Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've been incorrectly claiming UC and need to come clean

169 replies

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 02:14

I will try to keep this as short as possible whilst giving all the relevant information.

2.5 years ago after I gave birth to our second child and I was on maternity leave (from self employment) I discovered that my then-DP had been having an affair. I also discovered, after he had done a runner in the middle of the night, that he hadn't been paying the rent. He had left me with over £2500 in rent arrears that I had no idea about.

I made a single person's claim for universal credit shortly after he left so I could try to remain in the flat and show commitment to the landlord. I had been self employed (in a low skilled position earning not much more than NMW) up until the birth of my second child and we had been paying the rent through our wages 50/50 on a joint tenancy. I had a small amount of savings put aside to contribute my part of the rent whilst on maternity and he was supposed to be covering the rest. He didn't.

Within a few months I'd had a complete nervous breakdown, developed a chronic illness, lost my dad very suddenly in a traumatic way and wasn't looking after myself properly. I wasn't coping with the children so to stop them being taken away (as i was convinced they would be) I allowed him to move back in when he realised the grass wasn't greener with OW.

So this is where I fucked it all up.

Because of what he'd done to us with the rent I had no trust left in him and did not want to have to rely on any contributions from him to keep a roof over our heads. He had shown me that he could dissappear in the middle of the night, literally, and pull the rug from under our feet at a moments notice - yet I was genuinely unable to work and felt as though I needed him around as I wasn't capable of being a "good enough" mum without his support.

There are reasons for that which has its own backstory, not entirely relevant to the thread but I will go into it If necessary. Long history of abuse stemming back to my childhood and the associated MH problems and lack of self esteem you'd expect from that. However mainly it was the fact that our eldest child is disabled which makes the usual parenting struggles 10 x harder. There have been many times I have felt that I just couldn't go on and was thready to throw the towel in.

I didn't feel, or atleast was made to feel that I wouldn't be able to do any of it without him and had convinced myself, with some help from him I'm sure, that i would lose the children in one way or another.

So, I reasoned with myself that because we weren't a "proper" couple IE no longer shared a bed and I only had him there for support with the children somehow that made it OK. Of course I realise that it doesn't and I was just deluding myself so I could sleep better at night and bury my head in the sand. I'm almost certain that it would be seen as LTAMC after looking into the criteria and examples as he does contribute to the household in terms of shopping and giving me money for things the children need, food etc.

A handful of times I sat him down and said I wanted to update the claim to reflect the fact he was living with me and he was always vehemently against it. This is obviously because he doesn't want to be responsible for supporting us financially and still has one foot out of the door.

I can understand that really as there's no love/affection/intimacy between us and we are living as friends who get on one another's nerves half the time. We haven't shared a bed in years. He is either on the sofa or, his preference, an inflatable mattress in the living room. I was in touch with women's aid some time ago with regards to emotional abuse throughout the relationship and actually with the benefit of hindsight and counselling I think he has only ever contributed to my mental health problems.

With all that being said, he doesn't have great prospects when it comes to being able to afford and finance accommodation for himself. He's a low earner (only just above NMW) and we live in an expensive part of the country that he would never move away from. He would be able to afford a room in a house share, at best, so of course this current arrangement suits him just fine. It would, wouldn't It? In all likelihood he would go and lodge on his DF's sofa and probably use that as an excuse as to why he can never have the kids because you know, cock lodger

As is usually the case when somebody buries their head in the sand, things have snowballed. The longer it has gone on the more worried I've got and It has gotten to the point now that I am more scared of going to prison than I am of being on my with the kids. Either way I'm screwed.

So what the hell do I do now?

Do I come clean to the DWP and hope to god that goes in my favour? This is what I'm leaning heavily towards although they would understandably stop my benefits and no longer pay the rent. He doesn't earn enough to even pay the rent himself as it is £350 more than his total monthly take home so eventually I would lose the flat anyway.

