Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a ban on dangerous dogs as pets?

141 replies

humanity15 · 28/08/2023 20:05

I feel this is a matter of public safety and people need to be informed.

Whilst working for a well known dog rescue charity I was attacked by a breed banned in many countries, but not here.
Because it was not banned it was taken in just like any other dog.

My story can be found on youtube.

With many years of experience in the dog sector what I see happening on our streets right now is frightening.

Those advising the government on dangerous dogs are giving bad advice and as a result putting people's lives at risk.

People do not understand dogs, especially genetics. Because of this attacks will keep happening and people are going to get killed.

All dogs have inherited characteristics. Certain ones are stronger in certain breeds depending on what they were originally bred for.

Although all dogs can bite, there is a huge difference in why they bite and this unless understood could prove fatal.

To communicate a dog will often give signals. So if it feels uncomfortable with someone coming too close it may put its ears back, cower, tuck its tail in etc.
If these signs are ignored the dog may resort to biting as a last resort.
Once it has effectively communicated, with the person moving away it will stop.

This is totally different to a dog biting because it has been bred to fight and has a strong drive to do so.

This drive has been bred into certain breeds of dogs on purpose. How strong that drive will be different for every individual dog depending on what has been passed down.
No amount of good will is going to change this.
This is your starting point before any external influences.

Instead of breeding that instinct out what we are now seeing is the result of the opposite having been done.
Individual dogs that have shown high aggression have been bred from resulting in literally ticking timebombs now out on our streets.

No amount of cute photos or affection will change this.
No dog trainer or behaviourist no matter how good can do anything because this is in the dogs genes.
All that can be done is for this instinct to be surpressed, it cannot be removed.
At some point under certain circumstances it will come out.

If you have a dog with a high drive to fight you could be in serious trouble and so can anyone who encounters that dog.

When it takes sometimes five people and tazers to get a dog off someone that is serious.

  • This is what people are not being told but what they need to know.

Dogs are not good or bad, they just are.

Just because a dog brings you something because it was bred to retrieve does not make it bad.
This is the same for a dog bred to fight. It is doing what we have basically programmed it to do.
The fact we see one instinct as acceptable and one not is not the dogs fault, it is ours.
We are the ones who have brought both these dogs into our homes and labelled them as pets.
Certain dogs should never have been expected to fulfil this role.

Dogs are not morally driven, they will not sit and contemplate what they are about to do they just react.

They have the mental age of a toddler, a young child at best.

It is so important we understand and remember this to keep everyone safe.

https://youtu.be/mHREm4pO-CI?feature=shared

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Cognitivedisonance · 31/08/2023 10:06

@summergrey the DVLA do a fantastic job of monitoring and fining vehicle owners that break the rules, this is funded by taxes associated with motoring. Works a treat. So your ‘Dog tax’ or ‘Dog licence’ fee each year pays for the admin to issue it and enforce it and it comes with the strings attached of mandatory neutering , health care and insurance. The cost and accountability will drive out the scumbags who abuse animals and almost eradicate the need for shelters. Maybe add in a compulsory exam too, to make sure the owner is capable of managing the responsibility. Like driving, it should be considered a burden of responsibility and a privilege.

Cherrysoup · 31/08/2023 10:03

Cognitivedisonance · 31/08/2023 10:00

@Cherrysoup perhaps the answer is dog licences and approved breeds for households then? Small/ medium non muscular/ soft bite dogs for urban households only. Then working breeds are available on a different licence to people that can actually justify having them. It would mean complete eradication of the pit bull type dog, and the only people with guardian and mastiff breeds will be livestock farmers and mountain rescue teams or whatever. In my opinion, if you’re not under threat of being attacked by lions/ wolves/ bears then the only reason to have a powerful dog is with the intent it might harm another human on your behalf which makes it a weapon, just like a knife or gun.

Looking at a certain type of owner round here-teenage lads teaching their staffs to swing from tree branches-that sounds sensible. I remember watching a puppy programme where a woman bought a giant breed yet lived in a small upstairs flat and was then tearing out her hair over toilet training.

