Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone explain very simply to me how therapy is supposed to help heal childhood trauma?

109 replies

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 18:31

I'm going to a kind therapist I feel comfortable with. She is very experienced in one of the issues (relinquishment trauma) I'm seeing her for and I have generally a good impression.

However, I feel like I just talk about stuff and then feel even worse when I go home again?

What am I supposed to be doing that heals myself via the therapy process? I'm not sure I'm doing it correctly. I don't get it.

I've asked her if generally it is supposed to start hurting less at some point and she said yes, the act of airing the traumatic stuff and talking about it typically does make it hurt less at some time. Also that sometimes when trauma is pre verbal it can be very tightly locked in and hard to get at - so what am I supposed to do in that case?

OP posts:
thatsn0tmyname · 28/08/2023 20:41

I haven't had therapy but a friend said it's like picking at a scab and then allowing the wound to re- heal. It's uncomfortable. I guess different styles suit different needs.

Scarfweather · 28/08/2023 20:37

Echoing other posters that say there are different therapies to suit different people.
I work in mental health/therapy and have also had therapy myself for childhood issues.

I’m not someone who got along well with therapy that goes back over things in the past, but I recognise that for some it can be useful. I found solution-focused therapy and CBT (although this was the least useful of the two) was better - you can’t change what happened in the past but you can focus on recognising your own strengths and focus on how you want things in the future to be.
It’s obvious to me that my DM was a textbook narcissist and my childhood was far from ideal - I don’t need to understand more than I already knew, in that she was probably screwed up by her own childhood and didn’t have enough self-awareness to make her own changes.
As a person in my own right, I recognise none of this was my making and would prefer to focus on making sure I apply self care and my own solutions in the future.
Any therapy that went back there just reopened wounds and trauma.

Isolated17 · 28/08/2023 20:25

I tried psychotherapy a decade ago and quit after a few sessions because it made me too depressed to eat.

I've been going to person-centred therapy for almost two years and it works better for me. I just talk about what I feel like that session (relationship or general life progress) and get feedback.

The former therapy was NHS whereas the new one is private (but fairly cheap - £35). I only go when I need it, so every 5 weeks or so now, but every week or two if depressed in winter.

Raggammuffin · 28/08/2023 20:24

Yeh talking did lead me to a helpful breakthrough. I talked and talked until I realised I was so bored of it all. It had lost some of its power to hurt.

Themosswidow · 28/08/2023 20:18

Some therapists think that just talking about the issue will lead you to your own breakthrough.

Other therapists will give you practical tools and skills to help you better cope with your situation.

I personally would ditch any therapist who just wanted me to talk and talk about what is upsetting me. It doesn’t help. I want someone who can give me the practical tools to help me move forward.

Theforeverhome · 28/08/2023 20:17

After starting counselling for different issues over the years, I’ve usually come away from the first few sessions feeling completely wrung out because some deep emotions have been brought to the surface.

During one set of sessions, I was having a breast abscess treated and was talking to a friend about the similarities of the processes: The abscess was caused by some form of injury, that starts off looking like the surface of the skin is normal, but underneath, everything is churning. Once the abscess erupts, ie you have the first session, you have to dig deep to bring up all the damage to get back to clean, undamaged tissue, and this may hurt more than the abscess did to start with. If you don’t unpack the wound to clear out the damage, it will fester.

However, counselling is a painful process and our brains will often tell us to avoid things that are painful. You are trusting someone else with all of your internalised and repressed feelings of shame and guilt and that makes you feel extremely vulnerable - but it is worth persevering, especially if you have found someone you have a good bond with.

One thing that I found useful in my second and subsequent tranches of counselling was to draw a mind map of the issues I was facing and the emotions that I felt, and I used that to help me in some of the sessions, either to decide on a topic I wanted to focus on, or to make a note of things that I thought of during or after each session. I also have a place that I go when things are bad where I write down what I’m feeling as a stream of consciousness. I’d be absolutely mortified if anyone were to read what I’ve written but it has helped me uncover things that I know I need to look at.

