Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a ban on dangerous dogs as pets?

141 replies

humanity15 · 28/08/2023 20:05

I feel this is a matter of public safety and people need to be informed.

Whilst working for a well known dog rescue charity I was attacked by a breed banned in many countries, but not here.
Because it was not banned it was taken in just like any other dog.

My story can be found on youtube.

With many years of experience in the dog sector what I see happening on our streets right now is frightening.

Those advising the government on dangerous dogs are giving bad advice and as a result putting people's lives at risk.

People do not understand dogs, especially genetics. Because of this attacks will keep happening and people are going to get killed.

All dogs have inherited characteristics. Certain ones are stronger in certain breeds depending on what they were originally bred for.

Although all dogs can bite, there is a huge difference in why they bite and this unless understood could prove fatal.

To communicate a dog will often give signals. So if it feels uncomfortable with someone coming too close it may put its ears back, cower, tuck its tail in etc.
If these signs are ignored the dog may resort to biting as a last resort.
Once it has effectively communicated, with the person moving away it will stop.

This is totally different to a dog biting because it has been bred to fight and has a strong drive to do so.

This drive has been bred into certain breeds of dogs on purpose. How strong that drive will be different for every individual dog depending on what has been passed down.
No amount of good will is going to change this.
This is your starting point before any external influences.

Instead of breeding that instinct out what we are now seeing is the result of the opposite having been done.
Individual dogs that have shown high aggression have been bred from resulting in literally ticking timebombs now out on our streets.

No amount of cute photos or affection will change this.
No dog trainer or behaviourist no matter how good can do anything because this is in the dogs genes.
All that can be done is for this instinct to be surpressed, it cannot be removed.
At some point under certain circumstances it will come out.

If you have a dog with a high drive to fight you could be in serious trouble and so can anyone who encounters that dog.

When it takes sometimes five people and tazers to get a dog off someone that is serious.

  • This is what people are not being told but what they need to know.

Dogs are not good or bad, they just are.

Just because a dog brings you something because it was bred to retrieve does not make it bad.
This is the same for a dog bred to fight. It is doing what we have basically programmed it to do.
The fact we see one instinct as acceptable and one not is not the dogs fault, it is ours.
We are the ones who have brought both these dogs into our homes and labelled them as pets.
Certain dogs should never have been expected to fulfil this role.

Dogs are not morally driven, they will not sit and contemplate what they are about to do they just react.

They have the mental age of a toddler, a young child at best.

It is so important we understand and remember this to keep everyone safe.

https://youtu.be/mHREm4pO-CI?feature=shared

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Lovemusic82 · 30/08/2023 22:38

I love dogs and have nothing against any of them but I do think some dogs should not be bred or sold in this country due to the risk of them attacking/killing, especially one particular breed that seems to be very popular right now and ending up in the wrong hands, deaths from dog attacks have doubles and it’s mainly due to one breed.

Yes any dog can attack but there are some breeds that are more likely to kill due to their size and build.

And yes it’s down to owners and dogs not being trained, some breeds are just popular with the type of person that isn’t going to take their dog to classes or walk it daily.

Oysterbabe · 30/08/2023 22:28

XenoBitch · 30/08/2023 22:15

Something needs to be done about the rise in dog attacks. I'd like to see compulsory muzzles in public on dogs over a certain weight.

What weight would that be? Some greyhounds can be almost 40kg.... a breed known to be gentle and not aggressive.

Also a breed known for chasing and killing smaller animals. My friends greyhound killed 3 cats. They're near the top of dogs that should be muzzled.

XenoBitch · 30/08/2023 22:15

Something needs to be done about the rise in dog attacks. I'd like to see compulsory muzzles in public on dogs over a certain weight.

What weight would that be? Some greyhounds can be almost 40kg.... a breed known to be gentle and not aggressive.

Oysterbabe · 30/08/2023 22:01

I saw this shared earlier.

Something needs to be done about the rise in dog attacks. I'd like to see compulsory muzzles in public on dogs over a certain weight.

Appeal | Woman injured in Handsworth dog attack

We need your help finding this man after a dog he was walking attacked another dog and badly injured its 76-year-old owner.The victim was out with her labrad...

https://youtu.be/L7KW3YslF6I?si=uA4_CLwsinAlaOPP

RunningFromInsanity · 30/08/2023 21:59

cobden28 · 30/08/2023 21:39

How do you define a 'dangerous dog' ? A dog doesn't have to be one of the four breeds mentioned in the Dangerous Dogs Act 1990 to be considered 'dangerous' - it's not the dogs fault if it turns out the way it does, it's people who've made it that way.
Small dogs can often give people a nasty nip and/or have uncertain temperaments, but does that mean all small dogs should be done away with just because of their breed? I had a Pekingese a few years back who bit me, drew blood and ghe meant to bite, but does that mean all Pekingese can be classed as dangerous dogs that should be exterminated - NO !! My Peke that bit me, by the way, was 12 years of age with a heart condition and he had a brain tumour responsible for his change in temperament - but under no curcumatances do I believe that all dogs of this breed should be put down simp,y because of one biting incident?

