Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think academic success truly does not matter

457 replies

Hotstuff18 · 29/08/2023 12:05

Firstly, this isn’t sour grapes. I went to a very prestigious RG university and was always the annoying girl with my hand up at school (ah misspent youth 😂). However, in almost all the adults I know now their academic outcomes have had literally no bearing on their lives now in their late 30’s and early 40’s. In my own life, my A’s at A level count for absolutely nothing when my part time teacher salary is absolutely dwarfed by my non academic DH’s who spent most of his time at school messing around and smoking behind the bike sheds. At work, a lot of my colleagues didn’t do that well in their own exams and now do the exact same job as me. Many friends who work in trade jobs having left school at 16 earn very impressive salaries meanwhile others with top grades in their exams earn low money. One particular example that always sticks out to me is a lady who lives down the street, who’s also a teacher, absolutely bombed her exams as she spent the whole time partying (whilst I spent most of year 13 diligently writing up notes and doing practice essays) and yet we ended up living on the same street doing the exact same job. I’m not bitter about this at all, I absolutely love my life however, I do regret not just having more fun at school and not worrying about my grades because it really hasn’t paid off. Obviously, for certain jobs such as medicine too grades are needed but for the vast majority it truly doesn’t matter at all. I have definitely learned my lesson on it with my own DC and have never excessively pushed them and my main priority has always been their social progress/happiness at school rather than grades, which I think will honestly stand them in far better stead than getting all 9’s in their GCSE’s. Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
HamBone · 30/08/2023 15:19

I agree that trades are under appreciated and have spoken to my DC’s about this. DD is at university and DS is likely to go, but being qualified as an electrician, for example, is still v. useful. My FIL is a retired engineer and also a qualified electrician. He’s saved his children a ton of money!

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 30/08/2023 15:15

kitsuneghost · 30/08/2023 15:04

Depends if he was packing in his education to become a plumber
You can still be an academically high achiever AND be a plumber
as others said completing a good academic education opens more doors
you might not need it for your preferred job, but its always there if you choose a career change or something happens that we no longer need plumbers

Something happens that we no longer need plumbers? OK, so the Apocalypse? In which case we will only need people who know how to grow/forage for food. Your highly paid academics will be as badly off as the rest of us. I have seen the distain myself for plumbers - posh ignorant local woman's absolute disbelief that a mere plumber could have an intelligent discussion about anything other than football. But without people like him, and other tradespeople, this woman would be living in a cave. My electrician used to be head of cyber security at a Swiss bank but he decided to ditch the stress of that job, moved back to the UK and retrained as an electrician.

Tenegrief · 30/08/2023 15:15

kitsuneghost · 30/08/2023 15:04

Depends if he was packing in his education to become a plumber
You can still be an academically high achiever AND be a plumber
as others said completing a good academic education opens more doors
you might not need it for your preferred job, but its always there if you choose a career change or something happens that we no longer need plumbers

@kitsuneghost No - he wasn't giving up on his education. He was on track to get those grades. The head was just really disdainful that he'd decided to be a (god forbid!) plumber when he could have aimed for something much more meaningful. The point I was making was that lots of schools/school leaders still massively favour academic routes and genuinely look down their nose on anything other than that. She was also clearly conscious of the negative impact this boy's choice to become a plumber rather than use his good GCSE results on something worthy like the standard A-levels/undergrad degree route would have on the school's stats.

useitorlose · 30/08/2023 15:11

DH left school and joined the army at 16 and now aged 59 earns three times my salary, and I am well paid! He also gets bonuses and stock options. One of the key reasons for the difference is private sector vs public sector. I didn't go to uni when I left school, but now have a BSc, PGCE, MEd, MA and I'm working on my EdD. That won't help me earn any more either!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/08/2023 15:10

Qualifications are only of value if you have connections to help you get a job, or if you’re likeable and people feel a rapport with you so they give you opportunities. Both of those things count for way more than your actual grades

l know plenty of people with no connections and degrees. They all have good jobs. I completely disagree.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/08/2023 15:08

BishyBarnyBee · 30/08/2023 15:04

Can you link this please? It's the opposite of a lot of current thinking about good teaching being the critical factor in attainment.

There are obvious reasons why this government might like to blame poor teaching rather than poverty for underattainment, but I'm not aware of the study you mention so would be very interested to see it.

Yeah l know that too. Don’t know where this research came from.

A good teacher is one of the best predictions of academic success.

Sugarcoatt · 30/08/2023 15:07

Qualifications are only of value if you have connections to help you get a job, or if you’re likeable and people feel a rapport with you so they give you opportunities. Both of those things count for way more than your actual grades.

