Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a ban on dangerous dogs as pets?

141 replies

humanity15 · 28/08/2023 20:05

I feel this is a matter of public safety and people need to be informed.

Whilst working for a well known dog rescue charity I was attacked by a breed banned in many countries, but not here.
Because it was not banned it was taken in just like any other dog.

My story can be found on youtube.

With many years of experience in the dog sector what I see happening on our streets right now is frightening.

Those advising the government on dangerous dogs are giving bad advice and as a result putting people's lives at risk.

People do not understand dogs, especially genetics. Because of this attacks will keep happening and people are going to get killed.

All dogs have inherited characteristics. Certain ones are stronger in certain breeds depending on what they were originally bred for.

Although all dogs can bite, there is a huge difference in why they bite and this unless understood could prove fatal.

To communicate a dog will often give signals. So if it feels uncomfortable with someone coming too close it may put its ears back, cower, tuck its tail in etc.
If these signs are ignored the dog may resort to biting as a last resort.
Once it has effectively communicated, with the person moving away it will stop.

This is totally different to a dog biting because it has been bred to fight and has a strong drive to do so.

This drive has been bred into certain breeds of dogs on purpose. How strong that drive will be different for every individual dog depending on what has been passed down.
No amount of good will is going to change this.
This is your starting point before any external influences.

Instead of breeding that instinct out what we are now seeing is the result of the opposite having been done.
Individual dogs that have shown high aggression have been bred from resulting in literally ticking timebombs now out on our streets.

No amount of cute photos or affection will change this.
No dog trainer or behaviourist no matter how good can do anything because this is in the dogs genes.
All that can be done is for this instinct to be surpressed, it cannot be removed.
At some point under certain circumstances it will come out.

If you have a dog with a high drive to fight you could be in serious trouble and so can anyone who encounters that dog.

When it takes sometimes five people and tazers to get a dog off someone that is serious.

  • This is what people are not being told but what they need to know.

Dogs are not good or bad, they just are.

Just because a dog brings you something because it was bred to retrieve does not make it bad.
This is the same for a dog bred to fight. It is doing what we have basically programmed it to do.
The fact we see one instinct as acceptable and one not is not the dogs fault, it is ours.
We are the ones who have brought both these dogs into our homes and labelled them as pets.
Certain dogs should never have been expected to fulfil this role.

Dogs are not morally driven, they will not sit and contemplate what they are about to do they just react.

They have the mental age of a toddler, a young child at best.

It is so important we understand and remember this to keep everyone safe.

https://youtu.be/mHREm4pO-CI?feature=shared

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Ascendant15 · 28/08/2023 21:16

Furryrug · 28/08/2023 20:31

That's awful, the Dogs Trust should be investigated, they have a duty of care to their staff.

They certainly do. And I am sure that there will be an investigation as soon as the OP (who is clearly an expert in dogs) stops posting anonymous and unverifiable "facts". There are plenty of avenues, including the Health & Safety Executive, where workplace accidents not only can be reported, but often they must be reported.

Alarmist (and in many places factually inaccurate) posts and the most incredibly boring YouTube video imaginable created by anonymous sources do not make a good basis for judgements or public policy.

Of course, it's easy to attack a charity and give them no possible comeback when you remain anonymous. If this matters so much OP, come out and make it all public in person instead of hiding behind anonymity. Until that happens this is nothing more than another goady thread.

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2023 21:12

Deja vu ... we were here 30 years ago.

Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 28/08/2023 21:06

I’m all for banning breeds, I also think everyone who owns a dog should have a licence and have to pass a basic care and handling course before they are allowed them. Same for cats. Plus all should be spayed:neutered.
Mainly from a looking out for the animals point of view.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 28/08/2023 21:05

Ban that type of dog by all means - but you can guarantee another type will come along right after it to fill the void

Absolutely. And the OP is a case in point because most people reading it (and some on this thread already) will assume it refers to Bull breeds. It doesn’t. The OP is referring to an Ovcharka. I’ve long thought that guardian breeds are simply not suited to being pets and, given any kind of restriction on the Bull breed of choice for the kind of moron who should never own a Yorkshire Terrier let alone a dog that can potentially kill an adult, guardian breeds will be the next ‘problem dog’.