I do hope you manage to work things out Flowers

Balloonhearts · 28/08/2023 20:06

I'm not sure to be honest. I guess desensitisation is probably what happens. You just...talk about it until talking about it doesn't hurt anymore.

I think a big part of it for me was seeing my therapists reactions to what I said. He's got a good poker face but his eyes give him away.

When you've always been told it's no big deal, seeing him react to it brings it home that actually it was that bad. I guess it validates your feelings.

ifindyouveryattractive · 28/08/2023 20:06

Createausername1970 · 28/08/2023 19:39

You may know the full history, but I don't. If all her family died in a fire that she started because she was in huff, that could be deemed to be her fault.

As I don't know, I can only assume she wasn't at fault. You may know differently, but I don't.

Do you really think that’s helpful to say that in this context? Children are never reposnibke for their trauma. Neither to that end are adults. Trauma is something that happens to you as a result of something dreadful happening to or around you - no one actively goes out seeking to be traumatised. As adults, to an extent it becomes our responsibility to ourself, and potentially those around us, to - where possible - work through it, but trauma is never another’s fault.

GardeningIdiot · 28/08/2023 19:57

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 19:26

Digging straight into your past without creating stability and coping mechanisms first can be very unhelpful.

I don't really understand this - I'm stable already? I'm not doing anything unstable, behaviour wise.

What are coping mechanisms? I'd cringe myself inside out doing some deep breathing exercises with a therapist to calm down for example.

And I say this as somebody who loves yoga and meditation and happily embraces everything in yoga class.

I don't mean unstable or risky behaviours, but establishing some stability in your relationship with your therapist.

When you get very upset by what your are discussing with your therapist, you need some ways of calming down and grounding yourself back in the hear and now.

It's not a matter of "fixing yourself", but of gradually edging forward until you find someone and an approach you can make progress with.

And ending one form of therapy is absolutely fine. It's often advised to try until you find a 'good fit. It's actually very wise of you not to proceed with therapy if it doesn't feel right or safe.

Have you read much about healing childhood trauma? That might help to start with.

Northby · 28/08/2023 19:56

I’m so sorry OP and wish you all the best.

I’ve had psychotherapy (the therapist mentioned Freud’s theories a few times) which was mostly just talking about my traumatic upbringing. It was ok but I didn’t feel it helped very much. I had CBT for anxiety and depression. Again, this was fine and helped in some ways but it was a bit of a plaster over a deep wound that needed something more. I now have a counsellor who employs the theory of internal family systems. I’ve found this extremely beneficial as a key part of my healing has been to re-parent myself and to release the pain and anxiety which arose due to the lack of safety growing up. It sounds a bit wacky when you’re doing it but it’s incredible.

It sounds like it’s not therapy that’s the issue for you but it’s that the type of therapy may not be what your body and mind need right now.

Createausername1970 · 28/08/2023 19:50

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 18:51

And, assuming you were not at fault for a childhood trauma, they can help you look at the reasons why this happened

I can't assume it's not my fault though, this is the problem.

Everyone tells me and rationally I know, my mother wasn't in the right place to bring me up herself and it's not my fault.

But it feels at core like there is something wrong with me and no amount of me talking about it or other people listening can shift that. It feels actively shameful and dreadful to even talk about it.

Like my skin is being sandpapered off, when I talk about it and somebody listens.

We adopted our boy when he was 3. None of what happened to him was his fault, but he was the only sibling who ended up being adopted and I have had a number of conversations with him over the years, and no matter what I say, part of him still thinks that he must have been at fault.

I can't offer any suggestions, but he has found it helpful talking about it to his counsellor. So perhaps you could explore some of the other suggestions given. Or try again with the same therapist after you have given yourself time to process everything they have said so far.

