Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you found a torn up piece of paper with writing on in your DC bin, would you tape it back together to read it?

183 replies

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 11:23

In this scenario what would you do:

DD is 10 years old, has their own room. Upon cleaning the room you go to empty the bin and find lots of tiny pieces of paper. It looks like an A4 piece of paper has been written on and then torn up. Obviously not wanting anyone to ready it.

Would you tape the paper back together out of concern to read it? Or would you respect that your child obviously doesn't want you reading it so leave it?

Just for context here, it's not my DC, but a family members. They taped the paper back together but I'm not sure if I agree they should've done that. Just wondered if they were being unreasonable or if most parents would do this?

OP posts:
Pimpmyfeet · 29/08/2023 12:47

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 12:19

Yes they told her about it. They shouted her upstairs and when she walked into her room they were sat on her bedroom floor with the paper in front of them. I'm feeling really hurt for her. She is a member of my family and we are close and she speaks to me about things that she doesn't speak to her parents about. I don't have children but I just feel like I wouldn't have done this in their shoes, I would've ignored it

This is awful! I hope they were kind and concerned and didn’t tell her off for whatever she’d written? If I was her I would find it difficult to trust them going forward (and with good reason)

BustyDin · 29/08/2023 12:44

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 12:39

They have no reason to be concerned about her. She is well behaved, quiet, no issues that they know of, has friends, does well in school, eats well. In my original post I just meant general concern that you might have when you see a piece of paper torn up more than a few times instead of just screwed up and thrown in the bin. It clearly looked like it wasn't meant to be read from what she described. I don't know HOW they managed to put it all back together it must have taken them ages. Unless she's exaggerating how small she tore it

They have no reason to be concerned about her that you know of.

In the nicest possible way, you are not her parent, and your information has come from a 10 yr old, who may or may not be telling you the full story or the whole truth. 10 yr olds are very capable of exaggerating for effect. There may also be things going on to which you are not privy.

Alternatively, her parents may be controlling monsters.

There's no way for you to know, so I'd just carry on being someone she's happy to talk to for the time being.

Sugarfree23 · 29/08/2023 12:44

I'd check it just to be sure theirs no bullying or anything that I should be worried about.
But I wouldn't be taping it back together or confronting them.

More general questions, make sure they know that I'm there for them etc.

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 12:39

They have no reason to be concerned about her. She is well behaved, quiet, no issues that they know of, has friends, does well in school, eats well. In my original post I just meant general concern that you might have when you see a piece of paper torn up more than a few times instead of just screwed up and thrown in the bin. It clearly looked like it wasn't meant to be read from what she described. I don't know HOW they managed to put it all back together it must have taken them ages. Unless she's exaggerating how small she tore it

OP posts:
megletthesecond · 29/08/2023 12:36

DD has no idea I check this stuff.

megletthesecond · 29/08/2023 12:34

DS - no.
DD - yes. Every time. Huge mental health issues.

Blanketpolicy · 29/08/2023 12:33

My mum would have went to these extremes to find out information about me because I never spoke to her about what was going on.

The reason I didn't speak to her was because she was nosey and critical of my decisions and it felt very invasive.

Poking about in my things just made me more and more secretive and it resulted in a couple of serious events that could have been avoided by just keeping the lines of communication open and showing some respect for my autonomy and right to privacy.

fuckityfuckityfuckfuck · 29/08/2023 12:29

Your updates change things.

If I saw my name on a bit of paper, of course I'd read it! So would most people.

However, calling the child down to shout at her is wrong on so many levels, and makes the whole situation abusive.

BustyDin · 29/08/2023 12:27

I don't have children but I just feel like I wouldn't have done this in their shoes, I would've ignored it

You can't possibly know what you'd do with your children, given that you don't have any.

I would have done this with one of mine when he was 10.

I wouldn't have done it with the others.

Context is everything.

landbeforegrime · 29/08/2023 12:25

They sound awful. It's one thing to read it if they are worried about her mental health (which I could just about understand), but if they then confronted her with it in her room then they have done more damage to her than they will clearly ever realise. It will take a lot for her to ever trust or feel her parents are a "safe space" and it sounds like they don't have a clue and will not be able to do what they need to do for that trust and relationship to be rebuilt. Poor child. At least she has you because it sounds like her parents are off the scale.

nofuturewithout · 29/08/2023 12:25

I’m too busy to tape up bits of paper and actually have a life. 😂 Unless I was worried about a child who had shown disturbing behaviour then I wouldn’t have been nosey.

