Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to walk in a country park at 8:30-10pm on my own?

359 replies

danniegrace · 28/08/2023 21:06

dh annoyed at this suggestion by me and said he will be really annoyed if i do it as he will worry the whole time. we have a pretty high energy dog and the best time for his longer walk is simply in the evening time, dog is with me all day but i am a carer for a relative so with them all day, dh does take dog out in the morning but he needs another walk again in the evening and i just prefer somewhere than a pavement walk or small park... i am a fully grown woman in my late 20s. i know this sounds weird but there has been absolutely no crimes there that have come up in any sort of news, at all, not even over a decade ago, its a rather open country park vs very woodlandy. would you do it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RomeoandJomeo · 02/09/2023 23:25

CurlyhairedAssassin · 02/09/2023 10:02

How do you respond appropriately and carry on with your day if sometime appears from nowhere with a knife to rob you or sexually assault you?

Well that's never happened to me, so I've no idea how I'd respond in that situation. But in my experience fear is an anticipatory emotion - it's easy to whip yourself up into a state of fear when imagining what might happen, but when I've actually found myself in potentially hairy situations I've not actually been afraid, and have so far always responded in a way that has diffused things. It's often felt quite mundane at the time, and only afterwards have I realised how scary it sounds.
As an example, when a female friend and I were students we hitchhiked up to NW Scotland to go backpacking. On our first night we were in Glasgow, and were dropped off at a country park next to the motorway with a deserted campsite. We set up in the furthest corner, as we intended to leave early and wanted to avoid paying / being seen, and as we were doing so a slightly odd man who was staying in a static caravan in another part of the park saw us and came over to chat. He returned at about 3am, and in my sleepy state I remember telling my friend to ignore him as he was just being annoying before going back to sleep... obviously that could have ended very differently, but I wasn't actually scared at the time. It certainly didn't put me off camping, and in fact I didn't really give it another thought until much later when something reminded me of the incident and I realised that it was potentially pretty scary.

midgemadgemodge · 02/09/2023 10:17

You can't live you life being scared of events that are unlikely to happen

You are MUCH more likely to be in a serious car crash than robbed at knifepoint ( common sense reading of that required )

Sone people are afraid of their own shadow following them , people smiling at them when they walk past, people not smiling at them when they walk past , being automatically threatened by someone big or young, people with disabilities walking past ( all seen in MN over the last year )

Women in particular have been trained to have a warped sense of risk that can limit what they do - walking outside in nature is brilliant exercise for mental and physical health - if you won't do it after dark ( so after work in winter ) it's very restrictive and harmful - but somehow that a risk you are prepared to take

I think because inaction feels safer than choosing to do something ?

CurlyhairedAssassin · 02/09/2023 10:02

RomeoandJomeo · 01/09/2023 16:55

Great post. I think you're spot on about it being a patriarchal attitude about women needing protecting, and actually the flip side of the same coin that tolerates violence against women / turns a blind eye to 'low level' sexual harassment. The statistics show that men ARE more at risk of violent attack than women, but men are allowed to take risks that us poor vulnerable women need protecting from.
I'm aware that part of the reason that I have quite a gung ho attitude here is that in all my years of walking where I wanted, hitching alone, wild camping and so on, nothing bad has happened to me... except, reading some of these posts, I have realised that several of the things people are citing as reasons to be fearful have happened to me, but at the time I responded in the way that felt appropriate and sensible, and carried on with my day.

How do you respond appropriately and carry on with your day if sometime appears from nowhere with a knife to rob you or sexually assault you?

Robinni · 02/09/2023 09:32

I think the issue here is “opportunity”, if you go out and walk the dog at a set time, vary your route frequently and stay in well lit areas adjacent to houses/shops/busy places it is probably fine.

If you go out at the same time, take the same route through a park where it isn’t well lit, there are no people about etc…. Well you are a sitting duck if someone decides they want to attack you.

Personally, I don’t go out alone after about 9/9.30pm. Whoever posted about men being at risk as well is right; a man was raped in a local park near me about midnight, it happens.

RomeoandJomeo · 01/09/2023 16:59

RomeoandJomeo · 01/09/2023 16:55

Great post. I think you're spot on about it being a patriarchal attitude about women needing protecting, and actually the flip side of the same coin that tolerates violence against women / turns a blind eye to 'low level' sexual harassment. The statistics show that men ARE more at risk of violent attack than women, but men are allowed to take risks that us poor vulnerable women need protecting from.
I'm aware that part of the reason that I have quite a gung ho attitude here is that in all my years of walking where I wanted, hitching alone, wild camping and so on, nothing bad has happened to me... except, reading some of these posts, I have realised that several of the things people are citing as reasons to be fearful have happened to me, but at the time I responded in the way that felt appropriate and sensible, and carried on with my day.