GardeningIdiot · 28/08/2023 19:50

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 19:34

EMDR sounds great, I have read a lot of impressive things about it but isn't it for particular traumatic memories?

I don't have any memory of the initial separation from my mother at a couple of months old?

The therapist said trauma can be pre verbal, so I don't know if that can work with EMDR if you can't actually remember the distressing moments?

EMDR for cPTSD:

www.ptsduk.org/emdr-for-complex-ptsd/

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 19:41

MatildaTheCat · 28/08/2023 19:34

If you can’t face talking to your therapist right now could you write it down for her? Not your trauma but how you can’t face looking at her in the eye and talking? It may help her with helping you to finding a way forward.

I wish you all the very best x

No I don't think so.

Somewhat interestingly this post and thread in general is making me realise how uncomfortable and distressed I am at her knowing so much. It compounds the shame and distress.

It makes everything glaring technicolour and migraine-inducing, instead of dully painful sepia. I mean it's always there but the technicolour is far worse, as acute pain.

I can't tell her I can't look her in the eye because then she'll know that weird fact as well as everything else I've already told her Grin

I went into therapy very gungho and talked about everything and felt like it somewhat unburdened some things which was great - but this particular relinquishment issue has become much worse.

OP posts:
Createausername1970 · 28/08/2023 19:39

shouldistayorshouldigoorwhat · 28/08/2023 18:51

How can a child be 'at fault' for the trauma they experienced? Bloody hell.

You may know the full history, but I don't. If all her family died in a fire that she started because she was in huff, that could be deemed to be her fault.

As I don't know, I can only assume she wasn't at fault. You may know differently, but I don't.

TammyJones · 28/08/2023 19:39

What I did pick up on was :

@bewilderberrie
But it feels at core like there is something wrong with me and no amount of me talking about it or other people listening can shift that. It feels actively shameful and dreadful to even talk about it.

Like my skin is being sandpapered off, when I talk about it and somebody listens.#

^^^^^^^^

I understand exactly what you mean.

I used to feel similar - that I was fundamentally flawed.

But I don't feel like that anymore.

CBT turned it around for me.
Hours of going over the same old ground (depressing ) wasn't changing a thing.

Yes, stuff had happened- they hadn't treated me very well, they'd died / been addicted / was emotionally unavailable - etc , etc.
it's a lot of people's story.
But you wallow in it you can start to move on.

CBT gave me tools to cope with today - (oh and being nice to people. That always helps. A smile ,a helping hand )

Remember OP you were born perfect.

All babies are perfect.

Then we are taught by outside influences that we are'flawed'

But can unlearn it.

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 19:36

Flowers to everybody who has survived a shit time, thank you so much for taking the time to post your therapy experiences and what you thought about the process of it. It's such a hard thing to quantify.

OP posts:
ifindyouveryattractive · 28/08/2023 19:35

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 18:51

And, assuming you were not at fault for a childhood trauma, they can help you look at the reasons why this happened

I can't assume it's not my fault though, this is the problem.

Everyone tells me and rationally I know, my mother wasn't in the right place to bring me up herself and it's not my fault.

But it feels at core like there is something wrong with me and no amount of me talking about it or other people listening can shift that. It feels actively shameful and dreadful to even talk about it.

Like my skin is being sandpapered off, when I talk about it and somebody listens.

I hear you. I don’t have the answers but I get what you’ve written there, I’ve felt very similar and I find it very hard to accept I did nothing wrong. For 32 years it felt like my responsibility and my fault and my shame to carry around. As an adult I find it extremely hard to accept I did nothing wrong.

Some of it is very vivid, some of its it’s very sketchy. Most of it comes back randomly for no good reason and in no order. A lot of it I can’t tell you what it was exactly, it’s all smells, sounds, feelings. For example, I can’t stand the sound of supermarket checkout beeps, the smell of photography developer fluid, or a certain brand of soap.