How many fatalities have been caused by a Pekinese?

No one is denying that all dogs can bite, regardless of breed. The issue is that a bite from a Pekinese is very very different from a bite from an XL bully. And that is what makes them dangerous dogs.

SquirrelFeeder · 30/08/2023 21:44

BounceyB · 28/08/2023 21:01

I don't agree. It's not the breed that's usually the issue but the owner. I've seen beautifully behaved "dangerous dogs". I do believe the standard should be higher for ownership. Only registered breeders should be able to breed - if unregistered it should be a jail sentence; and all potential owners should have to attend a training course. Once they have completed the course and provided a clean DBS they can own a dog.

You are wrong. As I've just said above, the DDA exists because it has been PROVEN that certain breeds are more susceptible to attack. Proven. Fact.

SquirrelFeeder · 30/08/2023 21:43

Soubriquet · 28/08/2023 20:27

Banning breeds doesn’t work. A dog isn’t nasty and unpredictable due to a breed.

This is such nonsense! The Dangerous Dogs Act wouldn't exist if this hadn't been extensively PROVEN to be FACT

cobden28 · 30/08/2023 21:39

How do you define a 'dangerous dog' ? A dog doesn't have to be one of the four breeds mentioned in the Dangerous Dogs Act 1990 to be considered 'dangerous' - it's not the dogs fault if it turns out the way it does, it's people who've made it that way.
Small dogs can often give people a nasty nip and/or have uncertain temperaments, but does that mean all small dogs should be done away with just because of their breed? I had a Pekingese a few years back who bit me, drew blood and ghe meant to bite, but does that mean all Pekingese can be classed as dangerous dogs that should be exterminated - NO !! My Peke that bit me, by the way, was 12 years of age with a heart condition and he had a brain tumour responsible for his change in temperament - but under no curcumatances do I believe that all dogs of this breed should be put down simp,y because of one biting incident?

XenoBitch · 30/08/2023 21:39

Prescottdanni123 · 30/08/2023 20:49

@3ormoredogs

When it comes to gumtree, the people who sell dogs AND the ones who buy them should face some sort of punishment. Because there is no excuse for not knowing it is a bad idea any more.

Sadly, with many rescues full to bursting and closing intake, some dogs do end up on Gumtree because there is nowhere else for them to go.

Prescottdanni123 · 30/08/2023 20:49

@3ormoredogs

When it comes to gumtree, the people who sell dogs AND the ones who buy them should face some sort of punishment. Because there is no excuse for not knowing it is a bad idea any more.

RunningFromInsanity · 30/08/2023 19:14

enchantedsquirrelwood · 30/08/2023 18:53

I thought the Dangerous Dogs Act already did ban dangerous breeds. And any dog can be dangerous under the Act.

https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/dangerous-dog-offences

It bans 4 specific breeds (well 3 breeds and any pitbull type). And even then, you can own them if they are put on a register and kept muzzled in public- so they could still be a danger inside a house, or if they escaped.

and then of course it is illegal for any dog of any breed to be ‘dangerously out of control’ but that is very subjective, some police forces need an injury, others don’t.

PrrrplePineapple · 30/08/2023 19:06

I don't think a blanket breed ban is the answer because as you stated in your OP, people breed for aggression from aggressive dogs - and aggression can occur in many breeds. Plus where does a breed ban stop, how are cross breeds treated?

I would thoroughly support stricted breeding rules and harsher commercial breeding guidelines and fines for 'backyard' breeders however. I'd even support mandatory dog training classes for all new owners, although I don't know how you'd enforce it.

3ormoredogs · 30/08/2023 19:01

I would like to see the banning of selling or rehoming ANY dog unless via a registered method. I would make the passing on of any dog illegal unless via a proper channel, for example an assessed and registered breeder or a rescue centre where the dogs have been assessed and matched by a qualified behaviourist. Maybe if the clueless couldn’t go onto gumtree on a whim and buy some hideous untrained and unsocialised XL bully or deformed frog looking dog with its ears chopped off the problem wouldn’t exist.

Some dogs are just genetically prone to be aggressive, people deny it but it’s true. Maybe if people did acknowledge this then they would be more sensible with the type of dog they own and the situation they put it in. Any dog bred for ‘game’ I.e a dog bred to fight and never back down under any circumstances should not be available as a pet.

