Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to buy FIL a birthday gift?

60 replies

sugaraddict02 · 29/08/2023 13:37

So it’s my FIL’s birthday next month and he will be turning 88.

I have made it clear to my husband that I will not be buying him a birthday gift/ card or contributing towards / attending FIL’s birthday dinner.

It may sound petty but on my birthday earlier on in the year FIL never got me a birthday card/ present.

I dont see the point in wasting money on a birthday present for someone I am not particularly close too just to keep DH happy.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Echobelly · 20/09/2023 11:51

That you certainly don't have to get him a present, but tbh, not because he didn't get you you. He is your husband's father, he can organise a gift for him.

I have stopped reminding dh of family birthdays and buying his side presents - nb, he has adhd and isn't great with this stuff, he never expected me to do this, I did it voluntarily, but then decided it was just another bit of mental load I didn't need so I stopped. MIL, however expects people to be offended if you don't remember everyone's birthdays including all your in laws etc, but have decided that is also not my problem.

caringcarer · 20/09/2023 11:38

It all sounds very odd to me. My DH buys a Mother's Day card and writes it from both of us. Before FiL died he did it for him too. Both my parents are dead now so I don't buy Mother's day or Father's Day cards anymore. Why doesn't your DH buy his parents cards, and include your name too? That would be normal. In your case your FiL is 88 so I'd just attend a meal if you've been invited. He might not have many birthdays left. You don't want your DH memory of what might be his last birthday of you refusing to attend.

dcsp · 20/09/2023 11:23

What do you mean about the father's day gift?
1 - your DH didn't buy him a gift, and you FIL sees that as your responsibility
2 - your FIL expects an father's day gift from you

If it's 1, then you DH needs to make clear to your FIL that it was down to him, and that the FIL needs to stop giving you grief about that - or anything else.

If it's 2, then that's not a thing! Father's Day (and Mother's day) gifts are given by children, not children-in-law.

Throwncrumbs · 20/09/2023 11:13

I stopped buying in laws presents and cards years ago, they get nothing now because their son buys them nothing!

NynaeveSedaiOfTheYellowAjah · 20/09/2023 11:07

YABU not to go to the dinner, but YANBU not to buy separate gifts! That's super weird and unnecessary.

Loubelle70 · 20/09/2023 11:04

My ex...i bought his mum n dad gifts on behalf of us, in hindsight and if i was to find another OH they can buy their own family. Yet again all on the woman. His mum and dad were vile though...i bought them really thoughtful presents, but they never said thankyou. I bought them a portable slow cooker they wanted for caravan, they didn't stop going on about it and said they were going yo buy one in the sales...I bought the one they said they wanted £49.99 for them for xmas.. but when opened it said to my ex (their son)... did she get it? we can return it right? They were horrible in many ways. If their son had bought chosen it theyd have been over the moon. Really codependent family who didn't want outsiders unless approved by them (complicit...complying). Let their son buy the present OP.

LovelaceBiggWither · 20/09/2023 11:03

What? The DH forgets Father's Day so she should have got one?

RTFT there's more to it than that.

VeraMay · 20/09/2023 10:51

At the end of the day, DH would have known Father's Day was coming up, but obviously forgot, so it's your fault for not organising a card. Been there, got the t-shirt.
You didn't get anything for your Birthday in retaliation. You can be the bigger person and attend the party, but insist that DH organises a card and gift.

The only thing I will say is, you will be damned if you do and damned if you don't, regarding attending the party and the card/gift situation.
In-laws can be fabulous, as my parents were towards all their sil/dil's, or awful like my in-laws were, even their daughter went to great lengths to avoid them....

SezFrankly · 03/09/2023 07:58

I originally posted YABU, turn read the posts and changed my mind. It’s weird to get individual gifts, and if hubby wants you to buy his parents then he should buy yours - irrespective of whether ppl get on or not.

Sounds like you’ve had enough of their petty and rude behaviour, you do you 👏

Manthide · 30/08/2023 20:55

I originally thought you were being unreasonable but your fil does seem like a piece of work. Of course if your family adopted the normal card/present practices ie one card/ present from one family then there would be no issue except you not going to the birthday meal. I would probably still go as he is still dh's father and dc's grandfather - my late fil was not the nicest individual but we just politely ignored each other for the most part.

Hibiscrubbed · 30/08/2023 17:35

I have more or less cut contact after FIL pushed me a few weeks ago and caused me to fall.

With everything you’ve said, and this, he sounds like a horrible cunt. Cut the lot of them off. Including your husband…

TomatoSandwiches · 30/08/2023 16:56

sugaraddict02 · 30/08/2023 11:33

I think a lot of my bitterness stems from the fact that I have done so much to help in laws in the past and they have never been grateful, thankful or appreciative.

FIL is quite a nasty man and constantly makes sarcastic remarks.

I have more or less cut contact after FIL pushed me a few weeks ago and caused me to fall.
It was intended as a joke but it really upset me.

I never get any support of DH in regards to the issues with his parents.

He will always make excuses for them and tries to make me feel guilty, hence this post.

Moving forward I have told DH I wont be buying anymore Christmas/ birthday presents for in laws or helping them ( they have their own children to help them ).

I don't blame you, why do you you have to buy for his family but your DH does fuck all for yours?
No, he can deal with his side and you with yours, next time I'd be visiting is at FILs funeral, what a nasty old man.