Intended to quote previous post, but this one follows on directly...

RomeoandJomeo · 01/09/2023 16:55

Minglingpringle · 01/09/2023 11:54

And men are just as at risk as women. Maybe they are raped less but very nasty things can happen to them. And that shouldn’t just be dismissed - it would be awful for a man you loved to be attacked. But they don’t feed themselves the same narrative about hiding away, so they feel freer. Invincible even, accompanying those poor little women when they need to walk home and obviously can’t do it alone.

Great post. I think you're spot on about it being a patriarchal attitude about women needing protecting, and actually the flip side of the same coin that tolerates violence against women / turns a blind eye to 'low level' sexual harassment. The statistics show that men ARE more at risk of violent attack than women, but men are allowed to take risks that us poor vulnerable women need protecting from.
I'm aware that part of the reason that I have quite a gung ho attitude here is that in all my years of walking where I wanted, hitching alone, wild camping and so on, nothing bad has happened to me... except, reading some of these posts, I have realised that several of the things people are citing as reasons to be fearful have happened to me, but at the time I responded in the way that felt appropriate and sensible, and carried on with my day.

SuperNewMe · 01/09/2023 15:51

CharlotteBog · 01/09/2023 15:15

...and just another thing to bloody well organise.

I just want to bung some shoes on and clear off. I'm not an introvert, but I truly value and need the time when I can be sure not one single bugger will ask anything of me!

Ha, true - that as well! 😁

CharlotteBog · 01/09/2023 15:15

SuperNewMe · 01/09/2023 14:59

Some people like their alone time though.
I know I do, and a pp has said so too.
Would hate to have to make small talk with a neighbour or friend rather than be with my own thoughts, would feel a bit chaperoned.
Some of us are introverts and just need to go out by ourselves sometimes 😁

...and just another thing to bloody well organise.

I just want to bung some shoes on and clear off. I'm not an introvert, but I truly value and need the time when I can be sure not one single bugger will ask anything of me!

DepartureLounge · 01/09/2023 15:00

Good for you, OP. Lots of us would be nervous about this, but in all honesty I think the risk is not that great, probably rather less than walking somewhere more populated at night. YWNBU if you were too scared to do it either, and no one here who feels that way should berate themselves for their reluctance to take an unnecessary risk. But imo no one should be trying to talk you out of something you want to do and feel confident about, least of all your dh, who shouldn't be making you responsible for the management of his emotions, particularly when his position is fundamentally illogical (assuming he'd be okay with you walking the dog in a country park during the day).

SuperNewMe · 01/09/2023 14:59

Rosieroe · 01/09/2023 11:40

Can you ask friends and/or neighbours who might like the opportunity to have company for a little early evening exercise to get their step count up if they would like to join you? Also a good way to make closer friendships.

Some people like their alone time though.
I know I do, and a pp has said so too.
Would hate to have to make small talk with a neighbour or friend rather than be with my own thoughts, would feel a bit chaperoned.
Some of us are introverts and just need to go out by ourselves sometimes 😁

SuperNewMe · 01/09/2023 14:53

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 01/09/2023 14:24

He's allowed to be worried but he's not allowed to use that worry to control her actions. If she wants to go and walk the dog at 8.30pm then that's entirely her decision. It's nothing to do with him.

Well said

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 01/09/2023 14:24

DameCurlyBassey · 01/09/2023 14:18

Nah. Sounds like he’s just nervous something will happen to his dp. I doubt he wants to keep her under lock and key. If he did he wouldn’t have partnered with someone as independent as op.

He's allowed to be worried but he's not allowed to use that worry to control her actions. If she wants to go and walk the dog at 8.30pm then that's entirely her decision. It's nothing to do with him.

NerrSnerr · 01/09/2023 14:21

@DameCurlyBassey of course anyone being murdered is terrible and shouldn't happen but the way some talk on threads like this suggests that there are murderers waiting to pounce and women are being killed by strangers every day which isn't happening.

Women are being murdered by people they know all the fucking time (most days) but stranger attacks are a lot rarer.

DameCurlyBassey · 01/09/2023 14:18

AcesBaseballbat · 29/08/2023 19:38

Well yeah because we're not living in Gilead.

Personally I'd find a man saying he'd be "really annoyed" if his wife disobeyed his commands to be more of a red flag for risk than going for a walk.

(Not implying your husband is abusive, OP. But I wouldn't be happy to have a partner tell me he'd be "really annoyed" if I didn't let him dictate when I'm allowed to leave my own house.)

