Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

So is formula milk UPF?

415 replies

bumgripes · 28/08/2023 10:07

It is, right? I mean, the ingredients list certainly is. And it’s listed on the BBC website as an UPF.

Going to be interested to see if this influences the BF/FF debate now that it looks like awareness of UPF is about to skyrocket. Does it even matter when they’re only on it for about a year? Does that fact that it’s an UPF actually add any info to the pre-existing evidence on BF/FF?

OP posts:
Sirzy · 29/08/2023 13:58

I have battles every month to get DS tube feed properly supplied and delivered. His feed is basically a grown up ready made formula.

it would also be at massive cost to to the NHS in time alone let alone the actual cost of the feeds

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/08/2023 13:23

Redebs · 29/08/2023 11:08

But those would be able to get it on prescription

I'd be saying everything necessary to get it on prescription because like fuck would I be forced to breastfeed against my will.

Thankfully it is very unlikely to happen in reality.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/08/2023 13:18

Redebs · 29/08/2023 10:51

Very few mothers are unable to produce milk. (for example extreme hypothyroidism). Some babies are unable to suckle (for example cleft palate or other congenital malformations)

Formula should be reserved for cases where mothers cannot breastfeed due to medical reasons.

If it was available on prescription only, then we wouldn't be subjected to all the advertising to convince us that it's 'just as good'. And people would stop thinking of it as an option for otherwise capable mothers and babies.

Formula is not as good as breastmilk. Fact.

and women who don't want to breastfeed would be forced to use their bodies against their will.

No thanks.

Twizbe · 29/08/2023 11:51

@LuvSmallDogs I know a lot of qualified breastfeeding supporters, IBCLCs, breastfeeding councillors etc through my work. Without exception none of them give a monkeys about how a woman feeds their baby. They care that women have the information they need to make the right choice for them and their families. They care that those who want to breastfeed have the information and support they need to achieve their goals. They will support women to mix feed and be there there to wean / stop breastfeeding safely at any point.

They also believe that formula has an important role to play in infant feeding. They pretty much all feel that a formula sold at near cost price and free from branding / advertising is a great idea.

There’s also a huge difference between saying ‘just change meds’ and ‘if you want to, this group of qualified pharmacists can talk you through the evidence regarding your medication and breastfeeding.’

Their big issue is with the companies who make the formula. Those ones who prey on parents’ insecurities and fears. Those that try to convince parents that there is something wrong with their baby or that they are wrong (see recent study from the Lancet) Those that knowingly undermine those who want to breastfeed. Those that knowingly lie about what formula is actually capable of doing (for example there’s no evidence that formula helps babies sleep better)

CecilyP · 29/08/2023 11:36

And prescriptions are generally dispensed to the sick. A bottle fed baby is no sick.

JenniferBarkley · 29/08/2023 11:33

AliasGrape · 29/08/2023 11:22

And that's the kind of bullshit false equivalence that it deeply, deeply offensive - not that you care of course.

Feeding a baby formula is in no way comparable to subjecting them to passive smoking in a non-ventilated car, and you should be ashamed of yourself for saying so.

Exactly. You can't compare formula to the most notorious carcinogen on the market. Disgusting.

AnneAnon · 29/08/2023 11:31

This thread is terrible.

Women kicking women.

AliasGrape · 29/08/2023 11:22

Redebs · 29/08/2023 11:00

That kind of argument used to be used when people were told to stop smoking in cars with children in.
'How dare the government.... etc'

And that's the kind of bullshit false equivalence that it deeply, deeply offensive - not that you care of course.

Feeding a baby formula is in no way comparable to subjecting them to passive smoking in a non-ventilated car, and you should be ashamed of yourself for saying so.

ItstimeToMoveagain · 29/08/2023 11:17

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 11:10

Well that just makes you worse then.. I won't say what I really think ☺️

Like I'd care

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 11:10

ItstimeToMoveagain · 29/08/2023 00:33

I didn't have any traumatic experience 🤣

Well that just makes you worse then.. I won't say what I really think ☺️

Redebs · 29/08/2023 11:08

LuvSmallDogs · 29/08/2023 11:00

People FF due to medical reasons all the time. Women who have to take medication that isn't BFing safe, women who can't produce enough milk, women who have PND or are otherwise struggling with their mental health and find the added stress and pain of trying to establish BF too much.

Of course, for many hard-line lactivists these would count as choices - just switch meds and risk a manic episode, just trust that your milk will come in before your baby starves, BFing doesn't hurt with the right latch, etc etc.

But those would be able to get it on prescription

LuvSmallDogs · 29/08/2023 11:00

Unusualplumbing · 29/08/2023 10:53

But nobody thinks enteric feeding is just as good as normal eating. People only do it for medical reasons.

People FF due to medical reasons all the time. Women who have to take medication that isn't BFing safe, women who can't produce enough milk, women who have PND or are otherwise struggling with their mental health and find the added stress and pain of trying to establish BF too much.

Of course, for many hard-line lactivists these would count as choices - just switch meds and risk a manic episode, just trust that your milk will come in before your baby starves, BFing doesn't hurt with the right latch, etc etc.

Redebs · 29/08/2023 11:00

JenniferBarkley · 29/08/2023 10:53

What do you think gives you or the government the right to dictate how women use their breast?

I have no skin in this game, my babies were EBF bottle refusers so I get my breastfeeding gold star. But it gives me the absolute rage when people think there is something wrong with not wanting to do so.