Cognitivedisonance · 31/08/2023 10:00

@Cherrysoup perhaps the answer is dog licences and approved breeds for households then? Small/ medium non muscular/ soft bite dogs for urban households only. Then working breeds are available on a different licence to people that can actually justify having them. It would mean complete eradication of the pit bull type dog, and the only people with guardian and mastiff breeds will be livestock farmers and mountain rescue teams or whatever. In my opinion, if you’re not under threat of being attacked by lions/ wolves/ bears then the only reason to have a powerful dog is with the intent it might harm another human on your behalf which makes it a weapon, just like a knife or gun.

summergrey · 31/08/2023 10:00

I'm curious those who are suggesting going back to dog licenses, who do you expect will check those? There is no enforcement now from local councils for things that already require it like breeder licenses . There is no money for this. Dog wardens were do still exist are unqualified and paid terribly. Would you take the job on those conditions? I wouldn't.

I do think something needs to change but more public attitude / behaviour towards owning dogs and pets in general.

Cherrysoup · 31/08/2023 09:48

Sarvanga38 · 31/08/2023 09:24

This argument is getting so tired now. How many Greyhounds or Akitas are you seeing killing people? The Husky with the baby is hugely sad, but a bit of a freak one - and frankly those quoting breeds that have killed tiny babies is laughable. It's tragic and horrific, but it is simply not the same as dogs that can and are killing adults or causing them to lose limbs/other life-changing injuries.

I honestly don't know what the answer is. I get the argument that banning one breed just moves it all on to another, and there seems an endless supply of problem breeds waiting in the wings. Very few households will cope well with e.g. Ovcharka or Cane Corso, but their easy and frighteningly cheap availability is there for all to see.

Judgemental perhaps, but even suing doesn't seem to be any deterrent, as let's face it so many of those who are causing this issue have nothing much to be sued for anyway. 'Make an example of them' prison sentences for owners are about the only deterrent I can see having any effect, eventually.

I think that's such a poor argument. Shall we only ban breeds that have killed multiple people? It proves that no dog can be trusted. What about the police dog that went rogue the other week and attacked it's handler? One presumes it was incredibly well trained. It was euthanized.

Thementalloadisreal · 31/08/2023 09:28

Dog lovers may disagree (although I think true dog lovers should want some accountability for irresponsible owners) but I think all dog owners should have to hold licences for their dogs and have passed some kind of basic training in dog handling. Immediate consequences if you’re in public with a dog and found to be without your licence / proof when asked by police etc. Much like a car or gun.
I don’t care about the breed, poorly cared for dogs are dangerous to humans and other animals.

Sarvanga38 · 31/08/2023 09:24

Cherrysoup · 30/08/2023 18:57

But where do you stop? Xl bullies, ok, but will you also ban huskies because one killed the baby? A greyhound killed a dog here a while back. Will you ban that breed? An Akita attacked another dog in my local park then ripped open the owner’s arm as he tried to get it off. You going to ban akitas? It isn’t just bull breeds that attack. The worst most vicious dog I’ve met was a Labrador-weak, clueless owner.

This argument is getting so tired now. How many Greyhounds or Akitas are you seeing killing people? The Husky with the baby is hugely sad, but a bit of a freak one - and frankly those quoting breeds that have killed tiny babies is laughable. It's tragic and horrific, but it is simply not the same as dogs that can and are killing adults or causing them to lose limbs/other life-changing injuries.

I honestly don't know what the answer is. I get the argument that banning one breed just moves it all on to another, and there seems an endless supply of problem breeds waiting in the wings. Very few households will cope well with e.g. Ovcharka or Cane Corso, but their easy and frighteningly cheap availability is there for all to see.

Judgemental perhaps, but even suing doesn't seem to be any deterrent, as let's face it so many of those who are causing this issue have nothing much to be sued for anyway. 'Make an example of them' prison sentences for owners are about the only deterrent I can see having any effect, eventually.

notlucreziaborgia · 31/08/2023 09:14

Ovcharka’s are literally bred to fight off wolves and bears, my uncle has two for exactly that purpose (not in the UK, obviously). They’re also the preferred breed to use in Russian prisons. They’re beautiful, but they’re not a bigger, fluffier version of a Labrador.

DiscoBeat · 31/08/2023 09:04

Banning breeds doesn’t work. A dog isn’t nasty and unpredictable due to a breed.

I disagree. Physical and mental characteristics carefully and intensely bred in can be good or very bad. My Labrador was bred to be in water, guess what - he absolutely adores it and swims whenever he can. He also fetches things for us. My previous collie always tried to round up the children. When I think of dogs bred with very large jaws for fighting I really shudder to think of them as a family dog. Of course they CAN be lovely and a Labrador can be nasty but you have to look at the statistics.

summergrey · 31/08/2023 08:50

elifont · 31/08/2023 04:25

How do you enforce breed bans when most dogs are crosses now. Loads of people I know with dogs they're all imported from Romania and they are put up for adoption without a clue what breed they are, they're just classed as mixed.

