Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think academic success truly does not matter

457 replies

Hotstuff18 · 29/08/2023 12:05

Firstly, this isn’t sour grapes. I went to a very prestigious RG university and was always the annoying girl with my hand up at school (ah misspent youth 😂). However, in almost all the adults I know now their academic outcomes have had literally no bearing on their lives now in their late 30’s and early 40’s. In my own life, my A’s at A level count for absolutely nothing when my part time teacher salary is absolutely dwarfed by my non academic DH’s who spent most of his time at school messing around and smoking behind the bike sheds. At work, a lot of my colleagues didn’t do that well in their own exams and now do the exact same job as me. Many friends who work in trade jobs having left school at 16 earn very impressive salaries meanwhile others with top grades in their exams earn low money. One particular example that always sticks out to me is a lady who lives down the street, who’s also a teacher, absolutely bombed her exams as she spent the whole time partying (whilst I spent most of year 13 diligently writing up notes and doing practice essays) and yet we ended up living on the same street doing the exact same job. I’m not bitter about this at all, I absolutely love my life however, I do regret not just having more fun at school and not worrying about my grades because it really hasn’t paid off. Obviously, for certain jobs such as medicine too grades are needed but for the vast majority it truly doesn’t matter at all. I have definitely learned my lesson on it with my own DC and have never excessively pushed them and my main priority has always been their social progress/happiness at school rather than grades, which I think will honestly stand them in far better stead than getting all 9’s in their GCSE’s. Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2023 21:03

phlebasconsidered · 30/08/2023 20:34

I am super proud of my ds who got the (apparently low and awful) grades to train to be a plumber this year. It will take him 4 years to be gas qualified. No "less" a training than A levels, by far.

I've taught for over 20 years at secondary level. We utterly undervalue trade qualifications in this country and we assume that gcse at grade 4 and above are the be all and end all. They're not. I was just as proud on results day of my students who are going on to "lesser" courses as I was of those who will return to me for A Levels.

What I can say with absolute honesty is that every bit of my plumbing, plastering and decorating in the last few years has involved me realising I am employing old pupils and they are all earning more than me. One student now runs a chain of dog grooming mobile salons and they are doing brilliantly.

We really need to change our system and mindset.

You're absolutely right.
One size doesn't, couldn't, shouldn't fit all.

NosinaBook · 30/08/2023 21:02

It's not the end of the world if you don't do well in school but doing well increases your choices in life. I didn't do well at school due to personal circumstances at the time so I ended up going back to education as an adult to have a fulfilling, decent paying career. Some people do better with apprenticeships or working their way up but they still need to put the work in at some point. Surely it's better put the graft in early, when you have less responsibilities/ commitments?

CalatheaHoya · 30/08/2023 20:48

Very non academic parents/family (dropped out of school) state educated. I just really liked learning, excelled at school, top of the year at A-levels, top at medical school. Now a doctor on a fairly academic track in a ‘prestigious’ London teaching hospital. However I earn way less than friends in the city especially for the hours I work.

And I never felt pressured by anyone to study hard I just genuinely enjoyed learning and studying!

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 30/08/2023 20:46

Your salary is impacted by your work choices though. You have chosen to work part time, if you worked full time then you would be earning significantly more.

MrsValentine24 · 30/08/2023 20:35

That’s because most people (and schools) are stuck in the mindset that a degree is impressive, when actually a non-vocational degree by itself impresses nobody anymore. Everybody has a degree, gone are the days when only special smart people had degrees. Sixth form is now compulsory and sixth-formers are automatically funnelled into higher education unless they make a conscious effort not to be.

Something I find really telling about the status of a university degree: my uncle went to university in the 70s, paid no tuition and received a grant. My stepdad went to uni 10 years later and also paid no tuition fees and received a grant, but the value of the grant was the same figure my uncle had received 10 years previously. My mum went to uni as a mature student in the 90s, she still didn’t pay tuition but had to take a loan instead of receiving a grant, though the loan was minimal. People attending university today pay upwards of 30k for the privilege in tuition alone.

To have a university degree lead to a high paying job you have a long-term goal and study something vocational, like medicine or engineering, or else really make a strong effort to do lots of industry-specific internships/volunteering and have stand-out extracurriculars if you’re picking a subject with a less structured career pathway.

