Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've made a massive mistake and ruined my DC lives.

206 replies

fml666 · 28/08/2023 10:26

I finally left my exDH ( father to my 2 DC) 3 years ago. He was a complete cocklodger who had checked out of family life and spent all his ( considerable) spare time on his phone, messaging other women it turned out. He "worked" as a self employed gardener which amounted to cutting a couple of lawns a week at most. Refused to get a proper job. Didn't do anything at home either, except hoard, buy dogs, and make a mess.

After we split he hardly saw the children, once every couple of weeks possibly? Has never contributed financially towards them until recently when CMS calculated he needed to pay £30 a month. I was working full time and really, really struggling with after school care etc. A year after we split I made the decision to move myself and my children to live near all my family so they could support us. Unfortunately this was 350 miles away though. The children were excited about this adventure at the time. They weren't bothered about leaving their DF as they hardly saw him.

3 years on and they are both unhappy here and want to move back to live near their DF. My DD12 is unrecognisable. She cuts herself, has been suicidal, has done terribly at school, etc etc. She says it's because she hates living here. We have a lovely house, family nearby and they both have friends here. But they still miss their DF. Despite the fact he never ever contacts them unless I make him, and only see him if I arrange it and take them to see him.

I'm really happy here, other than worry about the DC. I have a job I love, friends and a new partner. Which makes me feel even more guilty.

I can't put this right. I can't afford to move back there, and struggle like I did. But I feel my DDs life is getting worse and worse due to her seemingly being intent on making bad decisions ( seeking out troubled children, shop lifting, etc etc.)

I've only just admitted to myself today it was a mistake. I kept thinking they'd settle. But they haven't. It was the wrong thing to do for them. Can I put this right?

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 28/08/2023 16:27

I don't really believe in taking not bad mouthing the other parent so far that you are essentially lying to children. It's very confusing. Obviously he doesn't love them much or care and their stable adult pretending he does makes it OK fir him to ignore them and affects what they think relationships are. I'm not convinced the truth is bad mouthing anyway.

AlienatedChildGrown · 28/08/2023 16:24

MumGMT · 28/08/2023 15:59

If there's a shit parent then there's a shit parent, whether that's the mother or the father.

The shit parent is the one who has to go in first to fixing it, because the not shit parent has generally always tried to get them involved and it hasn't worked.

Why would you put the least able parent at the helm of the ship your child is on when the first dark clouds of a storm are already apparent ?

Suicidal thinking doesn’t always disappear with the spots when adolescence has been and gone. It can be a significant symptom arising from the loss of a parent that manifests around that time and then dogs a person for decades to come. It’s really not the sort of context where “you lot fucked the kids up, so you lot fix them” is a risk worth taking.

Floralnomad · 28/08/2023 16:24

Now your daughter is 12 perhaps now is the time to just let her sort out contact with her dad , I assume she has a phone .

fml666 · 28/08/2023 16:21

Thanks for all your replies. Very thought provoking. I've been sat in tears reading your responses, and appreciate the ( mostly) kindness.

I will absolutely admit that I misjudged the emotional impact that moving away from their father has had on my DC. Although I'm not convinced it's all about that, on reflection, and considering all circumstances with the help of posters on here. They used to cry at the thought of going to their dad's when we still lived down there, it was heartbreaking having to hand them over to him distraught. That contact actually stopped completely after a couple of months as he used it as an excuse not to see them. He could have come to see them in their own house, but he didn't bother. I fully believe that if we were still there they would hardly ever see him.

Also, DD was upset a couple of months ago, said she missed her dad. It was half term the following week so I offered to take her to see him ( after him refusing to come here.) She didn't go in the end as she said she wanted to spend time with her friends instead.

Can I point out that their dad NEVER phones them even. And they never phone him either. In the beginning I would nag them to phone him, but stopped after he made no effort back. Every school holidays I ask HIM if they can come and stay. He has NEVER initiated contact with them in 3 years.

To answer another question, we moved from very rural to a large town.

