Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

can't work out if dsd had us over on rent

44 replies

todaysusernameisthis · 28/08/2023 23:50

think dsd has had us over on rent but not sure if it's on purpose or if i am miscalculating etc not keen on bringing it up to dh until i am for certain. dsd lives with us and pays rent, she usually pays on the 25th after being paid but then the date randomly changed to the 3rd of the month after and then not again until the 25th, which would mean 1 month was skipped wouldn't it? not sure if i am unreasonable to even mention it tbh

don't want to drip feed but my ds (previous marriage but 6 years older than dsd) always paid his rent and it wasn't ever negotiable so it isn't a case of me being ridiculous to care about 1 month etc just want it to be fair on him too.

thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ricekrispi · 29/08/2023 19:36

I paid my DM rent for the short window I lived at home after university and there is not a chance she'd have let me off a payment and she could very much afford it.

Ýsette · 29/08/2023 19:29

@todaysusernameisthis get her to pay weekly but it will cost her more in the long run

Ýsette · 29/08/2023 19:28

FFSDILIGAF · 29/08/2023 00:14

Oh for god sake. Who cares! I highly doubt your husband will appreciate you embarrassing his daughter. It's supposed to be a token gesture isnt it. How old is she?

My DSD came to visit this weekend. She hasnt used money once and her dad filled her car for her way home. She's 27. She could come live here at any point to save her money.

Well lucky old you to be able to afford it. There is a CoL crisis. She lives there, she should pay her way yes

Truemilk · 29/08/2023 08:44

I'd leave it this time but if she does it again mention it to your dh

SleepingStandingUp · 29/08/2023 08:24

So 25th January, 3rd March, 25th April? So yes 1 month missing

But how long ago was it and does DSD have form for trying to trick you and get away with stuff? Are they generally disrespectful? Are they skint but scared to tell you because you'll go off at them?

AnSolas · 29/08/2023 08:00

FFSDILIGAF · 29/08/2023 00:50

That's a big leap @AnSolas. The kid obviously has something going on thats shes been too embarrassed to talk about.

I'd be asking her if she was ok financially rather than making accusations.

That said, there's obviously a back story due to OPs crappy attitude towards here DSD.

Its not a leap the DSD made an agreement to pay rent. Its owed the same way she would owe a LL the money.

The kid is an adult if there is an obvious back story then she can tell her Dad, who should the OP, that she is behind in the rent but will catch up. She would have to discuss that with LL or housemate if she was in house share with strangers.

I dont get why the OP has to be the baddie chasing the DSD. If the OP has to come to MN to work out if a months rent is due or not then she is obviously finds the financial admin difficult. If the OP has difficulty working out her financial position and her DH has not noticed I am guessing that OP is left doing the life admin. If both DH and DSD came to an agreement it is very disrespectful of them both not to have informed the OP of it.

The OP is funding living costs that DSD agreed to fund, if it would not be socially acceptable to do that to a LL or a housemate why is it fine to do that with family?

__
So yes if the money is owed not paying it is stealing from family.

Autieangel · 29/08/2023 05:41

I'd write it all down and show dh from a perspective of "I think dad accidentally missed a payment..." then decide what to do together.

Tbh tho it's likely your dad knows it's happening as the extra money is still in his account.

RedHelenB · 29/08/2023 05:21

todaysusernameisthis · 29/08/2023 00:04

do you think doing that 3rd payment was to throw us off? or do i just casually mention it to dh to be safe and not accusing

Do you need the money? If not I wouldn't make an issue out of it unless ot happens again.

Trez1510 · 29/08/2023 04:50

The question you need. to ask yourself OP is would you automatically think your son had 'had you over' had the same happened with his payments? Or would you be concerned he had something going on? FWIW I don't believe you'd be making accusations about him either to your husband or on here.

shitt · 29/08/2023 03:46

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 29/08/2023 03:42

You seem a little confused by the timings so write down all the payments to work out properly if one is missing

Make sure you write down the time period the money covers too eg

25 December to 24 January was paid on 25 January
25 January to 24 February was paid on 3 March.
25 February to 24 March was paid on 25 April.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 29/08/2023 03:42

You seem a little confused by the timings so write down all the payments to work out properly if one is missing

Riverlee · 29/08/2023 03:42

I think if it’s a one-off, then let it go (if you can afford it). It was probably an oversight.

However, if it happens again, then maybe write down the payments like above, and explain she’s missed it.

Dillane · 29/08/2023 02:33

You don’t sound as though you like your DSD very much OP.

