Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a ban on dangerous dogs as pets?

141 replies

humanity15 · 28/08/2023 20:05

I feel this is a matter of public safety and people need to be informed.

Whilst working for a well known dog rescue charity I was attacked by a breed banned in many countries, but not here.
Because it was not banned it was taken in just like any other dog.

My story can be found on youtube.

With many years of experience in the dog sector what I see happening on our streets right now is frightening.

Those advising the government on dangerous dogs are giving bad advice and as a result putting people's lives at risk.

People do not understand dogs, especially genetics. Because of this attacks will keep happening and people are going to get killed.

All dogs have inherited characteristics. Certain ones are stronger in certain breeds depending on what they were originally bred for.

Although all dogs can bite, there is a huge difference in why they bite and this unless understood could prove fatal.

To communicate a dog will often give signals. So if it feels uncomfortable with someone coming too close it may put its ears back, cower, tuck its tail in etc.
If these signs are ignored the dog may resort to biting as a last resort.
Once it has effectively communicated, with the person moving away it will stop.

This is totally different to a dog biting because it has been bred to fight and has a strong drive to do so.

This drive has been bred into certain breeds of dogs on purpose. How strong that drive will be different for every individual dog depending on what has been passed down.
No amount of good will is going to change this.
This is your starting point before any external influences.

Instead of breeding that instinct out what we are now seeing is the result of the opposite having been done.
Individual dogs that have shown high aggression have been bred from resulting in literally ticking timebombs now out on our streets.

No amount of cute photos or affection will change this.
No dog trainer or behaviourist no matter how good can do anything because this is in the dogs genes.
All that can be done is for this instinct to be surpressed, it cannot be removed.
At some point under certain circumstances it will come out.

If you have a dog with a high drive to fight you could be in serious trouble and so can anyone who encounters that dog.

When it takes sometimes five people and tazers to get a dog off someone that is serious.

  • This is what people are not being told but what they need to know.

Dogs are not good or bad, they just are.

Just because a dog brings you something because it was bred to retrieve does not make it bad.
This is the same for a dog bred to fight. It is doing what we have basically programmed it to do.
The fact we see one instinct as acceptable and one not is not the dogs fault, it is ours.
We are the ones who have brought both these dogs into our homes and labelled them as pets.
Certain dogs should never have been expected to fulfil this role.

Dogs are not morally driven, they will not sit and contemplate what they are about to do they just react.

They have the mental age of a toddler, a young child at best.

It is so important we understand and remember this to keep everyone safe.

https://youtu.be/mHREm4pO-CI?feature=shared

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
CalistoNoSolo · 29/08/2023 19:36

Quisquam · 28/08/2023 20:50

Imo, dog licences should be brought back, and people should have to meet certain criteria before they can own a dog. As for dangerous breeds, they should be banned.

And ban all breeding of dogs for two years, all imports of dogs from anywhere for any reason, all clipping, docking etc of ears and tails. Every single dog should be chipped and dna'd when a pup. Any that are not should be seized and taken to a reputable rescue for rehoming, and there should be wardens everywhere checking dogs etc.

Prescottdanni123 · 29/08/2023 19:27

@Quisquam

When it comes to animals, China isn't a good role model to follow. When it comes to animals, wild and domestic, they have the biggest cruelty record in the world.

Do you honestly think installing dog licence fees that would bar everyone from owning a dog apart from the very rich I'd the way to go?

humanity15 · 29/08/2023 15:55

I have spent the last few years campaigning for better protection for whistleblowers as well as sharing my knowledge on dangerous dogs.

I've spoken with the Chief Executive of the charity where I worked about what needs to change.
To lose the trust of staff is a disaster, especially when you are working with potentially dangerous dogs.

What happened didnt just affect me, it affected all those in this sector, especially the dogs.
When people don't feel protected enough to speak out things don't get reported.

One of the things i've said needs bringing in immediately is an annonomous system for staff to report near misses and accidents.
Not only does non reporting put other staff in danger and those who the dogs are rehomed to, it also puts the dogs at greater risk of losing their lives.
If caught early, intervention can take place before a problem escalates.

I have a campaign page where I have called for various measures to be put in place to protect rescue workers.
I've also called for people to continue to support the charity.
I do not want the charity to suffer which is why they have been given every opportunity to inform the public.

People have no idea just how important whistleblowers are.
Without them not just you and me, but every last soul on this planet is at risk.

So yes, this charity needs to be honest with the public for the sake of all those in this sector and the wider population.

If not then like you see in the statement my colleagues sent, fear quickly spreads and people are put in danger as a result.

This cycle needs breaking

OP posts:
Lonicerax · 29/08/2023 09:10

I agree

Quisquam · 29/08/2023 09:07

You won't get dogs banned , they've already said if you ban a certain breed the Chavs will just turn their attention to another breed .
You need to stop indiscriminate breeding not ban certain breeds .

