Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

So is formula milk UPF?

415 replies

bumgripes · 28/08/2023 10:07

It is, right? I mean, the ingredients list certainly is. And it’s listed on the BBC website as an UPF.

Going to be interested to see if this influences the BF/FF debate now that it looks like awareness of UPF is about to skyrocket. Does it even matter when they’re only on it for about a year? Does that fact that it’s an UPF actually add any info to the pre-existing evidence on BF/FF?

OP posts:
carouselthoughts · 30/08/2023 14:42

@Cowlover89 same!

Also found that my children have never had a course of antibiotics in their life. My eldest is 5, my youngest is 2.4. Where as their formula fed cousins have had antibiotics 6 times before they even turned 9 months.

My eldest only first got a cold when she started nursery at 3.5

I do believe breastfeeding has contributed to that!

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 14:34

Jamtartforme · 30/08/2023 14:21

If he was a baby and you caught it through food then he wouldn’t have caught it would he? Not unless he ate the same dodgy curry or whatever you did.

It's not something that's caught through food. Antibodies stopped him getting it.

Jamtartforme · 30/08/2023 14:21

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 08:53

If we're going to do this. The amazing thing with breastfeeding. I got really poorly with gastroenteritis. Literally had to feed my son on the loo it was that bad. He never caught it. He's only been poorly 4 times and recovered fast. He's nearly 17 months. Yes it'll change when he goes to nursery. But my point it. Every baby is different. Some breastfed will get poorly more like some ff will get poorly more and its not always down to how they've been fed. Its down to the baby.

If he was a baby and you caught it through food then he wouldn’t have caught it would he? Not unless he ate the same dodgy curry or whatever you did.

ZoeCM · 30/08/2023 14:03

Schools really need to start drumming it into children that anecdotes are not data. I'm amazed by the number of adults who don't understand the difference.

ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2023 09:22

90% of the babies and children I know with eczema or allergies are or were breastfed. The formula fed kids actually seem healthier.

If FF is commoner than BF and one of the main publicised benefits of BF is reduction in allergies, then it may well be that the BF cohort contains a self-selected greater proportion of babies with a family history of allergies than the FF cohort. My DHs allergies were certainly one factor which encouraged me to persist BF despite initial low supply due to PCOS.

Twizbe · 30/08/2023 09:00

@Parker231 my anecdotal evidence disproved @Jamtartforme ’s anecdotal evidence.

There’s no point presenting such ‘evidence’ as fact.

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 08:53

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:49

Yes. But had I mix fed from the beginning I think he would’ve been less likely to have developed CMPA to start with. This is my personal belief. 90% of the babies and children I know with eczema or allergies are or were breastfed. The formula fed kids actually seem healthier. You can throw what statistics you like at me, this is the evidence of my eyes and ears.

If we're going to do this. The amazing thing with breastfeeding. I got really poorly with gastroenteritis. Literally had to feed my son on the loo it was that bad. He never caught it. He's only been poorly 4 times and recovered fast. He's nearly 17 months. Yes it'll change when he goes to nursery. But my point it. Every baby is different. Some breastfed will get poorly more like some ff will get poorly more and its not always down to how they've been fed. Its down to the baby.

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 08:49

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:49

Yes. But had I mix fed from the beginning I think he would’ve been less likely to have developed CMPA to start with. This is my personal belief. 90% of the babies and children I know with eczema or allergies are or were breastfed. The formula fed kids actually seem healthier. You can throw what statistics you like at me, this is the evidence of my eyes and ears.

That's just nonsense. Sorry. Your baby would of still had it. CMPA is in more ff babies.

Parker231 · 30/08/2023 08:43

Twizbe · 30/08/2023 08:32

Sorry to disappoint but my CMPA son was mixed fed and my non allergy suffer baby was EBF.

My experience is that formula made my son projectile vomit and didn’t help with weight issues as it made him just throw up all the food.

Exactly - we all have our own anecdotal evidence.

Twizbe · 30/08/2023 08:32

Sorry to disappoint but my CMPA son was mixed fed and my non allergy suffer baby was EBF.

My experience is that formula made my son projectile vomit and didn’t help with weight issues as it made him just throw up all the food.

Parker231 · 30/08/2023 08:11

AnIndianWoman · 30/08/2023 07:54

This is the type of ignorant nonsense that scares breastfeeding mums who aren’t able to do their own research. The scientific fact is that breastfed babies are least likely to have any kind of allergies and pediatricians advise families with a history severe allergies (like mine) to breastfeed - DS is the first person in my family to be breastfed and the first one who doesn’t have an anaphalactic allergy.

It’s not nonsense when people relate it to their own family - which is all that matters to us as individuals.