OP posts:
MrsLargeEmbodied · 28/08/2023 16:12

my dd had a rubber band on her wrist for her to ping when she felt overwhelmed,
also listen to her
without response, she might be happy to talk to you without the need for you to answer

menopausalbloat · 28/08/2023 16:09

This is not your fault.
Please, if you haven't already. get help from your GP.
It sounds like your daughter needs therapy.
I went through this with my son.

MumGMT · 28/08/2023 15:59

AlienatedChildGrown · 28/08/2023 15:44

For every lone parent I’ve watched (inc. my SIL with my useless lump of a brother & a friend with his erratic ex-wife) do the equivalent of climbing Mount Everest in ballet slippers to keep their child’s under-involved parent in the picture as much as possible, there’s one I’ve watched say one thing while doing the other (inc. my first late FIL who had complete custody of ex-DH and his sibling, and my own mother).

We can carry on for another 3 decades arguing til the cows come home which sex has to take more or less of the blame for the mess children are in and is therefore obliged to go first in fixing it. But that is time and energy lost to finding a better way to manage the fallout that’s flattening an ever growing proportion of children.

If there's a shit parent then there's a shit parent, whether that's the mother or the father.

The shit parent is the one who has to go in first to fixing it, because the not shit parent has generally always tried to get them involved and it hasn't worked.

AltheaVestr1t · 28/08/2023 15:44

If I had a child who was self harming I would move heaven and earth to get them into a specialist private therapist ASAP.

AlienatedChildGrown · 28/08/2023 15:44

MumGMT · 28/08/2023 15:24

@AlienatedChildGrown

As long as this gets framed as a battle of the sexes kids are going to keep falling through the cracks (well, more like yawning gulf at this point) and grow up at high risk of repeating the cycle with their own kids. It’s not about the sexes. It’s about children getting the best hand they can be dealt given the circumstances.

It gets framed that way due to people discussing that it's a common issue. It's not a battle of the sexes in individual families. Most single mothers I know have bent over backwards to try to facilitate and encourage the dads being involved, but unfortunately many just can't be arsed.

Lone parents move away for support. Which is understandable. And they alone cannot make a less involved parent get their act together. So maybe the way forward is looking at ways to keep even the less capable parents in the picture through social expectation and action at a governmental and community level.

The social expectation will need to come from men then, because women at an individual level have tried their best for a long time and it does nothing to encourage these dads to get their act together. And when women as a group discuss this phenomenon they tend to get attacked by deadbeats or by people trying to make out the women need to do more.

For every lone parent I’ve watched (inc. my SIL with my useless lump of a brother & a friend with his erratic ex-wife) do the equivalent of climbing Mount Everest in ballet slippers to keep their child’s under-involved parent in the picture as much as possible, there’s one I’ve watched say one thing while doing the other (inc. my first late FIL who had complete custody of ex-DH and his sibling, and my own mother).

We can carry on for another 3 decades arguing til the cows come home which sex has to take more or less of the blame for the mess children are in and is therefore obliged to go first in fixing it. But that is time and energy lost to finding a better way to manage the fallout that’s flattening an ever growing proportion of children.

TheCurtainQueen · 28/08/2023 15:39

Please don’t move back. It will make things worse, not better. Your life will be far more difficult because you won’t have your support network. Your ex partner still won’t have anything to do with his kids. True reason for his lack of involvement isn’t geography. Your daughter needs to understand this.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 28/08/2023 15:36

sounds like the grass is greener for her
she is changing schools and undergoing ASD assessment
she is 12, it is a stage,
she will get through it
the school may have counselling? my dd also self harmed at that age, the school provided counselling

Bonbon21 · 28/08/2023 15:33

I think you are coping amazingly. Getting out of a destructive relationship and building a new safer future for yourself and your kids.
Where I feel you have gone 'wrong'... to use that phrase.... is accomodating your kids useless father up to this point.
Tell the kids to write to their father and he can let them know when he wants to see them and you will do everything you can to make sure it happens.
This way he can 'prove' his committment to them.
And if he actually steps up and initiates contact THROUGH THE KIDS you will be able to eat your hat!!
And if he doesnt they will know HE is the one who let them down.
Tough lesson for them, but they will work it out in time anyway... and will take some of the strain off you and the power off him.

