Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you support the ULEZ expansion?

758 replies

icecream99 · 28/08/2023 19:42

Just curious as it is due to start at midnight tonight and could potentially cause a lot of chaos. I don't support it.

YANBU - I DON'T support ULEZ expansion

YABU - I DO support ULEZ expansion

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Ilmecourtsurleharicot · 29/08/2023 09:23

I need to add if TFL or Team Sadiq are reading this, that cycling isn’t always an option for urban residents who want to use a bike. Loads of converted houses to flats and many purpose built flats don’t have anywhere secure to store bicycles and you have to pay a lot and go on a waiting list for the council rented secure bike sheds which often aren’t located where the flats are. So that needs to be part of the joined up thinking too.

Fightyouforthatpie · 29/08/2023 09:21

Istanbulnotconstantinople72 · 28/08/2023 20:11

YABU the only way we'll do anything about the climate crisis is by extreme measures. If anything ULEZ doesn't go far enough.

ULEZ is not addressing climate change, it's (if it works) about cleaning up the air in cities.
If everyone switches to compliant vehicles, that will create an increase in Co2 emissions, not a decrease, both from the emissions of manufacture and recycling, but also moving to more petrol cars actually increases co2 per mile/km as they are not as efficient as diesels in co2 emissions.

Jumpingthruhoops · 29/08/2023 09:21

Squiblet · 28/08/2023 22:25

I don't drive, just cycle everywhere, and I'm supporting it for the sake of my lungs & others'. Why does one person's money trump another's health?

Ahh, that explains it. Of course you would support ANY charge on motorists.

How fortunate that you're able to cycle everywhere. Most people don't have that luxury and rely on their cars to get to work, school(s), hospitals with elderly relatives. How do you manage to do all that on a bike?

As someone who uses roads to go everywhere, have you considered paying £12.50 a day for their upkeep? No. Didn't think so.

user1477391263 · 29/08/2023 09:17

mrandmrsrobinson · 28/08/2023 22:10

Well this person won't be giving business to about 35 businesses. Everything from farm shops to deli's, cinemas, cafes, garden centres as well as BIG name retailers and fast food outlets. Won't be attending funerals when they come up. Won't be attending children's sports events when inside the ULEZ Zone.
Won't be dating anyone either if they fall in the zone and I won't be going into London by any other means and partaking of concerts or theatres or tourist destinations like museums etc.
I don't want a new car and I don't want the scappage scheme. So fuck em.

The thing is, shops and other businesses in urban areas tend to get better and more reliable custom from people living locally (either car-free or one-car-per-household) in the city center, and who do stuff on foot/bike in their local urban neighborhood…. Rather than people living on the outskirts of cities, who SAY “If you make it easy for me to drive my car into the center of town I’ll drive in there and spend money there!”but in practice they actually don’t do this very often and they mostly just hang out at home and go to out-of-town shopping centers/out-of-town big-box stores and shop online.

Cities are generally (I’m sure there are exceptions; there is more than one way to run a city) better off designing urban areas around the needs of local walking/biking/PT-using local residents and building lots of dense housing there, rather than designing urban areas around cars/driving/parking and then sort of hoping/praying that the suburbanites WILL actually drive in and revive the high street like they keep promising they will.

WhenLifeGivesYouLimes · 29/08/2023 09:16

jessycake · 29/08/2023 09:02

I'm not convinced that all this investment is just for a dwindling number of non compliant cars or air pollution

The camera infrastructure was already in place for the LEZ which applies to lorries and was introduced over ten years ago. The computer system to charge the daily fees was set up for the existing smaller ULEZ and the congestion charge.

Hence the cost of changing the footprint for the ULEZ was just the signage and a mail shot. Not free, but all the really expensive stuff was piggybacked on pre-existing projects.

That's why it goes all the way out so far. It's caused huge political angst and something smaller would probably have been easier to justify, but implementing a halfway house expansion between the old ULEZ zone and the LEZ zone would have been really expensive.

BBno4 · 29/08/2023 09:14

I've been in the original zone for years and could really tell the difference when I drove out into other areas. The fumes coming out of exhausts and just generally shitty cars.

Round here all the white vans seem to be new anyway. We are always saying look how dirty and scratched that van is and its only a 22 plate.

Ginmonkeyagain · 29/08/2023 09:09

Definitely support. We live near the boundary of the orginal ULEZ expansion and the world hasn't fallen in, businesses haven't failed, we still get tradesmen.

Something has to be done about air pollution - if this was a new virus killing people and damaging children's health in the same numbers people would be howling for government action.

I get the concerns about the "stick" of the £12.50 charge but sadly that is what it often takes for people to change their behaviour.

Ilmecourtsurleharicot · 29/08/2023 09:08

I support the expansion because dirty air= death and suffering.

All my life I have lived and worked inside the original ulez area or now inside the expansion area. We have a small family business and have one only-just non compliant van, by a year, that we can’t afford to replace. Many multiples of the scrappage payment would be needed to replace it. So we will save up as best we can and pay the charge every day it goes off the driveway.

So yes, it’s an absolute pain in the arse but yes, it’s also absolutely the right thing to do. I will vote for Khan again.
Agree that everything is so expensive though so we really need to work on the cost of living (housing, food, transport etc) and need to improve public transport for the whole of London which is not just a London Mayor thing but it is also a national government thing. So I really want to see them working together more.

So use your vote carefully- the past 13 years have taken us to being a struggling economy worse than neighbouring countries so I don’t think the answer can be for us to keep on voting for Christmas like turkeys.

GKD · 29/08/2023 09:05

Wotchaz · 29/08/2023 08:54

Interesting how the majority of votes are anti-ULEZ when the majority of posts seem to be pro. Not often that I see the benefit in the voting buttons, but this is an exception.

Aside from the air quality arguments, can you imagine if we get stuck with another 5 years of the Tories because Labour loses so many London seats?!?

I’m not sure Lab will lose LDN seats due to ULEZ.

  1. it will have settled by then, many naysayers will realise they are exempt
  2. Uxbridge was Tory anyway and even with ULEZ the Tory maj was hit hard.
  3. The hard objecting boroughs (Havering/Bromley etc) are Tory anyway. Plus point 1.

I do think Lab have handled it badly though - they’ve not publicised that this is/was Tory policy and seem to be throwing Khan under a bus with going ahead.

jessycake · 29/08/2023 09:02

I'm not convinced that all this investment is just for a dwindling number of non compliant cars or air pollution

C8H10N4O2 · 29/08/2023 08:55

Fifireee · 28/08/2023 20:17

Yes.
Too many nights in A&E with my DD struggling to breathe.
A friend who worked in the centre of Greenwich all her life and now has chronic asthma.
A friend who can no longer run - and he was an amazing runner - because he has such dreadful chest problems after running in the city of London every lunchtime during his working life.
A friend whose asthma is so bad his consultant has told him to move out of Clapham because air pollution is killing him.

ELLA KISSI DEBRAH
ELLA KISSI DEBRAH
ELLA KISSI DEBRAH.
That sweet smiling beautiful girl who died as a direct result of pollution.

Air quality in the outer London Boroughs is completely different from the air quality inner London boroughs pre inner London ULEZ zone. Will you also be demanding ULEZ is implemented in Cumbria because its a problem in central London?

Air quality always been vastly better than inner London (reports green against standards most days of the year).

If the politicians really believed in it then they wouldn't be using regressive tax which penalises the poorest and smaller businesses whilst exempting more polluting new and expensive cars.
Or they would be providing realistic scrappage support.

Or they would target changes instead of sitting in Islington and just assuming that the M25 is an air quality barrier and not a bloody road.

So they have a scheme which is designed to boost new car sales (a massive carbon hit) and penalise lower and average income famiies with no matching improvement in public transport to reduce the need for cars.

Its virtue signalling with a large side order of hypocrisy.

Wotchaz · 29/08/2023 08:54

Interesting how the majority of votes are anti-ULEZ when the majority of posts seem to be pro. Not often that I see the benefit in the voting buttons, but this is an exception.

Aside from the air quality arguments, can you imagine if we get stuck with another 5 years of the Tories because Labour loses so many London seats?!?

GKD · 29/08/2023 08:51

@PuttingDownRoots Dual carriage way I was aware of A406 A40 have homes on them - I was bought up a stones throw from one then a 5 min walk from another.

We declined offering in a few houses last year due to proximity to local A-road (noise, pollution, safety). Obviously if we had no choice then so be it.

Makes sense re green belt and everyday is a school day! I bet I notice the houses now

(For the record I’m on the fence re ULEZ, it’s been poorly rolled out and the misconceptions! But I didn’t know re 10min walk to motorway)

Croissantsandpistachio · 29/08/2023 08:40

(@LaurieFairyCake if you're disabled there's a much longer transition, I think you're exempt until 2027 currently).

Croissantsandpistachio · 29/08/2023 08:39

@SoupDragon quite right, sorry! But I think it was discussed, even if not formal policy as long ago as 2006 ish. BJ got cold feet about the initial stage 3 expansion in 2008 after lobbying from Heavy Freight industry. The history is here: https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cdp-2022-0240/

But I still think the writing has very reasonably been on the wall for a long time.

Haha at 'I'm alright Jack'. Quite the opposite. 70% of poor outer londoners do not have cars, of that 30% most cars are compliant. Yet they suffer the most from air pollution and are least likely to be able to do anything about it. As a pp said, look a child having an asthma attack in the eye and say your perceived right to drive a highly polluting vehicle beats theirs to breathe. Say you're OK to Ella's mother, Ella who choked to death. This faux outrage on behalf of others by the anti ULEZ crew is tedious. What they're really interested in is driving a polluting car to the golf course. Bromley, Havering et al have excess deaths due to particulate pollution, and so there is a public health imperative to act (and it is a public health policy, not a climate one).

Anyway, happy ULEZ day everyone.
Breathe easier. I'm off to enjoy my day.

PuttingDownRoots · 29/08/2023 08:38

@GKD I live up in Yorkshire and there's new build estates being built in sight of the A1 for example... the A1 isn't as bad as the M25... but there doesn't seem to be any control of where housing can be in relation to major roads.
These houses aren't cheap either.. its "Executive" housing!

A lot of the M25 goes through the green belt, so there may be less housing due to that not the road.

GKD · 29/08/2023 08:34

Yes I did @eurochick .

I regularly travel a few junctions on the east (not a hell of a lot I accept) and it’s fields on both sides.

We had concerns about being so close (3miles as the crow flies) to the M25 when we bought the house so conscious that there’s no housing within about a mile.

It’s something I’m aware of, I was bought up next to elevated section of A40 - could see westway flyover from my bedroom.
My childhood asthma disappeared when we moved east (again near a dual carriageway but not as close) never had an attack or hospitalised since.

Was the 80s mind so 4 star petrol and whatnot.

LaurieFairyCake · 29/08/2023 08:34

Yes

Clean air and environment trumps everything

(I do think people with disabilities who can't use public transport should have a scheme where they can register and be exempt)

enchantedsquirrelwood · 29/08/2023 08:33

I do support it but I'd like to see all SUVs of any age added to it. Even the electric ones take up too much room on the roads and therefore add to congestion and pollution.

Sigmama · 29/08/2023 08:32

Soupdrzgon, the big picture? You mean clean air for more people? I'm not sure why car drivers needs trump everyone else's, they've had it their way for the last 50 years, time things changed.

eurochick · 29/08/2023 08:26

@gkd 10 mins walking is around half a mile. Did you really think there were no houses for a mile (half a mile each side) around the M25? That seems really odd if you live fairly close to it.

JanesBlond · 29/08/2023 08:23

SoupDragon · 29/08/2023 07:55

Your attitude is a classic "I'm alright, Jack" one. A lot of people are unable to see past their own nose and grasp the bigger picture.

I'm also going to be OK. My on-order compliant car will arrive eventually and I'm lucky enough to be able to afford this and any incurred charges in the meantime. I'm still against the expansion as it makes no sense in how it's implemented. It's all about money.

You're lucky that you were able to buy a car recently. Many people bought theirs a long time ago and are not able to afford a replacement. Many people bought diesel based on the misinformation given about the pollution.

Like I said, a lot of people can't see the bigger picture because it doesn't affect them They're alright so don't give a shit about those who aren't. You're not alone.

Most of the anti-ULEZ posts are ‘I’m alright Jack’ too, except they’re alright with the air quality which is killing other Londoners, which is the real bigger picture here.

anunlikelyseahorse · 29/08/2023 08:22

Halfemptyhalfling · 29/08/2023 08:15

Try saying you don't support ulez expansion to a child having an asthma attack- look them right in the eye

My dc do have asthma, they've both been hospitalised with it at various times, but I don't believe ULEZ will make much of a difference. A decent public transport system would.

Halfemptyhalfling · 29/08/2023 08:15

Try saying you don't support ulez expansion to a child having an asthma attack- look them right in the eye

SoupDragon · 29/08/2023 08:08

It's certainly not in his election manifesto for 2021. Only the N/S circular expansion.