That is one of the many many ways that breed specific legislation fails. Even now, it's not DNA that is used to decide if a cross breed is 'technically' a pit bull and so a banned breed to be destroyed. It's an opinion of someone. Some are better trained than others, some verdicts are based on photos, some on in person visit to the dog, etc. it's very badly applied. Plus most councils no longer have funding for dog warden so who is checking? The application of it is a minefield.

summergrey · 31/08/2023 08:46

slore · 31/08/2023 03:57

@summergrey

Breed banning legislation is only ineffective when either un-enforced, or very localised, as it is in North America where different districts of different towns can have different bylaws from one another.

The Dangerous Dogs Act is a success in my opinion, you could count the number of dog bite deaths on one hand before pitbulls were re-bred to be giant (XL bullies) and got through under a loophole, which has caused dog bite deaths to sky rocket.

Edited

That's your view. I'm curious what facts and information you basing your opinion on?

Most legal animal welfare experts agree that the Dangerous Dogs Act is not a success but rather a failure of adequate policy. Its a rushed badly worded piece of legislation. It could have been fixed many times over, some issues with it could even have been closed recently through the Kept Animals Bill which the government dropped earlier this year.

Research shows that bites numbers have not decreased since the introduction of the Dangerous Dog Act but rather the overall dog population fell then rose again which accounts for the increase in news stories about serious bites.

Also let's not forget that those pandemic puppies are now adult dogs, most with some behavioural issue, many related to lack of appropriate socialisation in puppyhood. BVA are doing research on this.

Goldflap · 31/08/2023 06:27

I have always wondered about dangerous dogs in shelters and the staff who have to manage them.

If you look at the big shelters in any city the majority of dogs are bullies and the like, I'm guessing many are there because they have been taken off irresponsible owners so it's a perfect storm- dogs capable of doing serious damage mixed with a dodgy history.

My last visit to Liverpool o was shocked by how many 'homeless' men begging were sat with massive bully type dogs not on leads it was genuinely terrifying and their rescue centres seem to reflect this.

Everyone needs to start being honest about the fact this is a genuine problem and maybe start making difficult decisions to stop rehoming as well as tackling the trade and ownership issues

I also do always wonder what life must be like for these scallies that have the dogs like I get they buzz off people being scared of them but surely they must be scared too and ground down by trying to manage these dogs.
I've seen the half witted owners look like they are on edge handling their muscle mutants.

elifont · 31/08/2023 04:25

How do you enforce breed bans when most dogs are crosses now. Loads of people I know with dogs they're all imported from Romania and they are put up for adoption without a clue what breed they are, they're just classed as mixed.

slore · 31/08/2023 03:57

@summergrey

Breed banning legislation is only ineffective when either un-enforced, or very localised, as it is in North America where different districts of different towns can have different bylaws from one another.

The Dangerous Dogs Act is a success in my opinion, you could count the number of dog bite deaths on one hand before pitbulls were re-bred to be giant (XL bullies) and got through under a loophole, which has caused dog bite deaths to sky rocket.

summergrey · 31/08/2023 03:32

@humanity15 I read the whole thing before replying. There's so much I want to say but it would likely be outing as I work in a related field / sector to you.

I can only suggest that you and other posters look at the work being done by International Companion Animal Management (ICAM) and also advocacy work in the U.K. by rescues such as Hope Rescue and others. You talk about the Dog Bite group at Parliament, so you are more educated than most, but breed banning legislation has been proven not to be effective, other countries handle this differently and it's not by going down the 'pro life' / 'let's save them all' route the US is on.

slore · 31/08/2023 03:30

RunningFromInsanity · 28/08/2023 23:44

I will also say that I do agree certain breeds of dogs, or certain individual dogs that have shown worrying behaviour, should not be rehomed.
However rescue centres get vilified for every dog they put down.

If they put it down for being a certain breed- ‘murderers’ ‘Deed not breed’ ‘There’s no bad dogs, just bad owners’

If they put it down because it has a bite history or resource guarding or food aggression- ‘murderers’ ‘just needs training’ ‘every dog deserves a chance’ ‘just needs the right home’

Can’t win. I am a huge dog lover and dedicate my life to dogs, but I think we are too precious in this country, and too reluctant to euthanise. There are thousands of balanced, friendly dogs in rescue centres, why do we insist on putting a risky dog out into the community?

