Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you support the ULEZ expansion?

758 replies

icecream99 · 28/08/2023 19:42

Just curious as it is due to start at midnight tonight and could potentially cause a lot of chaos. I don't support it.

YANBU - I DON'T support ULEZ expansion

YABU - I DO support ULEZ expansion

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Sigmama · 31/08/2023 07:43

Grass321, it's not the greatest business model for money grabbing though, given as people will eventually give up their cars and join the thousands of non drivers in london who won't have to pay a penny

Sigmama · 31/08/2023 07:40

Jcyclops, 'a nightmare' is having 40 million cars on the road, if you want to drive, deal with the admin or find another way to travel

grass321 · 31/08/2023 06:55

It will be a nightmare for any driver entering a town and trying to work out the places where is vehicle is compliant and where it is not.

I have autopay set up for the ULEZ which is fine. I drove round Birmingham last year and wasn't sure whether I'd entered its clean air zone. Phoned up to check and they said they couldn't tell me and it was self declaration. So if I hadn't paid, they weren't running an ANPR system to send me a fine? It's ridiculous.

I'm sorry but the ULEZ is a money making scheme. And, as I've said, it's going to increase the pollution in our local area which already fails the guidelines. The Imperial report showed it has minimal effects for those inside too, because people can and will still drive in with high emission vehicles.

If you want to actually improve air pollution, ban all non electric cars by 2028. Not that I think they're environmentally friendly in many ways but at least there's some rationale to it. This pay model is just plugging Khan's massive hole in the TfL finances.

DdraigGoch · 31/08/2023 01:04

For those worried about tradesmen, this plumber does 95% of his work by bike. Obviously heavy deliveries will need a vehicle, but many cargo bikes can manage 100kg (five bags of cement) and let's face it most bigger loads will come on a lorry, not in a van. Unlike his van that takes 40 minutes to get to a job through the traffic, he says that he feels "quite smug" as he whizzes past the jams.

twitter.com/TfL/status/1399984125755330567

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2023 23:51

Jumpingthruhoops · 30/08/2023 22:55

What sort of ridiculous comment is that!? Of course it's only road users' opinion that matters on a road policy like ULEZ - they're the ones being asked to pay it!!
Non-drivers' opinion on ULEZ would of course matter if ULEZ was really about reducing air pollution. But it isn't. So it doesn't.🤷🏼‍♀️

And my question about Khan isn't strawman at all. If he succeeds in his aim of stopping cars driving into London and people decide to stop coming into London altogether, TFL would go under and he'd be begging drivers to come back! Either that, or start charging cyclists £12.50 instead. As they say, be careful what you wish for...

There are myriad ways to get into London that don’t involve cars, particularly ICE cars and they are widely used now. You’re being a bit silly.

jcyclops · 30/08/2023 23:41

Two things annoy me around this topic.

The first is calling it ULTRA LOW Emission Zone. What is "Ultra" about it when it will have a minimal effect on pollution and still allow 80-90% of fossil fuelled vehicles to travel without charge. It should really be called the "Slightly Lower Emission Zone". They can call it ULTRA when all fossil fuelled cars have to pay or are banned from the zone.

The second is that these schemes are being left up to local government to devise and implement. In the near future every city and large town will have Clean Air Zones, and they will all have different rules. It will be a nightmare for any driver entering a town and trying to work out the places where is vehicle is compliant and where it is not.

Jumpingthruhoops · 30/08/2023 22:55

snowgirl1 · 30/08/2023 22:36

Don't agree that other transport costs "nowhere near" what drivers have to pay. My car costs me about the same to run each year (taking fuel, insurance, MOT, maintenance, Vehicle Excise Duty (VED) - because there's no such thing as 'road tax' - and depreciation into account) as it costs me to commute into work by public transport 3 days per week.

Me pointing out that other methods of transport have a cost clearly isn't a strawman argument, when you're complaining that car drivers are the only ones always being penalised 😪

I didn't answer you question about Sadiq Khan, because that is a strawman argument - it's totally irrelevant to the point I raised, which was your offensive (and possibly incorrect, because you no idea how much tax the PP pays) view that PP's view was "redundant" because they didn't contribute as much to the roads as you. I haven't commented either way on ULEZ on this thread - just responded to your high-handed attitude towards other road users and attitude that car drivers somehow have more right to an opinion about road policy - so, no, I'm not interested in answering your question.

