Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you found a torn up piece of paper with writing on in your DC bin, would you tape it back together to read it?

183 replies

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 11:23

In this scenario what would you do:

DD is 10 years old, has their own room. Upon cleaning the room you go to empty the bin and find lots of tiny pieces of paper. It looks like an A4 piece of paper has been written on and then torn up. Obviously not wanting anyone to ready it.

Would you tape the paper back together out of concern to read it? Or would you respect that your child obviously doesn't want you reading it so leave it?

Just for context here, it's not my DC, but a family members. They taped the paper back together but I'm not sure if I agree they should've done that. Just wondered if they were being unreasonable or if most parents would do this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cascais · 02/09/2023 14:37

No

JennyCQ · 02/09/2023 14:34

Absolutely not. I wrote a letter once after watching something that said it could be beneficial if you were having a problem with someone to write down your feelings, then tear it up afterwards. So I wrote a letter to my mom, there were a few minor things (like when she promised we’d get ice cream and we didn’t, when she kept saying we’d go to the new Twilight movie and the day we went she turned to go home even though we could see the theatre and it was the last day it was showing), and a couple of more major things. I wrote down a bunch of things, then tore it up and threw it away, and I felt so much better. Until I came home from school the next day and saw the letter taped back up. My parents then shared some of the letters contents with extended family. And it still hurts when I think about that to this day. I have a good relationship with my parents now, but I’ve never forgotten that invasion of privacy. When I destroyed my hidden diary years later, I soaked the paper in water and scrubbed it so the ink wouldn’t be legible. There is zero reason to check something a child has torn and tossed, it’s a massive violation of privacy.

Totalwasteofpaper · 01/09/2023 02:25

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 12:19

Yes they told her about it. They shouted her upstairs and when she walked into her room they were sat on her bedroom floor with the paper in front of them. I'm feeling really hurt for her. She is a member of my family and we are close and she speaks to me about things that she doesn't speak to her parents about. I don't have children but I just feel like I wouldn't have done this in their shoes, I would've ignored it

This is digusting behaviour and completely wrong.

I might read it if i was concerned about my child's mentsl state but to do this is just bullying and controlling.

Please stay close to this child she will need a normal adult in her life.

oakleaffy · 01/09/2023 02:16

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 12:39

They have no reason to be concerned about her. She is well behaved, quiet, no issues that they know of, has friends, does well in school, eats well. In my original post I just meant general concern that you might have when you see a piece of paper torn up more than a few times instead of just screwed up and thrown in the bin. It clearly looked like it wasn't meant to be read from what she described. I don't know HOW they managed to put it all back together it must have taken them ages. Unless she's exaggerating how small she tore it

That's awful.
I had similar, and still cringe.

In future, advise your niece to absolutely mush any torn up writings with water, and throw them away outside of the house.
In a public bin.

It's awful that adults are invading her privacy like this.

DameCurlyBassey · 01/09/2023 01:23

Sorry, op. I didn’t read your updates.

DameCurlyBassey · 01/09/2023 01:20

It would be fantastic if it turned out to be a letter to the nosy Parker telling them
it was a test to see if they really were that nosy.

Lorelaigilless · 01/09/2023 00:24

No but my mum definitely would have done and it’s resulted in me feeling like I can never trust her

abs12 · 01/09/2023 00:19

You sound like an amazing 'aunty' x

PhantomUnicorn · 31/08/2023 11:49

i said no earlier, and i maintain my no.

My parents did it to me, i write poetry, i use it to work through my feelings about situations as part of my processing the emotions involved.

The words i use are very evocative, and the poems not always proportionate to what is going on.

I wrote one when i was 17, in the middle of my a levels about depression/suicide, and feeling like drowning, looking back it was VERY dramatic, but it helped me to write it and get those thoughts out. I ripped that one up and left it stuffed in the back of the folder i kept my poetry in
Mum decided to be nosy as she did like reading my poetry, and found it.

Next thing i know i'm being dragged into a meeting with my parents, my teacher and the pastoral/wellbeing teacher at college and being challenged over what i'd written. It was mortifying.

Sugargliderwombat · 31/08/2023 07:36

AnxiousAnniee · 29/08/2023 12:19

Yes they told her about it. They shouted her upstairs and when she walked into her room they were sat on her bedroom floor with the paper in front of them. I'm feeling really hurt for her. She is a member of my family and we are close and she speaks to me about things that she doesn't speak to her parents about. I don't have children but I just feel like I wouldn't have done this in their shoes, I would've ignored it

That's awful!!! What she must have felt in that moment, poor thing.

tuvamoodyson · 31/08/2023 07:06

purplecorkheart · 29/08/2023 11:31

Nope, I would have just emptied the bin. Don't most people just empty bins without really looking at the contents.

Maybe that was all that was in it 🤷‍♀️

oakleaffy · 31/08/2023 06:41

CallieTR · 29/08/2023 11:29

This is the kind of thing my Mum did that made my life a misery as a child and totally destroyed my trust in her.

Same here.
I had this happen, and vowed never, ever to do the same thing to DS {and never did} He's an adult now, but no way would I ever snoop at any child's writings.

Please don't, @AnxiousAnniee .

Incognitofits · 30/08/2023 21:31

roundtable · 29/08/2023 11:27

Depends on the context I guess.

Just being nosy - no.