When most people come out of university, they may have a 2.1 but they also probably have 0 work history and a lingering tendency to ask permission to use the bathroom. It just doesn’t compare in earning potential to a peer who has 3/4+ years of professional experience.

phlebasconsidered · 30/08/2023 20:34

I am super proud of my ds who got the (apparently low and awful) grades to train to be a plumber this year. It will take him 4 years to be gas qualified. No "less" a training than A levels, by far.

I've taught for over 20 years at secondary level. We utterly undervalue trade qualifications in this country and we assume that gcse at grade 4 and above are the be all and end all. They're not. I was just as proud on results day of my students who are going on to "lesser" courses as I was of those who will return to me for A Levels.

What I can say with absolute honesty is that every bit of my plumbing, plastering and decorating in the last few years has involved me realising I am employing old pupils and they are all earning more than me. One student now runs a chain of dog grooming mobile salons and they are doing brilliantly.

We really need to change our system and mindset.

ICanBuyMyOwnBooks · 30/08/2023 20:23

To be blunt, only some people judge you on your wealth, not your academic success. Not everyone is completely signed up to the capitalist value system or US priorities.

CharlieBoo · 30/08/2023 20:09

I agree, it’s not the be all and end all. It keeps options open and more avenues to pursue, but this doesn’t necessarily mean wealth.

Some of the wealthiest people I know, own their own businesses, be it plumbing, building, electrics. They don’t have degrees, but are skilled and very successful.

In life you are judged on your wealth, not your academic success, and they don’t always go hand in hand.

Eleganz · 30/08/2023 20:05

We love to talk down and devalue education in this country and I do think it certainly has a privilege element to it. Many of those telling our young people today that grades don't matter have had opportunities given to them via other routes.

I went to a bog standard comp in a post-industrial northern town in a very working class community. Those that did well at school (minority) got out and have decent careers, a smaller number got trades but most are stuck in poorly paid jobs in the local economy and or are unemployed.

Yet still there are many in my old community who like to talk down education because that is what they are told from the pages of the tabloid press by a bunch of public school Oxbridge graduates working to keep them in their place.

I have had lots of negative comments from people because I have a PhD (many are also sexist too - being an educated woman has its own extra issues as I'm sure many of you know). Even some folk I work with (usually people in operations) cannot understand that I can have a high level of education and also knowledge of how the real world actually operates. They assume that my PhD means I am a "boffin" divorced from reality, but more fool them if they underestimate me.

Positive41 · 30/08/2023 20:03

MrTiddlesTheCat · 29/08/2023 12:22

My husband is a nuclear chemist. I can't imagine he'd be much good at his job if he only had a woodwork GCSE.

But what about you?

What do you do?

Did your academic success (or not) affect you?

Why do we need to talk about husband's?

TheGuv1982 · 30/08/2023 19:56

My GCSE’s were woeful. I’ve done well, however I regret not making more of school, and possibly Uni, as it would have boosted my earning potential ahead by 10 years.

letloz · 30/08/2023 19:56

OP, I'm like you. Worked really hard at school, great grades, went to Oxford, and have ended up working in the NHS in job that although I'd need a degree for, definitely not straight As and an Oxford degree. And not earning loads (about on par with a teacher). But I love my job, and the way I saw it, was that the good grades opened doors - you could do what you wanted with good grades, but you couldn't always do the job you might later want with lower grades. Having said that, I have definitely reflected that people with much lower qualifications are earning lots more than me, so to a large extent grades don't matter. It's just working out what's going to make you happy in life- I think if you're not able to get the grades, don't sweat it, you'll probably do fine anyway (and there are much more important personal characteristics and skills in the job seeking market), but if you were able to get them, and didn't cos of being too lazy/having too much fun, I think most people would regret not having pushed themselves, even if it didn't lead to them being better off later in life.

MannekenP · 30/08/2023 19:52

Gwenhwyfar · 30/08/2023 17:49

Window cleaning? Aren't they usually very modest one-man businesses?
Even in hospitality people study for qualifications so someone trying to work their way up would be competing with qualified people who may also have the experience.