Cherrysoup · 30/08/2023 18:57

But where do you stop? Xl bullies, ok, but will you also ban huskies because one killed the baby? A greyhound killed a dog here a while back. Will you ban that breed? An Akita attacked another dog in my local park then ripped open the owner’s arm as he tried to get it off. You going to ban akitas? It isn’t just bull breeds that attack. The worst most vicious dog I’ve met was a Labrador-weak, clueless owner.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 30/08/2023 18:53

I thought the Dangerous Dogs Act already did ban dangerous breeds. And any dog can be dangerous under the Act.

https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/dangerous-dog-offences

Dangerous Dog Offences | The Crown Prosecution Service

https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/dangerous-dog-offences

RunningFromInsanity · 30/08/2023 18:30

WeetabixTowels · 30/08/2023 11:19

Lol sure. It’s just a concidence that XL bullys continue to mail and kill humans. Funny how it isn’t Shih Tzu whi do it. I wonder why that is

Banning breeds doesn’t work. Not with the current legislation. Dog attacks/fatalities have increased since the formation of the Dangerous Dogs Act and the 4 banned breeds. The statistics don’t lie.

All that’s happened after the formation of the banned list is that a)people naively think that other breeds are safe as they aren’t on the list and b) the popular breed changes (ie to XL bullies currently). After they are banned, it will probably be the cane corso that becomes the dog of choice.

I agree that most bull breeds are unsuitable as pets as they are genetically prone to aggression, and their size means attacks are severe.

But banning breeds doesn’t work. Mostly because identifying ‘pitbull’ types from staffie crosses and XL bullies is almost impossible.

Perhaps something as extreme as Ireland where certain breeds (including popular ones such as GSDs, Rottweilers, Dobermans, Ridgebacks) have to be muzzled and on lead at all times in public.

WeetabixTowels · 30/08/2023 11:20

I’m actually quite horrified that people know certain breeds are killing humans and other dogs at alarming rates and they just shrug and say ‘Oh well Irving can be do e’.

People in the UK are weird about dogs.

WeetabixTowels · 30/08/2023 11:19

Soubriquet · 28/08/2023 20:27

Banning breeds doesn’t work. A dog isn’t nasty and unpredictable due to a breed.

Lol sure. It’s just a concidence that XL bullys continue to mail and kill humans. Funny how it isn’t Shih Tzu whi do it. I wonder why that is

Fluffytoebeanz · 30/08/2023 11:04

I like the Swedish system where all dogs have to be registered, all puppies need to attend training and no dog can be left for a maximum of 6 hours. Also they have to have an outside view if they are left inside and need to be leashed in cities and public places. There are very few abandoned dogs as a result. They also have pretty strong breeding laws

WingingItSince1973 · 30/08/2023 08:58

I absolutely agree. I'm so sick of those that will come on and say it's not the breed it's the owners. Well the last few dogs I've read about were well loved family pets. Some breeds through no fault of their own have that instinct. It's in their dna. I was so relieved when my DDs boyfriend had to give up his xl bully because they stupidly bought one into the property they rent and the landlord told them it has to go. I was so scared for my dgs. Now they want to move so they can get the dog back. Actually in this case I do blame the owners because the boyfriend is an idiot having one of those breeeds in a flat for starters. They aren't family pets they need to be in the right environment not attached to some idiot who thinks they look hard.

BackAgainstWall · 29/08/2023 22:41

YANBU
When on earth is this government going to wake up and do something about it!!

rottweilersrock · 29/08/2023 22:19

Which breeds would you like banned?

user9630721458 · 29/08/2023 22:00

I agree that many dogs kept as pets are unsuitable. Any guardian dogs or breed powerful enough to kill is a project very few have time and knowledge to take on, and rescue dogs may have a host of complicating issues. OK to take on an anxious, overprotective rottie if you are home all the time, go for 8 mile walks every day, have a spacious secure garden and are an expert in dog behaviour and training - plus you are willing to stay away from other people and dogs in case your rescue gets triggered. But people like that are a tiny part of the population. We should never have made these dogs pets, and I would be happy to see all dangerous and potentially lethal dogs banned. I don't want them all put to sleep, but there must be a way to phase them out.

Prescottdanni123 · 29/08/2023 21:39

@Quisquam

I agree measures need to be put in place. In an ideal world, everyone would have dog licences (I say this as a dog owner) but who is going to keep on top of it all?

But dog licences that cost twice as much as the average salary? For one, that would rule most people in the UK out of owning a dog (and there are plenty of responsible, loving dog owners in the UK) and two, irresponsible dog owning doesn't start and end in council estates. A dog licence would need to protect dogs from people as well as protecting people from dogs. The worst case of dog cruelty I've seen, and reported, was carried out by a millionaire land owner.

Quisquam · 29/08/2023 19:39

@Prescottdanni123

I am well aware of the Chinese attitude to animals. However I do think there is a middle way to controlling, who can own a dog. Dogs are not here, imo to be used as weapons by people, who have no real idea how to look after a dog properly! We don’t let people loose on the roads with a car, with no driving lessons or knowledge of the highway code. What is the difference - both can kill people?

Swipe left for the next trending thread