Do I tell him I don't care what he says and I'm adding his details onto the claim as of now so that atleast from this point onwards the amount reflects what the actual entitlement would be? That would probably trigger an investigation in itself.

Or do I get him to move out and just say nothing at all repay my debt to the community somehow? This is the option I'm least in favour of as it's just more burying my head in the sand, isn't it? But I'm scared.

I think whatever happens I'm going to lose the kids as if I go to prison he isn't going to take them on himself. He's obsessed with working nights and his DF would never let him have them there. There's no way the landlord would ever let him back on the tenancy here.

I think I'd benefit from speaking to a solicitor so I'm going to make some enquiries and see whether this free 30 mins consultant we hear of is really a thing.

On an ending note I just want to say that dispite claiming incorrectly, at no point have I been living lavishly. I don't have flash technology, I don't smoke or drink, no nights out, all of my clothes are second hand the cost of living has absolutely flattened this household in spite of his wage coming in. I don't see the vast, vast majority of it or even know what he spends it on.

The shit part is - if I would have altered the claim to reflect him being present at the earliest opportunity we would have almost certainly been entitled to some financial help as he's a low earner. Of course I let him convince me that we wouldn't be but I've done my research now and know that we would have.

I've donned my hard hat and will accept the inevitable bashing as its nothing less than I deserve, although I am hoping for some genuine advice in amongst it for how I sort out this whole mess in the way that's going to cause the least amount of fallout for my DC.

Thank you 🙁

OP posts:
LovedFedAndNoonesDead · 29/08/2023 21:36

passiveaggressivenonsense · 29/08/2023 15:01

Tell him he has to leave because otherwise he'll be colluding in benefit fraud. I'm not sure what the rules are about how many nights a guest can stay over without actually living with you. Find this out and use it as a reason to get him to stay at his DF house 3 or 4 nights a week. Tell him it's the only way to keep the family financially solvent and to protect you both from benefit fraud.

Use this as an opportunity to get him out the house.

There are no rules about how many nights a week someone stays; it’s down to whether they contribute to the household - are they paying rent or are the utility bills in their name, tv subscription service; do they buy food, cook and eat together as a family; are they registered to voy there or elsewhere.

As the money the OP’s ex pays is listed as maintenance, it’s going to show any contribution is for the purpose of raising their child; if there was spousal maintenance in addition, that’s counted as “other income“ and deducted £ for £ from entitlement.

Gerrataere · 29/08/2023 15:32

passiveaggressivenonsense · 29/08/2023 15:01

Tell him he has to leave because otherwise he'll be colluding in benefit fraud. I'm not sure what the rules are about how many nights a guest can stay over without actually living with you. Find this out and use it as a reason to get him to stay at his DF house 3 or 4 nights a week. Tell him it's the only way to keep the family financially solvent and to protect you both from benefit fraud.

Use this as an opportunity to get him out the house.

Having another adult in the house doesn’t affect uc, it’s based on single or couples claim. Sometimes they’ll check that if you’re living with someone that you’re legitimately not a couple (happened to my ex years ago living with his male flat mate) but they rarely do.

Hibiscrubbed · 29/08/2023 15:27

Kick him out. Problem solved. Why are you trying to make it worse for yourself?

Vitriolinsanity · 29/08/2023 15:26

DinoMummsy · 29/08/2023 13:22

Yep, I would get him turfed out and keep your claim as it is - two problems solved in one fell swoop.

This with bells on.

BrawnWild · 29/08/2023 15:21

Think about getting him to move his stuff out so he is just sleeping on the sofa and speak unto your doctor about care options for you when you get out of hospital. They may well be able to arrange a carer a few times a day.

If he died you would have to cope and I think that's how you have to look at this. Binning him off properly.

passiveaggressivenonsense · 29/08/2023 15:01

Tell him he has to leave because otherwise he'll be colluding in benefit fraud. I'm not sure what the rules are about how many nights a guest can stay over without actually living with you. Find this out and use it as a reason to get him to stay at his DF house 3 or 4 nights a week. Tell him it's the only way to keep the family financially solvent and to protect you both from benefit fraud.

