Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

So is formula milk UPF?

415 replies

bumgripes · 28/08/2023 10:07

It is, right? I mean, the ingredients list certainly is. And it’s listed on the BBC website as an UPF.

Going to be interested to see if this influences the BF/FF debate now that it looks like awareness of UPF is about to skyrocket. Does it even matter when they’re only on it for about a year? Does that fact that it’s an UPF actually add any info to the pre-existing evidence on BF/FF?

OP posts:
Parker231 · 29/08/2023 20:01

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 19:27

Also "The WHO has found that “inappropriate marketing of breast milk substitutes” has undermined efforts to increase breastfeeding rates and duration worldwide". Was said.

The comment is irrelevant - some of us want to use formula. Are you proposing taking away our rights to feed our babies in the way we want to?

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 19:48

Mumof2teens79 · 29/08/2023 19:26

UPF is meaningless non-sense
Bread is a UPF

Fed is best

My first child was mix fed from the beginning. She’s fine. My second has been EBF from day 1, he has eczema, CMPA and is being investigated for other allergies. He’s never had a drop of formula and yet he seems to be such a reactive baby. My first was also slightly prem whereas he wasn’t.

To be honest, if I could go back six months I would’ve mix fed from the beginning.

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 19:46

Out of interest why is it always women who breastfeed who take such an ‘interest’ in other women’s feeding choices? I breastfeed, I couldn’t care less what other women do, let alone want to start threads because I’m ‘interested’ in informing them what they’re feeding their baby is artificially made like they don’t already know.

I’m also dying to know what these natural alternatives to formula would be. Does anyone have any ideas?

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 19:27

Also "The WHO has found that “inappropriate marketing of breast milk substitutes” has undermined efforts to increase breastfeeding rates and duration worldwide". Was said.

Mumof2teens79 · 29/08/2023 19:26

UPF is meaningless non-sense
Bread is a UPF

Fed is best

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 19:24

CecilyP · 29/08/2023 17:48

Everyone know that formula exists! It could only discourage breastfeeding if people weren’t aware of its existence.

Well it obviously does otherwise boots wouldn't of gotten into trouble for doing it. And I'm glad they've been told to not do it.

Twizbe · 29/08/2023 18:03

Look up the WHO code and the history behind it and the history of formula advertising. Lots of examples.

Mostly in this country it’s making claims that aren’t backed up with evidence. E.g. you need to ‘move on’ from breastfeeding or first stage formula at 6 months. Colic and constipation milk which has no evidence that it does anything.

Iam4eels · 29/08/2023 18:00

Twizbe · 29/08/2023 17:29

@Iam4eels you’ve hit the point. The advertisers have shown time and time again to not keep to factual information.

When? We have pretty strict advertising laws on this country and an advertising standards agency for raising concerns about claims in adverts.

Parker231 · 29/08/2023 17:51

Advertising had no impact onto my decision to only use formula. It was something i decided on whilst pregnant. I bought the brand the local supermarket stocked the most of so easily available. Nothing to do with advertising different brands

CecilyP · 29/08/2023 17:48

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 17:42

It still discouraging. But the product wasn't getting aimed at older babies. It was getting aimed at 0 to 6 months. Prime time for breastfeeding

Everyone know that formula exists! It could only discourage breastfeeding if people weren’t aware of its existence.

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 17:42

CecilyP · 29/08/2023 17:16

Surely it’s finding it that difficult that discourages breastfeeding far more than formula advertising! So many women, even on this thread alone, have wanted to breastfeed and had to give up. They seem to have been far more influenced by positive breastfeeding messages (that didn’t quite work out in reality) than advertising for a product aimed at older babies.

Edited

It still discouraging. But the product wasn't getting aimed at older babies. It was getting aimed at 0 to 6 months. Prime time for breastfeeding

Twizbe · 29/08/2023 17:31

@SOSWhen i don’t believe I was the one to derail the thread. Nor have I said anything about how anyone should feed their baby.

Twizbe · 29/08/2023 17:29

@Iam4eels you’ve hit the point. The advertisers have shown time and time again to not keep to factual information.

CecilyP · 29/08/2023 17:16

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 15:27

It's because its discouraging breastfeeding. Yeah don't get me wrong I imagine it's hard work and tiring doing formula. It is easier to just put baby on the boob but obstacles can get in the way. Pain. Tongue tie etc not getting the right support can be frustrating. But it is the easy way out because its not easy breastfeeding in the beginning. For some it can be hard work for months. Especially if youre pumping for not being able to latch baba. Because that does take its toll on you.

Surely it’s finding it that difficult that discourages breastfeeding far more than formula advertising! So many women, even on this thread alone, have wanted to breastfeed and had to give up. They seem to have been far more influenced by positive breastfeeding messages (that didn’t quite work out in reality) than advertising for a product aimed at older babies.

SOSWhen · 29/08/2023 17:15

God this thread is so BORING the same whinging @Redebs @Twizbe that pop up on any thread that mentions breastfeeding and start harping on and rehashing the same arguments. Jeez. The thread title is ‘is formula UPF’ not come on this thread and repeat what you’ve said on multiple times on other threads as you can shoehorn breastfeeding is better into the discussion.

I feel like setting up a bingo card for breastfeeding discussion - it’s the same crap over and over.

