Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Special occasions arrangements with ex

117 replies

Hare95 · 27/08/2023 20:26

Myself and my ex are trying to sort out who has our 6yo DS and when on special occasions.

I want to always have mornings on birthdays and Christmas and for ex to have afternoons. My reasons are that my ex sees family in the afternoon, and I see family in the morning, so DS won't miss out on seeing them. Also I'm disabled and my pain levels increase as the day goes on, especially during a full on time such as Christmas. So I'm worried if I'm on the afternoon rota I'll miss quality time with DS due to the pain I'm in. Are these good enough reasons to ask for consistent mornings? My ex is now saying I'm being taken to court for not agreeing to either full Christmas and birthday with me one year and switched the following year, OR one year I get mornings and the following year my ex gets mornings.

Another point that's infuriating me is that my ex is refusing to have DS at new year, saying it's not for children to celebrate (IMO my ex wants to get drunk and having DS isn't convenient). I've said children can have new year parties, fireworks, sparklers etc. They learn about the new year at school and so on. But my ex point blank won't have our son during this time but is threatening court regarding Christmas and birthday arrangements.

Just to give a bit of insight, my ex hasn't been the easiest since we split up. I was asked to do a favour and have our son back earlier on one of our rota weeks as my ex needed to visit an unwell elderly family member on that day. I agreed, but since have had many reasons to believe my ex isn't visiting said family member so I've said I can't honour the arrangement anymore and my ex will have to go back to the original plan which was my ex having DS on the day in question (bringing him back at 18:00 instead of 11am so my ex can visit family member). This was about 8 months ago and my ex's consistent response was "it's not changing'. Very dictatory and foolishly I continued to meet my ex at 11am since then. I've now decided to put foot down and said I can't continue with the favour of meeting earlier anymore (this happens one Saturday every 4 weeks). My ex has responded with "I haven't agreed to that so it's not changing"....I'm sorry but hasn't agreed to allowing me to stop offering a favour? The last time I checked if you do someone a favour and you can't continue it anymore, you don't need permission to stop the favour! This is just one issue I'm faced with. I feel my ex is out to be selfish and to not consider DS. There's been so many issues since our break up.just to give an insight into character...when I was suffering with my mental health after our break up, my ex handed me my car keys and told me to commit suicide.

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 28/08/2023 08:16

Agree to seeing your son for alternative Christmases. Don't split up the days into morning and night.
You will have some mornings and nights one Christmas and then next year he will be at his father's house and you will have to celebrate Christmas on another morning near to that date.

If you like celebrating New Year then can that be your compromise? You agree to do all New Years Eves and he will accept that you do not look after your son as a favour every four weeks.

I would look into getting legal representation or a mediator so that you can make plans formally without feeling intimidated.
Never agree to an on going favour. A one off for valid reasons is fair.

Rachie1973 · 28/08/2023 08:16

Hare95 · 28/08/2023 02:44

I haven't said I don't want DS on NYE. I've said if my ex wants DS 50% of special occasions, then that includes NYE but my ex is refusing to see him NYE at all. An excuse to go off and get drunk I assume

As for seeing family, my family live an hour away. They are elderly (in their 80s) grandparents. They don't want to travel to us later in the day when it's darker, colder and potentially icy. We can't go to them given the distance, particularly because it's more moving around if my son is then going to my ex in the afternoon. I've really really tried to see where you're coming from but I don't I'm sorry 😞 I just don't see how anyone can say it's unreasonable to want to get my son as much time with his great grandparents at Christmas as possible? Is this really being unreasonable? Plus given the fact my ex always sees great grandparents on that side in the afternoons, I just feel naturally that it then makes sense DS is with my ex during that part of the day so he doesn't miss out on seeing his great grant parents on that side too

you’ve posted before and people gave you the same opinions, but you’re still stuck in this same me me me narrative.

The courts are unlikely to give 2 hoots about the great grandparents etc, and it being better in morning for you. They will simply concern themselves with the child.

I broke the cardinal rule. I did a search. I’d be considering an alternate year arrangement.

Seashellies · 28/08/2023 08:09

Can I ask, do you think it's unreasonable that my disability worsens throughout the day which is another reason for wishing to have the mornings?

What do you do on normal days?

Honestly OP whether you think it's fair or not the court will prioritise the child first and foremost (which is invariably alternate days rather than split days) and also considers the other parent which is fair.

SavBlancTonight · 28/08/2023 07:59

Your reasons are valid but they don't trump his. Alternating both days completely seems a better option. Including.new years.

