Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

So is formula milk UPF?

415 replies

bumgripes · 28/08/2023 10:07

It is, right? I mean, the ingredients list certainly is. And it’s listed on the BBC website as an UPF.

Going to be interested to see if this influences the BF/FF debate now that it looks like awareness of UPF is about to skyrocket. Does it even matter when they’re only on it for about a year? Does that fact that it’s an UPF actually add any info to the pre-existing evidence on BF/FF?

OP posts:
Adorapan · 30/08/2023 20:52

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 19:38

That’s very sad but not really of any consequence to a mother who feeds their baby formula. I don’t really know why people bring this scandal from years ago in a different continent up time and time again in a discussion of formula feeding. Do they want formula feeding mothers to let their children die in solidarity or what is the purpose of bringing it up?

So sorry, I clearly focused on the wrong bit for this thread - the book was actually very clear that formula is not to be thought of in the same way as other UPF in diets which is a concern. It was just interesting about the ethics of big food companies generally, and made me want to avoid nestle.

lljkk · 30/08/2023 20:41

Am I the only one thinking "This is perfect example why the UPF paranoid are being ridiculous?"

IhearyouClemFandango · 30/08/2023 20:29

No, hence my saying "but not anything broader".

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 20:16

IhearyouClemFandango · 30/08/2023 20:15

It's relevant in a discussion about why formula advertising and marketing should be regulated, but not anything broader.

So not relevant to this thread then.

IhearyouClemFandango · 30/08/2023 20:15

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 19:38

That’s very sad but not really of any consequence to a mother who feeds their baby formula. I don’t really know why people bring this scandal from years ago in a different continent up time and time again in a discussion of formula feeding. Do they want formula feeding mothers to let their children die in solidarity or what is the purpose of bringing it up?

It's relevant in a discussion about why formula advertising and marketing should be regulated, but not anything broader.

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 20:11

It’s so boring isn’t it!! Droning on and on with their anecdotes of how breastmilk simultaneously cured all the illnesses their children have while also never having been ill in the first place because of breastmilk. Then if a formula fed baby parent comes on and says their child has never been sick they say it’s an anecdote only. I actually breastfed my child and I can’t stand this kind of nonsense.

Parker231 · 30/08/2023 19:59

cheeseandcrackers89 · 30/08/2023 19:53

Oh not this AGAIN! I just do not get this mentality. If you breast fed your child, FABULOUS, it's a wonderful experience. But for those of you (and I have to say it is a minority, as most breastfeeding mums really do not care how others feed their children) who feel the need to use this as a tool to shame others, I can only presume that you are extremely insecure people who are trying to hide your parenting inadequacies in other areas. Formula feeding mothers know the pros and cons of breast vs formula feeding, you discuss it in depth with your midwife. You do not need to pass on your supposed superior knowledge on the subject. Love to all the mothers out there, regardless of how you feed your babies ❤

Thank you - reading some of these posts you would think us formula feeding parents were trying to harm our babies and give them a poor start in life. We should be celebrating having a choice how we feed our babies and that we’re lucky in this country to have such an amazing readily available formula product to give our children such an excellent start in life.

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 19:56

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 16:08

Insisting your baby didn’t get gastroenteritis because you were breastfeeding on the toilet is not debating. It’s spouting random nonsense that is not even remotely backed up by science or research. I may as well say my 1 year old didn’t catch covid from me despite being a close contact because on that day she wore yellow socks.

It's hardly nonsense. It's not the fact because I was breastfeeding on the toilet. I had no choice. But I'm sorry but it certainly helped in him not catching it. Antibodies did its magic.

cheeseandcrackers89 · 30/08/2023 19:53

Oh not this AGAIN! I just do not get this mentality. If you breast fed your child, FABULOUS, it's a wonderful experience. But for those of you (and I have to say it is a minority, as most breastfeeding mums really do not care how others feed their children) who feel the need to use this as a tool to shame others, I can only presume that you are extremely insecure people who are trying to hide your parenting inadequacies in other areas. Formula feeding mothers know the pros and cons of breast vs formula feeding, you discuss it in depth with your midwife. You do not need to pass on your supposed superior knowledge on the subject. Love to all the mothers out there, regardless of how you feed your babies ❤

Iwantmyoldnameback · 30/08/2023 19:48

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 19:38

That’s very sad but not really of any consequence to a mother who feeds their baby formula. I don’t really know why people bring this scandal from years ago in a different continent up time and time again in a discussion of formula feeding. Do they want formula feeding mothers to let their children die in solidarity or what is the purpose of bringing it up?

👏👏👏

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 19:38

Adorapan · 30/08/2023 19:08

In the book Ultra Processed People there is a long discussion about formula milk - it is UPF but is of course on a different level to other UPF foods because without it there are babies that would die. But there’s a very disturbing deep dive into how Nestle persuaded people living in countries without easy access to safe drinking water and with very low incomes to use formula instead of breast milk (and then increased prices once the mothers’ breast milk had dried up) and how as a result thousands of babies died. It was truly awful.

That’s very sad but not really of any consequence to a mother who feeds their baby formula. I don’t really know why people bring this scandal from years ago in a different continent up time and time again in a discussion of formula feeding. Do they want formula feeding mothers to let their children die in solidarity or what is the purpose of bringing it up?