Edited

I agree with this. I am morally opposed to killing animals and acknowledge that no dog "deserves" capital punishment, but the reality is we do not have the resources to take care of dangerous dogs. It's either house them forever in a shelter (which is a very stressful life for them, and takes up resources for adoptable animals), or lie about their risk to the public in order to adopt them, which leads to maulings of humans, pets and wildlife.

At some point, euthanasia is the least worst option for the suffering of both the dangerous dog and any future victims.

slore · 31/08/2023 03:19

Soubriquet · 28/08/2023 20:27

Banning breeds doesn’t work. A dog isn’t nasty and unpredictable due to a breed.

You're wrong. The idea that dogs can be "nasty" is so childish and misinformed.

As OP says, dogs just "are". There is no moral element to their behaviour. Sharks and crocodiles aren't "bad" because they are apex predators, and blood-sports breeds aren't "bad" because of their potential for severe aggression to other dogs and sometimes humans.

Just a couple of weeks ago when I was in a holiday park, a giant staffie (that I suspect was a pitbull - not an XL bully as it wasn't visibly muscular) killed a little yorkie that was minding its own business in its own front garden. It was so quick and completely unprovoked, and there was so much damage that the yorkie had to be euthanised. After the attack, the staffie/pitbull was extremely calm and normal.

The owners had had the staffie for 6 years, and got it from a rescue at 1 year old. It had never been violent at all, in the whole time they'd had it, and the owners were loving and responsible. It just "turned" that day.

All blood sports breeds have the potential to go on the "turn" like this. And since they typically behave perfectly normally until they do, you have no way of ever knowing if a dog from a bully-family breed will go on the turn one day.

Banning the breed doesn't mean round them up and killing them, it just means banning breeding and selling them.

If we don't we'll end up like America, with shelters full of pitbulls and pit mixes that are basically unadoptable and no one wants. The solution isn't to pretend that bloodsport breeds are suitable for family life, or a "nanny dog", to encourage more unwitting people to adopt these timebombs. The solutions is to stop breeding them in the first place.

humanity15 · 31/08/2023 03:14

The poor lady from the article in this post was killed having bought two dogs she believed to be gentle giants.

People don't need to be given misleading slogans by charities or a sales pitch by breeders, they need to know the facts before bringing a dog into their household.

Understanding different dog breeds and the individual traits that they are likely to have is so important (a cross breed is also likely to display certain traits of the breeds it originated from).
This information is not only for the owners benefit but also that of the dog.

Rescue centres are overflowing, often full with certain breeds of dogs.
Lack of space leads to dogs being euthanised because there is nowhere for them to go.

Instead of giving the impression that all dogs are the same, if accurate information around breeds was given people could make informed decisions.
The demand for certain breeds would fall especially in households with children.

Less demand would result in fewer dogs being abandoned and ending up in rescue centres.

If charities really want to help save dogs, this is what they need to start doing.

https://www.thestar.co.uk/news/crime/police-concerns-over-xl-bully-dogs-after-south-yorkshire-woman-died-following-attack-by-gentle-giants-4203590Lady killed by dogs she believed to be gentle giants

OP posts:
humanity15 · 31/08/2023 01:37

I'm really sorry I haven't replied to everyone's comments, for me it is very distressing doing this.
I haven't been able to bring myself to read many of them yet.
I knew the sort of backlash I would get for doing this, but it is something that needs to happen or more people are going to suffer.

A serious dog attack in which you are fearing for your life is something I would not wish on anyone.

When I raised safety concerns at my workplace it was because people were afraid for their safety.
So many of my colleagues were getting injured, some very seriously.
I had a choice to make as I could very clearly see what was wrong.
Had I kept quiet my life would of been very different.
That wasn't the choice I took. It was only a matter of time before something really terrible was going to take place.
For myself I knew I'd would never forgive myself if I'd sat back and let that happen.

The consequences of remaining silent can be devastating.
We each have a voice, but too many of us are afraid to use it. We live in fear and this needs to change.

For the sake of all those who work in the dog sector, especially those working with rescue dogs I have asked my workplace to make public what happened.
I've said I will stand by them.

It is not the charity that did this, but its name is suffering and that of other charities as a result.
This is where individual responsibility comes in.
Most people in the rescue sector know what happened, if they don't other staff soon tell them.
This damages what trust individuals have and as a consequence puts them in danger.