What sort of ridiculous comment is that!? Of course it's only road users' opinion that matters on a road policy like ULEZ - they're the ones being asked to pay it!!
Non-drivers' opinion on ULEZ would of course matter if ULEZ was really about reducing air pollution. But it isn't. So it doesn't.🤷🏼‍♀️

And my question about Khan isn't strawman at all. If he succeeds in his aim of stopping cars driving into London and people decide to stop coming into London altogether, TFL would go under and he'd be begging drivers to come back! Either that, or start charging cyclists £12.50 instead. As they say, be careful what you wish for...

Seagullchippy · 30/08/2023 22:50

Fifireee · 28/08/2023 20:17

Yes.
Too many nights in A&E with my DD struggling to breathe.
A friend who worked in the centre of Greenwich all her life and now has chronic asthma.
A friend who can no longer run - and he was an amazing runner - because he has such dreadful chest problems after running in the city of London every lunchtime during his working life.
A friend whose asthma is so bad his consultant has told him to move out of Clapham because air pollution is killing him.

ELLA KISSI DEBRAH
ELLA KISSI DEBRAH
ELLA KISSI DEBRAH.
That sweet smiling beautiful girl who died as a direct result of pollution.

This.

snowgirl1 · 30/08/2023 22:36

Jumpingthruhoops · 30/08/2023 19:45

Ahh... the classic strawman argument. 🙄

To own a vehicle AND make sure it's legally road worthy, drivers must pay: Road tax, insurance, MOT (which could also mean new tyres), fuel, parking charges, plus various tolls like ULEZ, all of which costs hundreds, if not thousands, a year.

Yes, there are costs to those other modes of transport. Obviously. But they are nowhere near what drivers are required to pay. I'm sure you'll find another way to argue that point, though.

You did, however, neglect to answer my question, which was, if everyone ditched their cars tomorrow, would Sadiq Khan consider this a victory?

Don't agree that other transport costs "nowhere near" what drivers have to pay. My car costs me about the same to run each year (taking fuel, insurance, MOT, maintenance, Vehicle Excise Duty (VED) - because there's no such thing as 'road tax' - and depreciation into account) as it costs me to commute into work by public transport 3 days per week.

Me pointing out that other methods of transport have a cost clearly isn't a strawman argument, when you're complaining that car drivers are the only ones always being penalised 😪

I didn't answer you question about Sadiq Khan, because that is a strawman argument - it's totally irrelevant to the point I raised, which was your offensive (and possibly incorrect, because you no idea how much tax the PP pays) view that PP's view was "redundant" because they didn't contribute as much to the roads as you. I haven't commented either way on ULEZ on this thread - just responded to your high-handed attitude towards other road users and attitude that car drivers somehow have more right to an opinion about road policy - so, no, I'm not interested in answering your question.

Jumpingthruhoops · 30/08/2023 22:34

limitedperiodonly · 30/08/2023 20:02

I know @snowgirl1 It's like it's free to travel on public transport in London unless you are a child or over 60. I pay to travel on public transport because I weigh up the costs and time and think it's the best option for me. If it's not the best option for you @Jumpingthruhoops then do what you want to do. All I ask is that you pay your fair share. Why shouldn't you? I do.

I pay MORE than my 'fair share'. My point is, others don't. While at the same time being very vocal about expecting drivers to pay even more.

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2023 21:09

limitedperiodonly · 30/08/2023 20:28

I really hate to say this @greengreengrass25 but can you give me the relevant stats for air quality on the Underground? As a regular user I'd like to know. And would you cross-reference them to stats for air quality produced by cars and breathed by people living and driving around Central London, major arteries through the Capital and also the M25? A car is not a sealed unit and the driver will be breathing the polluted air around them as well as pumping it out. So even if you live in the leafy suburbs or rural bits of Essex you will still breathe it, won't you? Unless you give me it in an easily digestible form I'm not going to take it seriously.

It's certainly bad on the Underground. It's a confined space, after all so any dust created by wheel flange wear or by the contact shoe just accumulates.

Still, at least you're not living in it, you wouldn't spend anything like the time on the Underground as you would at home or at school.

Teajenny7 · 30/08/2023 20:56

I fully support it. I live outside greater London. I rarely drive into the city but have have an older car that is compliant. I usually use public transport.
Why wouldn't we want to protect people?
Hopefully, it will be brought out country wide

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2023 20:29

Comedycook · 30/08/2023 17:57

So you want all cars banned then?

I realise that this is impractical, so I'll settle for most of them.

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2023 20:28

Comedycook · 30/08/2023 17:55

Perish the thought someone who doesn't live on your road uses your road...oh the absolute horror! Non locals!!!

I'd be quite happy if fewer locals used roads too to be honest, fewer cars cluttering up the street that way. The parking wars where I live are unreal, eggs got thrown last time. But yes, I dislike the use of cars for through traffic more than I dislike the motorists who actually have business on that street. It's bad enough shitting on your own doorstep without shitting on other people's too.