Major concerns about the wellbeing/safety of your child - maybe/yes

Hard to say without context.

NRTFT but this. I have huge concerns about my DS. He is a twin. His twin sister is confident in every way possible, academically very successful and very much the dominant twin. My little boy in contrast is extremely under confident in every way possible. He is actually very clever but he feels he’s not as clever as her (in the same class, one form entry, not a very supportive primary school despite my best efforts). She has a whole circle of lovely friends. He struggles to make friends, largely because he just wants to be best friends with his twin. I do everything I can to support him. He is only nine but he has said things that break my heart. I wouldn’t physically tape the paper back together but I’d try to read it to see if I could covertly help him/see if I need to worry more (I’m not sure I could worry more to be honest). It’s not necessarily from a bad place.

stichguru · 30/08/2023 20:46

No unless maybe I already had big concerns.

LadyBird1973 · 30/08/2023 08:47

Given your updates, if I was the parent in this situation I still wouldn't have taped that paper back together - I'd be much more discreet about the conflict in my marriage and not arguing in front of my child. The paper doesn't contain anything they don't already know - they are fully aware the arguments are distressing their daughter but both are just being too selfish to fix it!
They need to start putting her first and either resolve their issues peacefully or call it a day!

Agapornis · 30/08/2023 00:58

Have you explained to her that she has nothing to be embarrassed about? She was honest about her feelings and that is a good thing. All feelings are valid including negative ones. I hope you tell her that she is clearly a very good writer, because her writing had the power to explain when she didn't feel able to talk, and it made her parents make a promise to try harder.

That said, no child should have to hear these arguments. Maybe she could live with you a while until they sort themselves out? Perhaps you could help her write a letter to her parents next time they argue.

BakewellGin1 · 29/08/2023 23:19

Absolutely no.
My own DM used to read personal things of mine and look through my drawers.
She read letters a boyfriend of the time sent when he was working away.
She found out I had an infection due to reading medical notes when I was admitted to hospital.
She knew I had counselling due to reading letters.
And so on....

GrammyBea · 29/08/2023 21:56

You sound lovely & just what your family member needs. I used to have an aunt who would do similar for me & just listen to me when I wasn’t heard. Over 40 years later & I adore her just as much and am very grateful for the time she spent with me.

But to answer your AIBU, yes, it is a horrible breach of her privacy but hopefully it will make them reflect on the impact of their behaviour & how they need to make positive changes.

Marezydotes · 29/08/2023 21:46

My mum used to do things like this.

I left home the first chance I could and 40 years on we are not close. Having your privacy violated damages relationships irreparably.

However - if I had concerns that a child of mine had some kind of terrible secret distress I would like to hope that I made sure they knew that they could bring problems to me without judgement.

melj1213 · 29/08/2023 21:41

I just wanted to know the answer to one simple question which was would you tape up a torn letter from your DC to read it? I purposefully didn't write a huge post containing all the details because I just wanted to simply know the answer to that one question.

But the answer will always depend on the context - it's not like you're asking a simple "Is 2+2 always 4?", you're asking a question where the answer will 100% change depending on the context of the question.

Scylax · 29/08/2023 21:35

Of course not! What a terrible invasion of privacy that would be :( my DM is genuinely one of the best people there is but she hates waste. Each week when I was a child she would go through the bins to rescue any scrap paper she could find. My embarrassment when private personal writings ended up on the backs of shopping lists, notes given to people, telephone messages etc still make me twitch now!

BustyDin · 29/08/2023 18:56

I just wanted to know the answer to one simple question which was would you tape up a torn letter from your DC to read it?

OP, you are being very obtuse here. As several people have said, the context is the crucial thing. In some situations, it would be the right thing to do. In other situations, it wouldn't. It isn't 'one simple question', and there is no blanket answer.

I can't believe you can't see this.

Fairymother · 29/08/2023 18:16

roundtable · 29/08/2023 11:27

Depends on the context I guess.

Just being nosy - no.

Major concerns about the wellbeing/safety of your child - maybe/yes

Hard to say without context.

This.

Really depends if i was worried about the child over something.

caramacyears · 29/08/2023 16:29

LemonadePockets · 29/08/2023 12:05

similar thing happened to one of my relatives, they taped it back together and it was a note their child had written about being SA’d for years by a grandparent. If they never found it and taped it back together, the child would likely not be here anymore. Dramatic story but true.

😥

Qilin · 29/08/2023 16:16

TripleDaisySummer · 29/08/2023 13:17

I never proactively go through phones etc.

We have always made it clear we reserve right to look through their phones - ones we pay for but we only have when there were serious concerns
(done once due to raised by school and proved groundless) and that child was aware and stood in front of us when we did so.

We wouldn't do that once past 16 either - though we still pay for said phones.

We had this rule.
When dd was younger and got a phone it was one of the conditions of being allowed a phone and certain apps.
We always reserved the right to have access to the phone and it's contents (including passwords) and to remove the phone if we felt there was a concern/issue where it's removal would be considered appropriate.
It was also not allowed in bedrooms at night time - had to be left downstairs charging overnight.

As it happens I have no real desire to read a ton of pre-teen messages to friends. And we had no big concerns and issues with dd and her phones, or her friendships - so we didn't actually do so.

I agree that children have a right to some privacy and personal space, but this can never be total privacy as part of a parent's role is to,safeguard their children.