JenWillsiam · 28/08/2023 07:59

Hare95 · 28/08/2023 02:44

I haven't said I don't want DS on NYE. I've said if my ex wants DS 50% of special occasions, then that includes NYE but my ex is refusing to see him NYE at all. An excuse to go off and get drunk I assume

As for seeing family, my family live an hour away. They are elderly (in their 80s) grandparents. They don't want to travel to us later in the day when it's darker, colder and potentially icy. We can't go to them given the distance, particularly because it's more moving around if my son is then going to my ex in the afternoon. I've really really tried to see where you're coming from but I don't I'm sorry 😞 I just don't see how anyone can say it's unreasonable to want to get my son as much time with his great grandparents at Christmas as possible? Is this really being unreasonable? Plus given the fact my ex always sees great grandparents on that side in the afternoons, I just feel naturally that it then makes sense DS is with my ex during that part of the day so he doesn't miss out on seeing his great grant parents on that side too

If it doesn’t court they will likely award alternate special occasions. Keep that in mind. And they don’t consider NYE a special occasion.

JenWillsiam · 28/08/2023 07:59

Hare95 · 28/08/2023 02:44

I haven't said I don't want DS on NYE. I've said if my ex wants DS 50% of special occasions, then that includes NYE but my ex is refusing to see him NYE at all. An excuse to go off and get drunk I assume

As for seeing family, my family live an hour away. They are elderly (in their 80s) grandparents. They don't want to travel to us later in the day when it's darker, colder and potentially icy. We can't go to them given the distance, particularly because it's more moving around if my son is then going to my ex in the afternoon. I've really really tried to see where you're coming from but I don't I'm sorry 😞 I just don't see how anyone can say it's unreasonable to want to get my son as much time with his great grandparents at Christmas as possible? Is this really being unreasonable? Plus given the fact my ex always sees great grandparents on that side in the afternoons, I just feel naturally that it then makes sense DS is with my ex during that part of the day so he doesn't miss out on seeing his great grant parents on that side too

If it doesn’t court they will likely award alternate special occasions. Keep that in mind. And they don’t consider NYE a special occasion.

CherryMaDeara · 28/08/2023 07:56

Stop meeting ex at 11am! Tell him it’s 6pm and when he says it’s 11am, tell him ‘it’s not happening’.

He is taking you for a mug.

If NYE falls on his time then he should have dc.

Birch101 · 28/08/2023 07:54

Personally I think it's better to alternate every year but your other option is to use the NYE to your advantage....
Whoever has Christmas AM then also has NYE.
See what he wants more.
Personally sounds like you need to go to court with his attitude over the whole early drop off (p.s. early is a couple of hrs imo. Not 7) start collecting all his texts and communications and deal in everything by writing.

My parents divorced when I was 6 I have never spent Christmas with my dad we'd see him on boxing day as kids at his parents. It never bothered me. Presents are presents. I think I would have been more annoyed to have to swop half way through the day.

Lonecatwithkitten · 28/08/2023 07:45

We alternated and I operated the 'christmas is just a day' policy. We did a bigger alternation25/12-28/12 and then 28/12-2/1we both had families that we would travel to for Christmas. So when I had 28/12-2/1we had our Christmas Day on the 2/1 presents and everything.
Now DD is an adult I am really glad I did as she has a career in musical theatre so Christmas is one of her busy times - so we will have to make a different Christmas now.
It's just a day make a new tradition that's yours only,

WhisperingHi · 28/08/2023 07:39

Oh dear, OP.

You seem to only want to see this from the perspective of your needs. But your ex and your son have needs too.

I absolutely would never agree to my ex having mornings for every special occasion, disability or not. Because that's a horrible end of the deal. Christmas morning is absolutely the best part of the day and you know it.

Can I ask how you manage having your child every other afternoon? I assume he's not left to fend for himself every time?

And time with his dad trumps time with your parents. If you can't make it work that they see him in the afternoon (can't they stay over or you both travel and stay there for the afternoon and night time?) then so be it. There are other days. His dad gets priority over your parents.

Sorry OP but you really do need to start considering your child and your ex more. The courts won't agree to your wishes anyway so much better to be amicable now, for your child's sake.

KatieB55 · 28/08/2023 07:25

I agree whole days are better for children. We alternated the whole of Xmas and the other parent had the whole of NY. Moving kids around during the day doesn't allow anyone to make plans or relax.

MummyJ36 · 28/08/2023 07:14

OP surely you must understand how special Christmas morning is with a child? And how limited those special mornings are whilst they’re still young enough to believe in it all? I’m bit saying your Ex is in the right about everything but I think you might be deliberately discounting how important this particular morning is for both parents.

millymollymoomoo · 28/08/2023 07:07

You need to alternate op

but I can see here that you won’t agree to it even though it’s the right thing and if it goes to court is exactly what will be ordered

yogasaurus · 28/08/2023 07:02

You’ve posted this before? The conclusion was pretty much that alternating was fairer for everyone, including the DC.

Christmas Eve into Christmas morning is the special part, I don’t think you can call that, every year; no.

