Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think academic success truly does not matter

457 replies

Hotstuff18 · 29/08/2023 12:05

Firstly, this isn’t sour grapes. I went to a very prestigious RG university and was always the annoying girl with my hand up at school (ah misspent youth 😂). However, in almost all the adults I know now their academic outcomes have had literally no bearing on their lives now in their late 30’s and early 40’s. In my own life, my A’s at A level count for absolutely nothing when my part time teacher salary is absolutely dwarfed by my non academic DH’s who spent most of his time at school messing around and smoking behind the bike sheds. At work, a lot of my colleagues didn’t do that well in their own exams and now do the exact same job as me. Many friends who work in trade jobs having left school at 16 earn very impressive salaries meanwhile others with top grades in their exams earn low money. One particular example that always sticks out to me is a lady who lives down the street, who’s also a teacher, absolutely bombed her exams as she spent the whole time partying (whilst I spent most of year 13 diligently writing up notes and doing practice essays) and yet we ended up living on the same street doing the exact same job. I’m not bitter about this at all, I absolutely love my life however, I do regret not just having more fun at school and not worrying about my grades because it really hasn’t paid off. Obviously, for certain jobs such as medicine too grades are needed but for the vast majority it truly doesn’t matter at all. I have definitely learned my lesson on it with my own DC and have never excessively pushed them and my main priority has always been their social progress/happiness at school rather than grades, which I think will honestly stand them in far better stead than getting all 9’s in their GCSE’s. Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2023 13:30

The more interesting debate for me in the age of institution blind job applications is whether it's worth going to a 'top' university where you will have to work harder to get a 2.1, or whether it's better to go to a less academic one and be more likely to get a first (or 2.2 and 2.1, but you get my point) or have more time to get work experience/participate in extra curriculars whilst at uni. As someone who went to Oxbridge I do question if it would be worth it for my kids now (should they even want to go/get in).

As with all these things, it depends on the individual. My dd very consciously made that choice - she opted for Cambridge because it would be a challenge. She had a good social life there too, great work experience in the summer vac.

I guess some people prefer being a big fish in a smaller pond but it's not the right choice for everyone.

NameChanged0800 · 29/08/2023 13:27

It matters in my job - top grades throughout, 1st/2:1 are minimum requirements, but it's also a profession that tends to pay >£100k. i earn 6 figures working part time. I am surprised that someone who did so badly in their exams is a teacher. Maybe if teaching paid better it would be more selective and could demand higher grades (which I am assuming would also improve quality). Your profession is underpaid and undervalued if they will let pretty much anyone do it regardless of results and you should feel annoyed about that if nothing else. Who knows what it will look like in 10-15 years time. If pay is increased then grades may well start to matter a lot more.

Enfys1982 · 29/08/2023 13:26

YANBU. Not everyone is academic. You can’t force it. There will be other things that non academic kids will good at, practical skills are just as important. They might be good at sport, music, drama, cooking, craft, art. My Dad isn’t academic in the slightest but still managed to set up and run a business. It’s not the be all and end all.

HamishTheCamel · 29/08/2023 13:26

My A level grades were a means to an end. They don't matter now, but without them I wouldn't have got onto the degree course that I did, and that has certainly affected my career.

1066andallthatagain · 29/08/2023 13:23

Gliomes · 29/08/2023 13:19

I think academic success buys you more choice. And some of those extra choices you get can be incredibly interesting, fulfilling and/or lucrative.

Life is also full of things that restrict people's choices - having people they need to care for, or mental health difficulties for example. These can happen to anyone. But that doesn't mean good grades don't make a difference.

Also....

... This

1066andallthatagain · 29/08/2023 13:22

Academic success absolutely matters. It doesn't meant that you can't be financially successful if you did poorly at school or university, or that getting a first somehow guarantees you will be a millionaire by 25, but you have a very small social circle if the correlation between academic success and earnings isn't pretty obvious. The fact that your As at a-level haven't led to a high paying career is significantly because you chose a relatively low paying field and have chosen* to be part time. The majority of people who got very poor grades in school are not earning a fortune now in trades - you notice the ones who are.