You'd be surprised at how much a one-man band makes.
FIL was (well, still is, a few jobs here and there) a farm contractor. Mostly cash in hand. Made very little on paper, both DH and SIL got the full loan for university. DH mother never worked.
However they have a large house that they spent quite a bit on renovating...quite a few posh cars and £££ in the bank.

Considering that 40K on PAYE equates to a take home of about 31K, and 50K, a take home of 38K, the equivalent 'self-employed' salary adds up to a higher take home pay with a clever accountant.

Yellowlegobrick · 30/08/2023 19:49

Hmm, i'm less sure.

I went to a v average suburban state school.

The students who got the highest a-level grades (especially those in STEM/or traditional subjects like history) are mostly in the better jobs.

Of course there are outliers. But on average, better academic results (particularly when paired with career choices) have paid dividends.

Op you have chosen part time teaching, so probably aren't utilising the full extent of your academic abilities.

Your choices are still going to drive outcomes, ultimately.

DH and I both did very well academically, chose high paid jobs and earn a lot.

TwoRoadsDiverged · 30/08/2023 19:38

I agree entirely OP. It’s just an observation as you outline.

I too ‘did everything right’ and as I was supposed to and enjoyed learning etc but have a pretty average life in the public sector and no one ever has asked about my qualifications either! Could have got C or A* - no one cares/checks etc.

It’s not bitterness but more of an observation. Everyone I know who was not academic and had more of a relaxed approach/dare I say ‘dossed about’ at school are mostly more financially successful than me. As bought houses early and don’t have university debt and seem to live in huge properties. Mostly these people also from working class backgrounds too (which makes me very happy btw 😃) as I too am working class.

I also think education used to be seen as the last social enabler - but this is less so now. Particularly outside London. This is due to unfair wealth distribution and other factors but certainly when I was doing my GcSE and A levels in the mid 00s it was seen as ‘get A grades and illuminate yourself and go to university and be a big winner 🥇’

Obviously there are exceptions to this and it can depend on career path - but for most being academic doesn’t mean all that much anymore.

MrsZargon · 30/08/2023 19:36

I have mixed feelings about this. I was academically bright and so pushed down the academic route at school. I did Physics, Chemistry, Maths A-Level and for the two years was the one smoking and drinking behind the shed, out partying all the time and not applying myself. Scraped the grades to go on to a red brick uni to study Astrophysics where I behaved even worse, I even took one of my final exams drunk. Scraped a 3rd Class degree and went away feeling like somewhat of a failure. I went on to carve out a good career in a corporate job but despite the good pay and prospects I never really enjoyed it. Was happy to give it up to be a SAHM. Now I have no idea what I want to do with the rest of my life. I wish that I had worked harder at school as perhaps I would have had more choices available once I graduated, but on the other hand I wonder if I just didn’t enjoy my subjects that much and would have worked harder at something different, more creative for example. I think that the most important thing is to try and find subjects that you enjoy and a career you enjoy regardless of money, as that is what matters in the long run. But absolutely try to balance work and fun. Wish I had learnt that sooner!!

geoqueen · 30/08/2023 19:23

I think it comes down to balance. Achieving good grades at school is beneficial because it teaches you how to learn and how to devote yourself to working hard, some important things (my career still references things I learned at school - however to be fair a lot I don’t use) and most importantly it leaves as many doors open as possible, and it is rewarding. However, it’s definitely not the be all and end all and unless your dream is to do medicine/pharmacy/actuarial science etc then perfect results aren’t necessary. Achieving a healthy work-life balance at school and beyond is so important. But working hard at work and good work experience is what gets you farthest.

Montelukast · 30/08/2023 19:18

Good grades at school give you options.
that’s all it is- it’s doors opened not doors closed. There are so many other factors that influence career prospects of course.
It also matters what you choose and how you maximise your own potential.
I had the worst A Levels of my friendship group / not for want of trying I worked very hard but I didn’t do well on the day. Those results are only a snapshot in time. I went to a less prestigious university to study the same course and I am a much higher earner at the moment than all my friends who did ‘academically ‘ better. I have been very savvy in my choices. This could change if I had a family or they changed careers for example. Life is a marathon !

xyz111 · 30/08/2023 19:04

@ErosandAgape of course not. But going to uni doesn't mean you'll have a better life or experience better things

