Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to buy FIL a birthday gift?

60 replies

sugaraddict02 · 29/08/2023 13:37

So it’s my FIL’s birthday next month and he will be turning 88.

I have made it clear to my husband that I will not be buying him a birthday gift/ card or contributing towards / attending FIL’s birthday dinner.

It may sound petty but on my birthday earlier on in the year FIL never got me a birthday card/ present.

I dont see the point in wasting money on a birthday present for someone I am not particularly close too just to keep DH happy.

OP posts:
Lelliekellie · 30/08/2023 08:54

As a general rule my DH & I sort our own families out. So he buys his for bdays, christmas and occasions. And I buy for mine. Works well x

honeyandfizz · 30/08/2023 08:36

Somanycats · 29/08/2023 14:39

Honestly, you sound like you hate your dh and fil is collateral damage. You should probably divorce DH.

Bit of a leap there!!

All sounds like a lot of hard work in the family, what is wrong with joint presents? Stop going along with this nonsense.

abs12 · 30/08/2023 08:31

This is so petty. That's nothing compared what I've seen. Be the better person, put your big girl pants on, get him a present, and go to dinner. Do it for DH, if not yourself.

MeridaBrave · 30/08/2023 08:28

Just don’t overthink. Leave to your DH to sort out and sign from you both. I have a perfectly good relationship with MIL but DH still signs card and gets present.

AliceOlive · 30/08/2023 08:08

The man sounds abusive. Not sure why he would expect a card or acknowledgment on his birthday from you after saying such terrible things.

larlypops · 30/08/2023 08:01

Now I’ve read it all I wouldn’t bother

Lengokengo · 30/08/2023 07:59

We also do separate presents. There is one of my in laws that I don’t particularly like ( I don’t dislike either, it’s more complete indifference). He doesn’t buy me presents and his wife always gives me something home made (ie costs very little) but extravagantly wrapped. This couple are praised by older generation as being so lovely and generous ( which they are not, but are golden child). If I didn’t get either of them an individual present, it would feed into the narrative of me being stingy (which I am not, but I am scapegoat.)

it used to wind me up enormously until I developed the game of giving them both as cheap or regifted a present as possible, no more than 3 pounds each and bonus marks if they will dislike it/ get no use for it. DH and I get much enjoyment doing this. It also makes receiving crap gifts a joy, as I can then regift. It’s simple fun and takes back control.

larlypops · 30/08/2023 07:59

My nan is 92, sometimes we get a card, sometimes a letter and money and sometimes nothing.
I know I’m loved and appreciated either way.
Ive always done a joint gift so can’t help with that but seems a bit odd not doing it from the household

WandaWonder · 30/08/2023 07:54

For not wanting to do something you are putting a hell of a lot of thought into it

Inertia · 30/08/2023 07:48

Time to knock the separate presents on the head. Surely each couple/ family can start buying a joint present? And why do you have to buy for your in-laws but your H doesn’t buy individual gifts for your family?

Anyway, since FIL has very pointedly not bought for you and has been nasty, I wouldn’t buy separately for him .

Mummyof32023 · 30/08/2023 07:30

Wow have you heard two wrongs don't make a right? You've just brought yourself down to his level and this feels like revenge. It's your in laws and your husbands dad at the end of the day.

deveronvalley · 29/08/2023 14:45

It's all really complicated. You all buying each other separate gifts and cards I mean. I think that's quite unusual!

Brefugee · 29/08/2023 14:41

Somanycats · 29/08/2023 14:39

Honestly, you sound like you hate your dh and fil is collateral damage. You should probably divorce DH.

nope the FIL is a knob.
The whole 2 presents thing is weird - but if your DH hadn't got OPs father something for father's day, why should she get something for his father? it's odd.

Just tell your DH that from now on he is responsible for all his side of the family, and to butt out if you say you're not going to the dinner (I'd go though, sounds like you and your MIL get on ok?)

sugaraddict02 · 29/08/2023 14:39

EmilyDickinson · 29/08/2023 14:28

I’m very confused. In our house my DH sorts out cards and gifts for his side of the family and I do mine. All cards and gifts are signed as being from both of us plus our children. It is DH’s responsibility to sort out gifts for his father from both of you. I wouldn’t be bothered whether I got a gift or not from my FIL to be honest, though I’m also curious as to whether that means you didn’t get one just from him or you didn’t get a joint gift from him and MIL. If things are tense between you right now then skip the dinner but give some kind of excuse (illness, prior commitment) to try and ensure that you don’t offend them unnecessarily

Yeah in the family we just buy presents separately.

My birthday present from MIL was not a joint present with FIL it was signed just from her.

I am expected to buy birthday/ Xmas presents for DH’s family.

I have told DH that from now I wont be buying his family birthday/ Christmas presents as it costs me a lot of money to buy presents for his family as well as my own family.

OP posts:
Somanycats · 29/08/2023 14:39

Honestly, you sound like you hate your dh and fil is collateral damage. You should probably divorce DH.

LookItsMeAgain · 29/08/2023 14:38

You're not being unreasonable.

You need to tell your DH that you're not responsible for any injury caused to MiL. To have this being held over you is awful.