Newestname002 · 30/08/2023 16:47

@sugaraddict02

Moving forward I have told DH I wont be buying anymore Christmas/ birthday presents for in laws or helping them ( they have their own children to help them ).

Good decision. Be on your guard for when you get digs from your In-laws (block their numbers and on your social media) and, worse, emotional blackmail from your husband. Stand your ground. No need to argue - just state your case briefly ("I've already told you I won't be doing that") then be as boringly grey rock and vague as you can. 🌹

GlomOfNit · 30/08/2023 12:53

sugaraddict02 · 29/08/2023 14:23

In the family we always buy separate presents for the recipient.

MIL did get me a birthday present which was from her only.
Usually FIL would get me a separate gift.

DH got FIL a Father’s Day gift and card was signed only from him.

DH was expecting me to get FIL something and said “ Well I would of got him something” meaning I should of got him a separate gift.

But again he is not my father and I defo dont see him in a fatherly role.

In the past DH has forced me to go to these type of things and it really has been for his benefit.

But I am at the point where I need to do what is best for me and stop being a people pleaser.

Anyone else shaking their head in bemusement at this scenario? Who on earth does things like this?! 😂 Grown adults. You surely give a present for birthdays from both partners to your dad or father in law?? Unless there's a special reason for being the appropriate person for a particular gift, like an in-joke or something. I certainly assume that the presents my husband gets for his parents at Christmas and birthdays are from both of us (or rather, from us and our children). But they're his parents so he thinks what to get, gets it and unless he's pressed for time, wraps and posts them if necessary.

But that's birthdays. Father's Day (which is made up anyway 😂) is for that man's offspring (and if you feel thus moved, maybe the grandchildren) to give a gift. My own PIL would really be taken aback if I sent them a separate card, just from me, on Mothering Sunday/Father's Day.

That aside, OP's FIL sounds petty and unpleasant and shouldn't be expecting all this scraping and bowing.

Good god, other people are strange sometimes. 😆

Mummyoflittledragon · 30/08/2023 12:11

Your fil pushed you over / into something? Did he apologise? I think you’ve got bigger issues than just your fil. Your dh should be supporting you after that.

WaltzingWaters · 30/08/2023 11:52

The buying separate presents and cards is very odd. We always just sign them from us both/all. Maybe a separate one from kids if they make their own.
Why not start doing that. Joint cards and presents.

Pineapples198 · 30/08/2023 11:46

This all seems a bit odd to me. I have never bought my in laws a separate card or present for anything. My husband buys a present for his dad and brothers and puts both our names on it. I buy presents for my parents, brother and sister in law, mother in law and sister in law on his side and we both put our names on it. Why on Earth would you need to be a separate gift?
ask your husband to just put “from husband names and wife’s name” on the card and present. Sorted.

this “he didn’t buy me a present so I’m not going to buy him one” thing seems a bit petty. My in laws completely forgot my birthday one year. I noticed but didn’t make an issue. I know they didn’t do it on purpose.

sugaraddict02 · 30/08/2023 11:33

I think a lot of my bitterness stems from the fact that I have done so much to help in laws in the past and they have never been grateful, thankful or appreciative.

FIL is quite a nasty man and constantly makes sarcastic remarks.

I have more or less cut contact after FIL pushed me a few weeks ago and caused me to fall.
It was intended as a joke but it really upset me.

I never get any support of DH in regards to the issues with his parents.

He will always make excuses for them and tries to make me feel guilty, hence this post.

Moving forward I have told DH I wont be buying anymore Christmas/ birthday presents for in laws or helping them ( they have their own children to help them ).

OP posts:
zizza · 30/08/2023 10:49

This is bonkers. People do overcomplicated life sometimes. IMHO when you're married you give joint presents organised by the relevant person for their side of the family. If you have joint finances you might just want to discuss how much to spend but otherwise it works fine surely

Mrsjayy · 30/08/2023 10:37

sugaraddict02 · 29/08/2023 13:37

So it’s my FIL’s birthday next month and he will be turning 88.

I have made it clear to my husband that I will not be buying him a birthday gift/ card or contributing towards / attending FIL’s birthday dinner.

It may sound petty but on my birthday earlier on in the year FIL never got me a birthday card/ present.

I dont see the point in wasting money on a birthday present for someone I am not particularly close too just to keep DH happy.

Oh I dunno its your husbands dad surely you could at least go to the dinner let your husband sort out a card .

Humidititties · 30/08/2023 10:35

Mummyof32023 · 30/08/2023 07:30

Wow have you heard two wrongs don't make a right? You've just brought yourself down to his level and this feels like revenge. It's your in laws and your husbands dad at the end of the day.

Wow, did you read any of OPs posts?

Star0Fire · 30/08/2023 10:29

Never heard of couples buying separate presents like that before, seems madness to me, why can't DH just write your name on his card this time

Walker1178 · 30/08/2023 10:28

My first thought was that you shouldn’t give to receive and you were being petty but looking further down the chain it appears to be just a tiny part of a bigger issue.

I wouldn’t buy a gift or attend a party for someone that I genuinely don’t like or get along with so no I don’t think you are being unreasonable

cameldigits · 30/08/2023 10:21

Christ! What a faff... all the individual present giving. Totally unnecessary

Especially the Fathers Day thing. Why on earth would you buy FIL a card for FD? That's the role of his off spring. Not your

cameldigits · 30/08/2023 10:16

It's up to your husband but adults buying gifts for each other is a silly waste of stuff IMO

Just a card is sufficient and a visit but that's not your responsibility