LovelyQuiche · 29/08/2023 01:49

I’m ashamed to say that I tried this trick with my parents when I lived with them. I was 22 at the time and very poor. They saw through the trick though

BillaBongGirl · 29/08/2023 01:39

think dsd has had us over on rent but not sure if it's on purpose or if i am miscalculating etc not keen on bringing it up to dh until i am for certain

Those aren’t the only two options. Her dad could have made an arrangement on the side where she could skip rent one month and didn’t mention it to you. Or she could have paid her dad in cash and he spent it instead of depositing it. Or she covered a separate expense her dad would normally cover like eyes/teeth and her dad said, oh if you pay for that don’t worry about rent that month.

It’s a tad odd that your mind goes straight to “think dsd has had us over” almost as if you think she is a natural born thief? You might want to reflect on your opinion of your DSD and why you jumped to such a conclusion.

And then you say like you don’t want to say anything “until I am for certain” - but how can you be certain of anything without talking to DSD or her dad?

Personally, she’s your DSD and I’d say that rent is between her and her Dad so I’d leave it be and not say anything. If her dad says something it’s easy to say, oh I didn’t think nothing of it, I thought you and DSD had come to some agreement for that month, why is there a problem?

Glorifried · 29/08/2023 01:11

Will you DH want to chase her for the money? If not, I'd be inclined to let it go this time but keep a spreadsheet for future payments.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 29/08/2023 01:05

Isn't it more likely that she gets paid at the end of the month (so after 25th) so moved it to the beginning of the month. I'm sure she didn't deliberately seek to do you out of money. I can't imagine thinking like that. Mention it in a neutral way if you need the money, no need to make more of it than it need be.

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 29/08/2023 01:03

FFSDILIGAF · 29/08/2023 00:50

That's a big leap @AnSolas. The kid obviously has something going on thats shes been too embarrassed to talk about.

I'd be asking her if she was ok financially rather than making accusations.

That said, there's obviously a back story due to OPs crappy attitude towards here DSD.

Wow. You got all that from OPs posts? Can you tell me next weeks winning lottery numbers as well since you seem to be all seeing, all knowing 🙄

FFSDILIGAF · 29/08/2023 00:50

That's a big leap @AnSolas. The kid obviously has something going on thats shes been too embarrassed to talk about.

I'd be asking her if she was ok financially rather than making accusations.

That said, there's obviously a back story due to OPs crappy attitude towards here DSD.

MindfulBear · 29/08/2023 00:44

What do you mean "you want it to be fair on your DS"?
What does fair mean?
If he earns £100k a year and she earns £25k a year....... then fair might mean checking she is ok rather than chasing a missing week or a missing month.....
And clearly you don't need the money or you would know whether you were missing a week or a month......

Tbh your post and subsequent additions don't make you sound very nice.

Or there is more to the story you are not sharing.....

Tbh your best bet is to share the bank statement with your OH and asking him to tell you whether his daughter is up to date with her rent.....

AnSolas · 29/08/2023 00:43

FFSDILIGAF · 29/08/2023 00:26

OP doesnt appear to be strapped for cash. Her main concern seems to be fairness to her OWN son.

Sounds like it @KajsaKavat

Why do you think it is ok to steal from family?

OP if you were being paid in advance the payment on the 25th would be for the next month
So
Jan 25 th pays Feb rent
Feb 25 th no payment for Mar
Mar 3 rd pays Mar rent
Mar 25 th no payment for Apr
Apr 3 rd no payment for Apr
Apr 25 th pays Apr rent in arrears
May 3 rd no payment for May
May 25 th pays May rent in arrears

shitt · 29/08/2023 00:40

todaysusernameisthis · 29/08/2023 00:04

do you think doing that 3rd payment was to throw us off? or do i just casually mention it to dh to be safe and not accusing

Girl it’s basic maths, it really isn’t hard to work out. Landlords around the world manage, so can you

shitt · 29/08/2023 00:39

It’s not that hard to work out. Can you write out the dates for us? It’s different if she paid for January on 25/01/23 and paid for February on 03/02/23 vs 03/03/23

DarkDayforMN · 29/08/2023 00:39

todaysusernameisthis · 29/08/2023 00:04

do you think doing that 3rd payment was to throw us off? or do i just casually mention it to dh to be safe and not accusing

Why would you assume she was trying to throw you off, instead of assuming she got confused with the dates herself?

Does she have form for being sly and deceitful? Definitely don’t say
you think it was deliberate, you’ll end up looking bad even if you’re right - because if you’re right, she is manipulative and sneaky enough to use the accusation against you. Just assume the best and ask for her to fix it!

FFSDILIGAF · 29/08/2023 00:38

@EinyLinky Because she cant figure out if the money is missing. Ive lived on both ends of the scale. If the OP needed the money she would have figured out that it was missing in that same month because she would have needed it to pay a bill.

It doesnt matter because it's one month. It's not like the poor kid is lounging around for free on a permanent basis.