Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you support the ULEZ expansion?

758 replies

icecream99 · 28/08/2023 19:42

Just curious as it is due to start at midnight tonight and could potentially cause a lot of chaos. I don't support it.

YANBU - I DON'T support ULEZ expansion

YABU - I DO support ULEZ expansion

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 21:05

Sigmama · 31/08/2023 20:55

Cars in general are not 'perfectly decent'

don't be silly. Yes they can but I have decided on the whole that they are not so that's why I don't drive one.

Sigmama · 31/08/2023 20:55

Cars in general are not 'perfectly decent'

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 20:53

@grass321 you'd have to get rid of your car if you drove in Ulez. So what? My last car was registered in 1988, I got rid of it in 2006 more than 20 years before Ulez came in because it wasn't worth it.

It was a perfectly decent car but it was costing me too much money.

It wouldn't be Ulez-compliant now but I got rid of it a long time ago. If I bought a new one afterwards it would probably be compliant. But I didn't.

Sigmama · 31/08/2023 20:48

Exdonkeylover, and how do you think people without cars go shopping?

grass321 · 31/08/2023 20:36

Would you prefer that for Ulez? I don't care but accept this gives people time to adjust their habits.

Yes. As a few of us have said on this thread, at least it would have the desired effect on emissions rather than being a money grab.

We're ending up with a lot of perfectly decent cars being scrapped (including mine) on supposed environmental grounds but without the benefit of much better air quality. Add in the Imperial study and the cost-benefit analysis of the current scheme looks rather questionable.

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 20:24

Exdonkeylover · 31/08/2023 20:22

Agree completely, plus clean air is one thing, but at what cost?

Really if someone is that desperate for clean air, move out of the city. You know when you live there air quality is worse.

Reality is it'll cost the economy, people won't go to certain shops because of the cost of driving, and they have less money to spend.

Plus it's forcing people to use an underground system that has massive levels of pollution.

Eh?

Exdonkeylover · 31/08/2023 20:22

Agree completely, plus clean air is one thing, but at what cost?

Really if someone is that desperate for clean air, move out of the city. You know when you live there air quality is worse.

Reality is it'll cost the economy, people won't go to certain shops because of the cost of driving, and they have less money to spend.

Plus it's forcing people to use an underground system that has massive levels of pollution.

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 20:13

grass321 · 31/08/2023 20:06

People whined about all about those things then but looking back, why would you? Would you insist on your freedom to not wear a seatbelt or to smoke indoors now?

It's not comparable because it's not a blanket ban, there's a paid for exemption, The equivalent would be to charge people for the privilege of smoking inside or not wearing a seatbelt.

@grass321 there was a blanket ban in the case of seatbelts and smoking indoors. Would you prefer that for Ulez? I don't care but accept this gives people time to adjust their habits.

grass321 · 31/08/2023 20:06

People whined about all about those things then but looking back, why would you? Would you insist on your freedom to not wear a seatbelt or to smoke indoors now?

It's not comparable because it's not a blanket ban, there's a paid for exemption, The equivalent would be to charge people for the privilege of smoking inside or not wearing a seatbelt.

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 20:01

@Exdonkeylover this is a public health issue. National government have been working to improve public health since at least 1948 when the NHS was founded under Labour and 1956 when the Clean Air Act were passed under the Tories.

Don't you agree those things were a good idea? If not, why not?

It's affected me for the best. My lungs are at their full capacity. I'm guessing it has helped you too. I wouldn't want a child to have stunted lungs just because she lived on the South Circular in London like Ella Kissi-Debrah. Look at her face and ask if her life was worth driving a car. Would you say that to her mum? https://ellaroberta.org/about-ella

Ulez has affected me from 2019 and I am fine with it. Just like I was in 2007 when smoking indoors was banned nationally or 1983 when it became compulsory nationally in the UK to wear seat belts. People whined about all about those things then but looking back, why would you? Would you insist on your freedom to not wear a seatbelt or to smoke indoors now?

Ella's Life Hero

About Ella | The Ella Roberta Foundation

Ella is the first person in the world to have air pollution listed as a cause of death on her death certificate.

https://ellaroberta.org/about-ella

Exdonkeylover · 31/08/2023 18:58

For someone who lives in the zone, might be a single parent or low income family, needs the car for work, if you factor in one day on a weekend to drove, that's £300pcm. When half the country is always struggling to get by with largest inflation for a number of years.
You say hurt, but £300 is enough to push some people in to poverty.