Use this as an opportunity to get him out the house.

Batalax · 29/08/2023 14:55

They won’t ask for proof of where he’s been living. Why should they? And even if they do, everything is registered at his dads address so he just says there.

Add him as if he’s just moved in now or get him to leave.

Make sure he pays maintenance if he leaves.

DragonFly98 · 29/08/2023 13:28

It reads to me that you are not a couple and he is paying you fixed maintenance.

DinoMummsy · 29/08/2023 13:22

Yep, I would get him turfed out and keep your claim as it is - two problems solved in one fell swoop.

monsteramunch · 29/08/2023 13:15

Gerrataere · 29/08/2023 13:10

Look op, if it makes you feel better then ring uc and explain that your ex will be in your home for the next 5 weeks due to your upcoming operation but he will be making other arrangements (whether he knows it or not) after. That way your backside is covered but you don’t have to add him to the claim. Tell them you’re happy to proof of your upcoming operation to show the nature of it means you/your children will need additional help for a while. Tell them he’s sleeping on the sofa during this time. I’m 99% their response will be ‘Righto’.

This sounds like a sensible course of action I think.

Gerrataere · 29/08/2023 13:10

Look op, if it makes you feel better then ring uc and explain that your ex will be in your home for the next 5 weeks due to your upcoming operation but he will be making other arrangements (whether he knows it or not) after. That way your backside is covered but you don’t have to add him to the claim. Tell them you’re happy to proof of your upcoming operation to show the nature of it means you/your children will need additional help for a while. Tell them he’s sleeping on the sofa during this time. I’m 99% their response will be ‘Righto’.

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 13:10

My local CAB have closed their in-person drop in service which is crap as I was hoping to go in today. I'm going to call them now and find out how I go about being seen.

OP posts:
Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 13:05

I think he's trying to put me off the idea of adding him to the claim by catastrophising about what would happen if I do, IE they would investigate and explore the possibility that he has been here all along.

I agree with those of you who say that not adding him to the claim and telling him to leave is the best way to proceed, although i do need him here for the next 5 weeks or so at the very least as I'll be recovering from surgery and not able to do everything for the kids by myself. I wouldn't put it past him to deliberately stick two fingers up to me and refuse to help out if I send him packing now. I don't have any family support.

So that leaves me with one of two options, on3 being to do nothing until after my surgery and then get him to leave, but that would mean I'm still commiting fraud for the next couple of months which I really don't want hanging over me so on that basis adding him to the claim in whatever capacity for the interim felt like the safest option.

God what a bloody mess I'm such an idiot.

OP posts:
Anactor · 29/08/2023 12:43

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 12:28

He said he will go onto the claim but thinks I'll regret it because they will ask him for proof of where he has been living until now, does that sound right?

In other words, he’s threatening you. “You’ll regret it” is a threat.

Especially since he’s the person who previously refused to make this a joint claim.

I’m joining in the chorus of ‘do not make a joint claim with this man’. You need to talk to the Woman’s Aid or Refuge helpline and you need to talk to CAB. Now.

gamerchick · 29/08/2023 12:43

What he does do is transfer me some money every time he gets paid and that is his contribution to the food shopping and anything to do with the children. If DWP were to look into my banking they would see that

He's giving you child support.

Don't update the claim. You aren't a couple are you? Tell him to leave. He's a liability.

greyhairnomore · 29/08/2023 12:43

I'd tell him to leave he sounds useless

Gerrataere · 29/08/2023 12:36

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 12:28

He said he will go onto the claim but thinks I'll regret it because they will ask him for proof of where he has been living until now, does that sound right?

For the last time, do not add him! Why on earth would you want to make a joint claim with this man? You should be arranging for him to leave not pretending you’re a couple, which will actually leave you financially worse off and even more tied to him.

UC will ask when he moved in but they wont check if it was last week or last year if you give them a date.

