Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you support the ULEZ expansion?

758 replies

icecream99 · 28/08/2023 19:42

Just curious as it is due to start at midnight tonight and could potentially cause a lot of chaos. I don't support it.

YANBU - I DON'T support ULEZ expansion

YABU - I DO support ULEZ expansion

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Carlapig1 · 05/09/2023 07:13

I can't believe the sob stories of people who say they can't manage without their car and how will they get anywhere, or visit their old parents, or do their voluntary work etc. Seriously what is wrong with people these days. If you can't afford to pay the ULEZ or get a compliant car the get on the bus or the train and if you can't do that then stay home - it's not rocket science.

user1477391263 · 04/09/2023 07:44

WildAlphabet · 03/09/2023 22:29

You got the wrong end of the stick. I’m totally fine with housing instead of the factories. They’re not building that. As I mentioned they are instead building a massive incinerator to burn most the waste of north London. All the wealthy boroughs will sent their rubbish to the NE corner and have it burnt here with a massive plume over the schools. More distribution has been built, more lorries come. MORE pollution is being generated. In the ulez zone on a grand scale and existing issues, like sewage overflowing into canals regularly etc isn’t being addressed. There’s no plan to curtail it, only increase it.
Id very very happily swap for more housing. It’s not that profitable. Unless you are going to do a really really shit conversion of an office block to flats, with no transport links, and house homeless families there in substandard housing outside town.
The schools are actually struggling with falling rolls and a funding crisis. I totally welcome family housing. Some have closed, others dropped forms of entry etc

Fair enough. I did not realize that you were talking about the incinerator rather than housing.

WildAlphabet · 03/09/2023 22:29

user1477391263 · 03/09/2023 19:44

And building MORE in the areas worse affected.

Well, as mentioned upthread, people object to building wherever you build. It has to be built somewhere.

If you're going to gradually make it harder and harder for people to drive cars into urban areas, that needs to go hand in hand with a policy of developing lots of dense housing in those areas, because those are the people who will staff local services and provide custom at local shops and businesses (rather than outsiders driving in).

You got the wrong end of the stick. I’m totally fine with housing instead of the factories. They’re not building that. As I mentioned they are instead building a massive incinerator to burn most the waste of north London. All the wealthy boroughs will sent their rubbish to the NE corner and have it burnt here with a massive plume over the schools. More distribution has been built, more lorries come. MORE pollution is being generated. In the ulez zone on a grand scale and existing issues, like sewage overflowing into canals regularly etc isn’t being addressed. There’s no plan to curtail it, only increase it.
Id very very happily swap for more housing. It’s not that profitable. Unless you are going to do a really really shit conversion of an office block to flats, with no transport links, and house homeless families there in substandard housing outside town.
The schools are actually struggling with falling rolls and a funding crisis. I totally welcome family housing. Some have closed, others dropped forms of entry etc

telestrations · 03/09/2023 20:45

Yes absoultly.

I grew up in London in zone 1/2 with very high levels of air pollution and a large number of children at my school were asthmatic. It's now said that children growing up in London have 20% lower lung capacity because of it. If true you have to be a monster to be ok with that imo.

There are of course some people who need a vehicle (disabled, night workers etc.) and they should be helped or excluded but very few people NEED a car in London or would be much better off with street car share scheme which sadly seem to have always failed. Maybe TFL could step in with this if they haven't already.

user1477391263 · 03/09/2023 20:15

If you build more housing in the center of town, it will gradually increase the general availability and affordability of housing there (and even in other areas), whatever you do.

You don't have to go all Singapore and start allocating new housing to specific types of people in a "social engineering" type of way.

Even if someone who isn't a nurse moves into a property among the newly built housing, that frees up a different property in the center which they would otherwise have moved into and which a nurse might now move into.

greengreengrass25 · 03/09/2023 19:57

user1477391263 · 03/09/2023 19:44

And building MORE in the areas worse affected.

Well, as mentioned upthread, people object to building wherever you build. It has to be built somewhere.

If you're going to gradually make it harder and harder for people to drive cars into urban areas, that needs to go hand in hand with a policy of developing lots of dense housing in those areas, because those are the people who will staff local services and provide custom at local shops and businesses (rather than outsiders driving in).

Will this be the reality though

Is it actually going to go to be allocated to nurses, teachers etc

user1477391263 · 03/09/2023 19:45

Sorry, posted too soon, but: It's a bit mad to say "I want a European city with nice tram and bus services" but then object to more housing being built in the city. If you want that kind of city, you need lots of people living in the center of town, or it's just not going to be financially viable to have all these public transit routes.

user1477391263 · 03/09/2023 19:44

And building MORE in the areas worse affected.

Well, as mentioned upthread, people object to building wherever you build. It has to be built somewhere.

If you're going to gradually make it harder and harder for people to drive cars into urban areas, that needs to go hand in hand with a policy of developing lots of dense housing in those areas, because those are the people who will staff local services and provide custom at local shops and businesses (rather than outsiders driving in).

WildAlphabet · 03/09/2023 19:16

Teentrauma · 03/09/2023 14:21

Of course that won't get sorted as it wouldn't make any money. Instead they are seen to be "doing their bit" for the environment by shafting people who can afford it least by taxing them to drive "polluting" vehicles. Unfortunately, there are mugs who will lap it up without question.

I’d actually support it if it was part of a greater change. If it meant stretching my legs on a decent walk, an actual change in air quality and cycle routes. Why not? I’d love a good bus network or a closer station. Why drive if I have that? I’d trade my car for a European style city with cheap trams, buses and a respect of cyclists. It would be an nice area.
All I’m getting is the same air whilst a bit of a mark up to cover any trade visits or a price mark on goods to cover hgvs doing the same thing.
They are showboating a few cars, that may just pay, and ignoring the actual biggest pollution issues. And building MORE in the areas worse affected

limitedperiodonly · 03/09/2023 17:19

Today I went in person to get my Bosch fridge from John Lewis on Oxford Street. I tried to order online but wanted to pay by the many gift vouchers I have - the biggest one was £150 - and a credit card payment but computer said no.

So I went there by walking and bus. After a bit of a kerfuffle where computer said no in the shop for which the sales assistant Martin apologised and shouldn't have needed to, my payment went through and the balance I had to pay was £39.

I think that was a bit of a result, not just because I got a fridge for £39 courtesy of people who kindly gave me John Lewis vouchers, but it got me out in the open air today by public transport and walking.

You don't have to do that but you could think about it. Oxford Street was very busy.

limitedperiodonly · 03/09/2023 16:27

uneffingbelievable · 03/09/2023 13:01

limited period - do you not get it. I have a drive way, ergo do not need a parking permit.
If I park on the street in my road or any in the immediate vicinity- I need a parking permit.

I reverse off my drive two houses from the T junction , where I turn right into a non ULEZ road. So for the privilege of driving those 10 metres - you think I should pay £12.5 . That must be one of the most expensive tolls on record.

Of course I get it. You feel aggrieved that you are tantalisingly on the edge but still within the Ulez boundary. But like catchment areas for schools or people living on one side of the street paying a different level of council tax to the people across the road, the line has to be drawn somewhere. Like Frozen, you have to let it go.

But to get round the charge you are planning to park in a street outside it. I think you said it's half a mile away and if you don't mind the walk, then I can see why you might do it.

All I'm saying is that you won't be the only driver just inside the Ulez with that idea and the residents in the streets you choose to park in might get fed up if they can't easily find a space and may lobby their local authority to bring in parking restrictions solely for local residents with a few meters for visitors.

That's what exists here because it is a very tempting place for people to park and continue their journey by bus, tube or national rail. The excellent public transport was a factor in my decision to live here and after a while I realised I didn't need the expense of a car at all.

It works. Today I ordered a new fridge from John Lewis and it will be delivered and installed (plugged in, which even I could do) on the date and time of my choosing and the old one will be taken away for (free) recycling. I didn't ask how they would get here or tell them where to park. John Lewis undoubtedly has compliable vans and drivers who know where to park, but if they don't and I was being charged for that, the price was still reasonable and this was one of their cheapest fridges.

It is a Bosch one though. I've never had anything as posh as a Bosch. I am looking forward to it.

But when I did have a car it was very annoying, on the rare occasions I used it, to have to park it three streets away after circling for ages because my road and the one round the corner were parked up by people who didn't live here. We had a residents' parking scheme but car-less locals were making extra cash by flogging off their parking permits until the council tightened the system. Again, I get why they would do that, but when it was stopped almost overnight I could find a parking space if not outside my house - I never needed that - but definitely in the same street or just round the corner.

I don't understand why the majority of my neighbours have cars but as long as they pay Ulez if their car is non-compliant, and their portion of the Congestion Charge and stick to the 20mph speed limit and other costs of driving like insurance and not doing a runner after paying for petrol, then I can ask no more.

There is one man who has a designated disabled spot outside his house. He needs a car and I wouldn't want his condition. You wouldn't believe the cheeky bastards who encroach on his space or even take it because: "I'm only going to be here for five minutes, mate." Or perhaps you would. Personally, I think it's never good look to say that to a small man in a wheelchair.

All in all I wouldn't be surprised if one day you needed a retinal scan to park round here and do you know what? I wouldn't care.

But enjoy sneaking over the border while it lasts.

greengreengrass25 · 03/09/2023 14:48

Yes isn't it just

Teentrauma · 03/09/2023 14:21

WildAlphabet · 03/09/2023 12:45

I’m near a huge coca-cola plant with its chimneys, a huge incinerator, massive warehouses and distribution centres spewing out pollution. Nothing is being done, the incinerator is actually being made bigger and will burn most of north londons waste with a plume over some of the most deprived areas in London. Lorries will still trundle on, the sewage pipe will still overflow often into the most polluted stretch of canal in the UK with boaters leaking fuel and discharging shit into the water. No one will sweep the built up on human shit, piss bottles and broken glass up so it can be cycled without puncturing the tyres constantly. No one is agreeing to a bus service for the road

Of course that won't get sorted as it wouldn't make any money. Instead they are seen to be "doing their bit" for the environment by shafting people who can afford it least by taxing them to drive "polluting" vehicles. Unfortunately, there are mugs who will lap it up without question.

Sigmama · 03/09/2023 13:34

Greentree, sure, that and multiple car ownership, and it's still the same amount of space, choked with traffic

greengreengrass25 · 03/09/2023 13:09

Sigmama · 03/09/2023 12:57

Thousands of people feel shafted that road traffic has been allowed to double to 41million in 30 years in the UK, that's no way to live

Surely that is to do with the rise in population

uneffingbelievable · 03/09/2023 13:01

limited period - do you not get it. I have a drive way, ergo do not need a parking permit.
If I park on the street in my road or any in the immediate vicinity- I need a parking permit.

I reverse off my drive two houses from the T junction , where I turn right into a non ULEZ road. So for the privilege of driving those 10 metres - you think I should pay £12.5 . That must be one of the most expensive tolls on record.

Sigmama · 03/09/2023 12:57

Thousands of people feel shafted that road traffic has been allowed to double to 41million in 30 years in the UK, that's no way to live

Teentrauma · 03/09/2023 12:51

@WildAlphabet fair enough but where did I say I live in a leafy suburb/semi rural? If you re-read my post you'll see that I'm very much against ULEZ. Thousands of people living in the new expanded zone feel shafted, regardless of whether they live in a nice area or somewhere that's a bit "grim".

WildAlphabet · 03/09/2023 12:45

I’m near a huge coca-cola plant with its chimneys, a huge incinerator, massive warehouses and distribution centres spewing out pollution. Nothing is being done, the incinerator is actually being made bigger and will burn most of north londons waste with a plume over some of the most deprived areas in London. Lorries will still trundle on, the sewage pipe will still overflow often into the most polluted stretch of canal in the UK with boaters leaking fuel and discharging shit into the water. No one will sweep the built up on human shit, piss bottles and broken glass up so it can be cycled without puncturing the tyres constantly. No one is agreeing to a bus service for the road

Sigmama · 03/09/2023 12:42

COmedycook, ah that old illogical chestnut, fewer cars on the road means less traffic, not more road space

WildAlphabet · 03/09/2023 12:42

Teentrauma · 03/09/2023 09:12

AND 90% of cars are exempt

If that's true, I can't understand why they've gone to so much trouble to catch a small number of drivers. These cars will be off the road naturally in the next few years anyway so it does seem like a sledgehammer to crack a nut. The difference to air quality is negligible and any truly poluting vehicles are already being kep off the roads thanks to the MOT emissions test. The reality is that this is causing a great deal of stress and worry to a lot of people in the midst of a cost of living crisis, it's appalling frankly. Aound 700,000 vehicles in the expanded ULEZ zone are non compliant, many of the areas affected are leafy suburbs or semi rural and certainly not "grim" as suggested (how rude!). It's a money making scheme pure and simple and it's not surprising there's so much opposition to it. I do feel a lot of people on this thread do not live in Greater London and are merely repeating what they've read in the media or heard come out of Mr Khan's mouth.

I can refer to my own bit as grim, I did add pictures to show. Good for you if it’s a leafy suburb bit with compliant cars, but not all of us are in the same boat. Those of us in the not so nice or affluent bits feel shafted.

Comedycook · 03/09/2023 12:40

Sigmama · 03/09/2023 12:37

The reality is that all the traffic choking up our streets is causing great deal of stress and worry to more people, no wonder there's so much support for it

Well traffic in my area would be greatly reduced if they moved the sodding plant pots blocking so many roads

Sigmama · 03/09/2023 12:37

The reality is that all the traffic choking up our streets is causing great deal of stress and worry to more people, no wonder there's so much support for it

Jumpingthruhoops · 03/09/2023 12:21

Teentrauma · 03/09/2023 09:12

AND 90% of cars are exempt

If that's true, I can't understand why they've gone to so much trouble to catch a small number of drivers. These cars will be off the road naturally in the next few years anyway so it does seem like a sledgehammer to crack a nut. The difference to air quality is negligible and any truly poluting vehicles are already being kep off the roads thanks to the MOT emissions test. The reality is that this is causing a great deal of stress and worry to a lot of people in the midst of a cost of living crisis, it's appalling frankly. Aound 700,000 vehicles in the expanded ULEZ zone are non compliant, many of the areas affected are leafy suburbs or semi rural and certainly not "grim" as suggested (how rude!). It's a money making scheme pure and simple and it's not surprising there's so much opposition to it. I do feel a lot of people on this thread do not live in Greater London and are merely repeating what they've read in the media or heard come out of Mr Khan's mouth.

100% this! 👏👏

Swipe left for the next trending thread