Having lived in London, transport outside zone 2 (central London) is not always great
All tubes head inwards and buses float in between, but traffic slows them down badly and many occasions people been more than one bus.
It'll probably cost Khan his job. He won't be spending a possible £300M a year on trees to improve air quality or reducing the cost of the tube. Congestion charge already makes that amount per year. Granted, running costs, but I never saw any effort to make public transport more affordable to those using it from that money.

user1477391263 · 31/08/2023 18:56

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 17:58

I find case studies for a living and it has been possible to find people who will be adversely affected by the Ulez expansion and I have reported on them.

But blow me, when I've asked for case studies I've been bombarded with people who say: "My car is Ulez-compliant but I'm worried about the little people."

Fine. That's really nice of you to care but like people on the roads you are useless to me. Can you just get out of my way so I can find the people who really do need to drive their non-compliant cars, will be badly affected and will make good stories.

I would concur with TfL's figures that most people drive compliant cars. There are some people who don't and if they really want to change then Central Government - that one being led by Rishi Sunak - should help Sadiq Khan for the good of our health and savings for the NHS.

The rest of you bleating whataboutery and tax grabs when your car is compliant just get in the way, Much like you do when I'm on the bus.

IKR?

It's really easy to comply with the Ulez. People are making it sound like you need a brand new vehicle or an EV! It's not true.

Sigmama · 31/08/2023 18:49

Jumping, perhaps some people might try and find other ways of getting their kids to school

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 18:47

Exdonkeylover · 31/08/2023 18:26

Remember, you can spread fumes, but only if you have money.

Life for the wealthy again.

Try lobbying China to stop building coal power stations and the US to reduce its pollution.

@Exdonkeylover Would you prefer it if people were banned from driving their non-compliant cars in London? I don't. At the moment they can do it but it will cost £12.50 a day. That will hurt but sometimes things hurt for the good of the rest of us. What do you suggest as a solution to make people switch to public transport or compliant cars beyond asking nicely? Our national Government, which is Conservative, could step in at any point but don't want to. Why do you think they don't want to assist in this public health issue by a Labour administration that will ease the burden on the NHS a year out from a General, Election ?

Exdonkeylover · 31/08/2023 18:26

Remember, you can spread fumes, but only if you have money.

Life for the wealthy again.

Try lobbying China to stop building coal power stations and the US to reduce its pollution.

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 17:58

I find case studies for a living and it has been possible to find people who will be adversely affected by the Ulez expansion and I have reported on them.

But blow me, when I've asked for case studies I've been bombarded with people who say: "My car is Ulez-compliant but I'm worried about the little people."

Fine. That's really nice of you to care but like people on the roads you are useless to me. Can you just get out of my way so I can find the people who really do need to drive their non-compliant cars, will be badly affected and will make good stories.

I would concur with TfL's figures that most people drive compliant cars. There are some people who don't and if they really want to change then Central Government - that one being led by Rishi Sunak - should help Sadiq Khan for the good of our health and savings for the NHS.

The rest of you bleating whataboutery and tax grabs when your car is compliant just get in the way, Much like you do when I'm on the bus.

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 17:39

Ontopofthesunset · 31/08/2023 16:31

One of the most annoying things to me about this debate (where there appears to be a lot more heat than light from many people, who are startlingly ill-informed) is the way people against ULEZ are blaming Sadiq Khan personally. It was, as others have said, originally a Tory policy, and it's not some strange personal vendetta against car owners.

Everyone is in favour of pollution reducing measures until it affects them personally. I get that. We are all a little bit selfish like that.

But we should be reducing car ownership to keep our cities clean and lower emissions. I understand public transport links are not as good in many outer London boroughs as they are more centrally, but the obvious choice is to vote for a government who will increase expenditure in public transport.

I've been living in the ULEZ since the first expansion. I have lived in London in both inner and outer boroughs all my life, bar a few years, and virtually everyone I know supports the expansion in principle, though some disagree with the speed of implementation, which is a fair point.

I agree with everything you said @Ontopofthesunset

Ontopofthesunset · 31/08/2023 16:31

One of the most annoying things to me about this debate (where there appears to be a lot more heat than light from many people, who are startlingly ill-informed) is the way people against ULEZ are blaming Sadiq Khan personally. It was, as others have said, originally a Tory policy, and it's not some strange personal vendetta against car owners.