BounceyB · 28/08/2023 21:01

I don't agree. It's not the breed that's usually the issue but the owner. I've seen beautifully behaved "dangerous dogs". I do believe the standard should be higher for ownership. Only registered breeders should be able to breed - if unregistered it should be a jail sentence; and all potential owners should have to attend a training course. Once they have completed the course and provided a clean DBS they can own a dog.

hattie43 · 28/08/2023 20:59

You won't get dogs banned , they've already said if you ban a certain breed the Chavs will just turn their attention to another breed .
You need to stop indiscriminate breeding not ban certain breeds .

Furryrug · 28/08/2023 20:56

WinterFireJanuaryEmbers · 28/08/2023 20:45

We're not really talking about a genetically controlled breed of dog here. At worst we're generally talking about the thousands of puppies that come from criminals knocking together two dogs and then selling the puppies as way to make and launder money.

At best we're talking about some idiot without brain calls breeding their 'pets' for cash.

Puppies bred with no concern for temperament or mental or physical health. Brought into the world without medical support and who spend the first 8 weeks of their life being ignored (or worse!) without proper upbringing.

That's not a breed. It's just a type and in many cases the law has already been broken several times by their existence by the time they are sold to some poor, ignorant fool who hasn't really understood what they are buying or even what a dog really is.

Ban that type of dog by all means - but you can guarantee another type will come along right after it to fill the void.

I agree, dogs shouldn't be so readily available and more should be done to close down puppy farms. I also think that people shouldn't be able to advertise puppies for sale as I'm sure people see the ads and buy on a whim without the knowledge of what they are getting into or the expertise to properly train them.

Quisquam · 28/08/2023 20:50

Imo, dog licences should be brought back, and people should have to meet certain criteria before they can own a dog. As for dangerous breeds, they should be banned.

WinterFireJanuaryEmbers · 28/08/2023 20:45

We're not really talking about a genetically controlled breed of dog here. At worst we're generally talking about the thousands of puppies that come from criminals knocking together two dogs and then selling the puppies as way to make and launder money.

At best we're talking about some idiot without brain calls breeding their 'pets' for cash.

Puppies bred with no concern for temperament or mental or physical health. Brought into the world without medical support and who spend the first 8 weeks of their life being ignored (or worse!) without proper upbringing.

That's not a breed. It's just a type and in many cases the law has already been broken several times by their existence by the time they are sold to some poor, ignorant fool who hasn't really understood what they are buying or even what a dog really is.

Ban that type of dog by all means - but you can guarantee another type will come along right after it to fill the void.

FoodFann · 28/08/2023 20:34

Yes I completely agree. We watch our back every walk we go on, and we are sure to leave the park/beach etc if we see a dangerous dog breed. They are terrifying.

SoShallINever · 28/08/2023 20:33

I adore dogs. I've met hundreds (I'm a community health professional) and have my own dog who is 15, but I can understand your point.
I've seen some horrendous injuries inflicted by dogs. Recently I asked for a particularly aggressive bull type dog to be put in another room before I entered a property. The owners begrudging agreed but we're very arsey about it, saying he was just noisy and wouldn't harm a fly. The following week, the dog attacked my colleague, she needed 15 stitches in 2 wounds.
It's not always down to breed though, sometimes it's just completely useless owners.

Aquaphant · 28/08/2023 20:32

Soubriquet · 28/08/2023 20:27

Banning breeds doesn’t work. A dog isn’t nasty and unpredictable due to a breed.

Yes, they certainly can be. I'm so tired of this simplistic view. Bully breeds are specifically bred to fight (bulls and bears and later other dogs) and to inflict maximum damage. It's quite literally the purpose of these breeds and what they were developed to do. This is literally how breeding animals works. You select for traits and keep breeding animals with those traits to strengthen them in the offspring. Repeat this for a few hundred years and the aggression and strength are hardwired in those dogs.

Furryrug · 28/08/2023 20:31

That's awful, the Dogs Trust should be investigated, they have a duty of care to their staff.

Soubriquet · 28/08/2023 20:27

Banning breeds doesn’t work. A dog isn’t nasty and unpredictable due to a breed.

OrigamiOwls · 28/08/2023 20:21

Which breed specifically do you want banned?