That kind of argument used to be used when people were told to stop smoking in cars with children in.
'How dare the government.... etc'

CecilyP · 29/08/2023 10:56

If it was available on prescription only, then we wouldn't be subjected to all the advertising to convince us that it's 'just as good'. And people would stop thinking of it as an option for otherwise capable mothers and babies.

If formula was only available on prescription (as if GPs don’t have enough to do) then mums would revert to using unmodified cows milk. And given that most families use semi-skimmed these days, expect to see a lot of rickety children!

JenniferBarkley · 29/08/2023 10:53

Redebs · 29/08/2023 10:51

Very few mothers are unable to produce milk. (for example extreme hypothyroidism). Some babies are unable to suckle (for example cleft palate or other congenital malformations)

Formula should be reserved for cases where mothers cannot breastfeed due to medical reasons.

If it was available on prescription only, then we wouldn't be subjected to all the advertising to convince us that it's 'just as good'. And people would stop thinking of it as an option for otherwise capable mothers and babies.

Formula is not as good as breastmilk. Fact.

What do you think gives you or the government the right to dictate how women use their breast?

I have no skin in this game, my babies were EBF bottle refusers so I get my breastfeeding gold star. But it gives me the absolute rage when people think there is something wrong with not wanting to do so.

Unusualplumbing · 29/08/2023 10:53

LuvSmallDogs · 29/08/2023 10:46

Is the stuff they pump into patients via feeding tubes also UPF? If so, shouldn't the NHS stop using it and just blend up some MN chickens (each patient would only need one a week, after all).

But nobody thinks enteric feeding is just as good as normal eating. People only do it for medical reasons.

Redebs · 29/08/2023 10:51

Very few mothers are unable to produce milk. (for example extreme hypothyroidism). Some babies are unable to suckle (for example cleft palate or other congenital malformations)

Formula should be reserved for cases where mothers cannot breastfeed due to medical reasons.

If it was available on prescription only, then we wouldn't be subjected to all the advertising to convince us that it's 'just as good'. And people would stop thinking of it as an option for otherwise capable mothers and babies.

Formula is not as good as breastmilk. Fact.

LuvSmallDogs · 29/08/2023 10:46

Is the stuff they pump into patients via feeding tubes also UPF? If so, shouldn't the NHS stop using it and just blend up some MN chickens (each patient would only need one a week, after all).

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/08/2023 10:41

It would be a whole load more productive if the discussion were about why a descriptive term for foods that are highly processed for whatever reason is now being coopted as a shorthand for poison/obesity/being lower class/gluttony.

Some UPFs are essential. Some UPFs are valuable. Some taste nice but are unhealthy in large quantities. None should have moral value attached to them.

If it weren't for the moral value people have absorbed as a result largely of people wanting to make millions from diet books, there wouldn't be a multiple page thread of women arguing about formula feeding vs. Breastfeeding, desperately kicking back against the idea that a perfect example of an ultra processed food is ultra processed.

Formula milk is ultra processed. And? It's better than babies not being fed.

Reminds me of the 1980s fuss about all E numbers or microwaves.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 29/08/2023 10:39

My cousin's were in Farex at 6 weeks and my younger siblings were fed on diluted Evaporated milk, all survived and are well and healthy now. Don't be so bloody precious!

CecilyP · 29/08/2023 10:32

No, I don’t think the advice has changed all that recently, I’m thinking more like 30 years ago!

maybein2022 · 29/08/2023 10:25

@CecilyP the advice is you can use cow’s milk (whole) in cooking for babies from 6 months so that’s what I’ve done, but only as a main drink from 1 year. I think that’s been the advice for a long time. Can’t wait to get rid of the formula! He’s only on two bottles a day anyway now.

CecilyP · 29/08/2023 10:23

maybein2022 · 28/08/2023 22:47

Of course formula milk in an UPF. It’s also what kept all three of my babies alive so I’m not too fussed, really, despite trying hard to cut back on other UPF. He’ll be one soon and then it can be gone.

That’s an interesting point! Breastfeeding aside, I’m sure the age at which you are advised not to give normal cows milk to babies has only gone up to one in recent years. So health professionals are advising mums to give a UPF, rather than a natural product to babies!

Somethingsnappy · 29/08/2023 09:29

The problem with lumping everything together under the UPF label, is that we automatically assume this label is bad/ junk food. But for formula, this is the opposite; it has become ultra processed because of the long journey to develop as nutritious an alternative to BF as possible for infants. Its ingredients are tightly regulated by a national body, and if any company find a new ingredient that is widely agreed to be beneficial, all formula companies are required by law to include the ingredient. So formula has benefitted from being an ultra processed food.

As other posters have said, people should know about the differences between BF and FF generally, and should not waste any time worrying about the UPF label, as it means something different in the case of formula.

I have 4 children and have never used formula, but I was always comforted to know a nutritious and perfectly healthy food was available if I needed or wanted it.

JenniferBarkley · 29/08/2023 08:59

You're right that formula is a UPF, and you're right that that makes an important point.

That point isn't that formula is bad because it's a UPF. The point is that using any rule of thumb like "UPF = bad" religiously without allowing for nuance is ridiculous.

@NeverDropYourMooncup put it perfectly right at the start of the thread:

It's one of the reasons why UPFs being demonised is such a shitty way to operate - it appeals to people who attach moral value to dietary choices and weight, but doesn't actually represent what is actually needed; food that is affordable and appropriate nutritionally for all sectors of the population.

Formula is great, it allows babies to be fed when their mothers can't or don't want to breastfeed. And not wanting to is just as valid a reason as not being able to, as I don't think anyone should get any say in how a woman uses her breasts. Bodily autonomy, freedom of choice - just as important here as in reproductive freedom.