Everyone is in favour of pollution reducing measures until it affects them personally. I get that. We are all a little bit selfish like that.

But we should be reducing car ownership to keep our cities clean and lower emissions. I understand public transport links are not as good in many outer London boroughs as they are more centrally, but the obvious choice is to vote for a government who will increase expenditure in public transport.

I've been living in the ULEZ since the first expansion. I have lived in London in both inner and outer boroughs all my life, bar a few years, and virtually everyone I know supports the expansion in principle, though some disagree with the speed of implementation, which is a fair point.

Pizfufffff · 31/08/2023 16:14

I'm for ulez style zones in principle. I am completely AGAINST the way this has been rolled out, especially Sadiq Khan's refusal to address people's legitimate concerns about the roll out. He's been bleating out the same talking points for months and months while refusing to acknowledge that people that are NOT in receipt of benefits may be having a tough time due to COL and they should get a scrappage allowance too. He finally opened it up to all Londoners ONE WEEK before the expansion starts, meaning no one has had enough time to apply for the scheme, scrap their car, wait for the cheque and then go and buy a new car. They are stuck paying the charge until further notice. I have voted labour my entire adult life but will NOT be voting for Khan in the next mayoral election.

user1477391263 · 31/08/2023 13:58

Comedycook · 31/08/2023 10:13

Electric cars are very heavy...there's even be talk as to how multi storey car parks won't be able to cope with the weight once ev's become more common.

The weight does indeed go up a bit, assuming all other factors are kept constant; the solution to this is for people to have smaller and lighter vehicles and drive less.

LittleBearPad · 31/08/2023 13:50

Jumpingthruhoops · 31/08/2023 09:31

Not being silly at all? Do you actually live in London?

Yes. Have done for over 20 years.

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 13:26

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2023 21:09

It's certainly bad on the Underground. It's a confined space, after all so any dust created by wheel flange wear or by the contact shoe just accumulates.

Still, at least you're not living in it, you wouldn't spend anything like the time on the Underground as you would at home or at school.

@DdraigGoch Thanks. I take all your points including the amount of time you spend there. A while ago I'd spend 40 minutes on the Tube but half that was above ground before I went into tunnels.

These days my usual journey is 10 minutes. The longest regular one is 25ish nearly all underground. It's to a hospital in a heavily polluted and not noticeably rich and car-owning part of East London ironically.

Their heart and lung departments are NHS centres of excellence. They probably get a lot of practice.

greengreengrass25 · 31/08/2023 13:14

The government receive a lot of revenue from petrol

limitedperiodonly · 31/08/2023 13:11

Jumpingthruhoops · 30/08/2023 22:34

I pay MORE than my 'fair share'. My point is, others don't. While at the same time being very vocal about expecting drivers to pay even more.

You don't. You pay the costs of owning and operating a car and in return you get convenience and depending on the type of car, the pleasure of owning and driving a nice thing. Some cars are very desirable. You can carry up to three or maybe four passengers, say, but if you don't want to share, you can be alone. I understand the attractions.

Anytime you feel it's not worth the cost then sell it and don't get another one. That's what I did. I pay my fair share on public transport and the cost is lower than yours because I am prepared to wait for a double decker bus that I don't own and have to fuel and maintain and then share it with up to 80 strangers at a time all paying their fare apart from children, over-60s and fare dodgers. Did you learn about economies of scale at school? Even if you didn't it's not hard to work out.

I also think public transport should be subsidised and private car driving penalised in some circumstances - stopping short of a blanket ban - for the good of the greater number of people in a community.

I understand how travelling like that might not be for you but fail to see how the prices we both choose to pay are not fair.

WhenLifeGivesYouLimes · 31/08/2023 12:20

On the subject of outer London transport improvements required, the "Superloop" bus plans are intended to increase frequency around the outer London periphery. The first upgraded section is being increased from every 30 minutes to every 15 minutes which is a quantum leap in useability. (I can hear the occupants of my parents' village which gets two buses a week laughing hollowly at this but of course the cost per passenger of running half hourly bus journeys to and from their village would be astronomical)
https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/buses/superloop

The pandemic has killed off plans for the Bakerloo extension alas. There are huge chunks of south east London for which that would have been transformational.

Superloop

Our proposed Superloop of bus routes would connect key outer London town centres, stations and transport hubs

https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/buses/superloop