DC’s - formula fed - no allergies but their cousins - bf all have a mixture of allergies.

Your comment wouldn’t have been a reason to persuade me to bf.

AnIndianWoman · 30/08/2023 07:54

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:49

Yes. But had I mix fed from the beginning I think he would’ve been less likely to have developed CMPA to start with. This is my personal belief. 90% of the babies and children I know with eczema or allergies are or were breastfed. The formula fed kids actually seem healthier. You can throw what statistics you like at me, this is the evidence of my eyes and ears.

This is the type of ignorant nonsense that scares breastfeeding mums who aren’t able to do their own research. The scientific fact is that breastfed babies are least likely to have any kind of allergies and pediatricians advise families with a history severe allergies (like mine) to breastfeed - DS is the first person in my family to be breastfed and the first one who doesn’t have an anaphalactic allergy.

Scottishskifun · 30/08/2023 05:55

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:21

I disagree. I don’t think babies are born with allergies, they develop them. It’s anecdata, but most of the babies I know with allergies/eczema/reactive type things are breastfed.

1 in 4 people have allergies the bf rates are not that high to be linked to bf it's an immune response.

Everyone knows a cmpa baby majority I know are ff with 2 out of 8 being bf it doesn't mean its caused by the feeding method.

RosieS22 · 29/08/2023 21:06

@Jamtartforme sure, some babies will develop allergies upon repeat exposure, either directly when older or through BM. But they can also be born with allergies from my personal experience. Allergies have different severities, IGE/NonIGE.

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:49

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 20:44

When they have cmpa you have to give them a different formula tho.

Yes. But had I mix fed from the beginning I think he would’ve been less likely to have developed CMPA to start with. This is my personal belief. 90% of the babies and children I know with eczema or allergies are or were breastfed. The formula fed kids actually seem healthier. You can throw what statistics you like at me, this is the evidence of my eyes and ears.

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 20:44

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:39

And vice versa. Maybe if I had then he wouldn’t.

When they have cmpa you have to give them a different formula tho.

So is formula milk UPF?
Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:39

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 20:38

Your baby might have reacted more if you did formula feed. But you won't know as you didn't.

And vice versa. Maybe if I had then he wouldn’t.

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 20:38

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:34

My family don’t have allergies. I have none. I drank milk while pregnant and ate yoghurt. Just my experience and personal suspicion.

Your baby might have reacted more if you did formula feed. But you won't know as you didn't.

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 20:36

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:35

And by the way you can’t be allergic to lactose. Lactose intolerance is not an allergy, they’re separate things.

I know they are. Was just giving examples.

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:35

And by the way you can’t be allergic to lactose. Lactose intolerance is not an allergy, they’re separate things.

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:34

My family don’t have allergies. I have none. I drank milk while pregnant and ate yoghurt. Just my experience and personal suspicion.

Cowlover89 · 29/08/2023 20:32

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:21

I disagree. I don’t think babies are born with allergies, they develop them. It’s anecdata, but most of the babies I know with allergies/eczema/reactive type things are breastfed.

Doesn't matter if your baby is breastfed or formula fed. If you have allergies in the family they are more likely to get them. I know formula fed babies who've had really bad allergies. Been lactose intolerance to formula. CMPA is more likely to happen in formula fed babies but breastfed babies can get it but more common in formula babies.

Also breastfeeding can help baby not get allergies. My partner has an allergy to certain nuts. HV told me to eat them whilst breastfeeding. Its not a competition between the two. So far so good. He's got no allergy and I know it can still develop later on. But I make sure to give him nutty foods often.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/08/2023 20:27

Parker231 · 29/08/2023 20:01

The comment is irrelevant - some of us want to use formula. Are you proposing taking away our rights to feed our babies in the way we want to?

Someone did just that earlier. It wasn't pp though.

They said formula should be prescription only for those who can't breastfeed and those who don't want to breastfeed would have no choice.

Jamtartforme · 29/08/2023 20:21

RosieS22 · 29/08/2023 20:17

@Jamtartforme this post makes no sense.
If your baby has CMPA, your baby has CMPA.
How you feed them would change nothing.
He'd probably have reacted worse to the formula and would have needed prescribed dairy free formula if you didn't want to EBF.

I disagree. I don’t think babies are born with allergies, they develop them. It’s anecdata, but most of the babies I know with allergies/eczema/reactive type things are breastfed.

RosieS22 · 29/08/2023 20:17

@Jamtartforme this post makes no sense.
If your baby has CMPA, your baby has CMPA.
How you feed them would change nothing.
He'd probably have reacted worse to the formula and would have needed prescribed dairy free formula if you didn't want to EBF.

Swipe left for the next trending thread