GreyGrid · 30/08/2023 19:25

Somethingsnappy · 30/08/2023 19:02

Wowee! Think what he could have achieved if you'd breastfed him... 😉

Like my 3 year old was? Not likely! He's known as Jimmy The Knife down at the local cop shop. He got off on a technicality last time but I keep telling him he needs to take his inhaler with him when he's on a job, because it's the sound of his wheezing that gets him caught Sad

Adorapan · 30/08/2023 19:08

In the book Ultra Processed People there is a long discussion about formula milk - it is UPF but is of course on a different level to other UPF foods because without it there are babies that would die. But there’s a very disturbing deep dive into how Nestle persuaded people living in countries without easy access to safe drinking water and with very low incomes to use formula instead of breast milk (and then increased prices once the mothers’ breast milk had dried up) and how as a result thousands of babies died. It was truly awful.

Somethingsnappy · 30/08/2023 19:02

GreyGrid · 30/08/2023 16:00

Yeah well, my FF one year old has just been given a place at Harvard College, Yale. He's predicted to ace every semester and get an A. So there!

Wowee! Think what he could have achieved if you'd breastfed him... 😉

IhearyouClemFandango · 30/08/2023 18:11

Indeed. All 3 of mine were breastfed. #1 self weaned at 18 months. #2 self weaned at 3 yrs. #3 self weaned with encouragement at nearly 4.

#1 had scarlet fever requiring antibiotics. #2 had bronchiolitis and needed steroids for a while after as every cough/cold went to his chest. #3 got a temperature every time he got over tired, but didn't need antibiotics, has the constitution of an ox.

So as they say, anecdata means nothing.

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 16:08

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 16:05

Just having a debate. Calm down 😅

Insisting your baby didn’t get gastroenteritis because you were breastfeeding on the toilet is not debating. It’s spouting random nonsense that is not even remotely backed up by science or research. I may as well say my 1 year old didn’t catch covid from me despite being a close contact because on that day she wore yellow socks.

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 16:05

Just having a debate. Calm down 😅

GreyGrid · 30/08/2023 16:00

Yeah well, my FF one year old has just been given a place at Harvard College, Yale. He's predicted to ace every semester and get an A. So there!

Dasisr · 30/08/2023 15:56

Gosh can we stop all this nonsense over sickness! One persons formula fed child hasn’t been sick. One persons breastfed child hasn’t been sick and they insist it’s due to breastfeeding.

well how do you explain formula fed children also not getting sick if they weren’t breastfed and breastfeeding stops sicknesses?

Here’s a clue - children differ in their levels of sickness regardless of how they are fed.

ItstimeToMoveagain · 30/08/2023 15:48

Some children just seem more prone to sickness, my younger 2 are never really ill

Although I've never felt so ill as the time I had a stomach bug and was bf the 4 month old and trying to look after a just turned 2 year old and couldn't even keep down water . None of the dc caught it though

I can't remember with the older 2 because they are adults but my 12 and 10 year old have only had Antibiotics once each, the 12 year old as a newborn in nicu and the 10 year old when he was about 18 months old for an ear infection, 1 bf the other ff

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 15:48

carouselthoughts · 30/08/2023 14:42

@Cowlover89 same!

Also found that my children have never had a course of antibiotics in their life. My eldest is 5, my youngest is 2.4. Where as their formula fed cousins have had antibiotics 6 times before they even turned 9 months.

My eldest only first got a cold when she started nursery at 3.5

I do believe breastfeeding has contributed to that!

It definitely has! My sons only been poorly like 4 times and recovered quickly. I just gave him extra boob. You wouldn't of suspected he was poorly. Was still his happy content self.

Parker231 · 30/08/2023 15:19

carouselthoughts · 30/08/2023 14:42

@Cowlover89 same!

Also found that my children have never had a course of antibiotics in their life. My eldest is 5, my youngest is 2.4. Where as their formula fed cousins have had antibiotics 6 times before they even turned 9 months.

My eldest only first got a cold when she started nursery at 3.5

I do believe breastfeeding has contributed to that!

My formula fed DC’s are in their early 20’s - neither have had any antibiotics. Only one hospital treatment between them - DS broken leg.

Both started full time nursery at six months old but no calls to collect them as they were unwell.

Cowlover89 · 30/08/2023 14:56

Yes bacterial can be caught by food water etc. Viral isn't. But I know it wasn't caused by food. And it is contagious. He very well could of easily caught it but didn't. He was constantly on the boob.

inloveandmarried · 30/08/2023 14:55

In the case of trying to replicate breast milk of course it will look ultra processed.

Look at all the fats, carbohydrates, vitamins minerals and proteins it needs to contain. It has to be a complete food.

There's no way this could ever be achieved with a few simple ingredients as it's not a simple food.

In this case it is ultra processed and couldn't deliver the nutrition needed without being just that.

Perfectly acceptable.

GreyGrid · 30/08/2023 14:48

ZoeCM · 30/08/2023 14:03

Schools really need to start drumming it into children that anecdotes are not data. I'm amazed by the number of adults who don't understand the difference.

It's painful, isn't it.