In the past, I think they call it narrative type therapy has helped me - writing down what happened, when and how I felt. But I’ve never shared that writing with any therapist.

Someone also mentioned inner child stuff like writing a letter to a much younger me, but I’ve never done that or felt able to.

I feel the same after therapy - knackered and frustrated. I’m getting CBT and we are focusing on how to cope with panic attacks when what I really want - as stupid and ridiculous as it sounds - is to shout and scream at the top of my lungs all the things that happened around me and to me and that they were wrong, I was let down too many times, and for my CPN to say, yes they were, and I was.

MatildaTheCat · 28/08/2023 19:34

If you can’t face talking to your therapist right now could you write it down for her? Not your trauma but how you can’t face looking at her in the eye and talking? It may help her with helping you to finding a way forward.

I wish you all the very best x

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 19:34

EMDR sounds great, I have read a lot of impressive things about it but isn't it for particular traumatic memories?

I don't have any memory of the initial separation from my mother at a couple of months old?

The therapist said trauma can be pre verbal, so I don't know if that can work with EMDR if you can't actually remember the distressing moments?

OP posts:
TolkiensFallow · 28/08/2023 19:30

Oh OP. You poor thing.

As a mental health professional, I can tell you that it’s completely normal to feel worse when you’ve just started therapy. You are talking about really tough stuff and if you didn’t feel worse then I’d say that was a sign it’s not the right therapy.

Emdr is really good for trauma BUT you need to learn some stabilisation strategies in order to be sure you can safely do emdr.

I would suggest talking to your therapist about how you feel about therapy at the moment. She can help you work through the difficulties.

Gettingbysomehow · 28/08/2023 19:30

I've had complex PTSD for 45 years and just wanted to tell someone what happened to me. I needed to tell someone. That's all I needed. The rest I did myself. Read everything I could and cut off the abusers. I need medication but I'm doing OK now.

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 19:30

Conkersinautumn · 28/08/2023 18:56

I found that as an adult I was able to recognise that events were not 'my fault', that the therapist recognised the pain was a real 'thing' that I could put feelings into words, I was able to recognise more how some situations were related to those memories and I found I could detatch more, not let things overwhelm me as I knew why I reacted how I did.

This is a really good summary of what I guess I was hoping would happen.

I am very glad it worked for you.

OP posts:
WildFeathers · 28/08/2023 19:29

i found EMDR the most successful. Person centred therapy helped me initially when I was younger to understand how I felt but after reaching clarity, I found anymore after that not helpful at all. When I fell off a mental health cliff after lockdown, my GP sign lost me to NHS counselling. I asked for trauma focused CBT but the therapist I spoke to said I was so cognitively aware of what was going on that any type of cognitive therapy would be more likely to re-traumatise me than help me. She suggested EMDR and that has worked well. I will always be triggered and have cPTSD but I find joy in life again. A couple of good books are “the body keeps the score” and “recovery of your inner child”.

bewilderberrie · 28/08/2023 19:26

Digging straight into your past without creating stability and coping mechanisms first can be very unhelpful.

I don't really understand this - I'm stable already? I'm not doing anything unstable, behaviour wise.

What are coping mechanisms? I'd cringe myself inside out doing some deep breathing exercises with a therapist to calm down for example.

And I say this as somebody who loves yoga and meditation and happily embraces everything in yoga class.

OP posts:
Poudretteite · 28/08/2023 19:25

Can you be honest with the therapist about how you felt and work with that?

It's also important not to feel you have to dive into anything too intense straight away.

7 years + of therapy sounds like my idea of hell. Each to their own I guess. To this poster - therapy isn't for fun, it's for healing. Living with PTSD and a dissociative disorder was certainly hell for me before I started getting therapy and was able to start working and forming relationships. I don't know if this comment was in reference to mine, but attitudes like this are why getting help for trauma can be so difficult.

Swipe left for the next trending thread