Nn9011 · 28/08/2023 15:31

You mentioned your daughter is waiting for an assessment for ASD - I would maybe focus on counseling and support based around Autism. For so many young girls with Autism, if they haven't received a diagnosis yet it can come out through poor mental health because they're struggling and it could even be that she's misplacing the blame - moving isn't going to fix how she's feeling, we know that as adults but she probably just feels if she was removed from the situation everything would get better.
Maybe look at Autism UK and consider if the school she's at is the right one for her. Also talk to her about the ASD, how it manifests in girls/women and how many other women have felt similar in their journey with neurodivergence.

MumGMT · 28/08/2023 15:26

fml666 · 28/08/2023 10:33

I'm going to see if I can organise some private therapy for her but it will be a struggle financially.

I've wondered if there's anything else going on for her too. But I really don't think there is. She likes my new DP and they have a good relationship, although she doesn't see much of him.

Are there local charities that can help?
I'm in Ireland and therapy from the HSE is so hard to get and there's such a long wait list, but there are lots of local charities who will offer free therapy or donation based only if you can afford a donation.

MumGMT · 28/08/2023 15:24

@AlienatedChildGrown

As long as this gets framed as a battle of the sexes kids are going to keep falling through the cracks (well, more like yawning gulf at this point) and grow up at high risk of repeating the cycle with their own kids. It’s not about the sexes. It’s about children getting the best hand they can be dealt given the circumstances.

It gets framed that way due to people discussing that it's a common issue. It's not a battle of the sexes in individual families. Most single mothers I know have bent over backwards to try to facilitate and encourage the dads being involved, but unfortunately many just can't be arsed.

Lone parents move away for support. Which is understandable. And they alone cannot make a less involved parent get their act together. So maybe the way forward is looking at ways to keep even the less capable parents in the picture through social expectation and action at a governmental and community level.

The social expectation will need to come from men then, because women at an individual level have tried their best for a long time and it does nothing to encourage these dads to get their act together. And when women as a group discuss this phenomenon they tend to get attacked by deadbeats or by people trying to make out the women need to do more.

ASGIRC · 28/08/2023 15:15

fml666 · 28/08/2023 10:33

I'm going to see if I can organise some private therapy for her but it will be a struggle financially.

I've wondered if there's anything else going on for her too. But I really don't think there is. She likes my new DP and they have a good relationship, although she doesn't see much of him.

Could your family pitch in to help?
Sometimes, even a tenner from a couple of people could help ease the load.
I understand not everyone would be in a position to do this, but it is worth asking.

My aunt pays for my nieces private speech therapy, as her parents would struggle to afford it on their own.

Hope you manage to find help for your DD.

MoreThanEnoughSoFar · 28/08/2023 15:14

fml666 · 28/08/2023 11:55

It's clear from some of the childrens' comments when they returned from a recent stay with him ( initiated by myself, and I took them to see him) that he has been making comments to the children about how mean I've been taking them away from him, etc. DD told me her dad said I'm "not bringing them up very well" and that this is the reason she SHs.

From day one I have actually said he could stay with us to facilitate him visiting them. But he won't. Not that I want that now as our relationship has deteriorated. But he won't. To make it clear: if I don't initiate it he will not have ANY contact with his DC at all. Im trying to protect them from discovering this.

Could I ask a question: Did you move from a large city to a rural area or is it about the same environment?

AlienatedChildGrown · 28/08/2023 15:12

Acornsoup · 28/08/2023 14:58

@Mooshamoo

Yeah but it was @AlienatedChildGrown that bored the life out of me 🥱 with their irrelevant diatribe.

her irrelevant diatribe

Inconveniently her

I’m not being surreptitiously cast as some kind male father’s rights activist in disguise (with the oh so casual use of “their”). A pox on their house too. They are just as guilty of making this all about adults’ wants and feelings while failing entirely to take a cold, hard look at their own contributions to the mess their children find themselves in.

Mmhmmn · 28/08/2023 15:09

Lonicerax · 28/08/2023 15:04

I don’t really think she misses her DF -in fact as she gets to teens spending time with him seems a bad idea.
It’s hard to admit as a teen that you aren’t popular/ have few friends/ not that bright/ want to be better looking due to who you are - or at least you think it’s some failing in yourself. So less hurtful to blame someone else -yr DM.
Counselling -ask around for suggestions -ime being able to speak openly and honestly to someone could make all the difference.