Iam4eels · 29/08/2023 17:11

No one ever chose to FF just because they saw an advert for Cow & Gate. Women aren't stupid, we know formula exists so I don't see the issue with allowing companies to advertise it provided it done so factually. What does discourage women from breastfeeding is lack of support and lack of information. I remember asking my HV why the antenatal class on breastfeeding didn't mention cluster-feeding, cracked nipples or latch problems despite these being common issues and instead had pushed the message of "your baby is born knowing how to breastfeed" and "it's so quick and easy". She told me that if they told everyone at the class about these issues then no one would attempt it, she didn't seem to see the irony that not knowing about these potential issues (and what to do about them) sets women up for failure. This is the sort of thing that stops women breastfeeding, not a voucher for 50p off a tin of SMA.

And of course there are women who simply don't want to breastfeed and that is also a valid choice because bodily autonomy trumps all else. The PP advocating for forced breastfeeding is mind-boggling, do they really want to live in a society where we tell women what to do with their bodies or force them to provide their body for use by another person against their own wishes. That's a slippery slope.

I BF'd for around ten years in total across four DC and I support the right of any woman to choose how she feeds her baby, for her to be provided with unbiased, judgement-free information on her choose method, and for her to go off and do that without comment or negativity from others.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/08/2023 15:41

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 15:27

It's because its discouraging breastfeeding. Yeah don't get me wrong I imagine it's hard work and tiring doing formula. It is easier to just put baby on the boob but obstacles can get in the way. Pain. Tongue tie etc not getting the right support can be frustrating. But it is the easy way out because its not easy breastfeeding in the beginning. For some it can be hard work for months. Especially if youre pumping for not being able to latch baba. Because that does take its toll on you.

What's wrong with taking the ''easy'' way out and not wanting to pump for months and/or not wanting to be in pain and miserable?

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 15:27

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2023 15:17

Boots have recently got in to trouble for advertising formula for babies up to 6 months.

Exactly. They got in trouble for it because it's not allowed. If producers and retailers are bending the law then they should be penalised.

Personally I don't see a particular issue with 'follow on milk', as an option (alternative to cows milk) from an age when babies are starting to be weaned. I'm not convinced it has much bearing on the decisions made for newborns. Maybe I'm wrong and that shouldn't be advertised either.

The posters on MN that comment the same three points about a particular brand on any thread about choosing formula.

That might be something MNHQ should look into and disallow. Do you report such posts?

It's because its discouraging breastfeeding. Yeah don't get me wrong I imagine it's hard work and tiring doing formula. It is easier to just put baby on the boob but obstacles can get in the way. Pain. Tongue tie etc not getting the right support can be frustrating. But it is the easy way out because its not easy breastfeeding in the beginning. For some it can be hard work for months. Especially if youre pumping for not being able to latch baba. Because that does take its toll on you.

Twizbe · 29/08/2023 15:26

There’s no issue with follow on milk as an option. But it’s an option that sold as a necessity. The adverts don’t tell you that you don’t have to swap to it or that it’s basically the same as first stage. It was only created to get around the bans.

Theres no proof that any of these posts are paid for or advertising. Regular readers though will notice just how similar they sound.

The ban really has nothing to do with individual’s choices around infant feeding. It’s to stop the companies engaging in unethical practices which ultimately harm babies and formula feeding families.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2023 15:17

Boots have recently got in to trouble for advertising formula for babies up to 6 months.

Exactly. They got in trouble for it because it's not allowed. If producers and retailers are bending the law then they should be penalised.

Personally I don't see a particular issue with 'follow on milk', as an option (alternative to cows milk) from an age when babies are starting to be weaned. I'm not convinced it has much bearing on the decisions made for newborns. Maybe I'm wrong and that shouldn't be advertised either.

The posters on MN that comment the same three points about a particular brand on any thread about choosing formula.

That might be something MNHQ should look into and disallow. Do you report such posts?

KnittedCardi · 29/08/2023 15:15

Why does no-one ever compare and contrast, cajole and berate, vaginal deliveries v. cesaereans. The former is "natural", arguably better for the baby, vaginal bacteria and all that jazz.

Because most people know that some women can't deliver vaginally, it might be dangerous and detrimental both in health and mental wellbeing to both baby and mother. The mother, along with advice from her physicians, gets to choose.

The same should therefore apply to the breastmilk v. ff debate. It is a complex decision making process, and the mother should get to choose, just like with her delivery options.

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 14:56

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2023 14:43

If it was available on prescription only, then we wouldn't be subjected to all the advertising to convince us that it's 'just as good'. And people would stop thinking of it as an option for otherwise capable mothers and babies.

All what advertising? Its illegal to advertise formula for babies up to 6 months in the U.K.

Boots have recently got in to trouble for advertising formula for babies up to 6 months.

Twizbe · 29/08/2023 14:53

@ErrolTheDragon ooooh there are many many loopholes that the formula companies go through. Not least the creation of follow on milk which they can advertise.

There is lots of ‘advice’ out there which really is thinly veiled advertising. Or an influencer feeding their baby and just happen to have the packet of formula in the background.

The posters on MN that comment the same three points about a particular brand on any thread about choosing formula.

this is just the tip of the iceberg.

RosieS22 · 29/08/2023 14:52

@ErrolTheDragon you know the only reason 'follow on milk' is a thing, is so they can get around that law/regulation and advertise their product and brand.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2023 14:43

If it was available on prescription only, then we wouldn't be subjected to all the advertising to convince us that it's 'just as good'. And people would stop thinking of it as an option for otherwise capable mothers and babies.

All what advertising? Its illegal to advertise formula for babies up to 6 months in the U.K.