PizzaPastaWine · 28/08/2023 06:54

I have no arrangement with my DC over NYE and neither any of the other co-parents I know.

For us it's birthdays/Christmas and Easter (when young) that are split. You start splitting NYE then where do you stop? Halloween/bonfire night?!

NYE is just kept as a normal day. Keep it simple.

R4ID · 28/08/2023 06:46

Sirzy · 28/08/2023 05:48

I assume you manage to parent the rest of the day throughout the rest of the year though?

surely if you only had his afternoons those days then you would be able to rest all morning to be ready?

some sort of split whereby you both get the same amount of mornings with him over the years is best.

sadly your posts seem to be about what is best for you and your extended family rather than what is best for your Son.

Complete ignorance of how disabilities work. Resting in the morning doesn’t guarantee someone will be at a level of functioning well in the afternoon.

OP, you are both being unreasonable.

I understand you may parent in the afternoon on other days of the year but you want to spend the part of Xmas day when you feel at your best because it’s a special day. Wanting this is not unreasonable. Stopping their other parent from having DC on Xmas morning every year is unreasonable. You need to come up with a fair way of doing it that takes into account everyone’s needs not just your own. It seems alternating Xmas day each year would work well. You can then make a big fuss of DC on Boxing Day morning they’ll love it.

Your Ex is acting like a dick not having them for NY, have cake and eat it comes to mind. Whether you can do anything about it I don’t know. But maybe you can relish having them for NY and make it a special day for you and DC so they’ll grow up with lovely memories of NY with you.

Coral12345 · 28/08/2023 06:34

I think alternating years seems fairest for all. Seems hard and sucks at first but once you start doing you will realise it’s pretty good!
that’s what we do, and you have to focus on positives each way.
so, the positive of not having them on Christmas Day is doing ‘second’ Christmas so you can still celebrate after but because it’s not actual Christmas food is cheaper and shops are open (batteries lol). so it’s more low key but you can still celebrate the occasion together.
and you can still celebrate birthday after too a nice home cooked meal with all the family. :)

laladoodoo · 28/08/2023 06:34

The decision you want is not fair isn't fair on the child.

They're not at fault for your breaking up, so it shouldn't inconvenience them by having to break up their day.

It's unfortunate and horrible for you I can only imagine, but alternating years seems to be the only fair way.

Im afraid while your disability is difficult, it's not a legitimate reason for your ex to get the scraps of a special day and you get the best part.

moomoosaka · 28/08/2023 06:26

Hare95 · 28/08/2023 02:47

Can I ask, do you think it's unreasonable that my disability worsens throughout the day which is another reason for wishing to have the mornings?

I do understand that but I still think for the kids sake one day with one parent is better.

moomoosaka · 28/08/2023 06:26

I think in your circumstances it might work but imo christmas being alternated whole days is best for the kids. Otherwise they end up trying to cram two Christmases into one day

Cowlover89 · 28/08/2023 06:20

Yabu

Sirzy · 28/08/2023 05:48

Hare95 · 28/08/2023 02:47

Can I ask, do you think it's unreasonable that my disability worsens throughout the day which is another reason for wishing to have the mornings?

I assume you manage to parent the rest of the day throughout the rest of the year though?

surely if you only had his afternoons those days then you would be able to rest all morning to be ready?

some sort of split whereby you both get the same amount of mornings with him over the years is best.

sadly your posts seem to be about what is best for you and your extended family rather than what is best for your Son.

WeirdBarbie · 28/08/2023 04:07

You are unreasonable to expect your son to have to move locations every Christmas Day or birthday. It would be much better for your son (and you) to alternate.

I think it takes while for parents to accept that separated parents miss things. It’s just the way it is. You need to alternate Xmas. We have the DSC every other Xmas. But deciding you get him every Xmas morning is absolutely unfair - everyone knows that Xmas eve night and Xmas day morning at the most exciting part.

Your ex is BU not to swap every other NYE, but surely that is good for you as it means you get him every year and don’t plan that night out due to your disability? If you want to make plans it sounds like telling ex that you’re delighted he doesn’t want his son for NYE will make him suddenly want him?

Autieangel · 28/08/2023 03:57

We did Xmas eve to 4pm Xmas day one year. And 4pm Xmas day to 27th the next. New year we alternated. Birthdays was whos day it fell on but the other could see them for a couple hours.

I'd suggest alternating,the morning is the important bit so it's only fair. New year I'd say who's ever day it falls on they have them.

Bournetilly · 28/08/2023 03:52

I think you are both being unreasonable.

You for wanting DC in the mornings which are the best part every year and your ex for not wanting to split new year.

I don’t think your disability comes into it if you usually manage to look after DC in the afternoons.

The best way IMO is to alternate each year. On the year you don’t have DC have a second Christmas with them on Boxing Day/ the day after with presents and Christmas dinner. Could you go and see family on this day too?