Fewer cars is the theme, do you see?

limitedperiodonly · 30/08/2023 20:28

greengreengrass25 · 30/08/2023 20:10

The other point is the air quality is dubious on the underground

I really hate to say this @greengreengrass25 but can you give me the relevant stats for air quality on the Underground? As a regular user I'd like to know. And would you cross-reference them to stats for air quality produced by cars and breathed by people living and driving around Central London, major arteries through the Capital and also the M25? A car is not a sealed unit and the driver will be breathing the polluted air around them as well as pumping it out. So even if you live in the leafy suburbs or rural bits of Essex you will still breathe it, won't you? Unless you give me it in an easily digestible form I'm not going to take it seriously.

limitedperiodonly · 30/08/2023 20:10

Ireallylikepictures · 30/08/2023 19:42

If they mean London, about 24% of Londoners actually voted for khan. Of those I bet not all support ulez

@Ireallylikepictures I voted for Sadiq Khan twice and fully support Ulez and the other things he has done for public transport. I will vote for him next time. But if you don't want to and are eligible to vote and your candidate wins I will abide by that.

greengreengrass25 · 30/08/2023 20:10

The other point is the air quality is dubious on the underground

limitedperiodonly · 30/08/2023 20:02

snowgirl1 · 30/08/2023 19:26

ALL of the extras drivers pay? Because every other method of transport is free isn't it? Trains, buses, trams, cycling...all free..oh no, wait...

I know @snowgirl1 It's like it's free to travel on public transport in London unless you are a child or over 60. I pay to travel on public transport because I weigh up the costs and time and think it's the best option for me. If it's not the best option for you @Jumpingthruhoops then do what you want to do. All I ask is that you pay your fair share. Why shouldn't you? I do.

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2023 19:58

To own a vehicle AND make sure it's legally road worthy, drivers must pay: Road tax, insurance, MOT (which could also mean new tyres), fuel, parking charges, plus various tolls like ULEZ, all of which costs hundreds, if not thousands, a year.

No one is required to own a car. So all of those costs result from the choice to own and use a car.

Even if someone chooses to own a car they aren’t required to pay tolls unless they want to use the relevant bridge / M6 or drive the car into central London (congestion charge) or drive it into the ULEZ (vast majority of cars are exempt).

If they replace it every three years no MOT.

Buy an electric car no VED

The only unavoidable cost is insurance.

Don’t want to pay, don’t own a car

limitedperiodonly · 30/08/2023 19:53

Comedycook · 30/08/2023 19:12

I'm currently parked up on a residential road and I don't live on it....arrrggghhhh a non local in a car on a road with houses on it.

That's fine if there are no restrictions. There are in my road. I don't understand why you don't understand that. If you have to pay then just do it or just don't park up there. What is hard to get about that? I'd get it if there were restrictions in your road and would comply.

Jumpingthruhoops · 30/08/2023 19:45

snowgirl1 · 30/08/2023 19:26

ALL of the extras drivers pay? Because every other method of transport is free isn't it? Trains, buses, trams, cycling...all free..oh no, wait...

Ahh... the classic strawman argument. 🙄

To own a vehicle AND make sure it's legally road worthy, drivers must pay: Road tax, insurance, MOT (which could also mean new tyres), fuel, parking charges, plus various tolls like ULEZ, all of which costs hundreds, if not thousands, a year.

Yes, there are costs to those other modes of transport. Obviously. But they are nowhere near what drivers are required to pay. I'm sure you'll find another way to argue that point, though.

You did, however, neglect to answer my question, which was, if everyone ditched their cars tomorrow, would Sadiq Khan consider this a victory?

Ireallylikepictures · 30/08/2023 19:42

Comedycook · 30/08/2023 16:55

I still don't understand what "your area" is?

If they mean London, about 24% of Londoners actually voted for khan. Of those I bet not all support ulez

snowgirl1 · 30/08/2023 19:26

Jumpingthruhoops · 30/08/2023 19:03

I've explained what I mean multiple times now - I'm referring to ALL of the extras drivers pay, only to be further penalised at every opportunity.

Answer me this. Hypothetically speaking, if everyone stopped driving into Greater/Inner London from tomorrow full stop for weeks on end, would Sadiq Khan consider this a victory?

ALL of the extras drivers pay? Because every other method of transport is free isn't it? Trains, buses, trams, cycling...all free..oh no, wait...

kalokagathos · 30/08/2023 19:15

YABU

Comedycook · 30/08/2023 19:12

I'm currently parked up on a residential road and I don't live on it....arrrggghhhh a non local in a car on a road with houses on it.