I'd be making very clear to my DH, that any gifts/cards etc. for his side of the family were now 100% up to him to sort out. He can decide whether these will be from both of you or just him going forwards.

I'd also be making it very clear to FiL & MiL that any care they require going forwards would be entirely at the whim of their son, seeing as how they were so generous when you needed emotional support and you were carrying out chores for them.

Brefugee · 29/08/2023 14:37

sugaraddict02 · 29/08/2023 13:52

No FIL still has his wife, they are both very active and fit for their age.

There was an issue on Father’s Day when I didnt buy FIL a Father’s Day gift/ card which caused tension.

I already have my own father and FIL defo does not treat me like a daughter.

We have had issues in the past with FIL’s nasty temper and I keep my distance.

As I dont particularly like FIL I dont think it would be appropriate to attend a birthday meal for him.

fair enough! just keep saying to your DH "you do your side of the family, i'll do mine" and just that.

Lilolilibet · 29/08/2023 14:33

Everyone's expectations sound too high. Your DH should buy a gift nominally from you both on Christmas. Your mil can buy something from both of them. You shouldn't be involved in Father's Day for him because he's not your father.

EmilyDickinson · 29/08/2023 14:28

I’m very confused. In our house my DH sorts out cards and gifts for his side of the family and I do mine. All cards and gifts are signed as being from both of us plus our children. It is DH’s responsibility to sort out gifts for his father from both of you. I wouldn’t be bothered whether I got a gift or not from my FIL to be honest, though I’m also curious as to whether that means you didn’t get one just from him or you didn’t get a joint gift from him and MIL. If things are tense between you right now then skip the dinner but give some kind of excuse (illness, prior commitment) to try and ensure that you don’t offend them unnecessarily

Beautiful3 · 29/08/2023 14:25

I read your updates. In that case I'd ask husband to be in charge of his family's birthday/Xmas gifts. This is what I do too. I do my side and he does his. This changed when his side stopped sending me birthday cards, so I left it to husband to deal with. Don't see why I should be in charge of all birthdays because I have a vagina.

sugaraddict02 · 29/08/2023 14:23

DelphiniumBlue · 29/08/2023 14:14

He doesn't sound very nice, but I'm not very clear about the Fathers Day thing. Dh said he would have got him a card... does that mean he thought you were going to get a joint one so he didn't bother, or did he mean that in your shoes, he would have got his FiL a separate card & present?
I'd have thought he'd just add your name onto the card that he was buying, most couples wouldn't send a card from each of them. If he thinks you should send a separate one, that's quite unusual, and why would you? He's not your father.
And the same applies for birthdays, surely he would just add your name on to whatever he buys?
As for FiL not getting anything for your birthday, that's old men for you. Sometimes their wife enables them, or sometimes they just don't do birthdays ( for other people). Sexist? Yes. Did MiL get something for you?
As for the upcoming birthday, let DH deal with it. If you don't want to go to the party, don't go, but be aware that they will read all sorts of insults into that decision. Is it worth causing an issue? Will it upset DH, and do you care about that?

In the family we always buy separate presents for the recipient.

MIL did get me a birthday present which was from her only.
Usually FIL would get me a separate gift.

DH got FIL a Father’s Day gift and card was signed only from him.

DH was expecting me to get FIL something and said “ Well I would of got him something” meaning I should of got him a separate gift.

But again he is not my father and I defo dont see him in a fatherly role.

In the past DH has forced me to go to these type of things and it really has been for his benefit.

But I am at the point where I need to do what is best for me and stop being a people pleaser.

OP posts:
pikkumyy77 · 29/08/2023 14:22

I think you are not unreasonable at all. Just tell DH you are done. He handles everything with his father. If you are so awful they shouldn’t want anything from you anyway.

Chowtime · 29/08/2023 14:18

We used to get on until he exploded at me during lockdown for wrongly accusing me of asking MIL to carry some rubbish down which resulted in MIL doing her back in.

FIL called me lazy and told DH he was better of being alone, all this was completely unprovoked and he made me cry.

During this I had a very sick relative and I was doing all my inlaws chores and received no emotional support from my inlaws hence why now I keep my distance from FIL.

Ah. In that case - fuck him. Let your DH get on with it and do whatever he wants to do.

DelphiniumBlue · 29/08/2023 14:14

He doesn't sound very nice, but I'm not very clear about the Fathers Day thing. Dh said he would have got him a card... does that mean he thought you were going to get a joint one so he didn't bother, or did he mean that in your shoes, he would have got his FiL a separate card & present?
I'd have thought he'd just add your name onto the card that he was buying, most couples wouldn't send a card from each of them. If he thinks you should send a separate one, that's quite unusual, and why would you? He's not your father.
And the same applies for birthdays, surely he would just add your name on to whatever he buys?
As for FiL not getting anything for your birthday, that's old men for you. Sometimes their wife enables them, or sometimes they just don't do birthdays ( for other people). Sexist? Yes. Did MiL get something for you?
As for the upcoming birthday, let DH deal with it. If you don't want to go to the party, don't go, but be aware that they will read all sorts of insults into that decision. Is it worth causing an issue? Will it upset DH, and do you care about that?

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 29/08/2023 14:12

In that case YANBU. I wouldn't bother either