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 12:28

He said he will go onto the claim but thinks I'll regret it because they will ask him for proof of where he has been living until now, does that sound right?

OP posts:
Anactor · 29/08/2023 12:07

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 11:37

Of course I don't, I'm just worried that if I don't add him onto the claim now I'm making things worse for myself.

I'm going to speak to him before I speak to the DWP and if he refuses to cooperate then he will have to go now as I don't want it hanging over my head any longer.

The timing is just shit as I do need him here for my surgery but he isn't the most reasonable person so I don't know if I'll be able to rely on him if he leaves now. I should have done this already instead of burying my head in the sand.

We'll see what he says.

You must talk to the CAB before you call the DWP. If he refuses to be added to a joint claim it’s proof he doesn’t consider himself your partner - your next step is to tell him to go. Bluntly, he’s freeloading on you and the kids and endangering their accommodation and their support.

Discuss the situation- not sharing a bed, persistent refusal to open a joint claim - with the CAB. You are taking legal advice because you thought yours was a single claim and are now uncertain what the situation was when your Ex ended up sleeping on the couch for months. You can also ask them what kind of support you’ll need for your op.

Once you know what they advise, then you contact UC (if CAB say this should have been a joint claim) and explain that you have now found out that you should have made a joint claim, and your ex has refused to do so.

You have to tell him to go. It’s put your own oxygen mask on first time - this ‘man’ is not supporting you, you’re supporting him.

WelfareRights · 29/08/2023 12:06

I agree with PP. From reading your posts you need to ask him to leave.

Having said that it's not at all clear you are actually a couple for benefits purposes (assuming you are not married?).

DWP should use a range of factors when deciding whether someone is a cohabiting. No one factor in itself is conclusive as it's your overall relationship and your particular circumstances that should be looked at. "Do you live in the same household?" Is only one of the factors. The others are:

-Do you have a sexual relationship?
-What are your financial arrangements?
-Is your relationship stable?
-Do you have children?
-How do you appear in public.

In addition, the emotional aspect of the relationship (your interdependence, devotion, love and affection) should also be considered.

From what you have said you are not ticking a lot of those boxes. Re the financial arrangements, you don't share finances, and I would argue that his contribution is just for his costs (ie his food) and maintenance for the children. You don't have a joint bank account and it sounds that you aren't making joint financial decisions..."There is a difference between on the one hand paying a fixed weekly contribution or rigidly sharing bills 50/50 (which does not suggest cohabitation) and, on the other hand, a common fund for income and expenditure (which might)."

Ideally if you are making a single claim in these or similar circumstances, you would have declared his presence upfront and asked DWP to make a decision on your single claim (having made an argument based on all of the above); however you are past that point now.

I think PPs are right in that you should just ask him to move out.

If not, one further option is to declare his presence now and try to make the argument for the single claim. You would need to provide an explanation as to why you didn't do this earlier. I would say that you thought you weren't a couple for benefits purposes (which you have said in your OP "you aren't a proper couple") and have recently sought advice suggesting you should still declare you ex's presence or similar). Whatever you say needs to be true of course.

You could wait and see if DWP pick this up themselves but this is likely to lead to compliance processes and could mean your benefit is suspended potentially for months while you try to argue your case. You'll be on the back foot there too and make the argument trickier. Plus the process isn't particularly pleasant.

And finally of course you can add him to the claim.

Personally if I were you I'd ask him to leave. It sounds like this arrangement is better for him than you and he's causing you all this angst and stress. If he leaves you can draw a line in the sand and move forward. If DWP ever query it (unlikely if he's moved out) you can argue you were never a couple during the period in question and he was just staying with you temporarily.

Gerrataere · 29/08/2023 11:40

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 11:37

Of course I don't, I'm just worried that if I don't add him onto the claim now I'm making things worse for myself.

I'm going to speak to him before I speak to the DWP and if he refuses to cooperate then he will have to go now as I don't want it hanging over my head any longer.