RamblingRosieLee · 30/08/2023 19:01

You had choice and options. Not everyone can be an entrepreneur etc. You had options and chose that job.

whenindoubtgotothelibrary · 30/08/2023 18:58

Education is about more than earning lots of money. As a child from a very working class background my degrees opened the door to travel, professional jobs and a more interesting (to me!) life that would not have been remotely possible otherwise. DH is similar. I doubt it will have quite the same impact on our dc as their starting point and the world is very different several decades later, but we have absolutely prioritised their education. My father was made to leave school at 15 and work in manual jobs that he hated, but my oldest son went to Cambridge. I'm enormously proud of that, whatever he ends up doing or earning in later life.

anonymousxoxo · 30/08/2023 18:56

FebandMarch · 30/08/2023 18:50

I really agree with the poster above. I’d like to think my academics have enriched my life. However, I got straight A’s at gcse and A levels plus a science degree and Masters from a Russell Group uni, but because I’ve been a stay at home mum for ten year, it’s literally impossible for me to get a job (no references, no experience etc etc). My husband on the other hand failed his GCSE’s but luckily for him was pretty good at sport so has managed a well paid career out of that. I’m very envious towards all those with ‘careers’. I so wish I had one! People say education keeps your options open, but I don’t feel like I have any options despite brilliant academics. I feel like I could be a real help to someone’s business but just can’t get anything…

People keep forgetting as they're naive on how hard it is to enter a career and strive in it.

I don't mean this to be harsh, but..

  1. You stayed home for 10 years which means your 10 years behind of your peers experience wise.
  2. Industries are very sexist towards women and most likely want younger employees in entry level roles.

In comparison to a woman who stayed in work would have had higher opportunities to progress (especially with women like you opting out of the workforce) e.g. less competition for her.
More flexibility and higher salary.

Part time is hard to come by aswell, my job literally cannot be done part time and my colleagues are 5 males on top of that.

People say education keeps your options open, but I don’t feel like I have any options despite brilliant academics. this is because you prioritised your husband job.

I always get slack for this but people who want to be SAHM are better of leaving education until they want a full time career because:

  1. Uni is expensive
  2. Your qualification will be fresh
  3. Socialising with peers
  4. Confidence
  5. Connections
  6. SFE won't fund second degree

It always pays for women to stay in full time work or even part time, otherwise they are well and truly fucked regardless of their education background unless they have connections.

FebandMarch · 30/08/2023 18:50

I really agree with the poster above. I’d like to think my academics have enriched my life. However, I got straight A’s at gcse and A levels plus a science degree and Masters from a Russell Group uni, but because I’ve been a stay at home mum for ten year, it’s literally impossible for me to get a job (no references, no experience etc etc). My husband on the other hand failed his GCSE’s but luckily for him was pretty good at sport so has managed a well paid career out of that. I’m very envious towards all those with ‘careers’. I so wish I had one! People say education keeps your options open, but I don’t feel like I have any options despite brilliant academics. I feel like I could be a real help to someone’s business but just can’t get anything…

Brightandshining · 30/08/2023 18:43

Depends what you mean by 'count for nothing' I agree it does not always equate to financial success. But it can often improve quality of life on other ways.
I certainly won't be too pushy with my kids academically.
I was a 'gifted child' 15 A* at GCSE. 5 As at AS level... then whilst I was doing my A levels I had a complete breakdown and ended up leaving home and basically being a homeless drug addict for a while. But there were other home life factors to this not just being pushed academically.
My husband always coasted along at school and he's the one with the masters degree now and the career. But neither of us are massively financially successful.
I do think both our educations have helped us as people in the end though. I do value having a wide range of interests and as I get older all the things I've been taught, I feel they've enriched my life. I feel I have a level of resilience from it. And as for my husband his degrees have certainly helped him progress in his career but its not a career where he would ever be considered wealthy.. however it is something that engages him.
I'd be happy if my kids were very academic but I would not expect that to equal financial success, and I won't push them to be.

SemperIdem · 30/08/2023 18:30

It would suit our current government very well if the general public started buying into the idea that education doesn’t matter, as long as you have a high salary.

Academic success is usually accompanied by a level of critical thinking ability that those less educated do not have.

Swipe left for the next trending thread