FlamingoQueen · 29/08/2023 12:24

That’s so bad! Unless you happened to see the word ‘die’ or something like that, there is no way I would read something like that. Even if it wasn’t torn up I still wouldn’t read it.
The poor girl has had a massive betrayal by her parents, but at least she has you to talk too.

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 12:19

Yes they told her about it. They shouted her upstairs and when she walked into her room they were sat on her bedroom floor with the paper in front of them. I'm feeling really hurt for her. She is a member of my family and we are close and she speaks to me about things that she doesn't speak to her parents about. I don't have children but I just feel like I wouldn't have done this in their shoes, I would've ignored it

OP posts:
ManateeFair · 29/08/2023 12:15

Trenchfootinthescottishhighlandstoday · 29/08/2023 11:57

Out of the blue my teen dd took an overdose. The best thing I could do for her was read the book filled with her writing. . Yes the paper should have been read.

I'm very sorry about what happened to your daughter Flowers

I still think, though, that everyone, children included, deserve privacy and an outlet for their feelings that isn't scrutinised by other people. I completely understand that your situation was awful and tragic, but it is a very extreme example.

I don't think that taping together a torn-up piece of paper from a 10-year-old's bin in order to read her private thoughts and feelings (and then confronting her about it, apparently, as the child was made aware that they had found it and read it) is kind, proportionate or good for the child's mental health. She's effectively lost her only outlet for expressing her private worries.

Thelonelygiraffe · 29/08/2023 12:15

Only if I had a strong concern about the dc's wellbeing. Otherwise, no.

Richmondgal · 29/08/2023 12:13

No
why would anyone

user1492757084 · 29/08/2023 12:13

Only if the child were having problems such as if she were suffering mental health or bullying. Or if it looked like a note from her teacher that she should have brought home for us to read. Or if it looked like a beautiful poem or song that I wanted to enjoy. Yes, one of my kids used to write gorgeous songs and sometimes disgarded them and she was happy that I complimented her on them.
Ordinarily, though, I would never notice ripped paper or give rubbish a second glance.

MBappse · 29/08/2023 12:10

Yes!
I love finding things children have written and often they are funny or silly or give an insight into what's going on in their brains which can be very helpful. Could also be a cry for help which needs addressing. So, I'd have a quick look and if it was any of the above, and not in tiny pieces, I'd piece it together.

FawnFrenchieMum · 29/08/2023 12:09

GolgafrinchamB · 29/08/2023 11:30

Only if I noticed any problematic words written when I was about to empty it - anything referencing self harm, suicidal ideation, anorexia etc.

In the normal scheme of things, heck no!

This I would be my answer.

Day to day, hell no. My DD11 writes / draws and rips it up all the time. Would never consider taping it together.

A few years ago when DS was going through a really tough time with lots of concerns for his mental health, then maybe based if I'd seen any of the above.

TripleDaisySummer · 29/08/2023 12:07

Ideally no unless there was any serious cause for concern.

However we are all human and if I caught some concerning words I might be tempted to read though would not go so far as to tape back together and I wouldn't be telling anyone I'd done that but might reflect and watch and try and gather more information.

everetting · 29/08/2023 12:07

Privacy really matters. Children with no privacy don't even have the healthy outlet of writing down their feelings.

BornAWoman · 29/08/2023 12:06

Not quite the same, but when I was a teenager (about 14), I was doing my English homework, which was a story. It was a bit rubbish so I ripped the page out of my exercise book and put it in the waste basket.

The next day, when I came home from school, my parents were in the kitchen and my father started going through the binned story telling me which words and phrases were not right, and how he'd improve it.

I kept saying that it was one I'd binned, that I knew it was poor and that's why I'd binned it, but they ignored me.

Humiliating, intrusive and overstepping my boundaries. I've not forgotten and I've not forgiven.

Name changed. I hate tabloid journalism.

Blarn · 29/08/2023 12:06

No, unless there was something already I was really concerned about. I'd have been mortified if my parents have taped back together and read some of my terrible song lyrics from the age of about 10-12! Children do need privacy and space to test things out.

Itick8outof10boxes · 29/08/2023 12:06

My mum used to snoop into EVERYTHING and privacy just didn't exsist in our household. I once caught Sf who was a perv [stately homes] going through my handbag counting out from a box of condoms and announcing three had gone since he last checked !

LemonadePockets · 29/08/2023 12:05

similar thing happened to one of my relatives, they taped it back together and it was a note their child had written about being SA’d for years by a grandparent. If they never found it and taped it back together, the child would likely not be here anymore. Dramatic story but true.