DD and I went to China 10 years ago. We were told the average salary was £3,000 pa and a dog license was £6,000. Dogs were very much a status symbol and only allowed outside after 10 pm. Despite visiting several mega cities and the countryside in 2.5 weeks, we only saw 2 dogs and they were at night.

RunningFromInsanity · 28/08/2023 23:44

I will also say that I do agree certain breeds of dogs, or certain individual dogs that have shown worrying behaviour, should not be rehomed.
However rescue centres get vilified for every dog they put down.

If they put it down for being a certain breed- ‘murderers’ ‘Deed not breed’ ‘There’s no bad dogs, just bad owners’

If they put it down because it has a bite history or resource guarding or food aggression- ‘murderers’ ‘just needs training’ ‘every dog deserves a chance’ ‘just needs the right home’

Can’t win. I am a huge dog lover and dedicate my life to dogs, but I think we are too precious in this country, and too reluctant to euthanise. There are thousands of balanced, friendly dogs in rescue centres, why do we insist on putting a risky dog out into the community?

RunningFromInsanity · 28/08/2023 23:34

Your issue is with the Dogs Trust and the branch you worked at. They failed to implement simple health and safety policies that would have prevented or reduced your attack.

I work at a rescue shelter. Dogs are categorised according to breed and temperament. Initially all dogs are categorised the highest risk until more is known about them.
Any of the highest risk categories need 2 handlers, at least one experienced and trained.
All staff carry a radio with a panic button.
Break sticks, fire extinguishers and slip leads are placed around the place incase of emergencies.
Behavioural assessments would be carried out, and the dogs risk category updated as necessary.

That particular breed would have been one of the higher risk categories to start with due to size but livestock guardian breeds are not particularly known for being aggressive.

I highly doubt they would be put onto your list of banned dangerous dog breeds.

Dente · 28/08/2023 22:41

100% agree with the poster. There are many dogs like this in my area and it makes me scared to walk on the street. Ofc a jackrussel can be aggressive, but it’s unlikely to overpower an adult on the otherside if the street.

recently I was in a beer garden with an XL bully off the lead, complained to management and the owners said “ wouldn’t hurt a fly”. Why would you get this breed if you are truly looking for a family dog with a kind gentle temperment ?

My other issue is that a 3 bed semi with a tiny garden is not appropriate for a dog that is bread to hunt bears! It’s just not! And this inappropriate environment makes them even more unstable.

MarshmaIIow · 28/08/2023 22:38

BSL would work if the police actually upheld the law.
i agree with banning bull breeds and the types of dogs that can do serious damage.

Cognitivedisonance · 28/08/2023 22:35

I have strong feelings about this due to personal experience. We have massive issues with dogs being bred for quick cash and certain types of people seeking out big, powerful breeds. The only way is to make it illegal to breed, buy , sell or give away any dog without an official contract and health meeting. By this , I mean by law the animal must be handed over in the company of a vet nurse who conducts a basic dog health MOT and books the vaccines and neutering ( paid for upfront) and then prints a dog ID card to match its chip. Any animal , in public at any time ( or encountered during a police or social worker visit) without this is removed. There should be an outright ban on breeding pit bull type breeds too. It’ll eventually wash the criminals out because no one will buy animals that they can’t walk or show anyone. Reputable breeders of safe breeds should be vetted annually to keep their licences. If someone can’t pay £200 to chip and register the animal then they Can’t afford it’s insurance and training etc can they?

HeadacheEarthquake · 28/08/2023 22:30

wheresmymojo · 28/08/2023 22:21

People in the US are already starting to move on to the next 'trend' in totally unsuitable dogs...

Kangals and Alagais Sad

Potentially even worse than XL Bullies.

OK I get the kangal a bit it looks like a cute Shiba inu tail.with a lab boxer face

But most of these aggressive breeds aren't even cute or attractive!!! They look like bald hellpigs. Sorry. The bullies look like gammons.

wheresmymojo · 28/08/2023 22:27

Alabais (not Alagais!)

wheresmymojo · 28/08/2023 22:21

People in the US are already starting to move on to the next 'trend' in totally unsuitable dogs...

Kangals and Alagais Sad

Potentially even worse than XL Bullies.

humanity15 · 28/08/2023 22:21

I think a serious discussion needs to take place. It is not for me to decide, I can only share my knowledge.
What I see is breeds or 'types' having been bred for aggression being put in a role they are too dangerous to be in, that of a pet in a domestic setting.
Some have been trying to breed this instinct out whilst others have done the opposite.
With no proper regulation on what can be bred or by who we now have a very dangerous situation.
For me it has got out of hand and the only way back is to ban certain breeds/types as pets.
Properly regulate breeders and licence them so they are the only ones allowed to breed dogs. All puppies to be able to be traced back to the breeder.
Catagorise certain dogs and who can own them.
Education around different breeds and also a dogs body language for not just children but for adults.
I would also introduce an acceptable breeds list to prevent more dangerous breeds/types.