The more interesting debate for me in the age of institution blind job applications is whether it's worth going to a 'top' university where you will have to work harder to get a 2.1, or whether it's better to go to a less academic one and be more likely to get a first (or 2.2 and 2.1, but you get my point) or have more time to get work experience/participate in extra curriculars whilst at uni. As someone who went to Oxbridge I do question if it would be worth it for my kids now (should they even want to go/get in).

*I say 'chose' as you mention your DH is a high earner so presumably your family wasn't forced for one person to go part time because you couldn't afford childcare.

Gliomes · 29/08/2023 13:19

I think academic success buys you more choice. And some of those extra choices you get can be incredibly interesting, fulfilling and/or lucrative.

Life is also full of things that restrict people's choices - having people they need to care for, or mental health difficulties for example. These can happen to anyone. But that doesn't mean good grades don't make a difference.

DelurkingAJ · 29/08/2023 13:15

I’m very confused by this idea that being happy and having a good social life and getting top grades are mutually exclusive. I’m hoping my DC will manage both. I agree that it’s not the be all and end all but it makes life easier.

CharlotteBog · 29/08/2023 13:15

I work in academia and most people have PhDs so in my world YABU.

Odiebay · 29/08/2023 13:14

A levels are seen as a way to get to university. The problem is the "Mickey mouse degrees" and not choosing a degree that's going to lead to an actual job. I did GCSEs that I needed to get into college. Went to college for accountancy and got by first job in it at 18. Whilst working studied CIMA. No uni, no debt and earning at the same time. Hard hard graft but worth it. Friend did A levels, did media at uni now works as a receptionist as she can't get a job with her degree.

Blacknosugarplease · 29/08/2023 13:13

MrTiddlesTheCat · 29/08/2023 12:22

My husband is a nuclear chemist. I can't imagine he'd be much good at his job if he only had a woodwork GCSE.

This type of job is obviously what the OP was caveating… but don’t let that stop your not so stealth boast 😂

LlynTegid · 29/08/2023 13:11

It can be important but can be overrated. I think with the 50% or so university target we have replaced the stigma of failing the 11 plus of old with a new divide.

I even think that providing you have GCSE English Language and Maths you should be able to leave formal education at 16.

Nomorescreentime · 29/08/2023 13:11

I don’t agree that academic success doesn’t matter. It opens doors and can smooth the path to where you would like to travel. What I tell my kids though is that soft skills are of equal importance. Communication skills, the ability to maintain networks…things I didn’t have any awareness of as a student!

Aserena · 29/08/2023 13:10

I completely agree with you that happiness & social wellbeing are more important than academics, although it isn’t necessarily an either / or situation and if possible it’s better to have both.

Nobody gives a flying fart now what I got in my GCSEs or A Levels. But, these grades had a bearing on the subjects and courses I could study later, and ultimately laid the foundation for the career I am doing now. If I had flunked my GCSEs then I wouldn’t have been on the same path. I might have done very well at a different path, but the two futures aren’t interchangeable.

So I do think grades are important, just not all-important.

Fizbosshoes · 29/08/2023 13:10

Not everyone is academic and for those who have more of an aptitude for more practical skills then I would encourage towards their skill set. DH is dyslexic (not recognised at school) and left with very few qualifications. He does a creative/practical job but I think in previous years there was probably more scope for this.

Although my dad was dissuaded by his parents from going to grammar school because they wanted him to leave at 15 and learn a trade so he could contribute to household finances.

However academic results do tend to open more choices. My message to my DC is that if you try and fail it's not the end of the world, there will be other options....but I'd expect them to try because having good results will usually give them more options.

GasPanic · 29/08/2023 13:09

A lot of the very richest people seem to have done pretty badly in their qualifications.

However, probably for everyone who does badly at school and makes it rich there are probably hundreds if not thousands more that live in poverty.