Definitely

IamfeelingSad · 28/08/2023 15:08

I think she might be projecting and her dad is not the issue something else is. My daughter has had a lot of therapy as have I. I have always found it helpful to help my daughter identify the feelings she is having and then track back to when she first had those feelings - what is was happening at the time.

Mmhmmn · 28/08/2023 15:07

Not suggesting your new DP is a replacement for her dad but this is a good thing that they get on.

I agree that even if DD blames the move, this probably isn't really the root of her sadness and self-harming - it's more likely the rejection by her dad. And moving back there and struggling, what would it achieve if the useless lump of her dad is not interested? It's his fault you had to move away, not yours.

Beetlebuggy · 28/08/2023 15:05

I think it's also being missed that the OP was moving the kids to be closer to family, family who would be engaged with them.

I moved a lot as a child, in fact was homeless at one point. It wasn't ideal but my Mum did her best and she stayed with my alcoholic father, which probably wasn't the best decision. In turn, I had to move my children where the work was, again not ideal. But we eventually moved back to somewhere, where everyone (except me) remembered being happy, we are still there and it wasn't a good move for any of us. Rose tinted glasses are a thing.

AlienatedChildGrown · 28/08/2023 15:04

Grimbelina · 28/08/2023 14:49

Those advocating for the fathers rights and the right for the child to see the father... that's all very well but the father in this case (and many others) doesn't want to exercise that right.

That’s just the results of geography. In the countries where the father is either automatically the “owner” of the children, or far more likely to be given primary custody the sex roles are reversed. But the kids get the same hand dealt. One of loss.

For better or worse is as applicable to becoming parents together as it is marriage. Except the recipients of the better or worse include the children in the mix.

One parent (NNT or otherwise) irresponsible, not good at getting their shit together, tends to place their own wants over the children’s needs ? Everybody’s problem. Everybody’s for better or worse. Because everybody gets to live with the ramifications of that, including the extent to which it fuels the emotions spiralling a kid out of control at an already tricky point of development.

Making “not bothering, not taking responsibility” even more seductive by placing the barrier of great distance between the parent and his/her ability to pull their finger out.

Lone parents move away for support. Which is understandable. And they alone cannot make a less involved parent get their act together. So maybe the way forward is looking at ways to keep even the less capable parents in the picture through social expectation and action at a governmental and community level.

As long as this gets framed as a battle of the sexes kids are going to keep falling through the cracks (well, more like yawning gulf at this point) and grow up at high risk of repeating the cycle with their own kids. It’s not about the sexes. It’s about children getting the best hand they can be dealt given the circumstances.

Lonicerax · 28/08/2023 15:04

I don’t really think she misses her DF -in fact as she gets to teens spending time with him seems a bad idea.
It’s hard to admit as a teen that you aren’t popular/ have few friends/ not that bright/ want to be better looking due to who you are - or at least you think it’s some failing in yourself. So less hurtful to blame someone else -yr DM.
Counselling -ask around for suggestions -ime being able to speak openly and honestly to someone could make all the difference.

Frencis · 28/08/2023 15:02

fml666 · 28/08/2023 11:55

It's clear from some of the childrens' comments when they returned from a recent stay with him ( initiated by myself, and I took them to see him) that he has been making comments to the children about how mean I've been taking them away from him, etc. DD told me her dad said I'm "not bringing them up very well" and that this is the reason she SHs.

From day one I have actually said he could stay with us to facilitate him visiting them. But he won't. Not that I want that now as our relationship has deteriorated. But he won't. To make it clear: if I don't initiate it he will not have ANY contact with his DC at all. Im trying to protect them from discovering this.

I just wanted to respond to your comment above.. I had similar with my dc and their dad. I asked an experienced family counsellor about how to deal with his terrible parenting without slagging him off to the dcs. She told me to be very careful of giving them a rose tinted view of him that would backfire later when they realised what he was really like. Instead, answer their questions truthfully and be as honest with them as is appropriate for their ages. Really helpful advice. I wish you all the best.. It sounds like you have done your best in a very difficult situation 💐