OP posts:
FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · 28/08/2023 22:12

For me you clearly have an agenda which is more to do with the charity than the dogs which is never going to be helpful.

humanity15 · 28/08/2023 22:04

The charity have had every opportunity to inform the public, but have chosen not to.

New members of staff only find out about the safety record of this charity through other staff informing them.
They are not aware when they are contemplating working for them.

There is currently a letter surrounding what took place at this charity on the
All Party Parliamentary Dog Advisory Welfare Group.
There is also many suggestions of what changes need to happen.
The MP's in the group are well aware of what happened as are many members of the Lords.

I'm sorry you didn't like the video, it wasn't meant to be entertaining.

This post is about public safety and an important discussion that needs to be had.

OP posts:
WarmButteryCrumpets · 28/08/2023 22:03

People always say "it's not bad dogs /specific breeds, it's the owners". And yes, your average chihuahua is probably ore aggressive than some of the big scary looking dogs, but... you wouldn't let any randomer own a tiger. So why do we let anyone keep a breed of dog which is on par with. Tiger when it comes to bite strength ?

Soapyspuds · 28/08/2023 22:03

I’m all for banning breeds, I also think everyone who owns a dog should have a licence and have to pass a basic care and handling course before they are allowed them

Great in theory but in practice most people will find a way to pass and then disregard all they have been told. We have the requirement for a driving license and yet the amount of absolute weapons on our roads is astounding.

Prescottdanni123 · 28/08/2023 22:01

It depends what you mean by dangerous dogs. Do you want all staffies, rottweilers, German shepherds etc to be banned? If so, yabu and I am saying that as someone who has also worked with dogs and studied dog behaviour/dog genetics.

Soapyspuds · 28/08/2023 22:01

Realistically this will not happen. I think the best we can hope for is compulsory muzzles on any dog out in public.

sleepyscientist · 28/08/2023 21:53

Can we just ban the sort of people who buy these dogs from breeding humans so it's all over in a few generations! I don't like bullybreeds but would you also add things like the German shepherd, husky even chihuahuas can be naughty.

ntmdino · 28/08/2023 21:47

Here's the thing...the existing breed-specific legislation is fundamentally broken, so adding more "breeds" to that list isn't going to help.

Remember, the way the government determines a dog's breed is by measuring its head, height and build - absolutely nothing to do with its genetics. That leads to the ridiculous situation Belfast council engineered - whereby a dog was confiscated and killed simply because a neighbour didn't like dogs and reported it as a pitbull. Sure enough, the wardens showed up, measured him, and determined that he was a pitbull...but determined that his littermates (who were in the same house) weren't. They then spent ridiculous amounts of money hiding the dog from the family's lawyers for well over a year, as well as fighting it in court, and eventually killed the dog without a court order. Incidentally, that court held up the legal standard that a dog's measurements determine its breed, and thus threw out actual DNA evidence proving that he wasn't even partially of any banned breed.

A dog that had never even growled at anyone, much less bitten - passed all temperament tests, and was so docile that he rolled over when attacked by other dogs.

Meanwhile, there are thousands of actually dangerous dogs out there, kept by shitty owners and used to bully and intimidate people.

So yeah...go after the breed of dog if you want, but the only result will be legal pantomime where the authorities confiscate and kill easy targets, and studiously avoid any of the dogs that are actually the problem, as well as doing legislative gymnastics to avoid doing the hard yards in making back yard breeding illegal under all circumstances (which is where the bulk of the problem begins).

shitt · 28/08/2023 21:34

i don’t disagree but you’re going to struggle getting support. It’s 2023. Who even posts YouTube videos that are a slideshow of text? You could have posted the transcript but you didn’t. It’s really hard to follow and your wall of text here doesn’t help. It’s a skill to deliver vital information in the right way, to get the support you need. Ultimately dogs in rescues are in a stressful situation so id assume regardless of breed that they’re more likely to bite

FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · 28/08/2023 21:27

if these signs are ignored the dog may resort to biting as a last resort I've always said there is no such thing as a bad dog, only bad owners and this is an example of that. If you are a responsible owner then you know the instant your dog is unhappy.
Unfortunately fuckwits like breeds that are big and are presumed to be aggressive, this is the fault of the fuckwits-not the dogs.

Amyh90 · 28/08/2023 21:25

My daughter was badly attacked by an American bulldog this year and I want this bully breed baned they are dangerous to the public

Swipe left for the next trending thread