I think doing well at school/university probably sets you up for a more middling position. You will never be poor as an engineer/accountant/IT but you are unlikely to ever be stonking rich either as you end up working mostly in a big company for someone else on a relatively decent but not massive wage.

It's the people who leave school at 16 who have 10 businesses go bust before they are 21 that can make it to be billionaires. Unless you are born into money that is.

If you have energy, drive and ambition then you can be rich I think irrespective of what happens at school. For some people school doesn't work and it takes them time to find their place in the world. Even for some of the tech bro billionaires it is clearly obvious that they have struggled in the education environment, even if they have eventually made it to Uni.

Spendonsend · 29/08/2023 13:08

The bonus of academic success is about the doors it opens, even if you never choose those routes (over and above the merit for educations sake which is a given)

I had a number of options from my good A levels that werent open if i had only poor gcses. If i had a degree I am sure there would have been even more options.

Its not to say though, that through hard work and effort you cant open doors in other ways. But its just that. A different form of hard work and effort. I dont know anyone who fucked about at school, then fucked about at work who did ok.

PinkPlantCase · 29/08/2023 13:07

minipie · 29/08/2023 12:37

I know lots of academically very successful people who have ended up in relatively low paying jobs, working part time or not at all.

The common denominator is that they are all women with children and a high earning (and therefore often absent) DH.

I’m sure their career paths would have looked very different if they’d not had children or if they’d been the higher earner.

I think this is often forgotten on threads like these.

Whichwhatnow · 29/08/2023 13:03

I pretty much agree with you. All of my siblings left school young (I was 13, my sister 12 and my brother 9! Traveller family...) and I'm the only one who went back to college and got a degree and now a well paid professional job. But my siblings both earn about the same as me as tattooists now. I think if you have the capacity to succeed you will regardless of the route you take to get there. We're all happy which I think is the main thing - I loved my degree and love my work and my siblings feel the same about their jobs

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 29/08/2023 13:00

I am pretty sure at a population level, higher academic success correlates to higher earning potential.

This doesn't mean that these people are happier or that it always correlates at individual level. We all know people who bombed school who have got amazing jobs, and people who were really successful at school who have non academic low paying job. I know an oxbridge grad for example who works in admin and I work with people who have high earning jobs who didn't go to uni.

However I know more people who didn't do great at school and now have low paying jobs and people who went to good unis who are now very high earners (consultants, City finance and City lawyers) who couldn't have got there without those qualifications.

I do agree you shouldn't push kids to do more than they are capable of and you should also teach them to have a good work life balance, and also a big one for me is to think about the money and the hours / shifts when choosing a career

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 29/08/2023 12:57

As an introvert with good exam results, my anxiety/nerves/awkwardness have held me back a lot.

But equally there are some jobs where academic qualifications would be a lot more important than good interpersonal skills.

I'm a teacher, like the OP, so I need both. I teach languages. While just being able to speak a language fluently might make me able to teach someone to speak it, I wouldn't have got my current job in a lovely, excellent girls' grammar school, teaching A Level literature etc, without my academic qualifications. In fact, as a 51yo, experienced therefore expensive, teacher with an extremely patchy and holey cv since having dc, and having been recently rejected my multiple other schools due to age and budget 'lack of recent full time experience', I suspect my Oxbridge degree was a big part of what got me in the door.

bonzaitree · 29/08/2023 12:56

I interview and review cvs a lot. Academics in my line of work make an ENORMOUS difference.

Absolutely huge.

So yeah you’re being unreasonable.

TheFretfulPorpentine · 29/08/2023 12:53

It matters in its own right. Education is about more than getting a job, or getting a well paid job.

Harrythehappypig · 29/08/2023 12:52

The people I know who have been most successful (by their own terms) in their careers have been those who were willing/able to put themselves out there and push for things. Even the ones who look “lucky” to the casual observer had been active before then making connections or applying for many many jobs. I don’t do this!