Money talks and connections open doors. Loads of people from poor backgrounds were encouraged to get expensive degrees but then found they didn’t have the middle class connections to get jobs afterwards.

I know someone who failed their degree but did well because Daddy bought them a company to run. I know someone with a PhD who couldn’t get hired despite genius level intelligence because they’re autistic. I know someone who pretty much runs their employer’s company while the employer (who knows fuck all about the business he inherited) just swans off on holiday several times a year. I know someone who qualified as a solicitor but ended up working in Asda, because they were raised on benefits so they didn’t have professional connections who could help them get jobs.

So no, qualifications don’t really matter. The government and teachers and others like to pretend that they do matter. They like to pretend that the world is fair. All that does is give hard working kids a shock when they realise the truth, and encourage them to waste £££ on qualifications that won’t get them anywhere.

BishyBarnyBee · 30/08/2023 15:04

anotherside · 30/08/2023 14:52

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Funnily enough, studies showed that teachers have very little effect on academic outcome. A recent twin study suggests the classroom/teacher is only responsible for 2-3% of academic outcome. IE 97%-98% of what makes a child’s academic performance see due to factors outside of the classroom.

Can you link this please? It's the opposite of a lot of current thinking about good teaching being the critical factor in attainment.

There are obvious reasons why this government might like to blame poor teaching rather than poverty for underattainment, but I'm not aware of the study you mention so would be very interested to see it.

kitsuneghost · 30/08/2023 15:04

Tenegrief · 30/08/2023 14:59

@Pocketfullofdogtreats I totally agree with this. Schools value academic qualifications and pathways far more highly than trades (which is, in many circumstances, hugely ridiculous as, as anyone who knows successful tradespeople will know, there is a lot of money to be made in these professions). I overheard my head teacher talking to the careers advisor at my school saying 'please have a good chat with Henry, he's predicted 6s and 7s but he's determined he wants to be a plumber' (the disgust on her face when she said this was immense). Fact is, schools are measured against their exam results as well as the pathways students choose to take, with favour being given to academic routes (such as A levels and university).

Without wanting to come across as too tin hat about all of this, there definitely seems to be questionable motives behind the drive to prioritise and incentivise traditional academic pathways for all students, regardless of their suitability for it (not to mention societies need for ALL types of workers and professions).

Depends if he was packing in his education to become a plumber
You can still be an academically high achiever AND be a plumber
as others said completing a good academic education opens more doors
you might not need it for your preferred job, but its always there if you choose a career change or something happens that we no longer need plumbers

DuckyLuck · 30/08/2023 15:03

I disagree. With academic success you open up choices that might not otherwise be there. I left school after achieving 1 A level and took a job as a sort of admin/typist. It took me years to progress to where I am, a fairly successful IT PM but others walked in to my level of role with a degree behind them and got there 10 years earlier.

I always say to my sons, it doesn't matter if you want to go live up a tree for 2 years, but succeeding at school, by trying your hardest means that there will more choice for you when you decide to come back down from that tree.

OakTree16 · 30/08/2023 15:02

I think it totally depends. I was very academic and now I’m a teacher. My DP dropped out of university, and now earns three times as much as me as a senior supervisor. I love my job though and wouldn’t want to do anything else.

kitsuneghost · 30/08/2023 14:59

I did well academically but I am not in a very high paid job (science)
But I do it for the love of it. Its how I am built.
I am good at maths and logic, rubbish at arts
I never think I wish I hadn't bothered because x is earning this because that isn't the career I chose
I never think y has a better life because they partied more as each person is different.

Tenegrief · 30/08/2023 14:59

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 30/08/2023 14:26

I mean, trades are underappreciated by those who only value academic success.

@Pocketfullofdogtreats I totally agree with this. Schools value academic qualifications and pathways far more highly than trades (which is, in many circumstances, hugely ridiculous as, as anyone who knows successful tradespeople will know, there is a lot of money to be made in these professions). I overheard my head teacher talking to the careers advisor at my school saying 'please have a good chat with Henry, he's predicted 6s and 7s but he's determined he wants to be a plumber' (the disgust on her face when she said this was immense). Fact is, schools are measured against their exam results as well as the pathways students choose to take, with favour being given to academic routes (such as A levels and university).

Without wanting to come across as too tin hat about all of this, there definitely seems to be questionable motives behind the drive to prioritise and incentivise traditional academic pathways for all students, regardless of their suitability for it (not to mention societies need for ALL types of workers and professions).

Eleganz · 30/08/2023 14:57

Of course it makes a difference. I might not be earning more than a plumber, but I'd much rather be doing what I am doing than fixing toilets.