The timing is just shit as I do need him here for my surgery but he isn't the most reasonable person so I don't know if I'll be able to rely on him if he leaves now. I should have done this already instead of burying my head in the sand.

We'll see what he says.

You’re not in a relationship, you are entitled to single claim. You don’t need to ring DWP you just need to get rid of him as a deadweight!

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 11:37

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/08/2023 11:30

You will get nothing at all.

Because he's not going to submit his details to be added to the claim. Without his full consent and participation, all payments will stop.

Why are you wanting to leave yourself and your children without rent or food?

Of course I don't, I'm just worried that if I don't add him onto the claim now I'm making things worse for myself.

I'm going to speak to him before I speak to the DWP and if he refuses to cooperate then he will have to go now as I don't want it hanging over my head any longer.

The timing is just shit as I do need him here for my surgery but he isn't the most reasonable person so I don't know if I'll be able to rely on him if he leaves now. I should have done this already instead of burying my head in the sand.

We'll see what he says.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/08/2023 11:30

You will get nothing at all.

Because he's not going to submit his details to be added to the claim. Without his full consent and participation, all payments will stop.

Why are you wanting to leave yourself and your children without rent or food?

Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 11:29

I've just told him I'm adding him to the claim today. He said he'll talk to me when he gets back. How readily he accepts that will determine what happens next. If he refuses to have any involvement with UC he will have to move out now. I will update the thread after we've discussed it.

OP posts:
Helpneededpls · 29/08/2023 11:22

Thank you all for the replies it's very helpful.

I'm going to look at the Entitled To calculator this afternoon and look at the financials of adding him to the claim so I can stop panicking from this point onwards. I don't suppose anybody would be able to give a rough estimate based on the following would they? The rent is £1700 (standard 2 bed flat but expensive because of the city we're in) and he brings between £1200 and £1300 If the figures he gives me are accurate.

I'm having surgery during the first week of September and it's quite a risky one (neuro) so I can say he is moving in ahead of this to help me.

Something that may be of benefit to me is that I haven't named him on the birth certificate of my youngest. That was deliberate on my part as I didn't want him having PR and disappearing with the kids. I'd found out that he had taken them both to see OW multiple times, DD being a literal newborn, and was worried / paranoid he'd take them away from me. It's a shame I didn't do the same with DC1 but everything was great between us then and there was no need to worry about things like this. DWP have never asked me about the paternity of DC2.

He does have all of his stuff in the flat but sets up his sleeping area in the living room.

He transfers me an amount every month with the reference "maintenance" which I then add to the months budget and use accordingly.

I've gone back into my emails from our correspondence last year and got the email address of women's aid. I'm going to send them another email for some guidance on extracting myself from the situation as I'm sure they've seen it all before.

I've got the number for CAB and I'm going to call shortly and ask for an appointment.

Somebody asked how my mental health was at the moment, it's not great. I received a pretty scary diagnosis earlier on in the year and have been waiting for surgery for that which has been hard. I've had to go NC from my last remaining parent due to alcoholism so don't have anybody else around me for support now. I'm a regular on the boards talking about all that stuff and some will recognise me. It's all a bit shit.

If I'm honest with myself I think my current panic about all of this stuff is my brains way of distracting myself from the other things that I really need to be worrying about right now iykwim? I've got my op in just over a week and have had to get my ducks in a row for that and it's all quite daunting. The other day I spent 7 hours straight panicking similarly about an idiot neighbour sending me arsey voice notes so I can understand that people think my worry is disproportionate as afterwards I thought what on earth is the matter with me that I'm wasting an entire day fretting about that rubbish when I should be doing XYZ.

So the plan for today is to get onto CAB, womens aid for advice and once all of that has been done and I know what I'm looking at I'm going to update my journal with a change of circumstances and declare him moving in.

I can assess the long term plan after my surgery.

Thank you all so much I do feel a bit more grounded for speaking about it. I couldn't sleep until almost 4am this morning my anxiety was so bad.

OP posts: