Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you support the ULEZ expansion?

758 replies

icecream99 · 28/08/2023 19:42

Just curious as it is due to start at midnight tonight and could potentially cause a lot of chaos. I don't support it.

YANBU - I DON'T support ULEZ expansion

YABU - I DO support ULEZ expansion

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Jumpingthruhoops · 30/08/2023 01:49

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2023 00:53

I'll be quite happy when pay-per-mile is a thing. Preferably with a weight-based multiplier to charge the heaviest vehicles the most, they do the most damage after all. Even if they decided to charge bicycles, my 10.5kg bike will barely weigh in compared with 1,500kg of SUV.

Well, of course you would, you'd hardly be paying anything. But it's not just about you, is it? A decent society shouldn't want to see anyone struggle.

DdraigGoch · 30/08/2023 00:53

Jumpingthruhoops · 28/08/2023 21:43

Easy to say you support a charge when it doesn't affect your income. Do report back when pay-per-mile starts for all vehicles, won't you?

I'll be quite happy when pay-per-mile is a thing. Preferably with a weight-based multiplier to charge the heaviest vehicles the most, they do the most damage after all. Even if they decided to charge bicycles, my 10.5kg bike will barely weigh in compared with 1,500kg of SUV.

LittleBearPad · 29/08/2023 23:51

Comedycook · 29/08/2023 21:18

Rat running is a nonsense term. Most people will drive the quickest route. As for driving down residential roads, virtually every road in London has residential property on it.

You’re being disingenuous. It’s perfectly obvious what rat running is. It leads to cars driving too fast down quiet residential streets to cut two minutes off their journey.

Jumpingthruhoops · 29/08/2023 23:40

SoupDragon · 29/08/2023 07:55

Your attitude is a classic "I'm alright, Jack" one. A lot of people are unable to see past their own nose and grasp the bigger picture.

I'm also going to be OK. My on-order compliant car will arrive eventually and I'm lucky enough to be able to afford this and any incurred charges in the meantime. I'm still against the expansion as it makes no sense in how it's implemented. It's all about money.

You're lucky that you were able to buy a car recently. Many people bought theirs a long time ago and are not able to afford a replacement. Many people bought diesel based on the misinformation given about the pollution.

Like I said, a lot of people can't see the bigger picture because it doesn't affect them They're alright so don't give a shit about those who aren't. You're not alone.

Exactly. I see so much of this. I am furious about the expansion... and our car is ULEZ complaint (bought new last month)!

Why? Because I can only imagine how stressful it's going to make the lives of those less well off, who are perhaps already struggling to make ends meet. Most people can't just 'go and buy' a new car... it's not a pint of bloody milk!!

An ONS freedom of information request confirmed that ONE person has officially died from 'pollution'. This is nothing more than a cash grab to fill a black hole in TFL.

Figmentofmyimagination · 29/08/2023 23:10

I think the big con here is that it is outrageous to be encouraging people to scrap viable vehicles in favour of what are effectively giant computers with limited shelf lives that are going to end up functionally unrepairable and consigned to landfill, far far sooner than used to be the case with the sort of vehicle a normal garage used to able to repair by looking under the bonnet. And when these vehicles fail, and speaking from experience, they do so spectacularly, cutting off the power with barely any warning at speed and there is nothing you can do about it. Imagine - like sitting inside your laptop but travelling along in the fast lane when you get a 10 second warning before the whole thing suddenly decides to shut down. Cynically, there seems to be so much green washing in favour of ‘new green jobs’ in the car manufacturing sector - building landfill mountains - and who can argue with ‘scrappage’ when it’s all in the name of protecting children’s lungs.

Just don’t imagine yourself driving your lovely new high spec car beyond a maximum of 5 years before you have no option but to throw it away and buy another.

Freepo · 29/08/2023 21:42

Sigmama · 29/08/2023 21:33

Freepo - you really think all those cars on your road are making necessary trips? But hey, let's blame the cyclists

Where did I blame cyclists for anything?

Or indeed say “all those cars are making necessary trips”? The point I was making was totally different but you didn’t bother to read it first time round so no point typing it out again.

Sigmama · 29/08/2023 21:33

Freepo - you really think all those cars on your road are making necessary trips? But hey, let's blame the cyclists

Sigmama · 29/08/2023 21:26

Oblomov, normal people are all ready being penalised, the ones who don't drive

Comedycook · 29/08/2023 21:18

LittleBearPad · 29/08/2023 20:18

Driving down a road to get to particular destination is not rat running...it's called driving down the road

Quite right. That’s not rat running.

Rat running is driving a less direct through residential streets to avoid traffic on the main roads. Usually done at too high a speed too

Rat running is a nonsense term. Most people will drive the quickest route. As for driving down residential roads, virtually every road in London has residential property on it.

LittleBearPad · 29/08/2023 20:29

Oblomov23 · 29/08/2023 20:26

No. It won't make air quality better. Just penalises normal people. Diesels are ok, but my cleaner hybrid isn't?

Which hybrid car isn’t ok?

Oblomov23 · 29/08/2023 20:26

No. It won't make air quality better. Just penalises normal people. Diesels are ok, but my cleaner hybrid isn't?

Jumpingthruhoops · 29/08/2023 20:22

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 29/08/2023 13:09

You know the "Own nothing; be happy" thing stems from an essay submitted to the WEF by a Danish politician that was meant to instigate debate about tech development and goods / materials as a service, right? It is not, and has never been, an official view or part of the WEF.

It's amazing how many people focus in on a tiny, insignificant part of something and decide that must be the sole focus of the whole organisation. I mean there's also essays on there called "Sir Elton John: 5 leadership lessons from my darkest hours" and "Why art has the power to change the world". Do you also think the WEF are also secretly working to make us all buy Elton's autobiography and take up art classes?

There are also essays called "Five changes for sustainable health systems that put people first", "Prioritizing Racial and Ethnic Equity in Business", and "Women's economic empowerment is the right and smart thing to do". Why haven't you picked up on any of those as a "specific agenda" of the WEF? Why is it only ever "Own nothing; be happy" that gets attention?

On the topic of the thread, support ULEZ in principle but not in the way it is being implemented i.e., it's a good thing to work on improving air quality but not if it disproportionately impacts poorer people in society or if it can be circumnavigated by rich people.

Why do people focus on that? Maybe because people object to being controlled? The other examples you cite don't.

The fact remains, this is definitely part of a wider agenda to stop people moving freely under the guise of saving the planet. If he really wanted to do that, he would just ban vehicles from certain parts of London. But he won't do that because it doesn't make anyone any money.

LittleBearPad · 29/08/2023 20:18

Comedycook · 29/08/2023 19:25

I'm not thinking of any particular scheme.

Oh and I really hate the term 'rat running'. Driving down a road to get to particular destination is not rat running...it's called driving down the road. Where I live in SE London we have these absolutely pathetic low traffic neighbourhoods where the supporters of these seem to have an issue with people driving down residential roads utterly ignoring the fact that virtually every road in London has residential property on it.

Driving down a road to get to particular destination is not rat running...it's called driving down the road

Quite right. That’s not rat running.

Rat running is driving a less direct through residential streets to avoid traffic on the main roads. Usually done at too high a speed too

LittleBearPad · 29/08/2023 20:16

Maybe…

Think About It GIF by Big Potato Games
dutysuite · 29/08/2023 20:00

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2023 15:23

You haven't got a clue what a 15 minute neighbourhood is, have you?

It's one where all basic facilities (shops, public transport, doctor's, primary schools etc.) are available within easy walking distance of one's home. If you want to go further then you simply walk the short distance to the bus stop and travel to where you want to go. What's wrong with any of that?

So naive

Comedycook · 29/08/2023 19:25

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2023 18:29

That's nothing to do with 15-minute neighbourhoods. The scheme in Oxford you are thinking of was about stopping rat-running.

I'm not thinking of any particular scheme.

Oh and I really hate the term 'rat running'. Driving down a road to get to particular destination is not rat running...it's called driving down the road. Where I live in SE London we have these absolutely pathetic low traffic neighbourhoods where the supporters of these seem to have an issue with people driving down residential roads utterly ignoring the fact that virtually every road in London has residential property on it.

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2023 18:50

That isn’t the current situation where I am (we live on such a “trunk” road and it’s a single carriage residential street, with every road inside this boundary being one way). It’s a total nightmare since the LTN and no one cares, they just say more people should cycle and leave my kids to choke on the increased smog.

Yeah, that's not what I would have done. Ironically the Oxford scheme a different PP was ranting about was designed to avoid such rat-running.

Freepo · 29/08/2023 18:35

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2023 18:27

So your complaint os that traffic that used to be split down two roads is now concentrated into one road? Presumably the road we're talking about is also some kind of residential or shopping street and now being used as a rat-run, please correct me if the situation I'm imagining isn't what you're talking about.

In which case my answer would be to impose restrictions on the rat-run too. Doesn't have to be a total ban, access can still be maintained for buses, vehicles loading and blue badges.

Basically force the cars out until they can only use the trunk roads if they need through-routes. Where trunk roads are closely-bounded by housing (didn't the recent coroner's case involve the South Circular?) then remove the nearside lanes, building both active travel routes and tree lines to provide a barrier between the traffic and the housing.

One way or the other, cars are the problem and the solution is to discourage them.

If that could be realistic, and air pollution on those trunk roads homes was monitored and showed to be reduced I’d be on board with that, as it’s making things better for everyone air pollution wise. This is also as long as the net effect on emissions was a downwards reduction.

That isn’t the current situation where I am (we live on such a “trunk” road and it’s a single carriage residential street, with every road inside this boundary being one way). It’s a total nightmare since the LTN and no one cares, they just say more people should cycle and leave my kids to choke on the increased smog.

My concern is that people are not realistic about the reasons people drive, and it not being that simple for everyone to just get out of their car. Traffic has a huge amount of negatives but there’s no denying cars are convenient and there are valid reasons for plenty (not all) journeys being by car. I don’t know whether your solution leaves road traffic as a viable option for those who need to do it (and there are many journeys that do need to be by car). But I agree with you in principle, if it could work in practice.

LakieLady · 29/08/2023 18:29

I feel very sorry for people living in the very outer parts of Greater London, which are really quite rural and don't have air quality issues. Many areas, especially the south-east of London, have poor public transport links as well. Not everyone can afford to get a newer car.

I was resigned to spending £12.50 every time I went to visit MIL in my 22 year old Audi, and was astonished to find it is actually ULEZ compliant.

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2023 18:29

Comedycook · 29/08/2023 18:23

Because what they put in first is not the amenities that people need...it's the cameras.

But regardless...it is not the government's business where I carry out my lawful business and activities.

That's nothing to do with 15-minute neighbourhoods. The scheme in Oxford you are thinking of was about stopping rat-running.

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2023 18:27

Freepo · 29/08/2023 18:06

It’s a simple question: would congestion be better or worse without the cycle lane? If the cycle lane creates a net reduction in congestion then great. If it increases it because it causes an insufficient number of people to get out of their cars to offset the reduced lanes for motor traffic, then the practical impacts have to be justified as being proportionate.

This is an LTN issue not ULEZ I am genuinely distressed at the fact my pre school kids, one of whom is asthmatic, are breathing increased levels of air pollution due to living on a now heavily congested boundary road, and all I get from people who support these schemes is to say blame the people who drive, while refusing to engage in a sensible conversation about if the scheme is in practice doing more harm than good. Policies have to be rooted in reality not idealism.

So your complaint os that traffic that used to be split down two roads is now concentrated into one road? Presumably the road we're talking about is also some kind of residential or shopping street and now being used as a rat-run, please correct me if the situation I'm imagining isn't what you're talking about.

In which case my answer would be to impose restrictions on the rat-run too. Doesn't have to be a total ban, access can still be maintained for buses, vehicles loading and blue badges.

Basically force the cars out until they can only use the trunk roads if they need through-routes. Where trunk roads are closely-bounded by housing (didn't the recent coroner's case involve the South Circular?) then remove the nearside lanes, building both active travel routes and tree lines to provide a barrier between the traffic and the housing.

One way or the other, cars are the problem and the solution is to discourage them.

Comedycook · 29/08/2023 18:23

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2023 15:23

You haven't got a clue what a 15 minute neighbourhood is, have you?

It's one where all basic facilities (shops, public transport, doctor's, primary schools etc.) are available within easy walking distance of one's home. If you want to go further then you simply walk the short distance to the bus stop and travel to where you want to go. What's wrong with any of that?

Because what they put in first is not the amenities that people need...it's the cameras.

But regardless...it is not the government's business where I carry out my lawful business and activities.

Comedycook · 29/08/2023 18:19

Ginmonkeyagain · 29/08/2023 15:21

@Comedycook the smoking ban was a massive benefit to tbe government - It was one of the most successful public health interventions in decades.

Smoking and smoking related diseases cost the NHS millions as sell as the related productivity issues caused by long term ill health from smoking.

You need to adjust you tinfoil hat.

If you read my comment carefully you will see I said direct financial benefit.

JenniferBooth · 29/08/2023 18:10

Accessiblity of properties is something of people take in to consideration when they buy or rent them

Yet on social housing threads prospective tenants are told they cant be choosy Make your minds up!

Freepo · 29/08/2023 18:08

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2023 18:03

Yes, so by introducing these policies the government (local or national) reduces the number of people who continue to drive.

no. Those are the aims, which are laudable. I’m talking about the practical impacts. Just because something has a stated aim it doesn’t mean that policy is a fair or effective way of achieving that aim.

My children’s health may be collateral damage to you but it isn’t to me. They are breathing more not less air pollution because of such a scheme. That needs to be part of the conversation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread