can express.

Ottersmith · 29/08/2023 21:02

11 weeks is way too young to be away that long. Everyone needs a break together from their baby but they don't get it because they are needed to look after their child. A carrier is a good thing as the baby will need some comfort. Letting her even contemplate formula when you are ebf is fucked and would be a deal breaker.

SuspiciousLampshade · 29/08/2023 21:01

Dragonwindow · 29/08/2023 20:48

Of course the OP is going to be safer using a carrier than her MIL because she'll be on much higher alert, checking baby's breathing more regularly, spotting small differences in breathing, making sure hips are carefully positioned etc etc.
She's more likely to have researched safe carrying in more detail.

Hence my qualifier of baby being positioned safely. Also see OPs post where she states MIL used carriers with her own kids. And where she states she won’t let her partner babywear because he won’t have the right reflexes. Nothing to do with being more alert.

My DH has worn both our kids and I’ve never been worried about him not being alert and aware of changes in our little ones breathing etc. Unless there’s a real reason to suspect MIL would just sling her DGC in there without a care in the world I don’t agree with your reasoning

Swipe left for the next trending thread