There is so much needs to change. The fact we have so many rescue centres is a terrible reflection on how we treat animals.
Some situations can't be helped, but many people literally use rescue centres as a dumping ground.

The public perception of what a rescue dog is can often be very different to reality.
The media often portray a certain image of rescue dogs, especially on talent shows.
However these dogs are often very straight forward and easy to train.

Many rescue dogs the public will never see because they are often deemed too dangerous and are put to sleep.
For many they come with problems, usually through a lack of early socialisation and habituation.
Staff where I worked were injured by dogs of all breeds, not just certain ones.
We also only used positive reinforcement.

At the moment it is far too easy for anyone to get hold of a dog.
Hopefully the day will come when rescue centres no longer need to exist.

OP posts:
humanity15 · 30/08/2023 23:54

When you hear places telling you reading a dogs body language will help avoid an attack, that does not work with a dog intent on fighting.

Please notice the speed of the dog and how intent it is. (very distressing images).

Notice as well like most dog attacks the owner flees the scene.
Not many are caught on camera like this one so there is no way of tracing the attacking dogs owners.

Often when pet dogs are killed and owners are injured the police do not even investigate.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12461755/amp/Shocking-moment-crazed-dog-launches-vicious-attack-pensioner-76-pet-labradoodle-police-launch-hunt-owner.html

Moment crazed dog launches savages pensioner, 76, and her labradoodle

WARNING GRAPHIC CONTENT: This is the horrific moment a 76-year-old pensioner and her pet labradoodle were viciously attacked by a crazed dog on the streets of Birmingham.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12461755/amp/Shocking-moment-crazed-dog-launches-vicious-attack-pensioner-76-pet-labradoodle-police-launch-hunt-owner.html

OP posts:
Xrays · 30/08/2023 22:55

Lovemusic82 · 30/08/2023 22:50

I don’t get how people can compare a greyhound killing a cat to a XL bully killing a child.

Most deaths from dog attacks in the last year have been from xl bull dogs, not greyhounds or huskies (I’m not a fan of huskies). They are status dogs that are being bred to sell to idiots that just want to look hard. Most of these dogs are kept cooped up in small flats, not being trained or exercised, it’s a recipe for disaster?

This 💯

Lovemusic82 · 30/08/2023 22:50

I don’t get how people can compare a greyhound killing a cat to a XL bully killing a child.

Most deaths from dog attacks in the last year have been from xl bull dogs, not greyhounds or huskies (I’m not a fan of huskies). They are status dogs that are being bred to sell to idiots that just want to look hard. Most of these dogs are kept cooped up in small flats, not being trained or exercised, it’s a recipe for disaster?

Prescottdanni123 · 30/08/2023 22:48

@XenoBitch

And look what happens. Someone who has never owned so much as a hamster before buys an XL bully off a random stranger on gumtree, thinking it will be a good playmate for their toddler as they grow up. It shouldn't be allowed and part of the reason why rescue centres are so full is because people buy a dog online, realize that while it is cute, it also barks, shits, needs excersize and can't be left to its own devices for 20 hours a day so they give it to a rescue centre.

Xrays · 30/08/2023 22:46

RunningFromInsanity · 30/08/2023 21:59

How many fatalities have been caused by a Pekinese?

No one is denying that all dogs can bite, regardless of breed. The issue is that a bite from a Pekinese is very very different from a bite from an XL bully. And that is what makes them dangerous dogs.

Agree.

I am horrified by the rise in attacks and can’t stand xl bully dogs and the culture that goes along with them.

I read this last night and couldn’t stop thinking about this poor boy and his Mum. Just horrendous.

Jack Lis: Mother of son killed by dog haunted by last image https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-64353711

Jack Lis

Jack Lis: Mother of son killed by dog haunted by last image

Emma Whitfield's son Jack was mauled to death by an American XL bully dog named Beast.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-64353711

XenoBitch · 30/08/2023 22:43

Oysterbabe · 30/08/2023 22:28

Also a breed known for chasing and killing smaller animals. My friends greyhound killed 3 cats. They're near the top of dogs that should be muzzled.

Racing greyhounds, yes. I had mine from a pup, and she was never raced. But OP is on about dogs that are dangerous to humans. The only danger a greyhound poses to a person is hogging the sofa and making the human sit on the floor.

Jack Russells, a small breed, are bred as ratters. My grandad's own JR killed rats on his farm for him (and a feral kitten).

Muzzling dogs based on weight is nuts.