Nah. Sounds like he’s just nervous something will happen to his dp. I doubt he wants to keep her under lock and key. If he did he wouldn’t have partnered with someone as independent as op.

DameCurlyBassey · 01/09/2023 14:16

6 too many.

DameCurlyBassey · 01/09/2023 14:15

Rosieroe · 01/09/2023 11:40

Can you ask friends and/or neighbours who might like the opportunity to have company for a little early evening exercise to get their step count up if they would like to join you? Also a good way to make closer friendships.

This is a brilliant idea.

dottiedodah · 01/09/2023 14:10

Apart from obvious risk from predatory males ,I always worry about falling over in the dark as well.There are lumps and bumps on the ground you may not see.Why not take him out on his lead a bit earlier just round the local area.We should be able to walk whenever we like ,but sadly dont live in a perfect world!

Minglingpringle · 01/09/2023 13:57

To go back to the original question, I think the best kind of love frees up the other person to do what they want and sucks up any worry it might cause. A relationship should enhance life, not limit it. Ask yourself this question: if your husband enjoyed a dangerous sport such as mountain climbing, would you be happy for him to do it just because he wanted to, even though you might worry every time? Would you “let” him do it? If the answer is yes, he should afford you the same respect. If the answer is no then maybe you guys have a different dynamic, but it would seem like an uncomfortable one to me.

WaitTheNoo · 01/09/2023 13:53

I have done before but I had a massive wolf-hybrid who would act as enough of a deterrent. With a "normal" dog I wouldn't. I know people are saying you're more likely to be attacked etc in town but at least there is a higher chance of cars passing and houses to knock on. Happened to a wee girl locally a couple of weeks ago and it was only thanks to two young lads being able to run to the road and flag down cars that the guy was caught (and dealt with appropriately before the police arrived). Imagine that in the middle of a country park.

ReginaRegina · 01/09/2023 13:45

14yo not 24yo

ReginaRegina · 01/09/2023 13:40

DoraSpenlow · 31/08/2023 09:09

I'm sorry but we are more vulnerable than men. Men are stronger than us. That's one of the arguments against trans women in women's sports.

Many years ago I worked with a woman who did judo. I don't know what level but she had been doing it for years. She had a conversation with a male colleague saying that she could hold her own against any man because of her training. He didn't agree. A couple of weeks after that he came up behind her in the office and she was on the floor before she knew where she was. She complained that she didn't see him coming so couldn't react, he said that most attackers didn't give you advance warning. It all ended well because they eventually got married.

I also think that men who walk alone in isolated places in the dark are putting themselves at risk.

You're better off being weaker with a low chance of being attacked than stronger with a much higher possibility. Physical strength is irrelevant if you're not attacked.

Most thugs tend to pick fights they think they can win and will also probably have more fighting experience than the average non violent bloke. And that's before we even consider knives. Do you really think that guy who was fatally stabbed by a 24yo a few months back wasn't stronger than the kid?

CharlotteBog · 01/09/2023 12:46

The suggestions to find someone to walk with would make the whole exercise pointless for me. Most of the walking I do around my village is on my own, the purpose being to have some time alone. I purposely wait until it's dark so that I know I will not meet anyone.
I head over the fields often around 11pm and in all the years I've done so have not met a single person. I am quite highly strung and get myself in all sorts of pickles day to day - my solitary walking is very, very good for me (and thus the people around me).

I enjoy running at night, too, and personally feel safer as the biggest danger is from the traffic and at night I can see the lights.

I listen to the news and make my own informed decisions.

midgemadgemodge · 01/09/2023 12:09

Men are at greater risk

Men are much more likely to be attacked and get injured than women

They just get raped less

Although actually most violence against women happens in the home or with people they already know

Stranger violence is much more likely to happen to a man and being over six foot won't help when there are three of them attacking you

AllllTheQuestions · 01/09/2023 12:04

Yep. I’d do it. I am not scared of my own shadow, I take a walking tracker with me and tell my husband where I go. I often jog in an evening as I work long hours.

FoodFann · 01/09/2023 12:01

Minglingpringle · 01/09/2023 11:54

And men are just as at risk as women. Maybe they are raped less but very nasty things can happen to them. And that shouldn’t just be dismissed - it would be awful for a man you loved to be attacked. But they don’t feed themselves the same narrative about hiding away, so they feel freer. Invincible even, accompanying those poor little women when they need to walk home and obviously can’t do it alone.

A great big strong 6 foot 5 man is just at risk as a 5 foot 1 woman? Really? You need to get your head checked.

Swipe left for the next trending thread