Academic success gives you choice and opportunity, it doesn't mean you have to be a CEO or you've failed.

anotherside · 30/08/2023 14:52

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Funnily enough, studies showed that teachers have very little effect on academic outcome. A recent twin study suggests the classroom/teacher is only responsible for 2-3% of academic outcome. IE 97%-98% of what makes a child’s academic performance see due to factors outside of the classroom.

TheCurtainQueen · 30/08/2023 14:52

All of the highest earners that I know did very well academically. They are software developers, lawyers, accountants, bankers etc. None of them could have got where they are without doing well at school and uni.

OP you could have made much more of your academic achievements if you had chosen a different career path. You must have known that as a teacher you wouldn’t be earning a great deal and would have colleagues who weren’t particularly academic.

LocalHobo · 30/08/2023 14:49

If what you value in life is wealth, then clearly not necessarily.
But anyone with intelligence would not see that as their number one priority surely?

Zanatdy · 30/08/2023 14:49

I think it depends - I went to Uni and earn a lot more than my friends who didn’t. They’ve still done ok in their life though. My DS and DD are both really academic and my DS I’m sure will go far

olivehaters · 30/08/2023 14:47

You chose a career path that always been low paying and doesn't really warrant A grades to do it as shown by your examples.
Your A grades could have got you in a career in which they were needed more.
It is possible to make more money in teaching if for example you go into leadership./exec roles but then it is no longer about the grades but who has the drive.

I am similar. In work in health care. I have a first class honours and a masters. My career has plateaued now, partly because it has a natural ceiling if I want to stay clinical and partly because I choose to work part time. My husband got a desmond in an easy degree. But he works in the right industry and plays the money game. He earns well over 6 figures.

We make our choices.

anotherside · 30/08/2023 14:44

In terms of salary, I think there’s another key thing at play: most people don’t actively pursue a high salaried position/job from the outset.

From my experience that’s what sets private school attending kids apart - most of them will make Money a big consideration right from the outset, ie from the age of 16 or 18 they’re being told to think about earnings. Whereas the equally bright, or brighter kid in state secondary school will be more trying to get good grades for their own sake.

If you want a highly paid career you have to actively pursue it - it won’t just drop from the sky after a bunch of good GCSEs + A-Levels and then a 2:1 at a decent university. That’s the reason why some trades people etc do well - as they first identify a strength they have and then vigorously apply that to a gap in the market with the goal of making as much money as possible.
As opposed to the bright student who just does a degree in history/English/modern art or drama etc just because it’s quite interesting or just because they like it.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/08/2023 14:43

How come you know all these teachers who do the same job as you but failed their exams. Most teachers still need a degree.

And also, why as someone who is delivering learning to people, are you so sure that academic success doesn’t matter? Should a teacher be pushing this?

TheMoth · 30/08/2023 14:40

Every time I have a whinge about this, dh just shrugs and says:"well, you went into teaching." A factory near me pays not far off the top end of a main scale teacher salary, but it would drive me nuts. And I don't have the physical strength for the role.

I think often in school, if you have the piss taken out of you for being good academically you console yourself with the idea that at least one day you'll have a good job and the pricks won't.

Except, one day you realise that it's just different paths. I'd like my dc to do well, but they won't need the clean sweep I got in order to do so.

ICanBuyMyOwnBooks · 30/08/2023 14:36

You seem to equate success with earning potential and yy if that's the only reason you studied at school then you'd be disappointed. But education and academic success is about so much more than that. It's about learning, about developing a passion for a subject or topic. It's about understanding the world, politics, history. It's about opportunity. We have friends with very successful businesses but tbh they haven't had access to the same experiences and people as our friends who were more academic.
As someone who grew up in a deprived area, my academic success has opened so many doors and given me so many opportunities. It has shaped the entire course of my life so yy for me it did matter

RampantIvy · 30/08/2023 14:35

I think people are forgetting that you need GCSEs in maths and English for most jobs these days. What people did 20 or 30 years ago is irrelevant to today's job market.

I agree that a lot of jobs that ask for degree educated staff don't actually need people educated to degree level, but saying that qualifications don't matter is naive at best.

PomegranateRose · 30/08/2023 14:33

And just to add - I think it's more what it takes to perform well academically for most of us that will, in the longer stretch of adulthood, open doors for you, not the grades themselves - e.g. hard work, perseverance, an enquiring mind, being someone who can see and capitalise on opportunities etc. Again, I think qualifications in the current educational system are in many senses hoops to jump through more than anything else, and you can certainly make a very good living for yourself going down a trade/vocational route too. Social skills and confidence are equally important for success in most fields either way.